Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sister angry I “yanked” my nephew’s arm and told him off

994 replies

Mmemm · 10/05/2025 06:06

So I live with my parents (saving up for flat in London). My sister often visits with her child and husband.

We have a gorgeous 12 yo Golden Retriever who is enjoying his golden years sunbathing on the sofa. Anyway, I was in the living room on my phone when I saw my little toddler nephew go up to my dog on the sofa and hit him on the head with a coaster. Obviously it’s not heavy but I reacted as I am protective of my elderly dog, poor boy was dozing. I ran up to my nephew and held him by arm and said “we do not throw things at ‘Lucky’, how would you like it if I hit you in the face? That was very mean of you”. I took the coaster away from him and said if he can’t use it nicely then he can’t have it. Not a big deal. Pretty normal way to deal with it in my view. I may have been a little cross.

But sister is now demanding an apology. BIL was sat sort of to the side reading a magazine and snitched. Didn’t say anything at the time. Errr how how about you parent your child mate.

But apparently I was very overboard. I don’t think I was. I refuse to apologise on principal. Dog took it in his stride but you can’t be allowing shit
like that to happen.

In my mind sister can do one but parents have literally begged me as apparently she won’t visit whilst I am home 😂

OP posts:
KarmaKameelion · 10/05/2025 09:08

ToysRus56 · 10/05/2025 09:03

As I said above:

You're right - I hadn't noticed the poll, so I stand corrected. But there's lots of really nice, nuanced responses here that the OP could read and maybe see her sisters perspective a bit more. I hate how polarised people become on here.

She’s literally been called a child abuser, aggressive, free loader…. Of course you would probably focus on that.

SnugMintFawn · 10/05/2025 09:07

Snapncrackle · 10/05/2025 08:36

I am grown up thank you

BIL should be looking after his son
Then it wouldn’t have been a problem

I agree BIL should have stepped in, 100%, and if I was the SIL in this situation I would be annoyed at my husband.

but to react with “I’m sooooooo sorry…” etc does make you sound 12 🙃

EG94 · 10/05/2025 09:06

ToysRus56 · 10/05/2025 09:02

Maybe? I don't know I don't know them. Better to assume the best of people than assume the worst?

I like how neutral you are 😊 actually your reply made me take a step back. I guess life and experiences takes you to believe the worst due to past experience when you’ve believed the best in people. Hmm slippery slope. Not a lot of trust and kindness in the world now

Rosscameasdoody · 10/05/2025 09:06

OK show of hands please 🤣 All those voting YABU. Have you genuinely never handled your child more roughly than you intended, or spoken to them more harshly than you meant to because you were panicked that what they were doing would cause them imminent harm ?

Butchyrestingface · 10/05/2025 09:06

ToysRus56 · 10/05/2025 08:59

You're right - I hadn't noticed the poll, so I stand corrected. But there's lots of really nice, nuanced responses here that the OP could read and maybe see her sisters perspective a bit more. I hate how polarised people become on here.

She's maybe struggling to see nuance amongst all the posts calling her a child abusing harpy.

ToysRus56 · 10/05/2025 09:05

TammyJones · 10/05/2025 08:58

Uh 59 % agree with op
41 % don’t agree with- …
you Do understand how percentage works don’t you?

I hadn't seen the poll. And anyway its not exactly a clean sweep, if I was the OP I'd be interested in different perspectives. God Mumsnet is a hostile place.

AthWat · 10/05/2025 09:05

ToysRus56 · 10/05/2025 09:02

Maybe? I don't know I don't know them. Better to assume the best of people than assume the worst?

She's demanding an apology and saying she won't set foot in the house until she has one. Does that info that was in the first post give you any clues?

BlackeyedSusan · 10/05/2025 09:05

Lilactimes · 10/05/2025 08:42

Your dog, old, slightly in pain and woken suddenly could have taken a snap out of your nephew’s face - that end result is hideous for everyone involved. So the situation needed stopping quickly and your anxiety at the possible end scenario can sometimes show as anger/ shouting/ pulling the kid.

Maybe you can simply tell your account of the situation like this? That you were really concerned about your DN being hurt and you reacted quickly and abruptly to stop this scenario.

”Apologise” for your parents sake - but say this is why you did it.

You need to frame it that you were protecting your nephew as he had hit your dog in the face and didn't want the dog to react. I bet bil didn't even see him hit the dog because he wasn't supervising.

Ask them what they would have done?

AthWat · 10/05/2025 09:04

ToysRus56 · 10/05/2025 09:03

As I said above:

You're right - I hadn't noticed the poll, so I stand corrected. But there's lots of really nice, nuanced responses here that the OP could read and maybe see her sisters perspective a bit more. I hate how polarised people become on here.

The sister is calling for an apology. The OP is right not to give one.

ToysRus56 · 10/05/2025 09:03

AthWat · 10/05/2025 09:00

Look at the poll.

As I said above:

You're right - I hadn't noticed the poll, so I stand corrected. But there's lots of really nice, nuanced responses here that the OP could read and maybe see her sisters perspective a bit more. I hate how polarised people become on here.

ToysRus56 · 10/05/2025 09:02

EG94 · 10/05/2025 09:00

Is the sister open to seeing the OP’s perspective? If no then she can fuck off asking anyone to consider hers

Maybe? I don't know I don't know them. Better to assume the best of people than assume the worst?

AthWat · 10/05/2025 09:00

ToysRus56 · 10/05/2025 08:55

Most people don't agree with the OPs actions. And I think in any situation it's good to be open minded to other people's perspectives/ ways of doing things. Nothing in life is black and white.

Look at the poll.

Rosscameasdoody · 10/05/2025 09:00

Undecided2025 · 10/05/2025 08:52

@Rosscameasdoody whataboutery is the worst. The post isn’t about the bil, it’s about op.

Waiting until the dog retaliated is not the only other outcome.

BiL is the child's father. He was in the room. He did nothing, and when he realised he should have been the one to intervene he bad mouthed OP to her sister to take the heat off himself. Of course it’s about him. And while there was even the remotest chance of the outcome being that the child was bitten, OP was right to act as she did.

EG94 · 10/05/2025 09:00

ToysRus56 · 10/05/2025 08:59

You're right - I hadn't noticed the poll, so I stand corrected. But there's lots of really nice, nuanced responses here that the OP could read and maybe see her sisters perspective a bit more. I hate how polarised people become on here.

Is the sister open to seeing the OP’s perspective? If no then she can fuck off asking anyone to consider hers

Floatlikeafeather2 · 10/05/2025 09:00

Mmemm · 10/05/2025 06:23

Haha I’m the back sheep

Yes and you thoroughly revel in it, don't you? I'm all for children being spoken to firmly (and absolutely, a nearly 3 year old should already know this is wrong, for their own protection if not the dog's, and especially if they see the dog regularly) but now you've added in the fact that you were hungover, it does shed a different light on it, and I suspect you were louder, grabbier and more angry than you're letting on here. You don't like kids - why did you not take yourself off to "recover" in your room when they arrived? You could have taken the dog with you. You say that your brother in law was right there, so did you say anything to him at the time? He was wrong but so we're you. Plus you've upset your parents in their own house.

EmeraldShamrock000 · 10/05/2025 09:00

HopscotchBanana · 10/05/2025 08:57

No no, he very much hit the dog in the face with a coaster and had to be stopped from whacking the dog in the face for a second time.

So, this is kind?

nephew go up to my dog on the sofa and hit him on the head with a coaster.

we do not throw things at ‘Lucky’, how would you like it if I hit you in the face? That was very mean of you”

Did he throw coaster at the dog or hit dog in the head while holding coaster? Bit different.

ToysRus56 · 10/05/2025 08:59

Butchyrestingface · 10/05/2025 08:53

"Kindly", the majority view, as evidenced by the voting, is that OP did nothing wrong.

Maybe it's YOU who needs to take on board the majority view?

You're right - I hadn't noticed the poll, so I stand corrected. But there's lots of really nice, nuanced responses here that the OP could read and maybe see her sisters perspective a bit more. I hate how polarised people become on here.

Butchyrestingface · 10/05/2025 08:59

ToysRus56 · 10/05/2025 08:55

Most people don't agree with the OPs actions. And I think in any situation it's good to be open minded to other people's perspectives/ ways of doing things. Nothing in life is black and white.

Most people DO agree with the OP's actions.

Are people wilfully ignoring the voting or are they GENUINELY this obtuse?

TammyJones · 10/05/2025 08:58

ToysRus56 · 10/05/2025 08:55

Most people don't agree with the OPs actions. And I think in any situation it's good to be open minded to other people's perspectives/ ways of doing things. Nothing in life is black and white.

Uh 59 % agree with op
41 % don’t agree with- …
you Do understand how percentage works don’t you?

Crackingprawn81 · 10/05/2025 08:57

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Lilactimes · 10/05/2025 08:57

Butchyrestingface · 10/05/2025 08:51

The OP disputes that she treated him roughly.

And him just doing what toddlers do could potentially have resulted in being bitten. Because his useless father did nothing. How 'kind' would it have been to let the the child be harmed?

OP prevented that. She reacted to an unexpected, stressful situation in which she had no time to prepare a speech. Generally, when people get a scare and need to react quickly to a developing hazard, they can be a bit sharper than they might otherwise be and allowances are made - especially if said person has potentially saved one's child from a nasty bite!

If the parents don't like her way of intervening, well, the father could always try parenting his own child in future.

Absolutely this @Butchyrestingface

JMSA · 10/05/2025 08:57

I’ll always side with the animal, so YANBU 😄

HopscotchBanana · 10/05/2025 08:57

EmeraldShamrock000 · 10/05/2025 08:52

He threw an item at the dog, he did not hit the dog in the face.
He most likely wanted to wake the dog up, I am sure they're close as he visits Dog regularly.

No no, he very much hit the dog in the face with a coaster and had to be stopped from whacking the dog in the face for a second time.

So, this is kind?

Crackingprawn81 · 10/05/2025 08:57

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Pickledpeanuts · 10/05/2025 08:55

EmeraldShamrock000 · 10/05/2025 08:52

He threw an item at the dog, he did not hit the dog in the face.
He most likely wanted to wake the dog up, I am sure they're close as he visits Dog regularly.

No, he hit the dog with the coaster. It's clearly in the OP. He's also 2, so I'm sure he's not wandering up gleefully thinking about cracking the dog on the head, but he didn't throw it.