Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Council houses owning brand new cars?

736 replies

TheCluelessMum · 06/05/2025 20:52

I’m writing this post with the hopes of being educated, not slandered

however I completely appreciate I may be just completely shot down for asking this.

i live on a new build estate, 12 houses at the start of the estate are council houses. I don’t know this because I’m a snob, I know this because it’s clearly marked on plans when you buy those houses.

i see so much stuff online about how the UK benefits system is failing people, the higher rise of food banks. It’s absolutely abhorrent people are in this situation.

however, when entering my estate today I noticed that each and every single council house had a car newer that a 20 plate. Mercedes, Audi’s, BMW’s even range rovers.. there was not a single house out of the 12 which had an older than 20 plate car.

I am now confused as to why this is the case? Everyone I know (including those receiving benefits) continually speaks about how hard the cost of living is.

so could someone please answer how/why those in what we would presume lower income families, are able to afford such lavish cars.

OP posts:
PluckyCheeks · 07/05/2025 11:48

TheFastTraybake · 07/05/2025 11:41

What do you mean?

ETA I see you've already refused/been unable to explain. So it looks like you're saying Grenfell was deserved.

Edited

Wrong again.

TheFastTraybake · 07/05/2025 11:41

PluckyCheeks · 06/05/2025 23:38

Sunlight is the best disinfectant.

What do you mean?

ETA I see you've already refused/been unable to explain. So it looks like you're saying Grenfell was deserved.

TheFastTraybake · 07/05/2025 11:40

Freeasa · 06/05/2025 23:29

Because the ONLY place rent control has ever worked was Austria and at that time it was coupled by a truly vast social housing building program.

Rent controls just mean landlords leave the market and private rental just gets more and more hard to come by, and more and more expensive. It’s something like 30,000 landlords have sold up since the rent controls were introduced in Scotland. It’s virtually impossible to find a place to rent in the big cities.

Worked ok in the UK before the housing act in 1988 deregulated the market. Not perfect but better than the wild west we have now.

TheFastTraybake · 07/05/2025 11:37

PluckyCheeks · 06/05/2025 23:28

Good to know. Anyway, I’m off to catch the last episode of Stacey & Joe. If you’re pro bennies no matter what, your mind will never be changed. Well, if you came to live in certain areas of North Kensington or Islington, it might be. But that’ll never happen and tbh, you’re better as you are as ignorance is more blissful instead of seeing daily injustices.

I guess you're 'pro bennies" (assuming you're talking about benefits and not drug addiction) since you've got a toilet paper list of what you've apparently already claimed!

jasflowers · 07/05/2025 11:36

Local council near me are buying private homes to rent out, such is the cost of housing to the council.

The policy of not allowing councils to build council houses, with the money obtained from selling council houses, has, like many Tory policies proved to be an utter failure.

TheFastTraybake · 07/05/2025 11:35

PluckyCheeks · 06/05/2025 23:23

I found out about PIP existing around 2 years ago but didn’t know what it was for. More lately I’ve seen MNs talk about it for anxiety and depression and this has been confirmed by my chat with CAB.

Perhaps if I belonged to one of these “communities” who look out for each other and share info on how to make the most of what you can claim, I’d be £749 per month better off already…

Don't hold your breath. PIP is hard to claim, being eligible for the enhanced components of both daily living and mobility is uncommon. Be prepared for a wait of up to or over 18 months while you complete the form, do the assessment, get awarded zero points, do the MR, get declined again and wait for tribunal.

But you'll know this, being such a prolific claimant already.

TheFastTraybake · 07/05/2025 11:30

Freeasa · 06/05/2025 23:13

Yes obviously there should be more social housing! Perhaps if housing associations and councils charged those who could afford it the market rent they’d have more money to invest. Does this not make sense to you?

I think it’s farcical that person A who’s never met the criteria for social housing pays a fortune to a private landlord when person B who once met the criteria pays a pittance, when person A and person B could currently have exactly the same financial circumstances.

Charging rent at market rates to social tenants was suggested by a previous Tory administration but councils didn't want to do it. It's unfair and not cost-effective.

TheFastTraybake · 07/05/2025 11:25

JorgyPorgy · 06/05/2025 22:59

Why should someone be allowed cheap rent so that they can afford a brand new car?

I struggle to understand this point of view. Is it morally virtuous to pay as high a rent as you can possibly find while driving an old, polluting, unreliable car? Because if not, why would anyone suggest that is the best route to take?

We need more social housing, not more people subsidising private landlords from their own pockets or via housing-related benefits.

jasflowers · 07/05/2025 11:23

A 20 plate car is hardly new!

Could be around 10 to 15k.

OP also said "these are clearly marked when you buy those houses" so are they "Affordable to buy" ? which near me can be around £300k, so hardly the "poor" buying them

Few councils are building new council houses, usually its Housing Associations buying these from the builder.

TheFastTraybake · 07/05/2025 11:16

WildflowerConstellations · 06/05/2025 22:11

Cost a bit in Council resources too, wouldn't it!

Exactly! Once the costs of building social housing are recouped via rent, they become a council asset. Who thinks it would be a good idea to remove working tenants so that the rent is once again funded via housing-related benefits?
I'm not suggesting that nobody who has their housing costs paid via UC should be without a home btw. Just that if there's income from rent on social housing, in a sane world that would go towards building/funding more affordable tenancies. Nobody can start to turn their life around, get a job or training if they don't have a secure roof over their head. Honestly, you'd think it was rocket science!

ThisPearlCrow · 07/05/2025 10:43

It depends where you live.

In many areas, council housing is very much tied to benefits. In some areas you don't even get on the list unless you're over 50, a care leaver, a successful asylum seeker or in receipt of certain benefits.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 07/05/2025 10:33

ToKittyornottoKitty · 06/05/2025 21:04

What ‘culture’ exactly?

It’s def. a case in some cultures (I’ve lived in one such abroad) that the ‘right’ make/model of car is intrinsically bound up with social status/self esteem, and may well be prioritised above other things.

Not that I’m saying the same doesn’t apply increasingly within average UK society.

PluckyCheeks · 07/05/2025 10:23

WildflowerConstellations · 07/05/2025 07:41

What does where I live have to do with it? I'm not about to tell you where I live.

You did not explain your shitty comment. Hopefully because you've realised that was a fucked up thing to say.

Obviously it was an awful way to die.

But unless you’re up close and personal to the shit that went on and is many cases is still going on, you don’t know what you’re talking about.

Digdongdoo · 07/05/2025 08:24

LakieLady · 07/05/2025 07:57

My parents lived in council property for all but the first ten years of their (long) marriage.

In the last year before he retired, my DF earned over £75k, which was a bloody lot of money in 1997. They could have bought their council house outright, but DF wouldn't, because he thought right to buy was wrong and that the house should go to someone in housing need, as they were when they first became council tenants.

If they were really so concerned about social housing stock they would have bought a different house outright...

LakieLady · 07/05/2025 07:57

XenoBitch · 06/05/2025 21:03

A few comments on here have said they live in, or know someone who lives in council housing and is not on benefits.

My parents lived in council property for all but the first ten years of their (long) marriage.

In the last year before he retired, my DF earned over £75k, which was a bloody lot of money in 1997. They could have bought their council house outright, but DF wouldn't, because he thought right to buy was wrong and that the house should go to someone in housing need, as they were when they first became council tenants.

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 07/05/2025 07:51

XenoBitch · 06/05/2025 21:30

Because if people are at risk of losing their home for doing better in life, then there is no incentive to do better. Housing is a vital need, and no one wants to risk losing it, even if that means they stay on a lower income.

This I 100% agree with, I would never have bothered spending 4 years studying to better our lives if we were under some kind of tenancy with a clause of being asked to leave just because we had bettered ourselves

Snailiewhalie · 07/05/2025 07:46

"Surely the point of council houses should be that they're for people who NEED subsidised housing, and when their circumstances improve they should have to go and pay market rent or get a mortgage. I have never understood how people get longterm tenancies without the situation being reviewed at intervals."

Both sets of my grandparents lived in council houses their entire adult lives and expected to have them for life. They always worked with a reasonable income. Living in a council house was what most working class people did.

WildflowerConstellations · 07/05/2025 07:41

PluckyCheeks · 07/05/2025 03:06

Do you live in the borough?

Thought not.

It’s actually disgusting and quite telling where your mind went with that.

What does where I live have to do with it? I'm not about to tell you where I live.

You did not explain your shitty comment. Hopefully because you've realised that was a fucked up thing to say.

GlitteryUnicornSparkles · 07/05/2025 07:31

Many people in council houses work. Lower rent = more spare cash for other things. They clearly prioritise a decent car.

Council rent in my area is half of what I pay as a private tenant, if I could get into a council property I could probably afford car finance too. Unfortunately I’m not eligible.

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 07/05/2025 07:21

We rent a HA property have been here 6 years. When we got the house it was a waiting list system you just moved up the list and we got offered our house in a rural area near where we were brought up and there was only 2 on the list at the time.

we both work i am a community nurse and have a new car but need a reliable car for my job and new cars come with warranty and no mot etc needing done for 3 years as well as service deals etc so it works for us, we pay full rent and get no benefits except child benefit. We looked at mortgages but the deposit money is too much and we are cheaper renting than buying currently

FishersGate · 07/05/2025 07:12

YourElatedLimeShark · 06/05/2025 20:58

I live in a council house. And I work so hard on my own business. My kids have brand new iPhones. I have a gorgeous 67 plate fancy car and have another vehicle too. We eat amazing food. Eat out often. Have nice clothes. Designer sunglasses. I vape. I don’t drink. I go the gym and have a PT. My kids go to multiple clubs almost every day of the week. I have a 65 inch TV on my wall. I have well cared for pets.

May be these guys are the same? Not everyone in a council house is poor etc. many work. And work bloody hard.

How about saving your money amd buying your property and freeing up yours for someone on the list then?

Boomer55 · 07/05/2025 06:47

TheCluelessMum · 06/05/2025 20:52

I’m writing this post with the hopes of being educated, not slandered

however I completely appreciate I may be just completely shot down for asking this.

i live on a new build estate, 12 houses at the start of the estate are council houses. I don’t know this because I’m a snob, I know this because it’s clearly marked on plans when you buy those houses.

i see so much stuff online about how the UK benefits system is failing people, the higher rise of food banks. It’s absolutely abhorrent people are in this situation.

however, when entering my estate today I noticed that each and every single council house had a car newer that a 20 plate. Mercedes, Audi’s, BMW’s even range rovers.. there was not a single house out of the 12 which had an older than 20 plate car.

I am now confused as to why this is the case? Everyone I know (including those receiving benefits) continually speaks about how hard the cost of living is.

so could someone please answer how/why those in what we would presume lower income families, are able to afford such lavish cars.

I’ve lived in social housing since the 1970’s. I have never once claimed benefits. 🙄

I worked and then I retired with private pensions.

And, yes, I’ve owned cars.🤷‍♀️

TammyJones · 07/05/2025 06:44

TheCluelessMum · 06/05/2025 20:56

oh!!!!!! I didn’t know this, so just like renting except council is your landlord.

case closed!!!!!! Thanks for responding

I have a relative who works full time - no benefits- rents from the council - no car though.

Numberfish · 07/05/2025 03:33

XenoBitch · 07/05/2025 02:19

DFOD my parents lease new cars and don't claim any benefits at all.
You can lease a new car too... then we can all judge you too.

Edited

Er, that’s exactly what I said. Why live in a council house if you can afford a lease car? But feel free to ignore what’s being said and have a little rant.

PluckyCheeks · 07/05/2025 03:06

WildflowerConstellations · 06/05/2025 23:56

@PluckyCheeks I really hope you do not mean to suggest that hatred towards social tenants has increased since "sunlight" was cast upon the fact they existed by social tenants being burnt alive in their homes??? And what is being "disinfected"? Truly disgusting way to talk about people who died in really horrific circumstances.

Do you live in the borough?

Thought not.

It’s actually disgusting and quite telling where your mind went with that.