Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To turn down council property?

93 replies

Dipitlow · 06/05/2025 16:51

I have been offered a council flat (recently split with partner) 2 children,
living with parents at the moment. If I decline what are my chances of being offered another one? I didn’t bid on it they have bidded for me? Do I just take it? Or should I private rent?

OP posts:
Mrsttcno1 · 06/05/2025 19:43

If you refuse then you are classed as making yourself intentionally homeless and then the council no longer have any duty whatsoever to house or help you, so unless you have the money to rent privately I would not advise declining.

PaintYourAssLikeRembrandt · 06/05/2025 19:41

blubbyblub · 06/05/2025 19:00

But surely once they are comfortable and stable in suitably paying employment they are just like everyone else not in council housing so that housing stock should be made available for people who are in the situation they were in when they got the house.

I can see a system when council housing is made available to more people who need it and then a few years like 5 or 10 years later when people have got on their feet and stable they then surrender the house for others who now need it

wouldn’t this be more socialist to do this? Help those in need and then those people move over for the next person in need.

What a great incentive to get on your feet.

"If you improve your financial situation then we will kick you out of the house and you can be at the mercy of private landlords and extortionate rents"

Icecreamandcoffee · 06/05/2025 19:34

It depends entirely on your council's policies. Different councils do different things. Housing is so tight in our area that our council's policy is you take what you are offered or you are taken off/ downgraded down the list as you are then considered voluntary homeless. The advice people are given in our area is to take the offer and then when you are eligible to swap you can try and swap. There are an awful lot of people wanting to swap so things come up for swap quickly.

In our area you need to be street homeless/ in a hotel/ temporary accommodation to be offered anything quickly. The fact you have been offered a property within weeks of bunking with parents suggests the strain on council housing in your area is not as tight so they may allow 1 or 2 refusals.

GarlicPile · 06/05/2025 19:28

SnoozingFox · 06/05/2025 18:16

You are not desperate if you are turning down a property, are you?

The first one I was offered was a concrete prefab with visible damp, an insecure back door opening onto a well-trodden woodland path. The wood was littered with syringes. I explained why I felt this wasn't a secure home and would not be good for my mental health. I was offered the flat I now live in less than two weeks later.

This is obviously different from OP's situation but "unsuitable" does actually mean something. I get a bit tired of the attitude on here that beggars can't be choosers. We are not beggars.

The idea is to provide a safe and appropriate long-term home, not any old thing with a roof. It's not at all impossible that OP's local provider has someone else on their list who'd be better suited by the home she saw. They should have it, and the provider should prioritise her for suitable homes near her kids' schools.

FortyElephants · 06/05/2025 19:24

tartyflette · 06/05/2025 17:08

It"s too far from her childcare arrangements! I'd contact the council and let them know this and see what they say about whether it would affect future offers of accommodation.

Edited

She needs to change childcare! Jesus, a council property is like unicorn shit in 2025

Limprichteabiscuit · 06/05/2025 19:24

5128gap · 06/05/2025 19:07

In my local authority this is done for people who are being put up by friends or relatives who want them to leave too.

they have to have a date on it and no caving in when the person is offered a direct let or temporary accommodation in the area or council will consider it collusion.

Limprichteabiscuit · 06/05/2025 19:14

5128gap · 06/05/2025 19:05

She could. Legally homeless doesn't require you to be sleeping on the streets. She is 'staying with' her parents but this isn't the same as it being her home.

In the same way your adult kids living at home are not homeless, nor is OP.
Of her parents ask her to leave then she will be from when she actually leaves the property.
She could then present at the council as homeless and that would be the case.
But until they do this OP will be considered currently housed but in NEED of housing due to overcrowding at parents I imagine.

BoredZelda · 06/05/2025 19:10

Why not ask the council? They will have their own rules which we don’t know.

Any system that says you have to take any house they offer no matter how badly it impacts your life is flawed and I’d be surprised if that is the case. By posting here you will find people falling over themselves to tell you how ungrateful you are and anyone in the position to need social housing should bow down and be thankful for any property no matter how bad it is. God forbid we actually try and help people who need it.

Seventree · 06/05/2025 19:08

OP, don't listen to the people being unsympathetic. Some people genuinely think that people who need social housing should be happy if they're put in a shed at the dump.

Different councils have different policies on turning down properties. Your best bet is to speak to them directly, tell them that your parents provide childcare and moving so far would make it impossible for you to work. I wouldn't mention the area being rough personally, just stick to the logistical problems. I used to occasionally help service users do similar at a previous job and my local council was far more likely to care about access to work than how safe the area was (even though it's a valid concern in my view).

Have you explored housing association housing? Sometimes the registers can be different to the council's list, and the areas can be nicer (where I am they are often on new build estates that have a mix of privately owned houses and housing association houses, I'm not sure if this is the same everywhere).

Good luck Flowers

5128gap · 06/05/2025 19:07

Limprichteabiscuit · 06/05/2025 19:02

This is what we would call a Direct Let - would only usually happen if OP was actually street homeless with the kids or about to be evicted by court order. And yes she would have to accept it or the council could discharge their duty and claim she would be making herself intentionally homeless.
They would then in theory have a duty to the kids via children’s social care but not the adults.

Edited

In my local authority this is done for people who are being put up by friends or relatives who want them to leave too.

5128gap · 06/05/2025 19:05

Limprichteabiscuit · 06/05/2025 18:58

OP wouldn’t be under the homelessness service
She living with her mum and dad.

She could. Legally homeless doesn't require you to be sleeping on the streets. She is 'staying with' her parents but this isn't the same as it being her home.

Limprichteabiscuit · 06/05/2025 19:02

5128gap · 06/05/2025 18:49

Are you registered under the homeless duty as oppose to the regular list? If they bid for you, it suggests you might be. Most local authorities consider they will have discharged their homelessness duty if they make one offer. So if you turn it down you will lose your priority place. Sometimes this can be challenged though. Before you do anything, talk to Shelter to understand your rights.

This is what we would call a Direct Let - would only usually happen if OP was actually street homeless with the kids or about to be evicted by court order. And yes she would have to accept it or the council could discharge their duty and claim she would be making herself intentionally homeless.
They would then in theory have a duty to the kids via children’s social care but not the adults.

waterrat · 06/05/2025 19:00

I would be very very careful OP - think this through. Once you are in council property you can look to swap later - you are secure for life.

Are you absolutely sure the area is problematic -? Have you been? how many miles/ what transport from your parents?

How many more chances do you get to a property?

blubbyblub · 06/05/2025 19:00

crackofdoom · 06/05/2025 18:38

Vanishingly few "rich" people are living in social housing in the UK!!

But would you want to remove all incentive for people to better themselves?! I know quite a few people who are living in social housing and are now "comfortable", although few who would be able to buy their own house. But their situation has generally improved because they have affordable, secure housing- so the solution isn't to throw them out and make their situation insecure again- it's to build more social housing so everyone has the chance of getting some.

But surely once they are comfortable and stable in suitably paying employment they are just like everyone else not in council housing so that housing stock should be made available for people who are in the situation they were in when they got the house.

I can see a system when council housing is made available to more people who need it and then a few years like 5 or 10 years later when people have got on their feet and stable they then surrender the house for others who now need it

wouldn’t this be more socialist to do this? Help those in need and then those people move over for the next person in need.

Limprichteabiscuit · 06/05/2025 18:58

5128gap · 06/05/2025 18:49

Are you registered under the homeless duty as oppose to the regular list? If they bid for you, it suggests you might be. Most local authorities consider they will have discharged their homelessness duty if they make one offer. So if you turn it down you will lose your priority place. Sometimes this can be challenged though. Before you do anything, talk to Shelter to understand your rights.

OP wouldn’t be under the homelessness service
She living with her mum and dad.

5128gap · 06/05/2025 18:49

Are you registered under the homeless duty as oppose to the regular list? If they bid for you, it suggests you might be. Most local authorities consider they will have discharged their homelessness duty if they make one offer. So if you turn it down you will lose your priority place. Sometimes this can be challenged though. Before you do anything, talk to Shelter to understand your rights.

FortyElephants · 06/05/2025 18:44

Take it! You would be absolutely mad not to!

Limprichteabiscuit · 06/05/2025 18:39

blubbyblub · 06/05/2025 17:54

not from the Uk so just wanting to understand how this works.

so if you don’t have the money to private rent you may be eligible for council housing.
but then in a year’s time you are in a great job, do you then surrender the council house? Or can you end up with people earning really good money in council housing that they got when they were poor?
if this is the case then is that not a bit weird?

It’s not about how poor you are , there is an upper limit earning cap however.

Its about NEED

Priorities given to:

Care Leavers

Veterans

Anyone who is about to be evicted - not given notice but evicted via court action

Anyone in Local Authority temporary accommodation-

-so those fleeing domestic violence
-there is risk to life eg kids involved with gangs/ county lines so that families need to be moved (loads in Peterborough from London/Nottingham)
-People who were evicted but could not be housed straight away or are homeless due to flooding or fire
-Asylum seekers who have been granted leave to remain and are in TA
-Substance misusers / ex street homeless people in hostel as part of moving on-
sped up if they have type 1 diabetes (need a fridge for insulin) as the risk of insecure housing is a factor.

Overcrowding/missing a bedroom- ( unless you deliberately put yourself in the situation eg. a family of 8 intentionally moving into a two bed house

-also a couple sharing one room property with a baby ( so long as lived there before baby was conceived)
-three kids in one room
-living in a dining room at parents for example
-opposite sex children sharing a room out of necessity over aged 10

That’s more or less it

crackofdoom · 06/05/2025 18:38

blubbyblub · 06/05/2025 18:16

So if there is a shortage wouldn’t one solution be to surrender the house if you earn over a certain amount? So there is enough for those in need? Why are rich people living in these houses whilst poor and needy are in emergency housing?

moving houses a couple of times in life is normal in the UK yes?

Vanishingly few "rich" people are living in social housing in the UK!!

But would you want to remove all incentive for people to better themselves?! I know quite a few people who are living in social housing and are now "comfortable", although few who would be able to buy their own house. But their situation has generally improved because they have affordable, secure housing- so the solution isn't to throw them out and make their situation insecure again- it's to build more social housing so everyone has the chance of getting some.

Cosycover · 06/05/2025 18:25

Desperation doesn't mean abandoning all practicality. If the offered house is too far from the only childcare support OP has, it could make working impossible. Being desperate doesn't mean you should make a choice that sets you up to fail.

Some of the replies here really lack empathy. Must be great to be able to judge people in these positions. Maybe save your pitchforks for the people running the country/systems instead of those simply trying to survive in it.

Limprichteabiscuit · 06/05/2025 18:21

DurbevillesGirl2 · 06/05/2025 18:15

OP said it was a flat in rough area, who would want to swap to that?!

There’s multiple reasons people swap, usually to be closer to family networks or work.
A lot of SH in cities are in so-called ‘rough areas’ it’s the nature of the beast.

Branleuse · 06/05/2025 18:19

Ask them if you would get another offer if you turned it down, but be aware that your next offer may not be as good, and youd be more sensible to take the flat and make the most of it.

WhitbyWoo · 06/05/2025 18:17

I wouldn’t risk turning it down. Your parents not driving wouldn’t be considered a valid reason.

How far is it from where you are currently?

What is your plan if the next offers made are equally as far?

Kirbert2 · 06/05/2025 18:16

This will entirely depend on your council, you need to look up their policy.

In mine, due to the banding I was on, I was coming 1st or 2nd in all applicable properties and policies made it very clear that turning down one would mean I'd be unlikely to stay where I was on the list. They never bid on any for me though which meant I was very careful as to what I did bid on because I knew it would be very highly likely that I'd be offered it and that is exactly what happened when I did bid.

blubbyblub · 06/05/2025 18:16

crackofdoom · 06/05/2025 18:03

Council housing was never intended to be just for the poor and desperate- it was originally for anyone who wanted it (typically the working classes).

However, since Right to Buy was introduced there is a severe shortage of social housing and councils are forced to prioritise who it goes to- usually those most in need. Once housed , your tenancy can be either for a fixed period or for life.

In recent years, rents have shot up- private far more than social- so it is entirely possible that someone can afford social rent but not private.

So if there is a shortage wouldn’t one solution be to surrender the house if you earn over a certain amount? So there is enough for those in need? Why are rich people living in these houses whilst poor and needy are in emergency housing?

moving houses a couple of times in life is normal in the UK yes?