Active discussions

Please or to access all these features

Talk
AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Original poster

To want fiance to get rid of his cats

759 replies

ellie09 · 02/05/2025 09:40

Hi all

I have been with my fiance for almost 3 years now and we will be moving in together in the next couple of months into my house, as mine is cheaper and we can save more for the wedding and to buy our own house (I live in a "family" home rent free and fiance currently rents on his own).

About a year into our relationship, he rehomed 2 kittens. They are house cats and very good natured but used to a really quiet environment.

I have a Rottweiler aged 6, who used to live with a cat when she was a puppy (before I rehomed her) but hasn't lived with one since.

Some concerns I have:

  • Shortly after getting his cats, I found out that I am allergic to them. If I go to his house, I need to make sure I take an antihistamine. If I forget to, I will get tight chest, sore eyes, runny nose etc.
  • His cats are house cats and I only live in a 3 bed terrace. I dont think there will be much room and I dont want any of our pets to go upstairs or lie on beds etc (its been a hard rule for my dog, and I would be enforcing it for the cats, especially due to my allergies)
  • I think the cats will struggle moving to a much noisier environment. I have a playful dog, and ASD child in a fairly smallish house. They're used to living in a really quiet environment
  • I have no idea how my much bigger dog will react to sharing a space with two cats

We are planning to "try" to introduce the animals beforehand and try living with them at least for a bit to see how it goes, but honestly, it sounds like a lot of hard work, especially with me and fiance both WFH and needing a quiet space also.

He is also aware that if my dog does not take well to his cats, that they will need to be rehomed.

AIBU to suggest just rehoming them from the get go?

Obviously, I am trying to put myself in his shoes if someone tried to persuade me to rehome my dog.

OP posts:
Grammarnut · 02/05/2025 11:51

galasphere · 02/05/2025 10:42

Childish?? Give over 🤣

Show quote history

Oh, come on! Men who play games all the time are being childish. He doesn't need a separate room for it. 😁

Original poster
ellie09 · 02/05/2025 11:49

MidnightPatrol · 02/05/2025 11:46

You are mad to rehome a Rottweiler into a small house with a child tbh.

What basis is this on? A biased view on bigger dogs or articles from dogs attacking children?

My dog has been with young children from a puppy. She loves children.

He has also grown up from a young age, never unsupervised and has been taught how to respect animals spaces. Unlike some children I see who run up and start patting unknown dogs in parks!

OP posts:
Catsandcannedbeans · 02/05/2025 11:49

I dumped someone because my cat didn’t like him, so maybe I’m crazy but I wouldn’t absolutely not be getting rid of her for any man. When we moved in DP had a dog, he was very happy and energetic and it did take a while for him and the cat to be introduced, but we both agreed at the end of the day if we can’t have them together moving in could wait. To some people that sounds crazy, but I wouldn’t give up my cat and I wouldn’t have put him through having to give up his dog. Other factors like we lived close and we were 21 so had all the time in the world probably helped.

scotstars · 02/05/2025 11:48

YABU if you were moving into his home would it be OK for him to insist you rehome your dog? It doesn't bode well for your relationship that you think him moving in to your home means you get to decide everything to suit you

Changeyourlifes · 02/05/2025 11:47

To be honest it doesn’t sound like you two should move in together. I know you’re engaged and tbh I don’t know what that means for your marriage. Just seems like a lack of compatibility. The new household set up sounds chaotic and no amount of potential monetary savings will balance that out. It’s not giving your relationship a stable foundation eg would he feel resentful if he needs to get rid of his cats for you? Would you feel resentful if he does not?

MidnightPatrol · 02/05/2025 11:46

You are mad to rehome a Rottweiler into a small house with a child tbh.

GeorgeMichaelsCat · 02/05/2025 11:46

Just wondering how you plan to keep the cats from going upstairs?

lonelyplanetmum · 02/05/2025 11:45

FeministUnderTheCatriarchy · 02/05/2025 10:19

This is absolute rubbish. I grew up with dogs. They would go to anyone and adored affection.

My cats pine for me, don't eat. Come racing to the door to see me, follow me around the house and are always within a few meters of me. They prefer me over anyone else and take a very long time to warm up.

I was connected to a cat charity and we saw cats literally die of heartbreak after their owners died or left them. They would stop eating and become depressed beyond help.

It is profoundly ignorant to say that cats don't bond like dogs do and it contributes to people treating them like shit in favor of "man's best friend".

Edited
Show quote history

Absolutely agree with this. Cats do bond completely with you. Mine follows me to the shed, putting the rubbish out, hanging out washing - he just likes being with me.

longtompot · 02/05/2025 11:43

I take antihistamine daily for hayfever and itchy skin (menopause). My dd is allergic to pet dander (has had allergy testing) but our cat has chosen her as her person and sleeps in her room. Dd takes antihistamine twice a day and hoovers her room a lot. Her bedding is washed weekly and she has an air purifier which all really help. It's not perfect and the allergy consultant wanted her to keep the cat out of her room, but that's not going to happen.

@ellie09 I know you say you don't want the cats upstairs, but realistically where will they go as their safe space? If your partner has a room for their computers, which you have given up as your office, I'd have that room as the cats safe space. Have a stair gate to stop your dog chasing them upstairs and that way you might be able to make this situation work.

Frequency · 02/05/2025 11:39

Cats are more adaptable than most people believe. Ours came from a similar environment as your DP's currently live in to a house with a rottweiler cross, two chihuahuas, and three people. They were unhappy at first, hiding under beds and only coming out when DD2 was on her own, but after a day or two, they got braver and ventured out more and more. They seem quite settled now. Ours also lost their person the day they moved. With yours, you DP will be moving with them.

TheNinkyNonkyIsATardis · 02/05/2025 11:38

MidoriNoRingo · 02/05/2025 11:27

I think mumsnet is the wrong place to ask. I don’t know anyone in real life who would put an animal above a human being.

It's not about the animal Vs the human being. It's about one human being's animals and another human being's animals.

They're moving in together for the first time, haven't lived together, OP has an SEN child (no mention if they will have more themselves), and her partner wants a gaming room when OP works from home. Oh, plus a rotweiller.

As someone with a cat in a terraced house, and a toddler, and both WFH, I know that this is a squeeze, and we have lived together in various places for the past 15 years.

It's not a good idea at all to start out living together in such constrained circumstances, IMO.

I think they need a better housing option and to live together a solid amount of time before getting married, and that's before you even think about the pets. (TBH, the rotweiller might be gone by the time they marry)

hydriotaphia · 02/05/2025 11:37

My mind is actually blown by the number of people voting YABU! It seems to me that this situation obviously won’t work - how can the OP possibly invite indoor cats into her home when (1) she is allergic and (2) she had a dog who likely won’t cope with them. It just can’t happen. So the choices are either the fiancé comes without the cats or he doesn’t come at all. Given that they are planning to spend their lives together OF COURSE there is absolutely nothing wrong with suggesting to the fiancé that he re-home them. It would be weird not to have this conversation given that the likely alternative is basically splitting up. This poll really cements my view that people just come on mumsnet for the opportunity to berate others.

JengaCupboard · 02/05/2025 11:36

I'm not sure you can ask him to do that - and equally I would be concerned as to the sort of person he was if he agreed to be honest...

I say this as a 100% 'dog person'. Flame me, but I don't care about cats; I had family cats historically and I can't even remember some of their names. That is not to say that I would give them away on somebody else's say so however.

Anyone who thinks re-homing a 6 year old Rotty is the same as re-homing two cats has no clue, cats would certainly be easier, but wouldn't make it right...

BangersAndGnash · 02/05/2025 11:35

I couldn't live with cats, being allergic, it just isn't comfortable, even with anti-histamines.

Do you know whether your Dc is allergic to cats? My Dc is so I wonder whether there is an inherited potential for cat allergy..

The two of you between you have practical challenges wrt moving in together.

Don't make it a battle of 'who is more selfish' or 'who is more unreasonable' or 'cats v dogs'....you intend to live together and eventually marry - solve problems together. It may be that now is not the right time to move in together.

JustSawJohnny · 02/05/2025 11:35

I wouldn't get rid of my cat for anyone. Especially a relationship.

I just wouldn't live together.

I'd also be utterly disgusted by a man who was prepared to get rid of a pet for me.

It's just horrible person vibes.

Hard nope.

Abracadabra12345 · 02/05/2025 11:34

@DisappearingGirl Cats need somewhere they can "escape" to if they want some quiet

I knew I was a cat in a previous life

Tarzofpan12 · 02/05/2025 11:33

It seems like you're just wanting him to slot into your life without disruption. It isn't all you and your house when you decide to live together. A 3 bedroom house is ample space to have 2 cats and a dog people have cats in less space than that. They do seem like excuses, why discuss living together if he's going to have to make these Sacrifices whilst you do nothing.

finallyskinny · 02/05/2025 11:32

I have dogs and cats and I would rather re home my husband than my animals! maybe you need to just break up if you can't accept his cats!

GeorgianaM · 02/05/2025 11:32

'and he got his 2 cats at a stage where we were talking about moving in together in the future. He got them knowing this may be a situation further down the line, but didn't really think about the repercussions back then'

He was t really that into you then and isn't into you now.

The relationship is not rock solid and he's just going along with the flow.

If you forced him to get rid of his cats he will always hold a deep resentment which he may use ago at you in arguments or even in his behaviour to get back at you.

Swiftie1878 · 02/05/2025 11:31

ellie09 · 02/05/2025 11:29

People seem to be thinking I am being unnecessarily cruel about the cats, but the cats will be in a massive change of environment also. Ever notice in rehoming ads, they'll specify environments each animal should be rehomed to?

I dont want to cause additional stress to the cats either. My house is a lot noisier and chaotic than they are currently used to.

Show quote history

That’s why you should delay moving in together.

Horticula · 02/05/2025 11:30

Poor poor cats, suddenly having to live with a Rottweiler and a child. I disagree with cats being house cats, but if they are it's going to be even harder for them. It's dreadful for either you or your partner to suggest rehoming them just for your convenience. The kindest thing would be to delay moving in together until your dog has died which you say is likely to be only a couple of years.

Original poster
ellie09 · 02/05/2025 11:29

MidoriNoRingo · 02/05/2025 11:27

I think mumsnet is the wrong place to ask. I don’t know anyone in real life who would put an animal above a human being.

People seem to be thinking I am being unnecessarily cruel about the cats, but the cats will be in a massive change of environment also. Ever notice in rehoming ads, they'll specify environments each animal should be rehomed to?

I dont want to cause additional stress to the cats either. My house is a lot noisier and chaotic than they are currently used to.

OP posts:
Aizen · 02/05/2025 11:28

I'm a firm believer that animals don't belong in homes.

Dogs should be workers, i.e. drug detection, sheepdogs, assistance etc.

Cats should be workers, i.e. vermin catchers on farms.

My DP is from a farming background, big family and not one of them will have a pet cat or dog, they are for working not petting.

Maybe that would solve the inexorable rise in pets everywhere now. Get them working and give them an NI number quick!

Swiftie1878 · 02/05/2025 11:28

MidoriNoRingo · 02/05/2025 11:27

I think mumsnet is the wrong place to ask. I don’t know anyone in real life who would put an animal above a human being.

@MidoriNoRingo
🙋‍♀️
It’s not putting an animal BEFORE a human being. It’s waiting until the animal won’t be adversely impacted.

Callie247 · 02/05/2025 11:28

Slightly different but I had a rottweiler when I met DP. He cried when he found out and said he didn't want to have this conversation but he's not a dog person and doesn't like dogs. So I said well you've got a decision to make then haven't you because the dog isn't going anywhere. We're still together 10 years later but nothing, absolutely nothing would make me get rid of my pet. Not even a partner.