Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel if they say no that I may as well bloody well give up on working? And that women are still having to make the compromise?

234 replies

AnwI · 02/05/2025 08:15

I’ve just been offered a great job. I have a DD who is starting school in September. There is an after school class that is until 5pm. However, for me to get there in time to collect her I would need to leave the office at 4pm. I’ve asked the recruiter to ask this and she’s waiting for a reply.

This job comes with a massive pay rise, it’s a good career move and since becoming a single parent when dd was 3 I’ve done everything I can to keep going. Ex does his bit financially but does absolutely nothing in the week…I’ve tried many times to ask him to change work pattern etc but he says he can’t (or won’t).

I am going to feel absolutely deflated and resentful if this company does not agree to this. I know it’s not the company’s job to ensure my dd is looked after etc etc (im familiar with these points!) but the entire office industry is set up for working men who came home to housewives running the home. I am trying my best here and yet I feel it’s all stacked against me…I absolutely hate that I’ve had to even ask it at all as I wish I could just work as late as I wanted in whichever location I wanted.

I am going to be so crushed if they don’t agree to it.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
OliveWah · 03/05/2025 19:01

Fingers crossed the organisation gives the thumbs up to the flex plan, but if not, don't despair!

Most schools will have a "Parents of X school" Facebook page, you could ask on there if anyone has recommendations for a childminder for your DD from September until 6:30pm each day. You could also ask the school if they have any recommendations, or see if any of the staff of the after school club fancy doing 90 mins extra paid childcare at the end of the session? Or how about asking staff from her current Nursery?

Failing that, I would advertise for a part time Nanny role, and ask them to collect from school at the end of the school day (rather than after school club) and do homework and dinner with her at home before you return at 6:30ish. A Nanny is more likely to be interested in 18 hours a week than just 8 or so.

It's crap that it all falls on you to organise, but it is possible. Best of luck to you with your flex request, keeping my fingers crossed for you @AnwI!

DollydaydreamTheThird · 03/05/2025 18:32

CrownCoats · 03/05/2025 08:13

I agree with you OP. Women have been trained to put other women down. It’s the patriarchy at its finest.

You employer has a huge role to play in fixing this, and can do it quite easily without any negative impact on their bottom line. They just choose not to.

Exactly. Sometimes the biggest misogynists are women. They have been so brainwashed they can't even see it in front of their noses.

Radra · 03/05/2025 15:40

UncertainPerson · 03/05/2025 15:18

Well I suggested moving as an overall strategy to make your life easier, as commuting is tiring and it will be hard to facilitate eg picking up your kid if they are sick from nursery if it is ‘very remote’. But yes clearly I am a woman putting down another woman and enabling the patriarchy 😆

Yeah I don't think it's the patriarchy's fault that OP has set up her life to be so hard

Needlenardlenoo · 03/05/2025 15:34

After school, we've used after school club (paid for private school mainly to be guaranteed 7.30am to 6pm cover each day without needing to book plus good holiday club at extra cost); used an after school nanny; used the adult son of a friend as informal pre-school childcare; negotiated some flexibility on start/finish times (this is the important part) in jobs we were already in. Also did swaps with friends and adopted an older friend as "honorary granny" for awkward stuff like parent's eves where you can't take the child and events during the school day (we're both teachers so if we've got a lesson/lecture, we must be there).

You can solve most childcare problems by throwing cash at them if you choose your school and location sensibly. And when you find a decent employer, stick to them like glue!

UncertainPerson · 03/05/2025 15:18

Well I suggested moving as an overall strategy to make your life easier, as commuting is tiring and it will be hard to facilitate eg picking up your kid if they are sick from nursery if it is ‘very remote’. But yes clearly I am a woman putting down another woman and enabling the patriarchy 😆

Radra · 03/05/2025 12:02

The point about location is really that it's fine if you want to live in the middle of nowhere a long way from your workplace and your child's school but then it's not going to be a surprise that you might need childcare after 5pm if you want a senior role.

Gandalfatemyhamster · 03/05/2025 11:49

@HotCrossBunpleasebecause
1.) our children have often gone through a significant adjustment or even multiple house moves before and we want to limit disruption. Kids of divorce are already sensitive to change.
2.) we have to consider where our ex lives and can’t move too far from them, or they’ll moan and may well reduce contact which fucks up our lives more.
3.) our support networks might be close to our house which helps us. Not necessarily in terms of school pick ups but if there is an emergency or just can provide company or support us in other ways e.g. will look after kid for an hour whilst we go to the shop or get our hair cut.
4.) we are less likely to be approved for a mortgage as a single breadwinner. We face discrimination by estate agents/ banks. We could be limited in terms of houses we can afford and don’t want to move into the rough areas. Maybe OPs school is in a much more affluent or much rougher area? Why would she want to move there?

KeenDuck · 03/05/2025 10:48

Kalikaa · 03/05/2025 10:23

Yes, why make life so difficult?

Move through school and yourself closer to work.

Of course the danger is what happens if she moves out and then two weeks later they make her redundant.

That happened to an ex of mine. He literally completed on a Property on the Saturday and on the Monday morning was called into a meeting completely reassigning his patch.
Spent three years commuting 2 1/2 hours a day.

HotCrossBunplease · 03/05/2025 10:37

People telling me to move house and so on like it’s the most simple thing. I’m a single parent and can’t just up sticks like that.

Surely a single parent with a child not yet at school is in a much better position to move house than someone who has to accommodate another adult’s needs, job situation and opinions, or someone who would need to move a child’s school?

There may be other reasons why moving is not an option but I’m not buying that being a single parent is the issue.

You also haven’t explained why your child will go to school in a remote place.

WobblyBoots · 03/05/2025 10:30

Pigsears · 02/05/2025 08:57

Um not in my experience!

Mine neither. I'm so great full for the massive flexibility my workplace offers that give the work I do absolutely everything. I am also flexible in the opposite direction and when on occasion I need to work a bit more in the evenings I do it.

All the women I know who have flex at work are pretty loyal to their jobs as they value it so much.

Fingers crossed OP I hope you get the flex you're after.

Kalikaa · 03/05/2025 10:23

UncertainPerson · 02/05/2025 11:04

Can you move house if you have a long commute and your DDs nursery is ‘very remote’?!

Yes, why make life so difficult?

Move through school and yourself closer to work.

CrownCoats · 03/05/2025 08:13

AnwI · 03/05/2025 07:33

Thanks for all the posts, I still have a few pages to read. All posts are appreciated!

I am quite surprised at the attitude of some posters, probably not to be unexpected given the situation I am in in the first place.

To answer a few questions… no ex wasn’t like this when we were together but obviously when you are separated the dynamic changes. I’m not excusing his lack of practical care for dd but highlighting that blaming me for my choice in man as to why I am unable to progress at work is absurd.

There was a poster talking about other people wanting flexibility and where does it end. I don’t understand this view point. My post is about the fact that this company could easily accommodate a 4pm finish and I am able to work flexibility. Of course some jobs are impossible to make that work. Large companies are however at the heart of the patriarchy as they are built upon it. I’m genuinely quite shocked that so many posters don’t see this… but I suppose that’s how the patriarchy maintains its grip, it hides in plain sight.

People telling me to move house and so on like it’s the most simple thing. I’m a single parent and can’t just up sticks like that.

From a philosophical perspective it’s interesting that all I am trying to do is a good job furthering the human race yet in doing so the world works in such a way to try and make it as difficult as possible. That’s not a ‘woe is me’ comment… I just find it sad that so many people (women included!) think that’s ok. I know it’s not and will always stand up for women, especially those simply wanting jobs that men have historically held.

Ps still haven’t heard back 😅

I agree with you OP. Women have been trained to put other women down. It’s the patriarchy at its finest.

You employer has a huge role to play in fixing this, and can do it quite easily without any negative impact on their bottom line. They just choose not to.

Dozer · 03/05/2025 07:43

I see / experience the problems in organisations, the unfairness for mothers and the ‘presenteeism’ silliness. It’s really hard to get and keep a good job as a mum with a deadbeat dad ex. It sounds like you have a good prospect to do so with this job.

But I don’t think focusing / reflecting on all that will help you. In your shoes my priority would be getting and making a good start in the job, mostly on their terms then hoping for more flexibility later - or if not a stronger CV to move elsewhere with more flexibility. In the short term seeking childcare to 6pm would help you. In the longer term a house move might, as this challenge will continue.

My DC were in childcare to 6pm Monday to Thursday during primary, it wasn’t ideal but financial stability has been good.

AnwI · 03/05/2025 07:33

Thanks for all the posts, I still have a few pages to read. All posts are appreciated!

I am quite surprised at the attitude of some posters, probably not to be unexpected given the situation I am in in the first place.

To answer a few questions… no ex wasn’t like this when we were together but obviously when you are separated the dynamic changes. I’m not excusing his lack of practical care for dd but highlighting that blaming me for my choice in man as to why I am unable to progress at work is absurd.

There was a poster talking about other people wanting flexibility and where does it end. I don’t understand this view point. My post is about the fact that this company could easily accommodate a 4pm finish and I am able to work flexibility. Of course some jobs are impossible to make that work. Large companies are however at the heart of the patriarchy as they are built upon it. I’m genuinely quite shocked that so many posters don’t see this… but I suppose that’s how the patriarchy maintains its grip, it hides in plain sight.

People telling me to move house and so on like it’s the most simple thing. I’m a single parent and can’t just up sticks like that.

From a philosophical perspective it’s interesting that all I am trying to do is a good job furthering the human race yet in doing so the world works in such a way to try and make it as difficult as possible. That’s not a ‘woe is me’ comment… I just find it sad that so many people (women included!) think that’s ok. I know it’s not and will always stand up for women, especially those simply wanting jobs that men have historically held.

Ps still haven’t heard back 😅

OP posts:
Hopelesscase32 · 02/05/2025 18:35

KeenDuck · 02/05/2025 10:01

A nanny for a school aged child ?

Yes

Viviennemary · 02/05/2025 17:18

Why can't you just get a childminder. But ask by all means.

rosemarble · 02/05/2025 16:48

I don't deny it's an issue, but I don't think its necessarily up to the employer to solve the problem if they need their staff to work specific hours.

OP says the job can be done flexibly, wfh in the evening etc.

For jobs that can be done this way, employers making it easier for employees to do so (ie stating in the job ad, mentioning at interview) would make things so much easier. Wouldn't it be nice for OP to be in a position where she didn't need to ask, but that she could go into the application process stating "I can work 40hrs / week and evenings as necessary with notice. My core hours will be 9-4pm and then I will do 7-9pm [or whatever]"

PatsFruitCake · 02/05/2025 15:32

Gandalfatemyhamster · 02/05/2025 10:15

@PatsFruitCakeso if it’s the same for both parents, why is it women taking 99% of the pay cuts/ lack of progression opportunities/ asking for flexibility?
I worked in a hospital in the pandemic. There was a female consultant who had to request to drop to two days a week due to homeschooling. Her husband couldn’t possibly be expected to help out due to his job. Bearing in mind she was a doctor in a pandemic. He was a solicitor. He wasn’t even doing the two days she was at work, they got a family member to drop in.

Dads, on the whole, are not making these sacrifices.

That's because some women have children with selfish twats. I understand it's difficult, I've raised 3 DC myself and worked throughout that time without a break. However the father of my children has never considered that caring for them was solely my responsibility.

I don't deny it's an issue, but I don't think its necessarily up to the employer to solve the problem if they need their staff to work specific hours. If the OPs ex would step up then it wouldn't be such a problem for her.

jannier · 02/05/2025 14:04

AnwI · 02/05/2025 08:19

@Shatandfattered she would have to be picked up and driven home and I wouldn’t be back until gone 6:30pm. I don’t think that’s right to do that to her and it would cost a huge amount due to the travel element.

A childminder takes child from school to their home often giving dinner you collect from them. Many children do this from a lot younger. You maybe eligible for financial help.

Gandalfatemyhamster · 02/05/2025 14:00

@Twilightstarbrightand that’s with two of you. But according to all these posters if you got divorced your ex would definitely step up and do exactly what you needed him to do for the good of your career, which no longer concerns him.

grecian2025 · 02/05/2025 13:55

Theroadt · 02/05/2025 11:51

You are batting every suggestion back which makes me wonder whether you have actually looked into alternatives properly of whether you are just sticking with leaving at 4pm. And elsewhere you say thd job requires flexibility into thd evening but how is that going to work in practice, if you don’t have support/backup?

This. You are coming across as completely inflexible with a this is the business' fault and they need to solve it for me. There are solutions out there, it isn't a unique situation. That alone will put employers off. They need employees who can deal with and solve problems. Be careful you don't sabotage this job before you start.

Twilightstarbright · 02/05/2025 13:45

I’m not sure my DH would have finishing at 4pm approved at his work (senior professional role like the OP). He does do it, as do I but it’s an ever changing balance of what’s in the diary and what the need is. My boss has no issue with me leaving at 4pm if I’m not missing anything big but if I left halfway through a Board Committee he would be unhappy.

We both do these kinds of jobs FT and commute into London, we use wraparound care 7.30-6pm. It’s hard!

EastEndQueen · 02/05/2025 13:19

OP, I get it - I think most parents get hit in the face a bit by the way that wraparound childcare isn’t ‘set up to work’ in any way. It’s frustrating and even more so when you don’t have a partner (or ex) willing to take on their share.

BUT I think this has to be faced, just like the vast majority of working parents do, especially in professional roles. As others have said, in an established role where you are known and valued, the offer of finishing at 4pm and making up an hour later in the evening might well fly. Especially if they operate a core hours model. But when you are an unknown quantity and they have no idea whether or not you would meaningfully make up the extra hours, if would put you at serious disadvantage to other candidates.

Several things to consider:

  • Have you asked around about local childminders, other mum’s willing to lift share etc ? That childminders are full for other people on this thread is totally meaningless. Have you checked Koru kids or with local universities or FT colleges (nursing or midwifery or other caring/ DBS professions can be a win.
  • Au pairs are a thing, I have one. It’s expensive and a pita but at a certain point you need to invest in back up if you have no other backup (I have no helpful family for 300 miles+)
  • Is another nearer school possible or one with later wraparound? Ours is till 6.30

Bottom line is that if you want the well paid professional role then childcare is a work expense and it’s best to just accept that and think about what works best

HoskinsChoice · 02/05/2025 12:33

AnwI · 02/05/2025 08:15

I’ve just been offered a great job. I have a DD who is starting school in September. There is an after school class that is until 5pm. However, for me to get there in time to collect her I would need to leave the office at 4pm. I’ve asked the recruiter to ask this and she’s waiting for a reply.

This job comes with a massive pay rise, it’s a good career move and since becoming a single parent when dd was 3 I’ve done everything I can to keep going. Ex does his bit financially but does absolutely nothing in the week…I’ve tried many times to ask him to change work pattern etc but he says he can’t (or won’t).

I am going to feel absolutely deflated and resentful if this company does not agree to this. I know it’s not the company’s job to ensure my dd is looked after etc etc (im familiar with these points!) but the entire office industry is set up for working men who came home to housewives running the home. I am trying my best here and yet I feel it’s all stacked against me…I absolutely hate that I’ve had to even ask it at all as I wish I could just work as late as I wanted in whichever location I wanted.

I am going to be so crushed if they don’t agree to it.

Did you apply and interview for the job going all the way to offer stage before asking this question? It is to be hoped that they can work to your hours because if they can't you've just cost you and, more importantly, them an awful lot of time and money.

HoskinsChoice · 02/05/2025 12:30

AnwI · 02/05/2025 08:22

@HoskinsChoice large companies are part of the patriarchal structure. They’re still in the main ran by men and men from a generation where they’ve done very little outside work in terms of parenting.

That's irrelevant. Stop looking for someone else to blame. It is not for companies whether they are small or large, male or female led to ensure you can parent your child.

Companies will continue to be run by men if women can't even manage their own time let alone a company's.

Swipe left for the next trending thread