Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Toy guns/weapons

59 replies

MumbleJumble123 · 29/04/2025 15:19

Am I being unreasonable to really, really hate these.
I honestly can’t understand who’s buying them or why anyone would want to buy a replica gun for their toddler/young child.

I’ve just picked my 3 year old up from nursery and another mum has brought a gun to the playground for him to play with during pick up (there’s a small park/plaza outside the nursery where parents take their kids to play if they’re not in a rush).

My son saw the gun and announced ‘I want one too’. I initially just said no like I do with most of the other plastic tat he asks for.
But then he said ‘but I need to kill people, pew, pew, pew’. (He obviously doesn’t actually understand what this means, he’s just copying)

I’m quite upset about this, I really didn’t want him exposed to this stuff so young. Obviously stopping him playing with other children isn’t an option so how do you explain in a way that he understands why they’re bad and why he’s not allowed it.

It feels different to when I just say no because we don’t need anymore dolls, trucks or Paw Patrol dogs.

Am I being unreasonable for having such a strong reaction and feeling like I need to make a bigger deal than when I just say no to other toys.
If so, what do I say/do?

OP posts:
GoodCharl · 29/04/2025 16:10

Just let him be. He only wants a plastic gun for goodness sake

minnienono · 29/04/2025 16:08

Unfortunately even if you ban guns they seem to improvise, old bottle, wooden brick, stick … I banned them and one dc is an officer in the military, seems they are interested in things you say no to!

BobbyBiscuits · 29/04/2025 16:05

I think it's a common part of child development to have toy 'weapons'? Maybe not so much now but I remember having toy guns, plastic swords, water pistols etc. it's literally just play fighting. The idea of goodies and baddies.

I don't think I've ever heard a court case where a kid stabbed someone up and their defense or the prosecution blamed it on the fact they had a toy sword when they were four?

Jellycatspyjamas · 29/04/2025 16:00

In my experience they get to a stage where anything can be repurposed to play with like a gun. Sticks, whisks, wooden spoons - we ended with with an extensive Nerf gun collection. He’s 12 now and showing no signs of being a mass murderer.

Needmorelego · 29/04/2025 15:51

The ones that look like real guns I don't like. That means the aim of the game is to pretend you're killing someone or something. Horrible.
I often see ones that look like AK-47s etc for sale on market stalls. I really hate those.
Nerf, paint or water guns are ok because the aim of the game isn't to pretend you're killing.
At age 3 you could start gently explaining what "killing" means. He probably doesn't understand it yet - because no one has taught him yet.

MumbleJumble123 · 29/04/2025 15:45

DancefloorAcrobatics · 29/04/2025 15:27

😁 good luck with that one!

I'm opposed to guns like you. But it didn't stop DS having them... we had a stick collection at some point: machine guns, pistols, knives and he was given a few replica ones. (I did draw a line at nerf guns!!)
He's a lovely teenager now but sadly not grown out of it! So he's a member of the archery club and is in the air cadets for the shooting/ weapons.

Just go with the flow, the more you opposed it the more they want it.

I know I can’t stop him being exposed to it, but I was just hoping he’d be a bit older and be able to understand a bit more. He still seems so little and innocent that it really bothered me that he was talking about killing people.

When he’s older/a teenager and can understand the nuance I’d be ok with stuff like archery, fencing, cadets, target shooting etc.
I just hate that my toddler is playing a game where he pretends to kill people.

OP posts:
friendsonly · 29/04/2025 15:30

I completely agree.
letting your child (and it’s always boys) have plastic guns/knifes to practice and get enjoyment out of pretending to kill and hurt people is terrible parenting.

DancefloorAcrobatics · 29/04/2025 15:27

😁 good luck with that one!

I'm opposed to guns like you. But it didn't stop DS having them... we had a stick collection at some point: machine guns, pistols, knives and he was given a few replica ones. (I did draw a line at nerf guns!!)
He's a lovely teenager now but sadly not grown out of it! So he's a member of the archery club and is in the air cadets for the shooting/ weapons.

Just go with the flow, the more you opposed it the more they want it.

Hottchoc · 29/04/2025 15:23

You are being ridiculous