Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand how people fund their lives and feel a bit jealous?

614 replies

Travelenthusiast · 28/04/2025 08:23

Just that really. Mid-30s and we have what I have always seen as a healthy income of £180k per annum (obviously been lower when we were younger and increased over time), and had some family help - about £50k to buy our first house several years ago.

And i’m not complaining about our quality of life- I know we are lucky and can afford a good holiday every year, and a more expensive/ luxury holiday occasionally. DS does a few extra-curricular activities, we don’t have to worry about the food shop total (we aren't extravagant at all) and can afford to eat out a few times a month etc. And I know we are lucky as I grew up in a poor family and understand the stress and implications.

But we have a very modest 3-bed house (with a big mortgage), our car is ten years old and there’s no way we could replace it, we can rarely afford to replace clothes and shoes for us (of course do for DS), days out are thought through to reduce cost, would make pack lunches to take into work and don’t buy shop coffees, we could not afford private school, and often we cut out the eating out to add to savings instead- basically £ is not abundant. And we are relatively careful financially and not big spenders generally. None of this is me saying our life is bad- I know we are really luckily, but just trying to give an idea of limitations / life.

We do live in SE commuter belt (not london) where everything is very expensive.

But we are surrounded by families who have so much more, so apparently effortlessly. We are genuinely one of the only local families without a 4x4 (i know cry me a river 🤣). How do others have it all and have the big house, the new car, endless holidays, SAHM often, the new clothes, meals out, lots of savings? Is it simply that they earn much more? I know we are lucky but I just don’t understand how so many can be so wealthy? Could most of our network really have a household income over £200k?!

OP posts:
Tryingtokeepgoing · 29/04/2025 13:03

HomeTheatreSystem · 29/04/2025 12:35

I think if you earn £10k a month you'd imagine you could afford a nice house in a nice area, new clothes and shoes as and when needed, a nice car or two and a lovely annual holiday. OP can afford some of these things, but not all and is simply wondering why, and how everyone else seems to manage it. It is pretty obscene that £10k net a month won't cover all that.

The slightly distressing reality is, if one earner has a salary of £180k, puts 7% into their pension and is still paying a student loan on the post 2012 scheme (which someone in their mid thirties could be) then their take home pay is around £7,700. That's not far off 50% gone before it hits the bank, and whil clearly very comfortable is not really in 'high earner' as in top 5% level.

I think also that we can't 'cope' with the level of visibility we have over everyone's lifestyle because of social media nowadays. Based on instagram or whatever, it appears as if someone is always having an extension, a new kitchen or has moved to a bigger house, but it's not all of your friends and it's not every year. Each time it's s different one. There is always someone on a fantastic holiday, but it's not everyone of your friends and (with the odd exception) its not the same people all the time. There's always someone getting a new car, better car, additional car, but again it's not everyone every year. But all you see on your feed is 'people' having a new car, a fantastic holiday or a new kitchen and you think you should be able to do all of that at the same time.

The reality is you need to be a high or very high earner for long enough to save / invest enough, have cleared the mortgage to be able to do everything you want. £180k, regrettably, is not enough. And mid 30's is (a) not old enough for most to be at the peak of their earnings potential, (b) too young to have benefitted from asset / property price growth much and (c) too young, unless unlucky, to have inherited much.

Helpforthosethatneedit · 29/04/2025 12:56

lechatnoir · 28/04/2025 10:43

As I said to OP, not everyone living there is commuting into London and earning mega money! There are still TA's, cleaners, retail & hospitality staff etc earning minimum wage who manage to live in the area. Compared to our relatives in the NW we do feel significantly poorer despite being on similar incomes. Obviously not everything is more expensive here but as a few examples, B&SIL live in a 3 bed semi like us - £80k mortgage paid off. We have 10 years left on our £180k mortgage and are frankly, bloody lucky it's so little purely because we are old enough to benefit from house price rises. I used to pay £7ph for my DC's childminder 5 years ago (per child) my SIL now only pays £4.20ph. G&T in my local pub £7.40, £4.90 in hers.

We have a combined income of c.£55k and we manage OK. We socialise with some very wealthy people who I suspect would never in a million years imagine we earn 'so little'. But please don't think everyone in the SE is rich.

I said nothing about the south east. I live on the south east. Very confused by your response?

HomeTheatreSystem · 29/04/2025 12:35

I think if you earn £10k a month you'd imagine you could afford a nice house in a nice area, new clothes and shoes as and when needed, a nice car or two and a lovely annual holiday. OP can afford some of these things, but not all and is simply wondering why, and how everyone else seems to manage it. It is pretty obscene that £10k net a month won't cover all that.

eurochick · 29/04/2025 10:34

peachie82 · 28/04/2025 14:40

Wow that to me is a huge salary. More than double our combined income. I’m amazed you can’t replace an old car or buy new clothes when earning almost £200k.

Tax means the difference isn’t as much as you would think.

on 2 salaries of £40k the take home would be around £65k for the household, plus you would be eligible for child benefit, free childcare, etc.

On one salary of £180k the take home would be £107k and there would be no child benefit or free childcare. It is still a substantial amount but less than you might think from the gross figure.

tortieCatLover · 29/04/2025 09:34

Tryingtokeepgoing · 29/04/2025 07:55

The problem is £180,000 between two people isn’t really enough to let you live like the tope few %, because you’re not earning enough, and you haven’t been earning at that level long enough to accumulate wealth. There’s an article in the economist about this - you are a Henry. High Earner Not Rich Yet

Our 30s with new mortgage and young kids was the hardest decade - but we'd spent our 20s saving the 50K the OP was gifted for a house.

I did look round but knew why others had more ( we had way lower income than OP) - they didn't go to Uni so bought houses earlier so had lower mortages and hosues already done up so they'd been paying off longer and often had at least partial help with childcare. A house move to one needing less work and better mortage deal and wage increases meant early 40s were a lot easier.

I would have thought inhertance or more debt - maybe interest only mortages - or higher incomes would be the obvious anwer for the OP. Though I agree if she waits it out pays down mortages builds saving next few decades should be much easier but in meantime she really should look at her spending and where they are priotising.

BertieBottsEveryFlavourBeans · 29/04/2025 07:57

You can't afford to replace clothes and shoes for you and your DH but you can afford a yearly holiday, sometimes a luxury holiday? You need to get your priorities straight.

Tryingtokeepgoing · 29/04/2025 07:55

The problem is £180,000 between two people isn’t really enough to let you live like the tope few %, because you’re not earning enough, and you haven’t been earning at that level long enough to accumulate wealth. There’s an article in the economist about this - you are a Henry. High Earner Not Rich Yet

SummerDaysOnTheWay · 29/04/2025 05:56
Biscuit
WinterFoxes · 29/04/2025 05:51

If you stop eating out a few times a month, you'll have plenty of money for clothes. You can replace the car on a loan to sale set up.

SapporoBaby · 29/04/2025 05:39

On £180,000 you should be able to afford to replace your car and get a bigger house and buy new clothes. Look at your outgoings because clearly something isn’t adding up.

But the answer is - they either: manage their money batter or have different priorities, earn more than you, have taken out loans or have family money/ lottery money. Those are the options.

Greenandchocolate · 28/04/2025 23:48

InveterateWineDrinker · 28/04/2025 20:23

I'm glad someone has brought this up. It's not just the vibe that holidays are essential, I often get the impression that they are some kind of entitlement, and with that comes the belief that only luxury foreign ones are worthy of the epithet.

I sometimes think that the people who think like this must be so deeply, deeply unhappy with their normal day to day lives that temporarily escaping from them is the only coping mechanism they have.

People do all sorts of things to temporarily escape reality. Although admittedly some are more expensive than others… and some are healthier forms of escapism than others…

A few spring to mind :

Binge watching tv, listening to true crime podcasts, reading books, drinking wine, immersing themselves in celebrity gossip, even engaging in romantic relationships or popping out another baby can sometimes be a form of escapism or distraction from the day to day reality …the list goes on! Just because something enriches your life and you prioritise it - it doesn’t necessarily mean you’re unhappy. Or if it does the same applies to people doing all those other things I’ve listed above.

BlessedBeTheGroot · 28/04/2025 23:28

Wow, £10k is more than I get in a year (am on benefits).
I manage to pay bills, and be able to eat, clothe myself and have a bit for hobbies.

If you can't on £180k then.... I don't even know.

BunnyLake · 28/04/2025 23:23

Keirawr · 28/04/2025 21:12

OP, you money doesn’t stretch very far, because you are paying buckets of tax to pay benefits for people who are having a go at you on this thread.

Pathetic and nasty (and no I’m not on benefits).

toomuchfaff · 28/04/2025 22:31

BunnyLake · 28/04/2025 15:15

Why do supposedly intelligent people not understand this? Saying you earn blah blah but by the time the school fees, massive mortgage on our five bed detached house, holidays three times a year, children’s horse, ice skating, ballet, piano and violin lessons are paid for we barely have enough to redo our kitchen, build the extension and have a swimming pool installed. People don’t appreciate that a six figure salary is barely over the poverty line :(

I know..... right! How can one be expected to live like this 😫

Missohnoyoubetterdont · 28/04/2025 22:30

Vaxtable · 28/04/2025 22:24

You have a joint income of £180k and can’t afford new cars

what do you spend your money on!

Or shoes?!!!?

Vaxtable · 28/04/2025 22:24

You have a joint income of £180k and can’t afford new cars

what do you spend your money on!

Charltonstrek · 28/04/2025 22:18

Bore off op

DrLottie · 28/04/2025 22:00

You probably just need to move away from the SE! Honestly, we own a detached cottage with 8 acres in a rural spot further north in the UK, run two (albeit ancient) 4x4s, and still manage a family holiday every year, on a THIRD of your income.

Flightfromhell · 28/04/2025 21:20

Kindersurprising · 28/04/2025 20:53

What you’re essentially moaning about is house prices. I get it - even a really healthy salary can’t get you much more than a very ordinary smallish house in MANY areas (not even just the really posh ones). We’re the same, but jointly earn 100k and live in the SW. Even then a nice 3 bed with an average garden that isn’t in a state of disrepair is £450,000 unless you want to live in the middle of the local sink estate. It’s really depressing.

Just checked Rightmove for an expensive area in the SE near London and there's a few semi detached 3 bed houses for £1.2 - £1.3million - that's a potentially huge mortgage - maybe £6000 a month. It's not any fancier than elsewhere but it's the location that adds the ££££ - we'll never know as OP isn't coming back.

Keirawr · 28/04/2025 21:12

OP, you money doesn’t stretch very far, because you are paying buckets of tax to pay benefits for people who are having a go at you on this thread.

Shelllendyouhertoothbrushtoo · 28/04/2025 21:06

Wtf. Is your other half squirreling away half your money or something? My husband is starting a new business and our joint income is currently about £70k. From what you've said we're living the same lifestyle but we have 3 kids and debt from previous serious illness. We have a very low mortgage but this still doesn't add up.

Kindersurprising · 28/04/2025 20:53

What you’re essentially moaning about is house prices. I get it - even a really healthy salary can’t get you much more than a very ordinary smallish house in MANY areas (not even just the really posh ones). We’re the same, but jointly earn 100k and live in the SW. Even then a nice 3 bed with an average garden that isn’t in a state of disrepair is £450,000 unless you want to live in the middle of the local sink estate. It’s really depressing.

ChompinCrocodiles · 28/04/2025 20:42

Bringing in £10k ish net every month and can't afford to replace clothes and shoes.

Did anyone get the tiny violin out yet or is it just so small I missed it?

LooserWooner77 · 28/04/2025 20:34

OP, I think you need to budget.

Perhaps share your incomings and outgoings?

Feelingstrange2 · 28/04/2025 20:31

I agree.

I find holidays away tiring! Sometimes they are a means to an end but I do love being at home in the garden!

We luckily live in Cornwall but when the kids were small we often went camping the other side of town! Honestly any camp site is like being away. And the kids could take friends because their parents just dropped them.off!

We did have some foreign holidays. The children now they are older remember all our holidays with fondness though. The memories are not exponentially better based on price.

Swipe left for the next trending thread