Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask DM to stop smoking in her own house

158 replies

ReadTheBlurb · 27/04/2025 09:17

My mum, now in her 50s, has been a heavy smoker as long as I can remember. I was embarrassed by it as a teenager because my school uniform always smelled smoky, and people would make comments at school (none of my friends parents smoked then, and actually my DM is the only person I know who smokes to this day). I've never been a smoker myself and I can't stand the smell of stale smoke.

DM knows I dislike it and makes a point of smoking outside when I visit her (she lives alone). But it's really obvious that she smokes indoors the rest of the time. The smell of smoke hits as soon as you walk in the door. Every room smells of it, even those she doesn't use and definitely doesn't smoke in, such as the guest bedroom I sleep in. When she buys gifts, I have to wash them before use because they smell. When I visit her, I have to shower soon as I get home and wash everything I've taken into her house, the smell is so strong (DH avoids visiting her now because he hates it too, and won't come near me until I've showered after a visit). She herself smells very unpleasant, despite trying to mask with gum and perfume.

I'm about to have my first child, her first grandchild, as I'm an only child myself. She's very excited and I know she's picturing the kind of relationship she had with her gran and I had with mine - sleepovers at hers and quality time together just the two of them. And selfishly, I hope for the same thing, so that DH and I can catch the odd break and enjoy time together! But, I really hate the idea of my child going into a smoky environment, both for health reasons and the practical/aesthetic issue of everything being smelly and needing washing after every visit.

DM clearly doesn't realise that it smells and is "noseblind" to it; if she did, she wouldn't bother to go outside to smoke in my presence, and she obviously thinks she's being courteous to me by doing so. I'm sure she would do the same when her grandchild visits. But the problem isn't the fresh smoke, it's the embedded smoke. Would it be unreasonable for me to tell her how bad she and her house smells, and to request that she puts a stop to indoor smoking altogether, as a condition to have her GC in her house? (And if any MNetters agree this is fine, advice on how to handle it sensitively would be appreciated!).

YANBU - a smoky environment is horrible and not suitable for a child.
YABU - it's her house and she's entitled to smoke in it if she chooses.

OP posts:
justasking111 · 27/04/2025 10:12

Buy her one of those disposable vapes. Have a chat with her about her health. You want her around to see babies grow up. Ask her to please try the vape. She's young enough to try something new.

My mil had a big health scare when I was pregnant with her first grandchild. Alcohol related. She was 64. She stopped drinking and lived another twenty seven years.

Flossflower · 27/04/2025 10:10

ReadTheBlurb · 27/04/2025 09:23

How would you suggest I raise the issue of refusing to take the child to her house, without raising the smoking issue? If I just never go to hers after the baby is born, without explanation, she'd be very confused and hurt.

I should probably add that she doesn't drive and lives an hour's drive from us, so unless we go to her, she wouldn't see us.

I think you really just have to tell her how it is.
You simply cannot take your baby into a house where she smokes or let her handle the baby when she has recently smoked.
You never know this could be the incentive for her to give up.
One of my grandchildren has an another grandparent who smokes. The grandchild is not allowed to go to their house. When the grandchild was a baby the grandparent would shower and put on clean clothes, then not smoke before coming over to see the baby. They stayed until they had to smoke and then left. The grandparents accepted this.

Eggsinthewhoopsiebasketalready · 27/04/2025 10:10

When your baby arrives the natural instincts to protect them will outweigh the feelings of a woman happy to smoke herself to an early grave..

OoLaOoLa · 27/04/2025 10:09

thepariscrimefiles · 27/04/2025 10:04

Surely your friend would have known about the risks of smoking around babies, even if she didn't know the extent of harm caused by second and third-hand smoke? I'm very surprised that she didn't work it out herself over the three years before she spoke to her son about it.

Nope it didn’t even cross her mind, and between me and her she thinks the dil is over the top with the issue.
She’d never say this aloud though to her dil or her son she has changed her habits.

SalfordQuays · 27/04/2025 10:08

I agree with others OP. You just have to tell her that all the current research shows that exposing young children to second and third hand smoke is harmful. She’ll obviously say that it didn’t do you any harm, and you can point out that times have changed and advice is different.

Also, she’s only in her 50s. It’s not as if she’s 85 and been smoking for 70 years. She could give up. My Gran smoked from age 16, but still managed to give up at age 60 when my brother was diagnosed with asthma.

You’ve just got to be straight with her. And actually OP, I think you’ll find it easier when your baby is born. The protective instinct is quite overwhelming. Nothing else matters as much.

Middleagedstriker · 27/04/2025 10:07

ReadTheBlurb · 27/04/2025 09:23

How would you suggest I raise the issue of refusing to take the child to her house, without raising the smoking issue? If I just never go to hers after the baby is born, without explanation, she'd be very confused and hurt.

I should probably add that she doesn't drive and lives an hour's drive from us, so unless we go to her, she wouldn't see us.

Can she get public transport?;MIL gets the train and bus to see us and she is 80. We also go and see her but means it's not always us.

Endofyear · 27/04/2025 10:05

It's difficult because you obviously want your children to have a close relationship with their Grandparents but I think you do need to raise it with her. It's worth emphasising that it's for her health too as you want her to be around to see your children grow up. Would she be open to switching to vaping? That's something you could explore with her and support her in.

thepariscrimefiles · 27/04/2025 10:04

OoLaOoLa · 27/04/2025 09:56

I’ve got a friend who is a heavy smoker. When her first grandchild was born and she realised that her son and dil were visiting everyone else in the family with the baby and not her, she was really upset.. didn’t know what she’d done wrong.
This went on for the first three years and she only saw the baby if she went to them, the dil mum was the one who got offered babysitting duties ect.
In the end she asked her son what the problem was, she was heartbroken because she’d pictured a much closer relationship.
When he told her.. It’s your house mum, it stinks of cigarette smoke she changed immediately. Washed all the soft furnishings, deep cleaned the house and now only smokes outside and washes her hands after.
The little boy can now go round there and she wishes they’d told her sooner.
How would your mum take it, surely she’d prefer the conversation to stop smoking indoors now rather than trying to guess why she can’t have her grandchild in the house.

Surely your friend would have known about the risks of smoking around babies, even if she didn't know the extent of harm caused by second and third-hand smoke? I'm very surprised that she didn't work it out herself over the three years before she spoke to her son about it.

OoLaOoLa · 27/04/2025 10:04

Devilsmommy · 27/04/2025 10:01

Not all smokers are like that. I'm a very heavy smoker but I wouldn't smoke in my house with my toddler, even if he wasn't here. Unfortunately for op it is kind of an awkward situation to try demanding someone doesn't do something in their own house

As a heavy smoker wouldn’t you rather that your daughter asked you to not smoke indoors rather than risk not having a relationship with your grandchildren?

Moveoverdarlin · 27/04/2025 10:04

I was going to say you’re being unreasonable until I got to the baby bit. On the day I left hospital with my day old son, the midwife gave me a debrief and said if you have any smokers visit make them wash their hands and take off their top layer of clothing before holding the baby. This was 2015.

I would have a serious chat with her, maybe go shopping for baby bits, have a lunch and say. ‘Mum I want you really involved in the baby, I’d love for you to have them as much as possible, I want you to have the relationship with my child like I did with Granny. But I have one concern, you know what I’m going to say don’t you? It’s the smoking Mum. It’s so harmful to children and not just fresh smoke, it’s the lingering old smoke. I’d like nothing more for you to give up smoking by the time baby arrives BUT I know you’re a grown woman and it’s a lot to ask, but I want you around as long as possible and we all know smoking will cut your life short. It will. But if you won’t do that for us, could you start smoking outside permanently? I know you’re going to think I’m being bossy or pushy or an OTT Mum to-be but I just wanted to put it out there. I’m so lucky to have a Mum in her 50s who is still really young and I just want you to be involved as long as possible but I can’t leave the baby in a smokers house Mum. It’s too harmful.

See what she says, it might just start the conversation. Surely you want her to give up? And not just smoke outside?

CopperWhite · 27/04/2025 10:03

I’m a smoker, and most smokers I know would agree that smoking needs to be done outside.

toomuchfaff · 27/04/2025 10:03

You can't dictate what SHE DOES IN HER OWN HOUSE.

You can dictate that you won't allow your child to go in that house.

You can dictate that you won't stay there.

You can only dictate YOUR OWN REACTION.

Misspotterer · 27/04/2025 10:01

ReadTheBlurb · 27/04/2025 09:59

This is good to hear and I'm glad your DM changed for you. My mum is a difficult lady who takes things very personally, so I've spent most of my life avoiding confronting her on anything just to maintain a peaceful existence. But obviously it's no longer just about my wellbeing, I'll have a child to consider too, and her feelings are third to mine and the baby's.

My mum's not the easiest either. Takes everything personally, fond of the silent treatment, BUT, she absolutely loves babies so I think that overrode everything.
Good luck. I would just say have an honest conversation.

Devilsmommy · 27/04/2025 10:01

BonfireToffee · 27/04/2025 09:23

There doesn’t seem to be a lot, including children, that will come between smokers and their cigs.

Not all smokers are like that. I'm a very heavy smoker but I wouldn't smoke in my house with my toddler, even if he wasn't here. Unfortunately for op it is kind of an awkward situation to try demanding someone doesn't do something in their own house

ReadTheBlurb · 27/04/2025 09:59

Misspotterer · 27/04/2025 09:45

My die hard smoker mother stopped smoking in her house when the first grandchild came along nearly 20 years ago.
She thought it was fine just to not smoke in the house when he was there but I pointed out to her the dangers of 3rd hand smoke and that absolutely everything was covered in it. I also guilted her for the health risks to my poor non smoking dad. She still to this day only smokes outside even though all the grandkids are almost adults now.
This was a woman who smoked in the house throughout my own childhood, on the buses next to me, in restaurants, everywhere! Smoking indoors is grim and I told her she wouldn't be seeing her grandchild if she continued smoking indoors. Can you not just be straight with your mum?

This is good to hear and I'm glad your DM changed for you. My mum is a difficult lady who takes things very personally, so I've spent most of my life avoiding confronting her on anything just to maintain a peaceful existence. But obviously it's no longer just about my wellbeing, I'll have a child to consider too, and her feelings are third to mine and the baby's.

OP posts:
OoLaOoLa · 27/04/2025 09:56

I’ve got a friend who is a heavy smoker. When her first grandchild was born and she realised that her son and dil were visiting everyone else in the family with the baby and not her, she was really upset.. didn’t know what she’d done wrong.
This went on for the first three years and she only saw the baby if she went to them, the dil mum was the one who got offered babysitting duties ect.
In the end she asked her son what the problem was, she was heartbroken because she’d pictured a much closer relationship.
When he told her.. It’s your house mum, it stinks of cigarette smoke she changed immediately. Washed all the soft furnishings, deep cleaned the house and now only smokes outside and washes her hands after.
The little boy can now go round there and she wishes they’d told her sooner.
How would your mum take it, surely she’d prefer the conversation to stop smoking indoors now rather than trying to guess why she can’t have her grandchild in the house.

Gassylady · 27/04/2025 09:56

Another one here with a mum who smoked throughout my childhood but then lots of my friends mums did too, could still smoke on buses and in cafes etc. I grew to hate the smell to the point of retching when home in uni holidays and getting back into the house.

Lived 50 miles away by the time had the first grandchild. Told her baby wouldn’t be coming to the house she needed to come to us but we would come and collect her. Kids only went there when they were much older for short periods, never overnights and I made clear why. She didn’t like it but tough, it was always freezing because she’d had doors and windows open to reduce the smell.

After she died the walls were bright white behind pictures and mirrors and yellow elsewhere. All the clothes, bedding and towels needed washing multiple times before donating. It reinforced for me that I’d made the right decision when I saw how it had affected the house let alone young lungs.

TidyDancer · 27/04/2025 09:55

You can’t tell someone else what to do in their own house which you know, the only way to approach this reasonably is to make clear the consequences they are not in control of if they continue.

Personally I would wait for the next time she mentions spending time with the baby and say something along the lines of ‘I’d love that but obviously the baby won’t be able to be here, will she/he?’ Then when she questions it (which presumably she will) reply with ‘well I can’t have the baby around the smoke can I? As you smoke indoors the baby won’t be able to come to the house at all unfortunately!’ If you present it as a done deal rule rather than something you’ve randomly decided on then it’s harder for it to become a debate with ill feeling. If she says she’ll stop then comment about getting the house in a ‘healthy’ condition etc. If she doesn’t then that’s on her not you.

nessiesnotreal · 27/04/2025 09:53

I had this with my Mum when I was expecting my first. I just took her out for lunch and just broached the subject over a cappuccino and a sandwich. Told her that it would be difficult for me to visit the house with the baby due to the smoke.

She was actually really reasonable and made the decision herself that from now on she would only smoke outside. Or if it was raining she would stand at the patio doors and blow the smoke outside. It worked! House was smoke free and started to smell much better. She did it because she knew how important it was to me and because she also wanted to keep her grandchild away from the smoke.

Can you chat with her about it without making demands and see what her reaction is?

Eyesopenwideawake · 27/04/2025 09:53

@ReadTheBlurb On the offchance your mum would like to give up but thinks she's too old or set in her ways, tell her that a Mumsnetter (me!) smoked heavily for 50 years but managed to give up easily. It can be done, if she wants to.

ReadTheBlurb · 27/04/2025 09:53

Thanks for all the suggestions so far. My DM is quite a difficult lady with a bit of a victim complex, so I know that she'll likely take this very personally if (or rather, when) I call her out on the smoking issue. Our relationship over the years has been volatile and she doesn't like me challenging her, but I'm taking hope in the idea that becoming a grandmother will be a catalyst for change - in many ways, not just the smoking issue.

I'll take on board the comments that have suggested I just need to be blunt, and explain why we won't be visiting her at her home. It'd likely be a couple of years before any overnight visits away from home would start anyway, so perhaps asking her (as opposed to telling her) to adjust her smoking habits by a particular point might be a compromise/motivator for her too.

I'm case anyone missed my earlier update, she doesn't drive and lives in a different town, so I always end up going to her as it's a longer journey on public transport for her to come to us. Hence why, if she isn't providing a suitable environment for her GC to be in, it will make it difficult for her to have regular contact.

OP posts:
Calliopespa · 27/04/2025 09:51

And the sooner the better op. A deadline works wonders. Work towards her holding your newborn Dc,.

Mulledjuice · 27/04/2025 09:51

thehorsesareallidiots · 27/04/2025 09:25

Why would you not raise the smoking issue? It's bleeding obvious why you wouldn't take a baby into her house. You tell her that the baby isn't going there because of the damage to its lungs from all the ingrained cigarette smoke.

This.

And unfortunately if the smell is that ingrained in the house it won't be enough if she didn't smoke another cigarette from this day forward.

Calliopespa · 27/04/2025 09:50

CalypsoCuthbertson · 27/04/2025 09:39

before the baby is born start dropping into conversation things about smoking. Say how happy you are that she goes outside to smoke as you don’t like being exposed to it. Make up a friend whose relatives smoke and say oh my god she exposes her baby to smoke I could never do that.
basically start dripping into her ear how much you hate smoking. Do this over a period of time.

Don’t do this - it’s manipulative. Have a straightforward, honest and calm conversation about it.

Yes I think this will make her feel attacked.

One face to face conversation. Say it’s important beforehand.

The drip drip approach is just nagging and niggling at her

caramac04 · 27/04/2025 09:50

It’s harsh but smokers tend to die younger and/or have more frequent chest infections/ toe amputations etc than non-smokers.
A new dgc might provide the reason for your dm to give up smoking. I’m sure her gp will offer support.

Swipe left for the next trending thread