Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To discuss the societal impacts of older parents?

541 replies

Kindersurprising · 26/04/2025 21:22

I feel like this is a really under-discussed area, particularly as it’s now really extremely common (particularly in middle class circles) to have a first baby after 30 and in many cases 35+.

I feel like in 20 years we are going to see quite a big impact, in adults having fewer (if any) siblings due to parental age, caring for elderly parents while having small children themselves, a lack of grandparent support and I guess a smaller family circle much earlier on. I only realised today that it will be vanishingly rare for kids to have great grandparents soon - my DC have only one, through me.

The positives are often cited as more money, and more life experience.

I was 30 when DC2 was born, so somewhere in the middle and not a young parent as such. I often wonder what it would be like to have had them earlier.

How do you think this will play out in the next 20-50 years?

OP posts:
AliBaliBee1234 · 26/04/2025 23:08

Kindersurprising · 26/04/2025 23:02

Having grey hair doesn’t mean you’re unhealthier or die earlier?

She clearly isn't saying that. But nobody notices okder mums now because they don't look older.

And we are living longer and being healthier. With medical advances everyday, who knows how much better things will be in 40 years.

Wouldratherbetherethanhere · 26/04/2025 23:07

Are you just trying to upset people?

I had my Dd at age 39, after neair

Bingbopboomboomboombopbam · 26/04/2025 23:07

dynamiccactus · 26/04/2025 21:57

Maybe they'd prefer to go travelling and enjoy their early retirement while they still have their health,

Of course, I’m not saying it’s a given.

I was just saying that realistically they have more time to be grandparents if they’re not workers.

meevee · 26/04/2025 23:07

If millions of women were having their first dc in their 40s the OP may have a point but that's not the case

Devonshiregal · 26/04/2025 23:07

CarrotVan · 26/04/2025 21:37

I had older parents (Mum, 46 & Dad, 50) and I was a carer from the age of 10.

I knew my dad’s parents but my mum’s died before I was born

my older siblings (20 year age gap to my eldest) STILL didn’t know our great grand parents but knew both sets of grandparents

it was shit having older parents, more shit because of added disability leading to caring at a young age. I was a carer for 30 years until they’d both died and have brought up kids along side (as have my siblings)

That must have been really tough for you and I say this gently and just because it’s part of the discussion, but how is old age relevant here? why were they both disabled? Not old age - they weren’t old when you became their carer. I mean people did used to seem older at 60 or even 50 than they do now but even then, most people were not/are not needing care in their 50s or 60s. And even despite your parents’ disabilities, you were 40 when they died so their age didn’t prevent you having time with them.

people get way too worked up about this all anyway. Life is short and muddled. People have ups and downs and do things at different times to other people. Have different experiences and different bodies and health issues and mental health issues and all sorts. There is not a perfect time to have kids. People regularly get sick when they’re young and young people become disabled too. Mental health can be debilitating and twenties are often a very bad time for this even if physically good for having kids.

(for what it’s worth I had older parents too and it’s not been an issue for me. Had other friends with older parents - in fact most of my school friends did.) only One girl got really worried because her mother, who was the younger partner, kept bleating on about how her dad was sooo old. Well the guy is still fit as a fiddle over two decades later and all that worrying was for nothing. On the other hand, a friend of mine who was desperate to have kids young so as to avoid the pitfalls of the ‘geriatric pregnancy’ had them in her 20s and has since been diagnosed with an incurable degenerative condition which impacts all of their lives on an almost daily basis.

and yes there’s the whole ‘it’s more likely they’ll die’ thing. Of course! But I’m not about to start telling a loving mother not to have a kid because she’s over 35 ffs. Let’s focus our attention on worrying about the people who actually harm kids, not just the ones for whom life didn’t pan out to a perfect timescale.

Spaceracer10 · 26/04/2025 23:07

My parents were ‘older’ when they had me, I had my children in mid to late 30s and thankfully my parents have been a fantastic help and enjoyed doing so. They’ve kept themselves healthy and fit down the years

People are living longer and are staying healthier so consequence wise it’s not a biggie. Generally
children don’t ’look after’ their elderly these days anyway, they pack them off to the OAP home / outsource the care.

People generally can’t afford to have children young these days. In olden days you might get a council house, these days you get fuck all.

Advantages of older parents are they can often provide a financially stable home and the benefit of their experience. Many older mums are in my experience, educated with a good career so know how to look after themselves and their children well

snackatack · 26/04/2025 23:06

I think the people who are shocked about childcare bills will be really shocked when they find out how much care homes cost.

I hear all the time at the outrage of the cost of childcare.. but rarely how that cost is about the same as a care home fees... only child care is about 8 hours a day and care homes are 24/7

merrymelody · 26/04/2025 23:06

MidoriNoRingo · 26/04/2025 21:30

I need to look up that stats for children with severe disabilities and parental age. I work in respite care for severely disabled children and all of the parents are older.

FWIW, I insisted on having amnios during both my pregnancies to rule out any possible ‘complications’ due to being over 35. XH was 13 years older than me and we didn’t think we’d be able to care for a severely disabled adult child into old age. Fortunately both DC are now relatively healthy adults (my DD is epileptic).

Nsky62 · 26/04/2025 23:06

TaupeMember · 26/04/2025 22:57

Are you that dense to think that your one experience is evidence for anything?

That’s unkind, no need, unfortunately due to child care costs, and housing it’s harder to have children these days.
It’s relative to the time frame or decades from which folks had their children years ago.

JLou08 · 26/04/2025 23:06

Bababear987 · 26/04/2025 21:35

I think it's been discussed a lot.

My opinion is that older parents (age brackets as above) will only bring about more self aware, confident children which will overall be a benefit to society.

Yes there are negatives as mentioned above but life experience, maturity, patience, stability (financial and physical) leave people better suited to bring up children. I know a few friends who had children young with big age gaps before having the second child and all have found it to be a more positive experience and that they were in a far better place to raise children when in their 30s as opposed to early twenties.

With regards to having less grandparent involvement, I'm not sure it matters as my parents are still working FT and I'm mid 30s with 1 child so it wouldnt be any different if I'd had them in my 20s. With regards to great grandparents I had 2 that I remember but the truth is as young children they didnt bring an awful lot to my life as they were both elderly and we only saw them occasionally and I was mostly afraid of them as a child and found them boring.

In general a smaller family circle isnt necessarily a bad thing- as seen repeatedly on here so many people have such toxic family with outdated attitudes that children would be better off without. People can grow a village of support and make friendships which are just as fulfilling if not more so than some relatives.

I had a big gap with my children, for me the experience in my 20s was much, much more positive. I had more energy, more patience, loved playing with them, sleepless nights had very little impact on me. I've found it more challenging having 1 in my late 30s, although my youngest is disabled so that makes parenting a lot more challenging, but the disability may also be a result of me and DH having him older as the risk does increase with parental age.

Kindersurprising · 26/04/2025 23:05

Ghosttofu99 · 26/04/2025 23:01

You can’t win.

Teen mother - Tut tut
Mother in 20’s - but she could have achieved x, y, z.
Mother in 30’s - leaving it a bit late aren’t you?!
Mother 35+ - Tut tut, destroying the traditional extended family, ‘causing’ additional needs
Spinster - ignored

Its fun being a woman

I think if everything else is in place, 30 is a sweet spot as it balances the 2 extremes. You’ve also had a decent number of years being able to do fun spontaneous things.

OP posts:
NetZeroZealot · 26/04/2025 23:05

Christ OP.
I had my DC at 32 & 35. They are now 23 & 26. My parents are mid - late 80s and only just starting to need a bit of extra help from me. DH has retired & I expect to retire in a year.
If there are problems ahead I’m not seeing them.

Thisshirtisonfire · 26/04/2025 23:05

Don't act like this hasn't always happened! I've just had my 3rd at 37. It wasn't planned.. I naturally fell pregnant. Women would regularly be having babies into their 40s if fertile in the past . The age menopause starts has not massively changed over time..
It's absolutely not some modern thing to be having babies in your 30s ffs!!!
What you maybe mean is having your first child then..
But honestly what real difference does that make?
Biggest worry is a dwindling birthrate and an aging population.. not the age women are having babies at but that they are just not choosing to have them at all in the UK!
For what it's worth it had my first at 27 and I felt like a teenage mother. I was the youngest in any group I attended. Only one of my friends had had a baby at that point..
But now I'm 37 not many more of my friends have had babies either!! They've just chosen not to be mothers.

AliBaliBee1234 · 26/04/2025 23:05

SouthLondonMum22 · 26/04/2025 23:03

Exactly.

My parents weren't abusive and tried their best but they were young when they had me and my sister and it was always a struggle financially. I didn't want children for a long time because of it but I eventually realised that things could be very different if I had my own children and I was determined it wouldn't be such a struggle financially which meant not having my first DC until 36.

I did the same thing at 33. Really made sure I was ready in everyway. Learned from their mistakes I guess!

Notsandwiches · 26/04/2025 23:04

The positive is kids will inherit at an age which will benefit them rather that when they're old. My parents had me at 23. I became a parent at 32 and 41 then 42.

Blondebrownorred · 26/04/2025 23:03

SwedishEdith · 26/04/2025 21:27

I don't think many people except to know their great grandparents.

I had 2 great grandparents until I was mid 30s. My DS was 10 so had 2 great great grandparents.

MermaidMummy06 · 26/04/2025 23:03

I think lifestyle plays a part, not just age. MIL was 23, FIL late 20's when DH born. A poor lifestyle led to MIL being too ill to work or drive by 60 & required full time care. Passed at 70. FIL's now rapidly declining. He's the same age as my DM, but more like my DGM was at 100. They never exercised, ate poorly & didn't look after their health (MIL was extremely obese).

My own parents were DM 31 & DF 35 when I was born (old then!). They're 76 & 83 now & still require no help (except tech!) from me. They eat well, drive, travel & still walk 5km round trip to the shops for coffee & lead full lives. This will change eventually, but the point I'm making is that lifestyle & genetics play a part, not just age.

TaupeMember · 26/04/2025 23:03

Kindersurprising · 26/04/2025 22:41

My thread isn’t about advantages to individuals, it’s about the effect on society in the future. Do you remember the ‘what will happen when boomers die?’ thread? There were loads of interesting points made on there - from the predictable ‘the property market will ease up’ to the more interesting ‘who will take on voluntary work at National Trust properties/charities’ etc

This was supposed to be the equivalent of that thread - not so people can gnash their teeth about their individual circumstances, but to discuss longer term impacts in more interesting ways.

Tbh I won’t reply to you again as you seem really het up

I'm not het up at all, just saying things you don't want to acknowledge.

If you wanted to genuinely discuss the effects of older parents on society, you'd be up for acknowledging the advantages bestowed upon society by families with older parents of which many have been stated.

You'd also not be spoutingnconstant mistruths, and stating things as facts with no evidence or links to back them up.

And certainly not be accusing anyone who disagrees with you and calls you out on the above of being 'het up'.

Laughable that you come on here pretending you want to discuss a sociological idea in such a one sided and biased way.

SouthLondonMum22 · 26/04/2025 23:03

AliBaliBee1234 · 26/04/2025 22:57

It is believed millennials are breaking cycles of abuse and childhood trauma and I believe this is why.

I had a very damaging childhood with parents who were too young and not ready.

Exactly.

My parents weren't abusive and tried their best but they were young when they had me and my sister and it was always a struggle financially. I didn't want children for a long time because of it but I eventually realised that things could be very different if I had my own children and I was determined it wouldn't be such a struggle financially which meant not having my first DC until 36.

Kindersurprising · 26/04/2025 23:02

ouch321 · 26/04/2025 23:02

I have no children so fall into neither category but much better an older parent than someone like you, OP, who takes pleasure in trying to make strangers feel guilty about the way their life has played out. Not a great example to be setting your children to indulge in online nastiness. One of the downsides of having children young funnily enough, the lack of maturity issue.

You may have a 'professional job where I can sign people's passports' (nice little side brag there) but this thread and your posts on it reflect poorly on you.

😂

OP posts:
Kindersurprising · 26/04/2025 23:02

usernamealreadytaken · 26/04/2025 23:01

Older people now are generally younger. DM had me when she was 33; I always remember her being old and she died when she was 60. I saw a photo of my GGM when she was my age now (early 50s) and she was an old lady with grey hair and looked like how I remember my Nan from childhood. I am not an old lady. DC were born when I was 29 and 31; not sure whether that makes me an older mum or not, but we’re finally financially secure and can help DC, while still hopefully having 20/30 good years left in us. Age isn’t what it used to be, because we age better.

Having grey hair doesn’t mean you’re unhealthier or die earlier?

OP posts:
ouch321 · 26/04/2025 23:02

I have no children so fall into neither category but much better an older parent than someone like you, OP, who takes pleasure in trying to make strangers feel guilty about the way their life has played out. Not a great example to be setting your children to indulge in online nastiness. One of the downsides of having children young funnily enough, the lack of maturity issue.

You may have a 'professional job where I can sign people's passports' (nice little side brag there) but this thread and your posts on it reflect poorly on you.

Ghosttofu99 · 26/04/2025 23:01

FlutterShite · 26/04/2025 22:47

This is what I was wondering. Go back in time to have another go? Kill ourselves and remove the problem from the world? Or maybe just feel ashamed while people feel superior and tut-tut about those hateful older mothers?

You can’t win.

Teen mother - Tut tut
Mother in 20’s - but she could have achieved x, y, z.
Mother in 30’s - leaving it a bit late aren’t you?!
Mother 35+ - Tut tut, destroying the traditional extended family, ‘causing’ additional needs
Spinster - ignored

Its fun being a woman

usernamealreadytaken · 26/04/2025 23:01

Kindersurprising · 26/04/2025 21:22

I feel like this is a really under-discussed area, particularly as it’s now really extremely common (particularly in middle class circles) to have a first baby after 30 and in many cases 35+.

I feel like in 20 years we are going to see quite a big impact, in adults having fewer (if any) siblings due to parental age, caring for elderly parents while having small children themselves, a lack of grandparent support and I guess a smaller family circle much earlier on. I only realised today that it will be vanishingly rare for kids to have great grandparents soon - my DC have only one, through me.

The positives are often cited as more money, and more life experience.

I was 30 when DC2 was born, so somewhere in the middle and not a young parent as such. I often wonder what it would be like to have had them earlier.

How do you think this will play out in the next 20-50 years?

Older people now are generally younger. DM had me when she was 33; I always remember her being old and she died when she was 60. I saw a photo of my GGM when she was my age now (early 50s) and she was an old lady with grey hair and looked like how I remember my Nan from childhood. I am not an old lady. DC were born when I was 29 and 31; not sure whether that makes me an older mum or not, but we’re finally financially secure and can help DC, while still hopefully having 20/30 good years left in us. Age isn’t what it used to be, because we age better.

AInightingale · 26/04/2025 23:00

I hear you OP. I live in a community where it's common to have your kids really young. One of my son's friends is 15, has a mum of 41, a 24 year old sister who is also a mum, a granny of 60, and great grandma of 80-odd.

In so many ways not ideal, yet having struggled with my own kids completely alone, (primary school ages when I was in my 40s), elderly mother with dementia and my own fecking menopause, I now ENVY that type of family so much!

You hear so many people saying 'well my parents are in their 70s and fit as fiddles', but in my experience, once grandparents are in their 80s things take a very different turn and you can end up in a bleak place, as users of the Elderly Parents board here will testify.