Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To give her this stuff for free

140 replies

Capnbagn · 26/04/2025 17:17

DH and I are in the middle of a debate about this. A young mum recently moved to our area, I won’t go into the details of her situation but she is widowed, been forced to move up here because of danger and has 4 children under 5. I met her through the church playgroup I take my grandchildren to, but I used to be a social worker so I feel a lot of empathy for her situation. She is from this area originally but has no family left here and she seems very stranded if I’m honest.

DH and I are down sizing, so a lot of furniture and stuff has to go. This woman has been in temporary accommodation and just offered a council house, she has nothing to even start furnishing it but obviously the homelessness team and her health visitor are directing her towards resources for things like white goods. Anyway the things I know for sure we don’t need in our new home are
-Dining Table & Chairs (good condition but nothing fancy just from ikea)
-2 Ikea extendable beds (bought for the grandchildren hardly used)
-2 Wardrobes, Chest of Drawers, 2 bedside tables and a dressing table from our room, they are only a little over a year old but the new house has built ins and I want something different anyway. They were just from Argos so again nothing fancy!
-Table and Chairs for the garden, it’s a sturdy metal set we bought a few years ago, needs repainted but otherwise in good condition
-Play Kitchen, our youngest grandchildren are now 4 and due to start school so won’t be around as much to use it, nowhere for it in the new house anyway.

I want to offer her this stuff for free, we don’t need the money, selling it on marketplace seems like a ballache and all she would need to do is pay for a van to pick it all up.

One of my friends has also offered 2 large chest of drawers and 2 further wardrobes, a sofa and an arm chair (basically brand new but they are white and she is too scared her grandkids will destroy them!) and a bunk bed. She said she’d want some money for all this but would be happy with £300 or so, which the woman has accepted and is over the moon with. I know she’s still stressed about getting the rest she needs though.

Obviously she doesn’t have to accept anything I offer her but I feel like it would be a nice thing to do.

DH thinks I’m crazy and if I want to offer I should ask for some money in return even if it’s just £150/200 as it’s a lot of stuff, all in amazing condition.

Im more inclined to think that the £200 would do very little for us in our situation but potentially a lot for this mum, therefore I don’t feel right asking for that.

AIBU wanting to give her all this for free? DH thinks it will create an expectation that we will give her money but I really don’t think it will and she is nothing but lovely, never asked for money or anything.

OP posts:
ilovesooty · 26/04/2025 17:31

EveryKneeShallBow · 26/04/2025 17:29

It’s a kind gesture, but it doesn’t only belong to you. Your DH and s entitled to his opinion and I agree with PP that it is better for her self esteem to give you something for it.

While I agree that the stuff belongs to her husband too, why should others be the judge of what is good for this woman's self esteem? That sounds like a patronising viewpoint to me.

Doseofreality · 26/04/2025 17:30

Different situation but when my parents died I gave away all their furniture for free, some of which was almost new. It didn’t feel right to profit off it and it made the process easier for me.
i think if you can afford to do that act of kindness, it would be much appreciated.
i

EveryKneeShallBow · 26/04/2025 17:29

It’s a kind gesture, but it doesn’t only belong to you. Your DH and s entitled to his opinion and I agree with PP that it is better for her self esteem to give you something for it.

WandaWomblesaurusWonka · 26/04/2025 17:27

She’s probably struggling financially to even out food on the table so your offer will be very kind.

ilovesooty · 26/04/2025 17:27

You're generous - your husband less so. It would be a lovely gesture.

SunshineAndFizz · 26/04/2025 17:27

That’s very kind of you, if you don’t need the money I’d give it away for free.

Maybe ask her to cover the transport costs, i.e. if you’d need to hire a van?

TheTigerWhoCameToBrunch · 26/04/2025 17:26

That is a really kind thing to do, I wouldn’t ask for any money if you really don’t need it. She will appreciate it so much.

ReplacementBusService · 26/04/2025 17:24

I'd give it. She needs it, you don't. Perfect timing!

KidsDoBetter · 26/04/2025 17:23

You are in the right. What is the point of charging her a nominal amount. We are currently buying a house from older downsizers and they are struggling to get rid of items like you describe. They will probably end up paying a clearance co

MaryGreenhill · 26/04/2025 17:22

As long as you can afford it OP then it's a very kind thing for you to do .

Wowzel · 26/04/2025 17:22

If I didn't need the money I wouldn't ask for it in this situation.

YourSnugHazelTraybake · 26/04/2025 17:22

I'm sort of with your dh. Not that i think it'll give her expectations, but it might feel less like charity and paying a 'small' ( in relation to what she'd be getting) amount might be good for her self esteem.

TheyreThreeTheyreSixTheyreNineandTen · 26/04/2025 17:20

YANBU.
Why would giving her items lead to an expectation of money? It’s nice to do something nice op.

murasaki · 26/04/2025 17:20

What a lovely offer, go for it.

hoopoemagic · 26/04/2025 17:19

I think it sounds like a lovely thing to do.

Swipe left for the next trending thread