Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boyfriend lied to me about getting banned from his gym

386 replies

ScarlettRunner · 26/04/2025 14:01

Hi all,

I would appreciate a bit of a hand hold here, I’ve only found out this morning and don’t know what to make of it all.

My boyfriend is really into the gym, goes most days etc. About a month ago he told me he was changing gyms as he needed a bit of a change of scenery and because his had got really busy, I felt it was odd as I know he really liked it there but thought nothing more of it.

Out shopping this morning I bumped into an old colleague who also goes to the original gym. We had small talk and she asked how my BF is, and said she thought it was ‘harsh’ what happened to him.

I asked what she meant and she was apologetic and said she thought I knew, and that her understanding was my BF had his membership cancelled due to a complaint by another member, and that I’d need to ask him about it.

I phoned him as soon as I left that shop, and he admitted this was true. He says he made what he thought was an innocent comment which was laughed off by a woman in there at the time but she complained to staff after and he received an email re. the cancellation.

Anyway, he said a woman was doing squats and he joked to her after ‘I thought your leggings were going to split’.

He didn’t want to tell me about this because he tonight I’d be annoyed but he says he feels hard done by and that he was clearly joking.

I can’t work out whether I’m right to be upset about the comment or if it’s him hiding it which is making it feel worse, it’s just a bit embarrassing all round.

He’s adamant the gym over-reacted and to be fair, that’s what my old colleague suggested too.

OP posts:
diddl · 26/04/2025 16:02

Why did he have to say anything to her at all?

What was he hoping by it?

bungobungobungo · 26/04/2025 16:02

Don’t usually comment on this kind of thread but I’m so glad the gym in question took the action they did. Sorry he lied to you though!

ambercabs · 26/04/2025 16:01

ScarlettRunner · 26/04/2025 15:50

Just to address a couple of the replies (including the charming request to STFU-such anger!) - I am not defending him at all. I have stated he should not have said it. I was just interested on some other views as the non MN ones I’ve heard all think the gym over-reacted.

Any what about the fact he lied to you? Are you seriously remaining in a relationship with a man you cannot trust?

BankHolidayBonanza · 26/04/2025 16:00

She's filming her workouts and putting them on social media for anyone to see?

Oh dear. It might be a big leap, but I can picture a few people like this.
I would just move on from there and forget about it. I absolutely think the gym over-reacted.

I wish gyms could crack down on people who confuse a public gym with their private recording studio. Some people would love to concentrate on their own workouts as it happens.

Don't get me wrong, if he was using his stupid Joke as a chat-up line, I would not forgive him, but because it's awful 😂

Fadesto · 26/04/2025 16:00

He stared at a woman squatting, then made it clear he’d been letching and objectifying her, to the point she felt uncomfortable, then he lied to you. Overreaction from the gym or not, or this woman being a PITA or not (what are your bfs friends basing this on? Her not thinking men commenting on her arse is hilarious?) I wouldn’t appreciate my DP doing any of that anyway.

Bellsize · 26/04/2025 15:59

ScarlettRunner · 26/04/2025 15:50

Just to address a couple of the replies (including the charming request to STFU-such anger!) - I am not defending him at all. I have stated he should not have said it. I was just interested on some other views as the non MN ones I’ve heard all think the gym over-reacted.

"Sexual harassment is illegal in the UK and can be a criminal offense. It's considered unlawful under the Equality Act 2010 and can also be prosecuted under the Protection from Harassment Act 1997. Specific behaviors, such as unwanted touching or comments of a sexual nature, can be grounds for criminal charges if they cause distress or alarm."

Looks to me that the gym could be liable for your BFs criminal behaviour.

Fioratourer · 26/04/2025 15:57

He shouldn’t have said it. He basically said I was checking out your arse. Which is probably why he didn't tell you.

ilovesooty · 26/04/2025 15:56

Bellsize · 26/04/2025 15:44

He also showed me a message to
him from one of the staff who basically said the woman who complained is a known pain in the arse and she wouldn’t have let it go if he wasn’t banned. The message said the staff found the comment funny as it was clearly a joke…

If you were any sort of human being you would take this message to the gym management to show them the degrading stance this employee has towards female customers.

Agreed. That member of staff should be disciplined. Are you going to inform the gym @ScarlettRunner ?

Bellsize · 26/04/2025 15:56

ScarlettRunner · 26/04/2025 15:50

Just to address a couple of the replies (including the charming request to STFU-such anger!) - I am not defending him at all. I have stated he should not have said it. I was just interested on some other views as the non MN ones I’ve heard all think the gym over-reacted.

Its likely that they have a behaviour policy that he read and signed up to on joining that he violated.

"Stunning figure" ... yes he was leering at her butt - she must be sick of creeps like him.

How do you feel about him doubling down and minimising it?

Has he learnt anything - does he have any respect or empathy for women and their personal space? Did he offer to apologise to the lady rather than justifying his actions as a 'joke' - thats what all the creeps say. Grim.

Houseplantsaresoothing · 26/04/2025 15:55

I can't believe the number of pp who actually think the gym was over reacting!

It must be a very unpleasant place for women members if the staff actually side with the male members sexually harassing them.

I can't understand OP appearing not to be bothered by his behaviour. That he pervs on other women while he is at the gym doesn't seem to be an issue for her. But I suppose if she is happy to be in a relationship with a man she describes as " laddish " I expect she is used to putting up with a lot of behaviour many women would find unacceptable.

It's just another sad MN thread where women can't get on with doing normal everyday things without being harassed and made to feel uncomfortable.
And another sad thread where some women are happy to condone and minimise men's disgusting attitudes and behaviour.

ginasevern · 26/04/2025 15:53

@Cornoffthecob

"Unfortunately people cant say anything now because others are too ‘easily offended’. God I’ve had worse than that said to me in my lifetime"

I know this will fall on deaf ears, but it's not about being easily offended. It's about ending male entitlement. Since time began men have felt free to talk to women any way they like. I was a teenager in the 70's and jesus christ, men thought they could say (and often do) absolutely anything. Like we were property and barely human. If we didn't laugh it off in a suitably sweet and girly way, we were branded lesbians or mentally ill - or both. Women shouldn't have to spend their lives poised for the next comment about their body from a complete stranger, or finding humourous and clever ways to fend them off. I shouldn't feel too sorry for this bloke if I was you.

Mumtobabyhavoc · 26/04/2025 15:53

utterlyfedup2 · 26/04/2025 15:37

Laddy/jokey = inappropriate and pervy.

His behaviour was totally unnecessary and inappropriate, a form of sexual harassment.

The member of staff taking his side is someone who thinks its totally acceptable for women to have to accept being sexually harrassed by strangers while they are at the gym.

You condoning it makes you part of the problem too OP.

Why do you think it was acceptable for this woman to have to experience this?

How about, why is he now on her IG? 🤮

ilovesooty · 26/04/2025 15:52

Cornoffthecob · 26/04/2025 15:35

For god sake, hardly a reason to end a relationship!
He should have kept his mouth shut but a bit OTT reaction to cancel the membership. Unfortunately people cant say anything now because others are too ‘easily offended’. God I’ve had worse than that said to me in my lifetime and if I thought it was inappropriate I said as much at the time. She laughed then reported him afterwards. I would really hate to be a man these days. If a woman had said that to a man it would’ve been left there.

Are you thinking of following up with references to banter and snowflakes?

ScarlettRunner · 26/04/2025 15:50

Just to address a couple of the replies (including the charming request to STFU-such anger!) - I am not defending him at all. I have stated he should not have said it. I was just interested on some other views as the non MN ones I’ve heard all think the gym over-reacted.

OP posts:
bibliotek · 26/04/2025 15:50

ScarlettRunner · 26/04/2025 15:29

He can be laddy/jokey so I can imagine he’s just said something to the wrong person. I don’t think he should have said it at all though.

It wasn’t said to a larger lady, he’s shown me the persons instagram page and she is usually filming her workouts etc, and she has got a stunning figure.

What does laddy mean, OP?
You sound quite permissive of his behaviour, OP.

It doesn’t matter if she was fat or not, he was still commenting on the size - saying it was about to burst out of her clothes. He wanted to indicate to her he was watching and see if she was interested.

BlueSpikeyPearls · 26/04/2025 15:49

Badly handled all around. Your boyfriend's comment was inappropriate. Did he even know the woman he was making the comment to? Would he have done the same to a man? I doubt it in both cases. She was right to complain. I do think the gym overreacted and are a bit spineless/part of the problem.

She is "a pain"? So they only banned him to cover their own asses? Spineless. They could have given him a warning and banned him if it had happened again. Then again, this may not be his first offense, given OP describes him as "laddish". In either case, they thought that his comments were fine when they weren't.

I do think the boyfriend is no price. Laddish behavior, inappropriate comments to strange women and lying about the consequences of his actions. That would be it for me, with both the boyfriend and the gym, if I were a member.

ilovesooty · 26/04/2025 15:49

surreygirlzz · 26/04/2025 15:27

FGs you sound like so much fun

You think harassment is funny?

Ponderingwindow · 26/04/2025 15:48

Gyms should have a zero tolerance policy for harassment. It’s so easy for people to be deterred from exercising. Everyone deserves to be able to come to the gym.

It’s also just good business. Weeding out the negative energy means more customers in the long run.

Yatzydog · 26/04/2025 15:48

So he was attempting to chat her up. Does that make it better or worse than an insulting joke to a fatty?

No wonder he lied. Then tried to blame on the woman (she complains about everything).

How long have you been together? At least you know he pervs over other women and hits on them when you aren't there.

I'd move on. At some stage, one woman will say yes and the relationship will be over anyway.

Theorderoftime · 26/04/2025 15:47

I’d be annoyed if he made a comment like that to a woman at the gym. I’d explain to him that women often feel unsafe in spaces like gyms, and that comments like this can add to that sense of discomfort. I’d be even more upset that he lied about it.

However, we’re all human and we all make mistakes. This could be a valuable opportunity for him to learn. What matters now is what he does with this knowledge — whether he takes responsibility for having said something that could feel invasive and inappropriate, and whether he acknowledges that lying about it made things worse.

If he can do that, it could still be ok for both of you.

cardibach · 26/04/2025 15:46

BankHolidayBonanza · 26/04/2025 15:02

Urgh puts me off joining a gym even more so now!

if I was put off using a gym, it's would be because of women to be honest. I've never been faced with any issue with men, maybe a one-off stupid interaction once or twice which are total non-issue. On the other hand, the nasty looks, whispering and blatantly nasty attitude of SOME weird women is horrendous.
I don't care, but I imagine if I was lacking confidence and self-conscious, it would put me right off.

I am not denying harassment exists, just that I have been lucky enough to avoid it. The stupid comment and bad joke here is not harassment.

It was a vile comment. And why bring the behaviour of women into it? This is about a man’s behaviour - and it’s not as uncommon as you think. There’s a reason I go to a PT with a private gym.

Bellsize · 26/04/2025 15:44

ScarlettRunner · 26/04/2025 14:38

Yeah I did question him and when I got home he was able to show me the email the manager sent him which explained the reasoning and quoted what he said word for word.

He also showed me a message to
him from one of the staff who basically said the woman who complained is a known pain in the arse and she wouldn’t have let it go if he wasn’t banned. The message said the staff found the comment funny as it was clearly a joke…

He also showed me a message to
him from one of the staff who basically said the woman who complained is a known pain in the arse and she wouldn’t have let it go if he wasn’t banned. The message said the staff found the comment funny as it was clearly a joke…

If you were any sort of human being you would take this message to the gym management to show them the degrading stance this employee has towards female customers.

Piglet89 · 26/04/2025 15:43

@Cornoffthecobyeah, so hard to be a man these days.

The problem with many men is that they’re just so fucking arrogant they think everyone needs to know their ‘banter’.

Also, I doubt she was offended as such. She probably just found it irritating and embarrassing to have a stranger make such a comment to her.

amazing how the many women on this thread might THINK the comment in private but have the good sense not to voice it. And yet such social tact is such an ARDUOUS STRUGGLE for men.

Yeah, poor men, right enough.

cardibach · 26/04/2025 15:42

MyUmberSeal · 26/04/2025 14:50

Total over reaction on the part of the gym.
Your BF has been an idiot, he shouldn’t have said it, but it’s not a tragedy.

Edited to add, it does look like leggings could give way when women squat. They are stretched to within an inch of their lives. Difference it, I’d think it, wouldn’t say it.

Edited

Just when women squat? Or do men’s clothes stretch then too? It’s what leggings are designed for.

LIZS · 26/04/2025 15:42

It feels like it perhaps was not a one off incident and he has downplayed what was said. Did he even apologise? To her or you?