Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think kids move schools too much

79 replies

wakingimpossible · 26/04/2025 08:28

Ok, I know there are lots of reasons for children to change schools- bullying, poor standards, relocation etc, but aside from this, I just can’t believe the amount of moving around that has gone on at DDs schools. I’m talking about primary and secondary (for transparency, this is in the private system and I don’t know if it’s the same at state). It’s not something I ever experienced as a child - indeed I basically had the same classmates aged 4-12 and 12-18.

In year 6 the class of 20 had about 8 original pupils from reception remaining, and it looks to be going the same way in secondary. Many of these pupils have just gone to another school in the same town or nearby.

Parents seem to whip their kids out for all sorts of reasons - friendship issues that would likely resolve in time, not liking a particular teacher, getting specific bees in their bonnets about eg sport, school trips, the lunch offering - maybe thinking maybe that the grass is greener. But no school is perfect.

DD has gone to just one school for primary and secondary and, yes, it’s not always been smooth sailing. We’ve weathered friendship problems, bad heads, low level bullying, less than brilliant teachers and disruptive classmates. Of course, I know I am lucky that these have been largely surmountable and of course I would move her if she/I was genuinely happy over an extended period. But, in general, I’ve found that most things do work themselves out over the course of one school year.

Each to their own, I know, but I can’t help but feel this has a negative effect on the school community and is setting a poor example to children about resilience, figuring things out and seeing things through.

Preparing to be flamed but please don’t think I’m getting at people whose kids have been genuinely miserable and needed to leave. I’m just wondering if parents need to consider whether problems/gripes should be worked through a bit more.

OP posts:
Icepop79 · 26/04/2025 08:35

Definitely not my experience of state primary school - son is in year 6. Started with about 30 kids. Of those, I would say at least 25-26 are still in his class. Very similar for my daughter a few years ago.
Daughter is now at private secondary (moved her from state secondary after 2 years of problems). Her year is relatively unchanged and most are staying onto sixth form.

Talipesmum · 26/04/2025 08:32

Not something we’ve experienced in either primary or secondary (state) - a few kids have moved around for various reasons, but nothing on that scale. So can’t comment, other than perhaps if people are paying for schooling, they may be more likely to have a different way of feeling empowered to get what they want? It might be just chance as well, or might be something about the school you’re at.

Alongtoe · 26/04/2025 08:31

I’m guessing if lots of movement in your school, it’s for issues that you’re not aware of

parents aren’t generally inclined to make their children’s lives difficult unless they have reason to. So if they take this decision, I’d trust they have thought about it and know more detail behind it all than… you

Alongtoe · 26/04/2025 08:29

Both mine at independent
and it happens rarely and only due to change in financial circumstances that I have been aware of