Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Think our relationship is over. TW sexual assault

161 replies

Costacosta220 · 25/04/2025 07:59

I posted about this when I fist found out but 4 weeks ago my DS aged 19 disclosed to me he had been sexually assaulted by my partners brother. I have been with partner 7 years. He lives with us. I have younger children who are early teens. I have known the brother a couple of years longer as we had a shared hobby.

My son doesn't want to report it to the police. No evidence and his word against the brothers being the reasons. PP on that thread said to be led by my son and respect his wishes. He's doing OK with everything that's happened. He simply said he doesn't wish to be on his own at any time going forward with the brother. That's a given and won't happen. The man won't ever set foot in my house again.

I told my partner who was shocked. Upset. In denial. Trying to come up with a logical explanation. Angry. Suggests perhaps his brother is gay and attracted to younger men and has 'mis read' the signs. His other two brothers and their father have been told about it. I went with him to tell one brother. And they told the other brother and father a few days ago due to logistics of getting people together in the same place. No one wanted it done over the phone . I respected this timeframe. I haven't spoken to the man who assaulted my son. I haven't contacted him or approached him.

My partner and family say the brother will be spoken to... then what ???

It's caused so many rows in my house between us. He seems massively in denial and to be honest it's pissing me off. My son has been assaulted and he's trying to come up with reasons why it's all a misunderstanding. I am angry. Absolutely boiling with furious rage.

I feel I have let My son down by not going round there and beating this c**t into next week. I want now to tell the brother I know and to tell him he either admits it to the family (so they can stop their denial and delusion) or I am going to the police and will tell everyone. I am looking to shake him up basically.

He's got away with what he's done. Scott free.

My partner won't cut his brother off..he's said that. I haven't actually asked him to. I simply said it leaves a bad taste in my mouth that he would want to speak to him and associate with him any more than is humanly necessary. Eg at family gatherings when it can't be avoided. I don't like him trotting off to their hobby together or meeting up for finner etc. Its complicated by the fact they own a property together. Which the brother lives in and My partner stays at from time to time. He lives with us 95% of the time.

My partner has his family to speak to and he sees a Counsellor every few weeks (long before this happened ) so he has a safe space to discuss. I don't.. no one knows and I cannot tell my family. All hell will break lose. My family would 100 per cent cut off someone who did something like this if it was in our family. They have done before. Also my son doesn't want people knowing. Sadly there is a stigma about this kind of thing and he doesn't want it getting out.

I am just turning on my partner. I know its not his fault the blame lies with one person. But having a chat with the brother. Then what ? Nothings going to change. It will just be swept under the carpet won't it.

I am fucking angry and feel it's incredibly fucking disloyal to me and my son.

Any advice and sorry for the swearing but I am so so angry

OP posts:
GRex · 25/04/2025 11:19

You need to kick the "partner" out, he is OK with his brother having assaulted your son, there is no coming back from that.

Get your son some counselling to ensure he is comfortable with his next steps around reporting this.

StopGo · 25/04/2025 11:14

@Costacosta220 thank you for the extra info. I agree with you re police, convictions etc etc.
Your doing a brilliant job supporting your son.

Vye1988 · 25/04/2025 10:59

Costacosta220 · 25/04/2025 08:11

My other children have never ever been alone with the brother. We don't have loads to do with him. My son being an adult did as they attend the same hobby which is how this happened. Its not a hobby which involves children . The brother isn't married or in a relationship and has no kids of his own.

I know you are not i tending it to come across this way but this sounds like you are minimising with each post. Regardless of your sons age this man sexually assaulted your son and your partner and his family are OK with continuing to socialise with him! Absolutely not, end the relationship, remove these people feom your life. Your son won't ask you to do this but I guarantee that he will feel better when you do. Should your son never attend family gatherings again because the brother may be there? That is the choice being made. Help your son move on by removing these people from his life. Your DPs excuses are ridiculous, sexual assault has little to do with sexuality, repressed gay men don't routinely abuse younger men, predatory men do!

Swiftie1878 · 25/04/2025 10:42

As PP have said;
Of course your son should have control over who hears his story and who doesn’t, but he doesn’t get to control how you respond to it.

Either your partner cuts his brother off, or you cut your partner off. You can’t demand he cuts off his brother, and he’s already told you that he won’t/can’t.
SO, you have to get rid of him and cut him off, out of your life, forever. That’s it. Done.

BillyBoe46 · 25/04/2025 10:18

It up to your son if he wants to report it or not. He's an adult. He's the victim. I wouldn't want to make him feel less in control. It's his choice. Although, I'd strongly encourage it because this could be a patten of predatory behaviour. This man has know your son since he was a pre teen.

When these things happen in families the do tend to be swept under the carpet. People don't want to damage the family relationship or the families reputation. However, your partner should be more concerned about your son who he's know since he was 12 than his relationship with his brother. His brother touched your son inappropriately. Itscnot an accident. It's not a joke. It not excusable. It can't be explained away. Your partner need to stop try to excuse it or talk it away. Realistically, i could continue a relationship with him because I couldn't look at him the same. He's meant to love, protect and priorities you. Going and having a jolly chat with his pervert brother isn't doing that. It's a message to the world IMO.

I am a victim of CSA. My parents tried to get me to invite my abuser to my wedding. My grandparents refuse to attend because he wasn't invited. There was a lot of " how will it look if you don't invite him". I said I don't give a fuck it's my day and I won't have him there and subject myself to him and also how will it look if I do invite him? Like it's okay?

Aknifewith16blades · 25/04/2025 10:05

OP, sharing this link on communities that enable abuse, which you might find interesting.

You have great instincts here. I hope you find the best way through for you and your son.

The missing stair.

Flickr user BadSwan Have you ever been in a house that had something just egregiously wrong with it?  Something massively unsafe and unc...

https://pervocracy.blogspot.com/2012/06/missing-stair.html?m=1

R053 · 25/04/2025 10:00

I have a 19 year old son too. He is still young and finding his way in life, still needing guidance though legally an adult. I’d be just as devastated by a sexual assault on him as if it happened to my daughter.

This will likely affect your DS for the rest of his life. He probably doesn’t want you and your partner to break up because he doesn’t want to be the reason you will then be alone without a partner and possibly unhappy because of that. So he is protecting everyone, including keeping the police out of it. This is such a difficult burden for a young person and your partner, being older, should step up and go no contact with this brother.

Azandme · 25/04/2025 09:48

Bumblebeestiltskin · 25/04/2025 09:36

@Costacosta220 I also wish people would read what I have written.

Have we all missed the part where you've said you've ended the relationship and blocked the whole family, including your EX partner.

Because so far all I'm seeing is you making excuses for your partner,which is absolutely disgusting.

You are failing to take into consideration that the son really likes the partner, possibly even loves him. He will feel responsible and guilty for the breakdown of the relationship even though it's not his fault.

Black and white thinking rarely suits any real life situations.

And, to be honest, asking the masses, with their varying opinions, experiences, values, knee jerk responses and, truthfully, comprehension skills which range from excellent to scarily poor, isn't the best way to determine a course of action.

Everyone is in shock. Everyone is processing. A knee jerk response is rarely a good thing. Everyone involved needs time to work through the feelings that this bomb in their lives has caused. It doesn't happen overnight - it's very similar to the stages of grief, the first of which is denial.

Knowing someone you love did something horrific is one thing, it takes the brain time to catch up and process, because denial is the NATURAL response. But it's only one stage of the process. People who don't understand that are lucky, because it means they have no direct experience.

It also means they have no knowledge or right to be berating others or instructing them on what they should do, when they're going through it.

It's all too easy to be righteous when it's not your family.

OP - I'm sorry you're going through this, I would highly recommend you talk to professionals in this field, rather than the baying masses of Mumsnet.

Sending love and support to you all.

NOTANUM · 25/04/2025 09:48

For those advocating telling the police, her son is an ADULT and doesn’t want to. His wishes come first here.
Secondly conviction rates are extremely low especially when it’s a crime of this nature so it won’t go anywhere in all likelihood.
On the relationship side though, it’s very tricky. It sounds like the family are taking it seriously but are not going to freeze him out.
The question is whether that’s enough for you or if you need to end this. Talking to a charity that deals with sexual abuse survivors may help you.
Sometimes it’s worth being clear in your mind what you’d like to see happen, what would be acceptable to you and where the red line of acceptability is.
Good luck OP. Not an easy situation.

Simplynotsimple · 25/04/2025 09:39

TaylorSwish · 25/04/2025 09:25

Bullshit. I would believe my child. I wouldn’t socialise with their abuser and I wouldn’t support the people who did.
This is why sexual abuse victims have the triple whammy of being abused, not being believed and then watching friends and family support the abuser. It’s soul destroying for them.
There’s been enough cases where celebrities are known sexual predators, do it for years and have hundreds of victims and everyone says it’s can’t be true and they get richer and more famous. Imagine being a victim and watching the man who did it win awards.

His mother does believe him, and it is horrific. But reading it through the internet and living it in real life are two different matters. I’m not saying the op is 100% correct in how she’s dealing with her husband’s reaction, but in realtime this is still all extremely raw. The op is not just trying to support her son through an extremely traumatic event, she’s also looking at losing her husband/family unit as a fallout. Can you not see at all the desperation in trying to hold on to normality? It’s very easy to berate the op from behind a screen, saying they would instantly kick out their husband. People don’t respond naturally to hearing something so awful.

Bumblebeestiltskin · 25/04/2025 09:36

@Costacosta220 I also wish people would read what I have written.

Have we all missed the part where you've said you've ended the relationship and blocked the whole family, including your EX partner.

Because so far all I'm seeing is you making excuses for your partner,which is absolutely disgusting.

LegoTherapy · 25/04/2025 09:34

My partner wouldn’t have been around long enough to argue about this. He’d have been out the door straight away. Your poor son.

Energe · 25/04/2025 09:31

No. That response from him means it’s the end. Choose your son.

Apreslapluielesoleil · 25/04/2025 09:27

Fwiw my impartial take on it:
Your partner tries to come up with a rational excuse for what happened —- there is never a rational excuse for sexual assault.
His brother assaulted your son. If there are no consequences then it is positive reinforcement for brother to do it again to someone else.
If your partner wants to excuse this, make it go away, what else would he want to excuse away, disappear ? An assault on a younger person? A vulnerable person?

Your son might not want it reported to police now but he may in the future. That is his choice. For now I’d suggest he speak to someone outside the family, there are lots of organisations listed here https://rsvporg.co.uk/services/male-survivors/#:~:text=Male%20Survivors%20Partnership%20A%20central,to%20sexual%20violence%20and%20abuse.

Ask yourself do you want to be with a man whose first thought isn’t support of a victim of assault? If you were assaulted would he want to excuse that away?

Male Survivors - Rape & Sexual Violence Project

We offer a range of services for male survivors to support you in making the decisions and choices that are right for you. Our Leaflet for Male SurvivorsDownload Our Poster for Male SurvivorsDownload Adult Advocacy, Child Advocacy and LGBT Advocacy Ind...

https://rsvporg.co.uk/services/male-survivors/

TaylorSwish · 25/04/2025 09:25

Simplynotsimple · 25/04/2025 09:17

The op and her son cannot be dictated to who they will see, if told that the brother will be at an event I’m sure they will make a decision whether to go. Her son is fully in his rights not to report but people here are being extremely righteous in their responses. If anyone here was told their brother/father/husband inappropriately touched a teen I bet most people would start mental gymnastics in those first few weeks as well. Because it’s never ‘our David’ who’s capable of it. I’m not saying that is the right response, I’m trying to point out that it’s a very difficult situation to take on board. It will take a long time for the family to come to terms with the fact that their closest relative abused a young man.

Bullshit. I would believe my child. I wouldn’t socialise with their abuser and I wouldn’t support the people who did.
This is why sexual abuse victims have the triple whammy of being abused, not being believed and then watching friends and family support the abuser. It’s soul destroying for them.
There’s been enough cases where celebrities are known sexual predators, do it for years and have hundreds of victims and everyone says it’s can’t be true and they get richer and more famous. Imagine being a victim and watching the man who did it win awards.

Costacosta220 · 25/04/2025 09:23

StopGo · 25/04/2025 09:19

Did your son give you permission to speak to the other brothers and the father?

Yes the relationship is over, thankfully your partner owns his own property. I suggest he moves out today to allow you and your son time to think and decide what works for you and him.

Yes he did. He wanted them told. He knows they were being told and when . He is fully aware and was fully on board with it. I haven't done anything without his say so in this . I haven't pressured him in any way. I have told him my opinion on it being reported and why but it's his decision to make as he would need to co operate with any investigation. He's said there's no evidence. It's one person's word against another.

Everyone here knows how low conviction rates for this type of thing are and even rape how shit the stats are. A few years ago he was mugged and had some valuables stolen and the police didn't submit paperwork in time. Lost some of the valuables and the perpetrators got away with it. So his confidence in the police is non existent.

OP posts:
ComeAsYouAreAsAFriend · 25/04/2025 09:22

mumda · 25/04/2025 09:17

The brother has done something that makes him a risk to others. Is 18/19 a child or young adult or adult? It's people who are at risk...
The hobby involves people.
No one should be at risk from this brother.
Your son should report the incident. It's been a significant issue and may well continue to affect his life. Telling the police will be stressful.

Your relationship is another thing entirely. You are free to end things with someone at any time for any reason.
You could hope your partner will cut off the brother but he won't. Blood is thicker than water I'm afraid. The ties that bind us are annoyingly tough to break. In a years time your partner will have completely minimised this matter.
They will justify it as something trivial and not worthy of reporting it to the police.
This means your son will be more affected by it going forward than otherwise.

How tied to your partner are you? How could you ease away?

Your son should report the incident.
Yes in theory but as a mum and someone who has seen how sexual assault victims are treated in the courts I can honestly say I am not sure I would want that for someone I love. They are completely retraumatised again, on trial effectively themselves and it is always extremely hard to convict. They can report to police but if they are not willing to press charges and go through the court system there s very little the police can do.

Greenartywitch · 25/04/2025 09:21

''@Totallytoti · Today 09:13 The entire post is my son is so important but but but,''

Exactly.

I am sorry OP but all your updates are just the same: excuses.The reality is that you are still with your partner although he took the side of the person who sexually assaulted your son.

Most people on this thread are rightly questioning why you are doing this.

StopGo · 25/04/2025 09:19

Did your son give you permission to speak to the other brothers and the father?

Yes the relationship is over, thankfully your partner owns his own property. I suggest he moves out today to allow you and your son time to think and decide what works for you and him.

Hoppinggreen · 25/04/2025 09:19

You are getting a hard time OP and a lot of people aren't reading your posts properly but I DO agree that in your shoes I couldn't even look at anyone minimising this mans behaviour let alone the man himself and that does include your partner.
Sounds like you don't live together or have kids together so leaving him shouldn't be too hard and of course your son will not encourage you too, he probably feels that he would be responsible for destroying your relationship but it is actually your partner who has done that.
MIL's partner SA a family member who was a young adult and the rest of the families reaction changed how I felt about them despite me and MIL being pretty close previously. I was never in the same postcode as him again and avoided the rest of them until MIL finally dumped him (for another reason).

Simplynotsimple · 25/04/2025 09:17

TaylorSwish · 25/04/2025 09:08

It’s been said that he will be there but not alone with them.

The op and her son cannot be dictated to who they will see, if told that the brother will be at an event I’m sure they will make a decision whether to go. Her son is fully in his rights not to report but people here are being extremely righteous in their responses. If anyone here was told their brother/father/husband inappropriately touched a teen I bet most people would start mental gymnastics in those first few weeks as well. Because it’s never ‘our David’ who’s capable of it. I’m not saying that is the right response, I’m trying to point out that it’s a very difficult situation to take on board. It will take a long time for the family to come to terms with the fact that their closest relative abused a young man.

yeesh · 25/04/2025 09:17

You are mad to even consider staying with this man. He knows his brother has abused your son & he doesn’t give a fuck

Poppins21 · 25/04/2025 09:17

Costacosta220 · 25/04/2025 08:09

Of course it has occurred to me as so politely put to end it. Hence all the arguments. I was told in a previous post to listen to the wishes of my son who's almost 20 years old . An adult. He was an adult when this happened. My son wanted time to think about the police being involved and whilst that happened the family be told. Which I did. I told my partner the same day my son disclosed this. I haven't seen or spoken to his brother since. He's not been in my home. Meanwhile my son has asked for time to think

If I was down to me the police would be told and the brother arrested . Make no bones about it. If it were down to me every single man woman and child in England would know about it. But my adult son does not want that. His wishes are important. I have never doubted him and his version of events for a second and have made that crystal clear.

I would just ditch the partner and the whole disgusting lot of his family.

Not a chance they would be near my child minimising something so serious and deplorable.

Their reaction, or should I say lack of reaction would be a massive red flag that they knew about him before this was disclosed.

i hope your DS can move on with his life.

mumda · 25/04/2025 09:17

The brother has done something that makes him a risk to others. Is 18/19 a child or young adult or adult? It's people who are at risk...
The hobby involves people.
No one should be at risk from this brother.
Your son should report the incident. It's been a significant issue and may well continue to affect his life. Telling the police will be stressful.

Your relationship is another thing entirely. You are free to end things with someone at any time for any reason.
You could hope your partner will cut off the brother but he won't. Blood is thicker than water I'm afraid. The ties that bind us are annoyingly tough to break. In a years time your partner will have completely minimised this matter.
They will justify it as something trivial and not worthy of reporting it to the police.
This means your son will be more affected by it going forward than otherwise.

How tied to your partner are you? How could you ease away?

Costacosta220 · 25/04/2025 09:16

TaylorSwish · 25/04/2025 09:12

Are any of your children your partners? Would it be different for them if it happened to one of them?

No my partner doesn't have children. Mine are from my previous relationship. Their father isn't around.

I can't answer what they would do if it was their own family . Neither can they in all honesty .

OP posts: