Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is my friend outrageously entitled in her expectations?

214 replies

MariadeiMiracoli · 24/04/2025 11:52

I moved to my current town 18 years ago and got to know a woman renting a house on the cheap from a local who was off travelling. She was an interesting woman who'd given up her teaching job after a few years and gone travelling to SE Asia and South America, teaching English. Very laid back, getting by on benefits and subs from friends and family. Used to do a few hours at the local pub or shop for cash in hand and when she'd built up enough, buy an air ticket and take off to Hawaii or India for a month or two, picking up bar work or sleeping on the beach when she got there, always anticipating that someone would help her out.

About 12 years ago she met a man and moved in with him in Devon. It didn't work out and she ended up in a caravan and, when she turned 55, was housed in a flat in a 55+ development. But she's unhappy: there's noise, one of her neighbours drinks and plays music loud, another has serious MH issues. I visited her there a couple of years ago and thought it was actually rather nice: smart modern flat in a very desirable Devon town and no issues on the days I was there. I've said to her that even in the smartest private flats you can end up living next door to someone noisy but she says she's not prepared to put up with it.

She wants a bungalow with two bedrooms, so she can have a yoga/ meditation/ craft room. She wants a south-facing garden she can tend. It's got to be within walking distance of a decent town, but somewhere quiet and peaceful with a green outlook. And parking because she has a car. She's found a number of HAs (one here near me, where she used to live, one where she lives now and a third in the Bristol area) that have a tiny number of properties that fit her bill. All of them have been built for disabled people. She's been driving around inspecting them and knows precisely which ones she's after.

She's asked for my support to try and get one of her chosen properties in this area. I'm not sure what that will entail, but I suspect it'll involve spinning the truth to match the HA criteria. I've told her very clearly that I don't think there's any way she'll actually get one of these properties and she needs to compromise, but she says that if you don't ask firmly you don't get. Is this how it is now? I don't know what to make of it.

OP posts:
MariadeiMiracoli · 24/04/2025 14:23

MooseAndSquirrelLoveFlannel · 24/04/2025 14:15

Well, Devon Home Choice are like bulldogs when it comes to their properties, ain't no chance she would ever get anything but the bare minimum out of them.

Bungalows are massively popular (I work for a HA) and usually have waiting lists going into decades.

Some over 55 schemes are hard to let though, usually as they're not so modern but sounds like she is looking for something a bit better.

Re her needing an extra room due to depression, I can promise you that's a non starter. If she needs a live in carer, then she might qualify but medical proof would be required. But in my experience, every resident I speak to in our HA has depression and anxiety so it really doesn't get you a leg up.

Thanks, this is informative. I've never had to use the public housing system so the rules are a mystery to me. It's a relief to know she's unlikely to get what she wants, which sounds mean. What I mean is that she won't get what she wants at the cost to someone who needs it more.

OP posts:
1MuffinSocks · 24/04/2025 14:21

MariadeiMiracoli · 24/04/2025 13:49

I have no idea whether MH issues count. When we met, I'd just managed to buy the house I still live in and have, fortunately, not needed to rely on public sector housing. I don't know how the system works.

She'd need to get a medical professional to state very clearly why she needed a 2 bed (and as someone else has said why a living room wouldn't suffice as a space for meditation, etc). Even if a HA or council accepted that she needed a 2 bed (unlikely), they still wouldn't offer her an adapted bungalow over someone who would be able to make use of those adaptations.

MariadeiMiracoli · 24/04/2025 14:21

I hope your friend gets what she wants, but it might also be a useful exercise for her to understand that what she has now is actually pretty good and she might not be able to do better.
Sounds like she's away with the fairies a bit, unrealistic expectations, perhaps quite naive.

I can hear her saying to you what she said to me. Something along the lines of 'What's the problem with aiming for what you really want and what would bring you happiness, instead of just settling for what you're offered?'

My family are the sort who worked hard, lived modestly, had limited expectations and led lives that weren't dependent on the state unless in emergencies. Quite small lives: not much adventure. I watched this woman's different approach to life with interest, because she had taken a different path. That's it, really. We both seemed to accept each other's differences until now, when I realise that actually there are some things I can't accept.

OP posts:
333FionaG · 24/04/2025 14:17

I know a woman like this, single, in her 50s, has spent the majority of her life travelling, working cash in hand seasonal jobs, sofa surfing, living in a van etc but now she’s older, she wants a secure home she can grow old in, with chickens and some land to cultivate. She’s no way of paying for this herself but is busy trying to manifest it.

EmmaWoodhouseOfHighbury · 24/04/2025 14:16

You don't sound like much of a friend. You say she's helped you in the past but now you realise she's self-serving. I think she's had a life of adventure and now she's stuck in a depressing flat. So she's doing what she can to have a happier life because she feels she deserves it.

I think you should start being a better friend and stop getting the people of Mumsnet to validate your opinion. You know full well what people are like on here and what they think of people who choose a less conventional life. You're entitled to your opinion but don't cherry-pick your validation of that opinion.

MooseAndSquirrelLoveFlannel · 24/04/2025 14:15

Well, Devon Home Choice are like bulldogs when it comes to their properties, ain't no chance she would ever get anything but the bare minimum out of them.

Bungalows are massively popular (I work for a HA) and usually have waiting lists going into decades.

Some over 55 schemes are hard to let though, usually as they're not so modern but sounds like she is looking for something a bit better.

Re her needing an extra room due to depression, I can promise you that's a non starter. If she needs a live in carer, then she might qualify but medical proof would be required. But in my experience, every resident I speak to in our HA has depression and anxiety so it really doesn't get you a leg up.

telestrations · 24/04/2025 14:15

I would say sure but I'm not lying and if she still wants you to provide a statement or whatever you will but truthfully.

It's not untrue that she is connected to the community and you are part of that, but she is not disabled and certainly not to the extent of needing a bungalow. It is true that living next to drinking and excessive noise is not good for MH which she has had diagnosis and treatment for

Praying4Peace · 24/04/2025 14:09

toomuchfaff · 24/04/2025 12:09

Exactly

Spent a life coasting, still wants more...

Sense of entitlement is staggering 😡

Hastentoadd · 24/04/2025 14:06

MariadeiMiracoli · 24/04/2025 13:26

My guess is that she'll be claiming that she needs an extra room for her MH, so that she can do yoga and meditate in order to avoid a depressive episode like the one she had during lockdown. She is likely also to claim to need a private garden for the same reason. She was on medication for a while when she left her last relationship and during and after lockdown. Seems okay now, but she doesn't talk about it. It's the only thing I can think of that might give her any hope of getting a property designated for the disabled.

Why can’t she do Yoga / meditate in the bloody living room

Is she expecting you to lie on a statement / form

I would say I will help her but I won’t lie

She does not need a 2 bed place, she has been given plenty of help ( benefits) over the years and she should stop taking the piss

The reason why she has gotten this far without having a perm job is because she is a user, she is probably friends with loads of people and asks various people for little favours and rotates between them.

crockofshite · 24/04/2025 13:54

No harm in 'helping' your friend - whatever that actually means - so long as you don't put yourself at risk of committing fraud, lying, bending truth or saying or doing anything illegal or untruthful, or get pressured to say or do anything you don't feel comfortable doing.

I hope your friend gets what she wants, but it might also be a useful exercise for her to understand that what she has now is actually pretty good and she might not be able to do better.

Sounds like she's away with the fairies a bit, unrealistic expectations, perhaps quite naive.

MariadeiMiracoli · 24/04/2025 13:49

EmeraldRoulette · 24/04/2025 13:29

@MariadeiMiracoli "My guess is that she'll be claiming that she needs an extra room for her MH"

does this work? Sometimes I wonder if I should have declared my well documented MH issues

I honestly don't think this kind of help is available. Imagine all of us with A&D declaring we must have 2 bed flats!

I have no idea whether MH issues count. When we met, I'd just managed to buy the house I still live in and have, fortunately, not needed to rely on public sector housing. I don't know how the system works.

OP posts:
Gundogday · 24/04/2025 13:43

Wouldn’t we all like a house in a nice area with a nice garden (and someone else to pay for it!).

Don’t do anything you feel uncomfortable with. It sounds she’s used to people helping her without question, but doesn’t mean you have to be complicit.

willowthecat · 24/04/2025 13:40

Furtivenasturtium · 24/04/2025 13:39

There's no evidence of that, just OP's accusations, which she's shown no evidence of.

Yes it's all untrue and she's not eyeing up properties for the disabled then it's fine but if not, she must be very deluded to think she will get one with a few little embellishments - my son is severely disabled and it's no easy task I can tell her !

Jenkibuble · 24/04/2025 13:40

MariadeiMiracoli · 24/04/2025 12:47

Thanks for all the responses. I used to watch her living this free and easy lifestyle while I was paying the mortgage and working FT and envy her and wonder what it was about her that gave her the courage to live freely like that. I guess I wanted to learn from her. I didn't envy the times when she came back from Hawaii or wherever and had to live in her car or sofa-surf with friends, but somehow something always came up for her. She has done a lot of volunteering in the last decade and is supportive to others. When I broke my leg she came to visit for a few days and mowed my lawn and cut my hedges and scrubbed all my hard floors, which I couldn't do.

To whoever said I don't like her: I think it's come home to me, with a thump, how ruthless and self-focussed she is. She's always been this gentle-hippy-chick type: easy going, peace and love to the world. But when it comes to a two-bed bungalow, she's prepared to elbow someone disabled out of the way if she can. It's opened my eyes to how essentially different our values are.

A friend of my sister's is like this....... sofa surfs, rejects jobs on the grounds that they go against her morals / ethics etc, yet claiming UC isn't against her principles!

Then, all of a sudden, despite having paid nothing to those she loafs off, she will find the money for a return flight to some zen workshop in the US or some organic retreat overseas.

Takers !!!!!

She still owes me travel costs to a concert I took her to 7 years ago !

Give a WIDE berth!

Furtivenasturtium · 24/04/2025 13:39

willowthecat · 24/04/2025 13:35

How would it be better if more people took over flats for the disabled by deception and lies ?

There's no evidence of that, just OP's accusations, which she's shown no evidence of.

Furtivenasturtium · 24/04/2025 13:38

EmeraldRoulette · 24/04/2025 13:32

You think the world would be better if more people lied to get benefits?

okay, enough internet for me today.

There's no suggestion here that she's lied to get benefits. Just that she's done a lot of voluntary work and odd jobs and what sounds like mutual support.

Hdjdb42 · 24/04/2025 13:36

I wouldn't help her. Anyway, without proof they won't do anything.

willowthecat · 24/04/2025 13:35

Furtivenasturtium · 24/04/2025 13:31

I don't think it's common, but I think the world would be a far better place if it was.

Edited

How would it be better if more people took over flats for the disabled by deception and lies ?

RedHelenB · 24/04/2025 13:33

MariadeiMiracoli · 24/04/2025 12:57

I also feel the need to add that she only twice asked me for help before this time. Once she needed some money to pay a bill. I lent it to her and she paid me back within the month. And once she asked if I would allow her to stay for one night and have a bath and a hot meal while she was here. She'd been on one of her trips and had been living in her car. I volunteered the use of my washing machine. It's how we stayed friends. I didn't see her as a CF.

I dint think she has been to you. She's been a friend, you've helped her out when she needed it and she helped you.

EmeraldRoulette · 24/04/2025 13:32

Furtivenasturtium · 24/04/2025 13:31

I don't think it's common, but I think the world would be a far better place if it was.

Edited

You think the world would be better if more people lied to get benefits?

okay, enough internet for me today.

Furtivenasturtium · 24/04/2025 13:31

EmeraldRoulette · 24/04/2025 13:30

I think what's confused me about this thread is that people seem to think it's pretty normal to behave the way this woman does.

I don't think it's common, but I think the world would be a far better place if it was.

MariadeiMiracoli · 24/04/2025 13:31

EmeraldRoulette · 24/04/2025 13:05

@MariadeiMiracoli you didn't see her as a CF? But did you wonder how she paid bills?

I knew she was able to claim benefits, that her family helped out at times and that she worked occasionally cash-in-hand at the local pub or shop or dog-walking or doing some gardening.

OP posts:
EmeraldRoulette · 24/04/2025 13:30

I think what's confused me about this thread is that people seem to think it's pretty normal to behave the way this woman does.

Furtivenasturtium · 24/04/2025 13:29

Billben · 24/04/2025 13:25

She seem to want a lot of things for someone who has never or barely ever has contributed to the system 😂
I would stay well clear

She sounds like someone who has contributed a lot, while taking little. Our society is kept going by the unpaid work of volunteers and carers.

EmeraldRoulette · 24/04/2025 13:29

@MariadeiMiracoli "My guess is that she'll be claiming that she needs an extra room for her MH"

does this work? Sometimes I wonder if I should have declared my well documented MH issues

I honestly don't think this kind of help is available. Imagine all of us with A&D declaring we must have 2 bed flats!