Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

He no longer wants kids

467 replies

Lizzielost · 23/04/2025 08:19

I’m a bit lost here so was hoping for some opinions on my current position please.

I’m 41 and have been with my partner, 39, for 8 years (1 engaged). We are currently renovating our first home together and I love him to bits. He is the only person who has ever completely understood me and he has helped me to grow so much while we’ve been together. I’ve also supported him and helped him to grow into someone who is more secure and aware of his own value. He is a kind person and thinks of me a lot.

From the very start, we both wanted children. We’ve had so many conversations about it that it was never really considered to be an issue, until last year. My partner has been through some difficult times over the last 2-3 years (including the loss of a parent and an increase in narcissistic behaviour from the remaining parent as well as significant work stress) and he has been in a very dark place at times. Now that we are finally in a position where we have some security to try for a child (as my age is already against me somewhat) he has decided that he no longer wants a child.

He didn’t tell me outright for some time. It’s been a topic of conversation for 16 months and he only admitted it at the end of last year. His response has always been either just a quiet grunt, ‘ok’ or no response at all with a look akin to a deer caught in the headlights. In the meantime I have to mix with his friends and all of their children and he doesn’t seem to see how difficult that is for me.

I had a coil which I was struggling with (pain, heavy periods etc) and he suggested getting it removed about 2.5 years ago and trying for a baby then. By the time I’d managed to have it removed 4 months later though, he’d changed his mind and I went on the pill. It doesn’t agree with me (moods, loss of desire etc) and this also seems to have caused some issues between us, even though there is little I can do to change that without coming off the pill.

We talk about it but I usually end up upset and, to try to pacify me, he says that we can try. I know he is only saying that and doesn’t mean it though so I ask him to speak about it the following day, when things have calmed, and he doesn’t. This has happened at least 10 times now and it is hurting.

If he had told me properly about his change of heart then I would not have bought the house with him. Really, I had little idea of how things had changed with him.

Over the last few days things seem to have come to a head. I just can’t cope with him almost playing games now and, after being upset a couple of nights ago and sleeping on the couch, I’ve told him that we can’t continue and that we need to split before I hate him for this. The situation is difficult, with the house renovation, and we’ll probably end up having to keep going with this for a bit until we can sell it and move on.

My head is telling me I’m overreacting and that I can’t leave him as he is everything to me. I just can’t keep being dragged down by this baby thing as it is taking over my
life and I’m beginning to hate him for it. It is, to me, a point of fundamental incompatibility and I feel betrayed. My mind is reeling - do we go for counselling to see if we can deal with this? Is it dead in the water now, even with the love on both sides? I can’t see up for down at the minute and I don’t know whether I’m talking myself round, only to be stuck again. I probably won’t go on to have children anyway if we split. I’m quite shy and finding someone new to trust in that way probably won’t be doable in time for me to try for a child. I just don’t know what to do at the moment. Has anyone got any thoughts on this please?

OP posts:
Timmygnome · 23/04/2025 11:39

I had a baby at 39 ,so 41 isn't that much older .
But definitely don't waste any more time waiting for him to agree
You need to get on with getting pregnant as a single mum
I'm married with 4 children,and having children gives me so much more joy and purpose than being married does ,I know which is more important to me ,and it's not a man

Timmygnome · 23/04/2025 11:35

Your 41 ,it's a gamble either way
Come of your contraception and tell him it's his responsibility now .
You have a home you own half of
You could look at a sperm donor
He can't stop you getting pregnant with someone else ,so look in to other ways to have baby that don't involve him .
Sounds like the relationship is over anyway
And you haven't got time to wait untill the house is sold and you have somewhere else to live

maddening · 23/04/2025 11:31

LadyTwattington · 23/04/2025 08:25

I am sorry to read this. He has the luxury of being able to change his mind again in 5 or 10 years; you don't. If having children is a deal-breaker, then the deal is broken.

In your situation, at your age, I would split and go for single parenthood via donor sperm - but then I always knew very firmly that I definitely wanted children, and time is not on your side.

This is what I would do also in that situation- there is never a right time or situation imo so I would not worry about the romance of "finding the one" imo.

Withoutfearorfavour · 23/04/2025 11:27

NuffSaidSam · 23/04/2025 09:39

No, but significantly better for the child to have both parents in their lives. In the OP's situation this would be the best possible outcome! Unfortunately doesn't sound like her partner will step up.

Oh it is for the baby, the ex is furious watching us play happy families with “her” child. It must be difficult for her.

Lots to bear in mind and consider.

Sunshineandoranges · 23/04/2025 11:26

I always wavered. Got pregnant very quickly then decided I didn’t want a child. Now have two and adore them. If I was you I would stop talking about it and, if you definitely want a child, I’d try to get pregnant. He will probably be very happy to be a dad. I wouldn’t normally suggest this to anyone but he does sound like he wants a child but is scared of being a dad.

LucyMonth · 23/04/2025 11:25

LudvillasCave · 23/04/2025 11:21

Use your imagination!

5 years ago, during the pandemic, they’d been together 4 years. Plenty of time to have started trying for a baby before then. & I’m assuming a couple together 4 years will have holed up together during the pandemic even if they hadn’t been living together by that point.

Plenty of “pandemic babies” from couples holed up together with nowhere together and nothing else to do! So utterly irrelevant to OPs situation.

He also lost a parent 3 years ago. So 6 years after being together.

Withoutfearorfavour · 23/04/2025 11:24

FrenchandSaunders · 23/04/2025 11:19

What has the pandemic and lockdown got to do with trying for a baby?

The uncertainty put alot of people off.
I know several who lost jobs, businesses. It was all furlough and payrises

pinkdelight · 23/04/2025 11:22

LudvillasCave · 23/04/2025 11:12

Bear in mind, 5 years ago the pandemic and lockdown started, then 3 years ago he lost a parent. Life happens. I wouldn’t just assume it’s complacency.

I get that life happens but any woman who wants kids (says she always has) and is with a long-term partner doesn't wait till 41 for this realisation. They don't come off the coil to TTC at 39 and then agree to go back on the pill. These are active choices not to have a baby and to say 'my age is against me somewhat' is very different to the women on here who long for a DC at that age (sometimes a second or third DC on those threads where a DP doesn't want another) and have already tried IVF and are so desperate they'll leave their husband. Even with covid and his parent, this would have shot up the priority list by 40, above getting engaged, getting the house etc. I could understand it if she'd not met DP until late 30s, but to have been together so long and still be on contraception... I'm just questioning the narrative that this is him pulling the rug vs both of them have ignored the ticking clock. As PP says, it's not his ticking clock anyway and he can change his mind down the line so OP needs to take her own lead not his.

LudvillasCave · 23/04/2025 11:21

FrenchandSaunders · 23/04/2025 11:19

What has the pandemic and lockdown got to do with trying for a baby?

Use your imagination!

jolota · 23/04/2025 11:21

I think you have to decide what your priority is.
Do you want to leave him and try to have a child? Would you have a child alone?
Will you ever be able to forgive him for this if you stay with him and accept no children or will it just break the relationship further down the line when your chances for children are even lower?
It sounds like based on the timeline of having the coil removed that he first specified being unsure about having children over 2 years ago. That was when you should have really nailed down the conversation, letting this drag on for several more years when he was showing signs of not being 100% on board for kids was a mistake, he always has the luxury of time, you don't and after having been together for 6 years, you should both have been on the same page and able to have mature and honest conversations about it. Instead he's strung you along and you've allowed it.

FrenchandSaunders · 23/04/2025 11:19

What has the pandemic and lockdown got to do with trying for a baby?

LudvillasCave · 23/04/2025 11:17

Solocatmum · 23/04/2025 11:11

And with every pregnancy, the body is swamped (in a good way) with oestrogen. With breastfeeding, it’s keeping the body pregnancy ready.
most v different starting afresh at age 41.

Yep this! V different prospect going for your first in your 40s.

LudvillasCave · 23/04/2025 11:16

LudvillasCave · 23/04/2025 11:12

Bear in mind, 5 years ago the pandemic and lockdown started, then 3 years ago he lost a parent. Life happens. I wouldn’t just assume it’s complacency.

If you also look at this thread, there are a lot of people (unhelpfully imo) urging OP not to worry as she‘s easily got until her mid-40s! 🙈 If everyone left it till their mid-40s, there’d be a lot of very disappointed, very regretful people.

ForWildLemon · 23/04/2025 11:13

I can understand you are upset and focusing on trying for a baby or not but have you truly thought about what sort of parent he would be anyway? You’ve described an eight year project with him to get him to a place of greater happiness in his life (and he’s still struggling by the sounds of it) do you really want to take on ‘project make him a decent dad’ as well?

Because you’d resent him even more and that’s even without the fact you’ve poured all this love time and attention into him for the last eight years while he timed you out fertility wise.

LudvillasCave · 23/04/2025 11:12

pinkdelight · 23/04/2025 11:05

If you got together early 30s and 'from the start... always wanted children' then something here doesn't add up. I get that you say you were waiting to get secure enough to have kids, but you know that your 30s is the time to TTC if you want kids - which you both did 'from the start' so how was this conversation never getting from abstract to tangible ttc by age 35, or 36? If you were staying on contraception, that's an active choice you're making not to have kids and then he even articulated that choice and you went along with it. So it's not that 'he no longer wants kids' - he's never demonstrably wanted them and you've either lied to yourself or not been that bothered through the whole of your 30s until age 41. I think you have to wonder how much you do really want them, because it doesn't seem to have been a priority for you either. If I'm wrong and it truly is, I agree with others advising donor route asap. But if you're dithering and want to stay with him, then admit to yourself that you're okay without having kids and that it's not a matter of him hoodwinking you, you've both gone this route by design (him) or default (you).

Bear in mind, 5 years ago the pandemic and lockdown started, then 3 years ago he lost a parent. Life happens. I wouldn’t just assume it’s complacency.

IrritatedEarthling · 23/04/2025 11:12

I'm 41 too, and I'm pregnant now. But I've had ten miscarriages. I feel blessed to be at 17 weeks.

Op as pp said, come off the pill. You might need a couple of months for your body to reset. The first poster nailed it - the pill disagrees with you, so the ball must be in his court. Does he really want to leave after all you've built together, or is he just hurting from the events of the last few years.

You don't have much time now. Practically speaking, if you come through this and decide to try, I recommend the clear blue ovulation tracker.

Best wishes.

Solocatmum · 23/04/2025 11:11

VintedVirginal · 23/04/2025 10:45

I have records of my family tree going back 200 years and more.
Most women then were having a child every 2 years from 20 up to around 44.
Many of them had 10 children, some 11.

And with every pregnancy, the body is swamped (in a good way) with oestrogen. With breastfeeding, it’s keeping the body pregnancy ready.
most v different starting afresh at age 41.

AffableApple · 23/04/2025 11:10

He told you two years and one month ago - after you had to go on the Pill, after the removal of your coil for the purpose of getting pregnant, the discussion about which took place 2.5 years ago, that he did not want to have children. You did not hear him.

A year ago, under the new regime of him not having children, you agreed to marry him. These are the terms of your future with him you agreed to by getting engaged. Did you understand that?

Is a date set for the wedding?

Will he come out of this grieving fug in 5 years, the pair of you still unwed, straight into the vagina of another woman, who he'll immediately get up the duff?

He's not at your stage of life. His clock is not ticking. He's feeling the final countdown from you, but not his own death knell on fertility. He's got plenty of mileage left before his hard no on kids forever. He's allowed to change his mind, and he's said no at this point. So that's a hard no to kids with you, because time is very much ticking for you. So you're done with him.

You would never, never be able to move past the fact he made the decision not to have kids on your behalf. Even if you stayed together. It would always be there. His selfish, barnacle-behaviour that kept you hanging. And your inability to hear his underlying message.

Acknowledge the collective wisdom accrued by many of your MN friends here and cut your losses now. Get out, get a fertility MOT, and enjoy your life howsoever it goes on from here. You deserve an amazing life, with or without children.

Nsky62 · 23/04/2025 11:09

Clockface8 · 23/04/2025 08:27

If he had told me properly about his change of heart then I would not have bought the house with him.

he told you explicitly 2.5 years ago

Maybe she choose not to listen

LucyMonth · 23/04/2025 11:09

People telling a woman in her 40s to skip off to a sperm bank to have a child is dumb founding.

Very optimistically she’d be having a baby at 43 and single. Almost guaranteed to be an only child. So someone will be 10 with a (at best) 53 year old Mum, no father and no siblings…but as long as OP gets the baby she wanted who cares about what fair for kid right?

OPs only just now been able to purchase a property with her fiancé so I’m assuming would struggle to on her own? But yeah sure, get that strangers sperm in you TODAY OP.

OP has had 9 years to have the baby she supposedly desperately wanted. She has chosen not to. Let’s stop pretending she didn’t have a choice. She did. Her partner has made is so clear he wasn’t keen on parenthood and she chose to ignore the warning signs despite her age. She should not have required repeated explicit communication that her partner didn’t want kids. Anyone can see that he did not want kids from her words and his actions.

pinkdelight · 23/04/2025 11:05

If you got together early 30s and 'from the start... always wanted children' then something here doesn't add up. I get that you say you were waiting to get secure enough to have kids, but you know that your 30s is the time to TTC if you want kids - which you both did 'from the start' so how was this conversation never getting from abstract to tangible ttc by age 35, or 36? If you were staying on contraception, that's an active choice you're making not to have kids and then he even articulated that choice and you went along with it. So it's not that 'he no longer wants kids' - he's never demonstrably wanted them and you've either lied to yourself or not been that bothered through the whole of your 30s until age 41. I think you have to wonder how much you do really want them, because it doesn't seem to have been a priority for you either. If I'm wrong and it truly is, I agree with others advising donor route asap. But if you're dithering and want to stay with him, then admit to yourself that you're okay without having kids and that it's not a matter of him hoodwinking you, you've both gone this route by design (him) or default (you).

VictoriaSponge987 · 23/04/2025 11:03

Luv2luv9 · 23/04/2025 10:43

Why make the OP feel worse about her situation. I was fortunate to never have been in this type of position although I know many women who became naturally pregnant in their 40s despite statistics. This includes my auntie who had her 3rd baby at 44.

You will never know unless you start trying OP & the sooner the better.

Edited

It doesn’t help OP to be unrealistic about the odds. If she wants to be a mum and she is 41, I would tell her to get herself checked out. Then she can make an informed choice about the options.

Imonlyhappywhenitrains · 23/04/2025 11:03

OP just my two cents worth but if you do want children I would get private fertility tests and counselling if I were you, now - presumably you are still menstruating regularly at least? - to get an idea of how the land lies there.
Female fertility can vary wildly. The majority of women are fertile in their very early forties, but a small cohort of women start to have fertility drop from the very late twenties and conversely a small cohort of women stay fertile well into their forties. Until you try you can't know for sure where you are, but tests can give some indication.
Committing (or not) to these tests should help clarify for yourself how you feel about wanting a baby.

anotherusernamehere · 23/04/2025 11:02

mintandpistachio · 23/04/2025 10:03

I'm in a really similar situation to you and similarly have no idea what to do. I'm almost 41 and for the past few years partner has been saying that we will try for children (complicated by the fact that we would need to use donor sperm and possibly eggs due to my age and his indecisiveness over everything). After 3 years of doing all the research, getting tests, booking consultations, searching for donors, he decided he "wasn't ready" to go ahead – the day we had everything lined up, had signed initial contracts, and were about to pay for the treatment. That was a few months ago and I spiralled badly. I'm now trying to get myself in a better headspace and come to terms with the fact that I will never have children – largely because of his actions. It's painful. I don't know whether to leave or stay because if I leave I will have no partner, no home, and no children. If I stay I think I will resent him hugely. It's a shit situation that people don't understand unless they have been in a similar situation themselves (and a lot of the comments you get on your post will be from people who had the children they wanted when they wanted them and have no understanding of the devastation you are experiencing). I'm so sorry that you are in this position.

@mintandpistachio sorry to hijack the thread but I just wanted to say I was in this very position a month ago (although thankfully I still had my own place, but we were living in his) at 38.5. I've now left him and am pursuing donor sperm to make embryos.. my clinic were surprisingly ok when I informed them about the change in plan. They only wanted to check I wasn't married to my partner etc as that would have meant I could not proceed on my own as easily. My partner had not been fully keen/ready for trying for a baby but we had decided to create embryos together to give ourselves more time to get to the "ready now for a baby" stage without hopefully running out of time. But then he decided he wasn't ready.. so after a lot of painful conversations I've ended the relationship. It was hell but even after 3 weeks or so it's getting easier...

I'm obviously not planning on implanting just yet as I'm still dealing with the emotions from a break up, and I am holding out hope that I might meet someone sooner and still have the chance of a family together. But I want options if, say, in a year I'm no closer to that and then I'll go ahead as a single mum.

to the OP and to you @mintandpistachio , I think you really need to think how you will feel without children in 10 years if the relationship ends. There's no guarantee you'll be with this same person (interesting in all of these situations it seems like the partner has not married you? same here - maybe also an indication of commitment issues!) in 10 years but if you have a baby (and are a good mum!) then you'll have that relationship and love for the rest of your life. Which one can you really live without?

I would (and am) want to do everything to see if I can have children and not delegate that power to someone. Then at least if it hasn't worked out for me, I know at least I did everything I could. I wouldn't want to look back with regrets wishing I'd tried. Are you likely to regret having stayed with the partner in 5 years time or regret having left and tried to have children? I also tend to think that if the relationship is really meant to be, then maybe if the children stuff doesn't work out then maybe they'll still be there in a few years time too!

VictoriaSponge987 · 23/04/2025 11:01

VintedVirginal · 23/04/2025 10:44

Even if that 5% is true (I'll check it out) it means that within 10 months half of all women of 40 would be pregnant.

And that is obviously an average or median percentage.

Not quite as the percentage chance is then dropping every month (after 40). At age 43 it’s around 1-2%. I can only repeat that I worked in fertility for over ten years.