Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To just want to be a housewife?

518 replies

CasketBase · 22/04/2025 10:23

I don’t know what’s happened to me. Growing up as a teen I was very rebellious and independent, I wanted the world. Started working early, went to university, started working full time and studied in my spare time. My job prior to having a child was serious and I was working my way up. Then DC came and I went part time self employed and ever since I’ve had her, I don’t want that life at all. She is 3 and is part time in nursery whilst I work but originally I wanted to do well in my work but now I don’t care. All I want is to look after my daughter, clean my home, and spend my time cooking and gardening.
Is this normal?! I could t care less about a career or earning lots of money or anything. I live rurally and all I care about now is nature and ‘homliness’. I genuinely love ironing, hanging out the washing and making the beds. I have ADHD and these were jobs that used to paralyse me, but now I find comfort and calmness in them and it’s the work I can’t cope with. Is this a phase? Or is this something to do with becoming a parent? It’s bizarre, it’s like I’ve had a personality transplant.

OP posts:
MeAndMyCatCharlotte · 23/04/2025 14:20

@TheAmusedQuail 'And if your marriage breaks down? A huge % do.
Then you'll be left, with children, no up to date marketable skills. With a man that pays you the bare minimum. Trying to exist in poverty. Making your children suffer not just a working mum (against your vision of earth mother) but also poverty. All because you lost ambition when you had a baby and couldn't see that you need to be financially productive. It's called the feminisation of poverty for a reason. It's a trap.'

Ridiculously dramatic statements, there. I have quite a few friends who were SAHM's when their dc were little and who's marriages subsequently broke down (myself included). None of us are living in 'poverty'. In reality, the norm is that exH supports and mum goes back to work part or full time.

The desire to be at home with your baby rather than being in paid employment is not a 'loss of ambition'; it is an alteration in ambition and priority. It is not and does not make a woman any less important than another (and you have not written that but it is very much in the tone of your statements).

EnergyCreatesReality · 23/04/2025 14:10

I feel exactly the same!!

I was so career-driven when I was younger and very ambitious, now I have an almost 6 year old and I couldn't give a toss about work. If we could afford for me to give up and be a SAHM I would in a heart beat!

Dhxusksgxuks · 23/04/2025 14:09

I don’t think there’s anything wrong with it if you’re happy, your husband is happy and it suits your family.

I love my job and think I’m a better mother for balancing it with an interesting and stimulating career, but everyone is different. Lots of people find fulfillment in creating a really beautiful home life.

CasketBase · 23/04/2025 14:04

RedHairBob · 23/04/2025 13:59

You think all my points are irrelevant? Like how some cultures like mine would be so grateful to have the opportunities women in the UK do? Or the point about older kids being expensive and how it’s helpful to be able to support them if we can? Or how I like that we have senior women doctors and MPs and lawyers? If you disagree with all that, well then I think we are clearly very different people and won’t find common ground.

Because those were actually my main points which perhaps you missed in your indignant ranting about flashy lifestyles.

I responded to what was irrelevant already, don’t twist my words and make out that I said anything if the sort. You clearly didn’t read my post, how ironic, because I said in response to you and somebody else how I celebrated such women and am thankful for them.

But your rhetoric of women who choose not to have careers is baseless and irrelevant, yes. And I say that as a woman with a career, despite not enjoying it.

OP posts:
RedHairBob · 23/04/2025 14:01

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 23/04/2025 13:57

Surely what women that went before us fought for was equality? Which means choices?

If a woman, or a man, or anyone actually wants to stay home doing the domestic stuff, and can afford to, that's ok?

The women that went before us didn't fight for us to have to work five days a week and be career driven. They fought so we could if we chose to.

Talking about choices, how many men choose to stay at home? Women giving up work to stay home isn’t a free choice made in a vacuum. It reflects society’s expectations for men and for women.

RedHairBob · 23/04/2025 13:59

CasketBase · 23/04/2025 13:44

No, I’m confirming that you’ve said a load of tripe as when I’ve called you up on it you’ve had a huff about one tiny detail rather than actually discussing the response. Which has only shown that your points are utterly irrelevant as even you can’t be arsed to have the conviction to stand by them. But that’s your prerogative.

You think all my points are irrelevant? Like how some cultures like mine would be so grateful to have the opportunities women in the UK do? Or the point about older kids being expensive and how it’s helpful to be able to support them if we can? Or how I like that we have senior women doctors and MPs and lawyers? If you disagree with all that, well then I think we are clearly very different people and won’t find common ground.

Because those were actually my main points which perhaps you missed in your indignant ranting about flashy lifestyles.

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 23/04/2025 13:57

RedHairBob · 23/04/2025 10:40

This has been a bit of a depressing read. It is like the gender pay gap never happened. But then again, I am allergic to words like ‘housewife’ and ‘pottering’!

And there are some privileged viewpoints on here. I am from a culture where girls and women would do anything to get into good careers and senior positions. We don’t have it perfect in the UK but at least on paper women are able to apply for the highest roles, technically on an equal footing to men. On this thread we have so many women wanting to stay home, bake and clean whilst men do the Big Jobs. We have fought so hard for equality, yet women here now they (kind of) have it, want to turn their backs on it. I guess we take things for granted when we have them.

It is also naive to talk about the simple life and condemn people for wanting to earn more money. It is easy to label others as wanting a flashy lifestyle. The thing is, young kids are quite cheap. You don’t need much money. But when your children are older, it can be really helpful too assist them a bit when they are at university or leaving home, or with driving lessons. Also as the NHS becomes more and more challenged, it is good to have a bit of extra cash to help with health issues in yourselves and your children. I wouldn’t dismiss how helpful some extra money can be. It is not just needed for ‘flashy’ houses, cars or holidays. Money can relieve worries too. It is often people with enough money anyway who say money doesn’t matter…

The other thing I find irritating is all this talk about the rat race. There are many people who aren’t working in offices for big corporate firms. Many are public sector workers or people just keeping the country running as it is. I for one am also glad we have women MPs, doctors, lawyers, CEOs and judges. Women who established their careers in their child bearing years so that they can be in senior positions of power and achieve some equality and balance in the workplace at a senior level. I seem to be in a minority!

Anyway, I hope never to depend on a man or benefits (if I am lucky and healthy enough). Financial independence has always been important to me. My kids are at university now and thankfully realise the importance of being financially independent. I hope they manage to achieve that and don’t have to depend on a partner. Luck will come into that too of course.

I enjoy baking. But I also manage it with working full-time!

Surely what women that went before us fought for was equality? Which means choices?

If a woman, or a man, or anyone actually wants to stay home doing the domestic stuff, and can afford to, that's ok?

The women that went before us didn't fight for us to have to work five days a week and be career driven. They fought so we could if we chose to.

CasketBase · 23/04/2025 13:44

RedHairBob · 23/04/2025 13:42

Thanks for confirming that you made a baseless accusation.

No, I’m confirming that you’ve said a load of tripe as when I’ve called you up on it you’ve had a huff about one tiny detail rather than actually discussing the response. Which has only shown that your points are utterly irrelevant as even you can’t be arsed to have the conviction to stand by them. But that’s your prerogative.

OP posts:
RedHairBob · 23/04/2025 13:42

CasketBase · 23/04/2025 12:09

What a well thought out and carefully constructed response.

Thanks for confirming that you made a baseless accusation.

TheHerboriste · 23/04/2025 13:23

SouthLondonMum22 · 22/04/2025 21:53

Because mumsnet is full of desperately sad women trapped in horrible marriages and one of the first things they usually say is ''I can't leave, I'm a SAHM and have nothing''.

It is a huge risk and I don't blame others for pointing it out.

Exactly.

And usually it’s the “it will never happen to me”
smug types.

Thepeopleversuswork · 23/04/2025 13:19

BeneathTheSea · 23/04/2025 10:07

We are brainwashed into thinking if we are not frantically rushing around all day , juggling 10 balls in the air whilst still managing to earn a full time wage, our lives are meaningless.
Yes you will always get the women on here who find no enjoyment or contentment in being at home, looking after children, let them get on with it. They are usually miserable as sin in every area of their lives.
My Mum never worked once she had her children. She was the happiest Mum l knew.
never stressed, and never bothered going back to work once we were all independent.
We grew up in a calm and peaceful household. We all saw her as a fantastic role model, and feel sad we never got the same opportunity to stay home and concentrate on raising children and looking after the home.
Simplicity is key, if you can afford to stay home or just work part time then do it. You will never regret it.

This is a breathtakingly dim, reductive and offensive post. Women who enjoy work are "miserable as sin"?

What about women who have to work. Are they miserable as sin? Or is it just the ones who want to? Is it OK to slag off women who support their kids out of necessity or only the ones who enjoy their jobs?

There are people who enjoy working and people who enjoy being at home. I can come up with plenty of anecdata to counteract your ridiculous homespun bullshit about all SAHMs being happy. Like my own mother who hated being a SAHM so much it hugely impacted her mental health. t

CasketBase · 23/04/2025 13:13

SouthLondonMum22 · 23/04/2025 13:08

Men aren't socialised in the same way women are so it's hard to say as society and societal norms have such a huge influence.

Yes this is absolutely true.

OP posts:
CasketBase · 23/04/2025 13:13

Kellybonita · 23/04/2025 13:10

I know a lot of men who hate working , I have to say.

My father hated working. He always told me that. My brother hates working. My male cousin has told Me that he hates working.

My male colleagues in my job have said things like "we hate this place we are only here for the money. If only I could win the lottery etc"

I think a lot of people don't like working

Oh I don’t disagree about working, but I’m not sure how many would want to give up work to do cleaning and cooking and child rearing is my point. I may be wrong, but I haven’t met many men who would say they enjoy hanging the washing and baking and would choose that over going to work, does that make sense? I don’t mean just quitting work, I think many people would give up working in a formal sense if they had to!

OP posts:
Kellybonita · 23/04/2025 13:10

CasketBase · 23/04/2025 13:01

I want to point out that I support longer paternity leave, more maternity/paternity options and I support equal pay and opportunities so that men can be at home instead of women (in heterosexual partnerships) if that’s what both parties want. However as I said earlier, I’m not aure that men want a life of domesticity. Yes not working, but a domestic life over work is t something I’ve heard many men say they desire, I only know one.

I know a lot of men who hate working , I have to say.

My father hated working. He always told me that. My brother hates working. My male cousin has told Me that he hates working.

My male colleagues in my job have said things like "we hate this place we are only here for the money. If only I could win the lottery etc"

I think a lot of people don't like working

SouthLondonMum22 · 23/04/2025 13:08

CasketBase · 23/04/2025 13:01

I want to point out that I support longer paternity leave, more maternity/paternity options and I support equal pay and opportunities so that men can be at home instead of women (in heterosexual partnerships) if that’s what both parties want. However as I said earlier, I’m not aure that men want a life of domesticity. Yes not working, but a domestic life over work is t something I’ve heard many men say they desire, I only know one.

Men aren't socialised in the same way women are so it's hard to say as society and societal norms have such a huge influence.

G5000 · 23/04/2025 13:07

Yes you will always get the women on here who find no enjoyment or contentment in being at home, looking after children, let them get on with it. They are usually miserable as sin in every area of their lives.

Wow seriously?

CasketBase · 23/04/2025 13:01

I want to point out that I support longer paternity leave, more maternity/paternity options and I support equal pay and opportunities so that men can be at home instead of women (in heterosexual partnerships) if that’s what both parties want. However as I said earlier, I’m not aure that men want a life of domesticity. Yes not working, but a domestic life over work is t something I’ve heard many men say they desire, I only know one.

OP posts:
SouthLondonMum22 · 23/04/2025 12:51

BeneathTheSea · 23/04/2025 10:07

We are brainwashed into thinking if we are not frantically rushing around all day , juggling 10 balls in the air whilst still managing to earn a full time wage, our lives are meaningless.
Yes you will always get the women on here who find no enjoyment or contentment in being at home, looking after children, let them get on with it. They are usually miserable as sin in every area of their lives.
My Mum never worked once she had her children. She was the happiest Mum l knew.
never stressed, and never bothered going back to work once we were all independent.
We grew up in a calm and peaceful household. We all saw her as a fantastic role model, and feel sad we never got the same opportunity to stay home and concentrate on raising children and looking after the home.
Simplicity is key, if you can afford to stay home or just work part time then do it. You will never regret it.

Are men with careers and parents miserable as sin too? Or does it just apply to women who dare have careers as parents?

Vergus · 23/04/2025 12:41

@Tartanboots

It is easier to stay at home with the kids if you can afford it, so I can see why women do it but I do feel like they are letting the side down a bit.

No, there should be no judgement on a woman who chooses to be a full time mum and run her house. There is profound joy and satisfaction in doing this. More rewarding in many ways than sitting at a desk crunching numbers and wasting energy sustaining a work personality - no one gives a hoot about you at work, you'd be replaced tomorrow if you walked out the door and forgotten about in a month or less. I'm all for working mums - I am one, but let's not pour scorn on those who choose what is often the harder but more rewarding path

CasketBase · 23/04/2025 12:32

MerlinsBeard1 · 23/04/2025 12:20

@CasketBase Didn't you get the memo? A fair few Mumsnutters can't stand the idea of SAHM/housewives. The usual suspects have jumped on this thread quicker than a tramp on chips.. AGAIN. 😴

I find the ‘you must want what we want otherwise you’re betraying women’ (and now letting them down apparently) rhetoric really uncomfortable. Why can’t we have different desires in life?! I’m incredibly grateful to so many women who went before me, who paved the way, but I’m also grateful to my mam who stayed off work till I was 8 to be with me before she went to work full time. It’s weird how to some people, wanting to just raise your child is a negative issue. It’s just a choice!

OP posts:
Tartanboots · 23/04/2025 12:24

RedHairBob · 23/04/2025 10:40

This has been a bit of a depressing read. It is like the gender pay gap never happened. But then again, I am allergic to words like ‘housewife’ and ‘pottering’!

And there are some privileged viewpoints on here. I am from a culture where girls and women would do anything to get into good careers and senior positions. We don’t have it perfect in the UK but at least on paper women are able to apply for the highest roles, technically on an equal footing to men. On this thread we have so many women wanting to stay home, bake and clean whilst men do the Big Jobs. We have fought so hard for equality, yet women here now they (kind of) have it, want to turn their backs on it. I guess we take things for granted when we have them.

It is also naive to talk about the simple life and condemn people for wanting to earn more money. It is easy to label others as wanting a flashy lifestyle. The thing is, young kids are quite cheap. You don’t need much money. But when your children are older, it can be really helpful too assist them a bit when they are at university or leaving home, or with driving lessons. Also as the NHS becomes more and more challenged, it is good to have a bit of extra cash to help with health issues in yourselves and your children. I wouldn’t dismiss how helpful some extra money can be. It is not just needed for ‘flashy’ houses, cars or holidays. Money can relieve worries too. It is often people with enough money anyway who say money doesn’t matter…

The other thing I find irritating is all this talk about the rat race. There are many people who aren’t working in offices for big corporate firms. Many are public sector workers or people just keeping the country running as it is. I for one am also glad we have women MPs, doctors, lawyers, CEOs and judges. Women who established their careers in their child bearing years so that they can be in senior positions of power and achieve some equality and balance in the workplace at a senior level. I seem to be in a minority!

Anyway, I hope never to depend on a man or benefits (if I am lucky and healthy enough). Financial independence has always been important to me. My kids are at university now and thankfully realise the importance of being financially independent. I hope they manage to achieve that and don’t have to depend on a partner. Luck will come into that too of course.

I enjoy baking. But I also manage it with working full-time!

I really relate to this. It has taken so long for women to be taken seriously workwise and it is so important for women to be represented in professions. It is easier to stay at home with the kids if you can afford it, so I can see why women do it but I do feel like they are letting the side down a bit. Friends of mine who chose that path put up with so much shit from their husbands too! They never get a day off from serving people.
I did work part time 3 - 4 days a week when the kids were pre school age, there's a massive gap between doing that and doing no paid work at all.

Vergus · 23/04/2025 12:22

When I had my first son aged 32 I had been used to working in a demanding full-time job that required lots of interaction with people on a daily basis. I found suddenly going from that, to sitting at home with a crying baby a total and utter shock to the system. It was like the rug had just been literally yanked from under me and I was in freefall. I was a rabbit in the headlights. I don't think I enjoyed my 9 months at home with my first baby that much because of the culture shock. In fact, I was itching to get back to the office and have a break!

So back I went, part-time, but it wasn't like it was before. Everything and nothing had changed. I remember sitting in the office one morning and looking at an excel spreadsheet, and everyone was so quiet and calm and collected around me. I could go to the toilet in peace. Eat my lunch in peace. But..............it felt............surreal. I felt like it wasn't "real." I missed my baby boy. I kept thinking about him - and never stopped. He was always on my mind. I worried about whether he was happy, what he was doing, were the nursery staff looking after him well and had he eaten his lunch? If he had cried and clung to me when dropping him off in the morning I felt uneasy all day.

I had my 2nd son aged 36 and I LOVED my maternity leave with him. I think he healed me. I was no longer in transition. I knew I could do both, and when I went back to work the 2nd time around, I was a lot more easy going because I had made some peace with who I was and where my true priorities lie. Work is important to me but my sons come first, always have, always will. You can be a devoted mum and work, but having my babies fundamentally changed me, on a profound level. If I lost my job tomorrow I would worry, from the financial side but I'd be ok. I'd just find another one. My sons - they are irreplaceable and I like watching them grow.

MerlinsBeard1 · 23/04/2025 12:20

@CasketBase Didn't you get the memo? A fair few Mumsnutters can't stand the idea of SAHM/housewives. The usual suspects have jumped on this thread quicker than a tramp on chips.. AGAIN. 😴

JHound · 23/04/2025 12:15

And yes this leaves women with gaps in their CV / in a financally precarious position (which marriage offers some protection for) but that’s their business.

CasketBase · 23/04/2025 12:14

exprecis · 23/04/2025 12:05

I also really dislike dismissive comments about women's careers as being about "the rat race and flashy stuff"

My career makes a real difference to the world around me, it's no "rat race" and it's not about flashy stuff any more than DH's career is

I haven’t said that women’s careers are those things, I would defend any woman’s choice of career or choice to solely raise her children. I haven’t used the phrase ‘Ray race’ I don’t think, but when I’ve talked about not wanting things like foreign holidays and cars etc I’m referring to my own choice not to dearie more money. None of this has been linked to women choosing to have a career.

The difference is that whilst I’m willing to defend a woman’s choice to work all she wants and have equal pay and rights, it seems I have to apologise for discussing my internal desire to stay home and raise my child. Even though I’m not actually going to stop working. That’s not fair feminism to make me feel bad for assessing my feelings. It’s not right.

Im sorry if anyone has made you feel a type of way but I don’t feel that way about your choices at all, your choices are your choices and I respect them, but some posters don’t respect mine.

OP posts: