Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think you are NOT a good dad?

107 replies

BobbyDazzler11 · 21/04/2025 07:15

Met with a friend over the weekend who's 1YO is awake a lot in the night. Her DP doesn't get up for any wakes as she said he believes 'it's her issue to sort' . He has always just left her to it.

He does no other care type responsibilities. Just the fun stuff. She plans to have multiple more children with him.

I am honestly sick of hearing of these lazy men. Then they take their child/children to the park for an hour and believe they are father of the year????

So AIBU to think you are NOT a good dad if you don't do all of the following...

  • pitch in for night wakes
  • making breakfasts/lunches/dinners
  • do self care for the children inc teeth brushing/ nails cut etc
  • look after your children with ridiculous amount of instruction and prep from the mum!

I can't imagine as a mother just opting out of these things?????

OP posts:
Bumpitybumper · 21/04/2025 09:05

ThejoyofNC · 21/04/2025 08:55

Right so whilst he's out of the house for 12 hours a day he is also sat on his arse watching me. Makes sense.

He works all weekend too does he?

The cognitive dissonance on this thread is crazy. People going to great lengths to justify why their clearly lazy and inconsiderate partners are actually great dads. Other women are suggesting it's not good enough because they have partners that do more. They work difficult, hard jobs and do their share at home and with the kids.

CopperWhite · 21/04/2025 09:04

Tbrh · 21/04/2025 08:53

Comments like this really bug me because it shows how so many people have no idea how hard it is to be a SAHP to a young child. The difference when you have a useless partner is your job is 24/7 and theirs in 40hrs. Have a moment to ponder that. If you were working 24/7 with minimal sleep and your boss (ie baby) needing constant care and attention you'd want some help or a break every now and then too. Piss off with your providing money comment 🙄

Erm, I had maternity leaves and was a SAHM apart from one shift a week, so I don’t need a moment to ponder it thanks, I lived it. And my ex didn’t earn much money in all the hours he worked either, so I can can see the value of having a partner who does provide well financially even if they don’t do much baby care.

I agree that a partner should help out at weekends, but I object to fathers being called shit fathers when they are making a massive contribution to the family. No one calls mothers shit mothers if they only do the caring part and not the providing part, so why is it different the other way around?

BobbyDazzler11 · 21/04/2025 09:02

Neemie · 21/04/2025 08:53

When I was on maternity leave I did pretty much everything. DH worked really hard and saved up enough money to buy a house near my work so I wouldn’t have a long commute when I went back. He often got less sleep than me. People divide things up differently and you never know what goes on in a relationship. If your friend is happy with the setup, it is fine.

She wasn't. Thats the whole point. Shes asked for help and he said it's her problem.

She is also just back to work.

OP posts:
Rastyopolis · 21/04/2025 09:00

IButtleSir · 21/04/2025 08:48

Are you seriously claiming there are as many useless mothers as there are useless fathers? That just as many women abandon their children as men do?

And for your reasons on staying if you’re with someone and you can’t trust them to look after their own kids then that is quite frankly your own fault!
Unless that person had access to a crystal ball before having children with someone, then no, it is not their fault if their partner is a shit parent.

@IButtleSir i said useless, not abandon. And yes there are lots of useless mothers. I had one! I personally just hate the narrative of it’s always the dads fault. A lot of wormen don’t help themselves, for which there is no excuse!

Bumpitybumper · 21/04/2025 08:56

AliBaliBee1234 · 21/04/2025 07:48

06:30 is early to wake up if you've had to get up through the night and that's her whole point...

I agree completely. My post was in response to another poster who suggested that their partner shouldn't have to get involved with the night wakings because they woke up at 6:30am for work I was merely point out that this isn't a particularly early wake up time and certainly doesn't excuse anyone from pulling their weight at night.

ThejoyofNC · 21/04/2025 08:55

JoyousRoseExpert · 21/04/2025 08:47

"I wouldn't know how to do his job without instructions would I?"

But parenting is his job. So yes, he should know how. And if you watched him do his job daily and gave a shit you could learn it too. Just as he could.

Right so whilst he's out of the house for 12 hours a day he is also sat on his arse watching me. Makes sense.

Minimalistmamaoftwo · 21/04/2025 08:54

My husband and I have always shared the night wakes despite him working and me being a SAHM. Why should I have no sleep when I am also working all day looking after our child. He has never even questioned this. He also does all of the above you have listed OP and our children are equally well looked after by both of us. Your friends husband sounds awful

Neemie · 21/04/2025 08:53

When I was on maternity leave I did pretty much everything. DH worked really hard and saved up enough money to buy a house near my work so I wouldn’t have a long commute when I went back. He often got less sleep than me. People divide things up differently and you never know what goes on in a relationship. If your friend is happy with the setup, it is fine.

Tbrh · 21/04/2025 08:53

CopperWhite · 21/04/2025 08:14

I don’t think it’s a problem when one parent is a SAHP and one parent is working. Both parents are equally contributing to the family.

The working parent cant ask the other parent to chip in with providing money when he’s tired or needs more money.

Comments like this really bug me because it shows how so many people have no idea how hard it is to be a SAHP to a young child. The difference when you have a useless partner is your job is 24/7 and theirs in 40hrs. Have a moment to ponder that. If you were working 24/7 with minimal sleep and your boss (ie baby) needing constant care and attention you'd want some help or a break every now and then too. Piss off with your providing money comment 🙄

SomethingFun · 21/04/2025 08:52

Even if you’re a sahm the work of child rearing should be split when your partner isn’t working outside the home. I don’t see how as a parent you can have anymore than a superficial relationship with your dc if you don’t spend any time with them.

MsCactus · 21/04/2025 08:51

Me and DH did sleep shifts and split the nights - it meant we both got a chunk of uninterrupted sleep.

We did this regardless of who was off with the baby Vs who was working out of the home (we split parental leave so both did both roles). I think it's ridiculous when people say the person looking after the baby doesn't need sleep as they're not "working". Your baby is your most precious thing! If you're too sleep deprived you could fall asleep with them on the sofa or something and they could die - the worst that usually happens if you're sleep deprived at a job is that you get fired and get another job. It's not comparable - the person looking after the baby should get more sleep imo (I still think this and both me and DH are in high earning/high pressure jobs)

IButtleSir · 21/04/2025 08:51

ThejoyofNC · 21/04/2025 08:43

I'm an excellent example to my kids thank you. So is their dad. You've clearly never met a gypsy before. Your loss.

Being a gypsy is not an excuse for sexism.

JoyousRoseExpert · 21/04/2025 08:50

My father is French gypsy btw. It's fuck all excuse to treat women like shit.

IButtleSir · 21/04/2025 08:48

Rastyopolis · 21/04/2025 08:37

@IButtleSir it’s not nearly always the father. Why is MN so anti dads? There are loads of useless mothers too! The blame sits with both the partner being lazy and the partner putting up with it. Often people behave like shit because people let them get away with it! And for your reasons on staying if you’re with someone and you can’t trust them to look after their own kids then that is quite frankly your own fault!

Are you seriously claiming there are as many useless mothers as there are useless fathers? That just as many women abandon their children as men do?

And for your reasons on staying if you’re with someone and you can’t trust them to look after their own kids then that is quite frankly your own fault!
Unless that person had access to a crystal ball before having children with someone, then no, it is not their fault if their partner is a shit parent.

JoyousRoseExpert · 21/04/2025 08:47

"I wouldn't know how to do his job without instructions would I?"

But parenting is his job. So yes, he should know how. And if you watched him do his job daily and gave a shit you could learn it too. Just as he could.

Tbrh · 21/04/2025 08:45

I only disagree on night wakes if one parent doesn't work, but they should still do breakfast one morning so the other parent gets a sleep in

JoyousRoseExpert · 21/04/2025 08:44

How does one "not allow it" anyway? Does she leave the partner knowing he's not going to do 50/50 when they split so she'll have all the work and a higher financial burden?

And where all the shit mums who neglect their children because the men don't "allow it"?. It's one more job for women micro managing men

ThejoyofNC · 21/04/2025 08:43

Simonjt · 21/04/2025 08:39

Yes darling we have to have ten people helping while mummy is in hospital because daddy is rubbish and doesn’t want to raise you.

What a brilliant example to children, training daughters to be household appliances and sons to do absolutely nothing.

I'm an excellent example to my kids thank you. So is their dad. You've clearly never met a gypsy before. Your loss.

Thejazzz · 21/04/2025 08:42

My exes mum a full blown narc would did all the night feeds, cleaning, self care, lunches l, dinner stay home mum, etc his step father would go to work, she told him you work and bring me the money 😳 she also alienated the kids from their real dad, made them call step dad their real dad, changed their surnames, poisoned them into hating their real dad, and so much more, of course she was always the victim. She got 2 houses out of those men and never worked in a job. Let’s not make all women out to be hero’s. Some men work damn hard to make a nice home, and work all hours. 2 out if the kids don’t talk to her due to her instability of mind but she did all those things you mentioned and kept a clean and tidy home too

JoyousRoseExpert · 21/04/2025 08:42

Yanbu but people don't like it when you point out that their husband is kind of shit as this thread is basically doing.

And fuck the pp who say women on mat leave don't need sleep because men have big important jobs. Not falling asleep with a newborn is life or death, it's at least as important as your husband's crappy self important nonsense job.

I can't remember what book it was (invisible women?) but they showed two families with GPs. In the female GP couple she was the one doing the bulk of childcare because her job allowed it. In the second couple he was the GP so his wife did the bulk of childcare because his job didn't allow it. 🙄

BobbyDazzler11 · 21/04/2025 08:40

For those saying the mother shouldn't put up with it etc. I think some of the comments here prove why they do? They think it's there job to get on with and to have low expectations.

It makes me sad.

OP posts:
Simonjt · 21/04/2025 08:39

ThejoyofNC · 21/04/2025 08:31

What a load of rubbish. My children would have at least 10 people who would care for them.

Traditional set ups work just fine.

You quite obviously think you know everything, but actually know very little.

Yes darling we have to have ten people helping while mummy is in hospital because daddy is rubbish and doesn’t want to raise you.

What a brilliant example to children, training daughters to be household appliances and sons to do absolutely nothing.

BobbyDazzler11 · 21/04/2025 08:38

Simonjt · 21/04/2025 08:34

Its a bit odd to say a man acting like that is shit (i agree) and then to reveal your own partner is the same, but its okay because he has a job, no, he’s exactly the same as the person you’re complaining about.

I said the conversation came up as I shared that on the weekend, when I was on mat leave, we both had a night totally off wakings.
So we both had a full night sleep and lie in.

This is when she shared her DP wouldn't do this as he said it's her problem to deal with.

How is this the same?

No my DP didn't do night wakings in the working week generally but when I was as raggid as my friend currently is and was diagnosed pnd. He booked a week off work and did all care as I felt so poorly. And I just slept! Not the same :)

OP posts:
Rastyopolis · 21/04/2025 08:37

IButtleSir · 21/04/2025 08:31

why would either a mum or dad put up with the other parent not pulling their weight.

Lots of reasons: because they don't want to split up their family, because they don't trust the other parent to look after the kids properly if they share custody, because the thought of being a single parent is more terrifying than having a useless partner, because of finances.

Put the blame where it belongs: on the partner (almost always the father) not pulling their weight with the parenting.

@IButtleSir it’s not nearly always the father. Why is MN so anti dads? There are loads of useless mothers too! The blame sits with both the partner being lazy and the partner putting up with it. Often people behave like shit because people let them get away with it! And for your reasons on staying if you’re with someone and you can’t trust them to look after their own kids then that is quite frankly your own fault!

Cookiedoughsundays · 21/04/2025 08:35

ThejoyofNC · 21/04/2025 08:31

What a load of rubbish. My children would have at least 10 people who would care for them.

Traditional set ups work just fine.

You quite obviously think you know everything, but actually know very little.

Whether relatives or paid employees, I do think it is incredibly sad that your husband needed to be supervised by a team of people when around his children. You can have a traditional set up AND make your children a priority.