Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can I take this NIGHTMARE landlord to court?

184 replies

DisgracefulBehaviour · 20/04/2025 22:31

We sold our house last year to release funds as we inherited a house in a different area that we wanted to live in ourselves due to position, large plot etc, as our forever home but the house itself needed fully gutting and we also wanted to add on a self contained annex for our disabled adult son which we needed planning permission for. Our youngest son was also due to start GCSEs so we decided to rent while we completed work on inherited house and he finished school when we will then move up there.

We found a rented property literally a few streets from our old house and stressed that we needed to rent for two years, landlord wanted long term renters so no problem.

Within a short time after moving in it became apparent there was a major issue in the house, house was tenanted previously but letting agents apparently were not aware. After months of toing and froing, landlord had to get builders in and complete costly work which took 8 weeks. We’d been in the property 3 months.

Landlord not happy as said he could not afford to do the work.

We’d requested compensation for the inconvenience as having builders in was a major disruption and we had issues with them leaving mess in the house. I was very upset that we had to leave people we did not know in the property while we were all out.

Landlord said compensation was not justified! Decided not to pursue it as we didn’t want to antagonise the landlord and get kicked out.

A month ago, I contacted environmental health due to a further issue the landlord has refused to deal with. The officer also noticed a major issue that needed immediate rectification so landlord had to do more work.

We have now been served with a Section 21 - no reason given - after 6 months.

I am absolutely furious I have to say. Rent paid on time, house immaculate etc.

We put up with all the work being done as we expected when it was done, we’d be left to it and obviously didn’t want to move again in such a short time considering our timescale. We’d never taken the property if we had known this would happen. It’s a high rent for our area too!

We also never had a copy of the EICR, a serious safety hazard pertaining to that was what was picked up by environmental health, so we are assuming a report was never done.

I have an online court claim prepared to sue the landlord for all 6 months rent in compensation, for stress and breach of quiet enjoyment. I think I have a chance of success.

AIBU?

OP posts:
DisgracefulBehaviour · 20/04/2025 22:44

ToKittyornottoKitty · 20/04/2025 22:38

I can’t see why you’d get 6 months back. And with problems keep coming up and you guys complaining about the disruption and wanting compensation I’m not surprised he’s served notice on you, he can’t really afford to keep you. Fingers crossed you can find another rental to keep you going. Is your deposit properly protected?

What on earth! We’ve done absolutely nothing wrong and fully abided by our side of the tenancy agreement.

Landlord let out an unsafe house which was not fit for habitation!

Are you a landlord perchance?

OP posts:
AhBiscuits · 20/04/2025 22:43

You have zero chance of getting 6 months rent back, you'd only get that if deemed uninhabitable for the entire 6 months.

Make a more reasonable demand and send a letter before claim, see what comes back.

Tootiredtowhat · 20/04/2025 22:43

You need to prove a loss. You can’t prove a loss for the 6 months rent you are asking for. At best you can prove 2 months. I think you undermine your case by exaggerating the value.

You are in shaky ground because the landlord is doing work you asked for. So I don’t think it is a given by any stretch of the imagination

DisgracefulBehaviour · 20/04/2025 22:42

I’ve only just realised about the EICR. Looked for documents when we got the Section 21. I thought it was tacked onto end of tenancy agreement which was electronically generated. Makes sense now as house did not meet legal requirements and that would have been picked up in it.

OP posts:
ToKittyornottoKitty · 20/04/2025 22:38

I can’t see why you’d get 6 months back. And with problems keep coming up and you guys complaining about the disruption and wanting compensation I’m not surprised he’s served notice on you, he can’t really afford to keep you. Fingers crossed you can find another rental to keep you going. Is your deposit properly protected?

DisgracefulBehaviour · 20/04/2025 22:37

Thanks. I have tried Shelter recently and going back months ago when landlord was dragging his heels about doing the major work, but can never get to speak to anyone!

I have checked the legal side myself and am pretty confident we have a case.

OP posts:
Longhotsummers · 20/04/2025 22:36

The building work took 8 weeks not the full six months that you will have rented the property, therefore I do not think a claim for all rent paid will succeed, especially if you are claiming for stress.

Why did you not follow up via the agent re the EICR? In my opinion, that also weakens your case.

Welshmonster · 20/04/2025 22:35

You won't get anywhere with the landlord in court. You would need to prove financial loss.

They want you out and they will rent to people who won't actually hold them to account. I would make sure that relevant Council departments are informed and letting agent made aware. Any new tenants that come to view the property, make them aware of issues.

Hoppinggreen · 20/04/2025 22:35

Speak to Shelter or get proper Legal advice

Swipe left for the next trending thread