Another mosley cashing in

Jeez. Ignore him if you're gonna get triggered. Personally I like reading diet advice and ignore it as I see fit. Dr Mosley did a lot of good stuff that I never paid for.

So you'd rather give your money to big pharma instead? So hypocritical. Don't see much wrong with someone trying to help people lose weight healthily instead of pumping themselves with drugs when we have no idea of the long term effects of them.

There are side effects to all drugs. Some
of the worst side effects I’ve dealt with have been the side effects of obesity. Including people who are quite simply too fat to breathe. Those people need help. Their obesity is life threatening.

I learned some things from Michael Mosley and have never purchased any of his books. The principles were usually distilled in various newspapers (I don’t read the Daily Mail). But in any event it’s perfectly fine to ‘cash in’
or ’make a living’ as others would say.

I followed Mosleys blood sugar diet, lost a significant amount of weight, there was an excellent free website and active forum - all free, no pressure to buy books/diet plans.

I loved Michael Mosely TBF.

I always liked Michael Moseley and have a couple of his books as I'm a thinner prediabetic as he was.

@badgermushroomm fair point.

I honestly don't know what his motivations might be, and was playing devil's advocate

It’s great that his son is continuing his dad’s work. What big shoes to step in to but what a privilege it must be.

Everyone has different approaches to losing weight and mm obviously isn’t for you. WLI aren’t for everyone either.

MM is one of the very few people I would listen to regarding lifestyle and maybe his son is doing this in honour of his dads very successful work.

Well, yes. He was a science communicator, not a research scientist.

Communicating science in a way that’s understandable to the average person, especially at a time when most people barely have a GCSE in biology, is really difficult.

MM helped a lot of people understand the fundamentals of weight loss and healthy eating.

If you want to get angry at someone ‘cashing in’, I suggest you start with those lying and selling snake oil supplements, not a family of doctors.

I do agree on the Mail, though - but if you’re reading it, you don’t really have a principled stance, do you?

Sounds sensible, and he's qualified at least!

I agree 👍🏻

YABU

I lost 50kg without paying out a penny to anyone... Proper old style.

Mosley had a business, son took over the business. Simple as that. I never thought highly of these businesses, but at least it's not full on scamming people. 🤷

It sounds quite sensible, I don't have a problem with him.
Quote from the Mirror:
Jack, a GP Registrar and an expert in GLP-1 drugs - medications that can help manage Type 2 diabetes and obesity - explained the reason behind the book. He said: "I've spent years researching these groundbreaking medications. My medical training and Masters of Research in Diabetes has given me deep insight into the treatment of obesity, as well as the science behind these drugs, which are helping many people take control of their weight by silencing the “food noise” in their brains.

"But with these new "miracle" drugs comes the responsibility of using them safely and effectively. Many people buy them online without proper guidance, leading to potential risks like malnutrition and muscle loss.
"That’s why I’ve written Food Noise - to explain the science behind GLP-1s and how to use them safely. I combine real-life stories with practical advice on maintaining nutrients, preserving muscle mass, and building lasting habits to keep food noise at bay, even after stopping the medication."

Yeah, jacking up is a bit extreme! It's an injection into the muscle. You're not gonna turn into Pete fucking Doherty!

YABU for looking at the DM

There's nothing wrong with a doctor using someone else's research. The difference between a scientist/doctor doing this and an influencer is that the former is likely to have academic training in how to filter / use research. It's not just about reading it, it's about being able to understand it and look at where it is published, how reliable each source is. Not all published material is equal.

Why does he have to be doing it for some hollow, nefarious reason?

Michael Mosely was respected as a great medical journalist and talented communicator who made a positive impact in a lot of people’s lives.

Maybe his (still grieving) family are proud of him and his legacy? Maybe they want to continue projects he was working on and follow in his footsteps rather than ‘move on’ and consign MM’s work to the past. He died less than a year ago, I’m sure anything they do to do with their Dad will mean a fair bit to them, as it would to any human in the same position.

Not really, diet plans don't have thyroid cancer, kidney malfunction or gall bladder issues as a potential side effect.

Critique and discuss any approach to health you like.

But personal digs are just nasty.

Avarice, ego, cashing in, etc etc.

Laughable when you consider the huge profits made by faceless corporations to provide drugs on a commercial basis.

Read all sources you trust (preferably researched or offered by qualified professionals) and pick what suits you.

No bitterness or vitriol required.

Two people at my work use/used them. One is a size 14, stopped at Christmas and is still suffering with some side affects such as wind and upset stomach. She barely changed her diet, still ate chocolate and crisps and drank alcohol. The second one has been on them for a month because she wants to lose a stone for her holidays, again still eats chocolate and drinks alcohol.

Surely THAT is cashing in?

You don’t need any will power for the injections. That’s the whole point of them.

This is also where I drew the line.

I've followed the 800 diet plan and there some really lovely recipes in the books, I also get the newsletters which have recipes on too. I have 3 of the recipe books. I found this fairly easy to follow and could adjust the recipes to accommodate the rest of the family so as not to be cooking lots of different meals, I can cook these then add extra carbs for them.

I will admit that I felt disappointed when they started promoting the milkshakes, it was like Michael of all people should have known better as it was these types of diet products that caused issues for lots of us. Replacement shakes are the worst and certainly not true the Mediterranean Diet that MM has previously promoted so much.

In Food Noise, he explains the science behind the diabetes and weight-loss drugs and suggests what to eat while using them, to maintain good nutrition and retain muscle mass, along with what to do to keep the weight off using recipes and meal plans after stopping the medication.

Sounds sensible to me, especially as most of the people I know taking them are not getting them via the NHS, so don't have this sort of dedicated advice ?