Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it such a bad thing If I don't have children?

117 replies

Notsure54 · 19/04/2025 18:02

I'm 25 soon to be 26 and have pcos hypothyroidism anxiety depression and schizophrenia. Im not 100% on not having children because I do love babys but at the same time I know it will be a struggle for me to conceive and carry a baby of my own not to mention the problems my child might have due to my illnesses and the medication I'm on. I think about it alot as I always hear guys and other woman saying ill regret it if I don't have children and will end up alone with cats. Don't get me wrong I love cats but the way they put it. Its like its a bad thing. In the media it's very romanticised online having children and a blood line. I dont care about ending my bloodline tbh. It was never spectacular anyway. Is anyone else the same or older with the same issues and haven't had children and not regretted it?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CandidRaven · 28/04/2025 15:50

I wouldn't have children in your position because as a child of someone with psychosis, it was so very hard for me and my sibling growing up, we had to be passed around a lot because my mums illness couldn't be controlled and when it was controlled we didn't know how long for, i witnessed things a child should never see, i became a carer for her when I was still a teenager and missed school because of this I wouldn't willingly put a child through that, if I had developed the same illness I absolutely would never have had children, I don't know your situation or how well controlled your illness is but it is a big risk to put a child through if you go downhill

DataColour · 28/04/2025 14:46

Parenting teenagers through peri menopause honestly was one of the hardest phases of life I've ever been through.

Same here. Currently in the middle of it now and it is HELL. Lots of people find the baby and toddler phase hard, but this is far harder and I had 2 kids under 2.

TokyoKyoto · 28/04/2025 13:59

I have kids and it's been ok. I adore them but the immersion and the process of motherhood was only occasionally fulfilling. I very much didn't enjoy the societal inequality. Getting all that straight within the family was a slog. It's very bitty as an experience, overall. There are great parts of it and the actual people, my children, are wonderful.

I have a good number of close friends without children. Some chose it, some did not. I think when they were in their 30s it was far more of a pain in the arse, because people kept expecting them to want children and seemed to judge them a lot (they all say this). All are in their 40s and 50s now and don't regret it. They are very free, very financially stable (by design) and not all of them have a relationship. It is a good life.

I've just gone through menopause and I'll say, I don't know how it is with schizophrenia, but don't discount hormonal upheavals and mental illness. The you that is typing now wouldn't be the version of you who goes through pregnancy and the postpartum period (which is up and down anyway). Age changes you. Parenting teenagers through peri menopause honestly was one of the hardest phases of life I've ever been through.

Notsure54 · 28/04/2025 13:49

I'm on flouxetine and olanzapine which there is a risk of muscular skeletal problems and heart defects

OP posts:
oOiluvfriendsOo · 21/04/2025 15:47

My partner has 3 siblings and only 1 of the 4 of them has children. All past child bearing age now and no regrets from any of them.
You do you, don't be swayed by others.

Webbedlife · 21/04/2025 15:28

I'm in my early 60s and never had a child. I was never sure I wanted kids, had a somewhat unhappy childhood and have struggled with depression on/off. I am married, but he too was ambivalent about having children. I don't regret it, and am in a good phase of my life right now. I do wonder what will happen when I get much older, as I, my husband and sister have been quite supportive to my parents when elderly, helping with hospital appointments and the like and we won't have that. But having children as some kind of insurance policy against the future seems a bit off anyway.

Surferosa · 21/04/2025 14:56

Anyway I'm not sure if I've addressed the OPs post fully. You are only 25 and if having children is something you do think you want, it can be worth discussing with your doctor and psychiatrist in terms of medication, your illnesses and what support is out there. I've known people who have had pcos and hypothyroidism who have also concieved and carried babies.

Equally you might decide you don't want to be a mum and that the sacrifice to your health isn't worth it or you just don't want children full stop. No one should justify or explain why they don't want children. It's completely fine to say you don't want children because you just don't want them!

It's a very personal decision with no right or wrong answer. Some people do regret not having children, other people are completely at ease with their decision. Other people completely love being a mother and others regret their children.

I would as hard as it is, ignore all these stereotypes or comments that if you don't have children that it is guaranteed you'll regret it or you'll end up lonely with cats. Some people get very weird about someone's decision to not have children and come out with all sorts of nonsense to try and shame or scare people.

I have anxiety and depression (though not schizophrenia) and it took me a lot of counselling and soul searching before I decided to have my son. It's not been easy but I am happy and don't regret my decision. However this only applies to me and your own situation and thoughts are entirely different.

EmeraldShamrock000 · 21/04/2025 14:29

I think it is a very mature decision, many people don't assess their personal situation when it comes to having DC.
DC are wonderful but they are hard word that requires a lot input.
Sadly, many of those children end up as carers or neglected when the parents illness becomes unmanageable.
Then there is the risk of passing on hereditary illnesses.
Well done on considering the long-term implications.

Viviennemary · 21/04/2025 14:18

If you are not sure it would be better not to have children. But on the other hand you might feel differently in a few years. You've got plenty of time to decide.

curtaintwitcher78 · 21/04/2025 14:12

My mum always said "None to make you laugh, none to make you cry."
It helped me with my decision. You'll miss out on good things, you'll miss out on bad things. Go with your true desires.

pinkyredrose · 21/04/2025 14:06

I'm in my 50s and ND. Being single with cats has always sounded a million times better than having children!

Coconutter24 · 21/04/2025 13:59

Do you take any medication that will affect pregnancy or baby?

Strawberriesandpears · 21/04/2025 13:54

@Surferosa It is interesting to think about how the landscape might change with regard to elderly care. Near me there are plans for a 'wellness village' which seems a bit different to a retirement village. It includes an 'integrated fragility hub' which I think means like an onsite hospital.

Strawberriesandpears · 21/04/2025 13:48

Surferosa · 21/04/2025 13:19

I don't want to derail this thread as I know you've posted a lot about this and I think professional support is what you need. But having children isn't going to stop you have dementia and wandering into a road. It isn't going to stop you being on your own with just carers popping in.

I've had many many clients who have had children and dealt with the exact same situations you have described above. Having children doesn't mean you're somehow sorted for old age or you're going to avoid being lonely or all these catastrophic things you think will happen.
It would be very wrong to have children for these reasons. Would you have them and then demand that they stay with you for the rest of their lives so you're not lonely and they can look after you? What if they want their own family or want to move abroad?

Not everyone needs care or gets dementia, and in fact many people don't even live to old age. I've had many relatives drop dead suddenly at a young age. You're worrying about and catasphrosing about things that entirely outwith your control. And deciding to spend the next 30-40 years with a sense of panic and dread is frankly ludicrous when you could be out there living your life, making connections and getting proper support to help you live a meaningful life.

Not having children doesn't doom you to a life of lonelieness and no support. More and more women and men are not having children and I think this in itself will make people rely more on communities and external support which is a good thing. And as mentioned before I know many family friends in their 60s and 70s who don't have children and they are all happy, content and live full rich lives.

Oh absolutely I wouldn't have children for the sole purpose of having someone to look after me in old age. I see on the elderly parents board how burnt out some people are looking after parents who refuse outside help.

It's just I read so much online (and here on Mumsnet) about how difficult the care system is to navigate if you don't have loving advocates. I guess they don't have to be children though, could be nieces or nephews (for those who have them). For me I will have no choice but to rely on friends and that feels like a huge burden to put on them.

This is why I would like to move to a retirement village setting where the care is delivered by paid professionals and any decisions on when to increase levels of care are again made by professionals. I don't want to be a burden on anyone (be that children or friends).

Surferosa · 21/04/2025 13:19

Strawberriesandpears · 21/04/2025 10:30

Thank you. I think it's understandable and reasonable for me to want to try and plan ahead and imagine myself living in a place with companionship and care. The retirement village I have been looking at is celebrating its 100th birthday soon (it hasn't always been a village - it has been just a care home too) and it has also undergone some development lately, so it seems like its future is relatively certain? Currently it's all privately funded. It doesn't accept LA funded residents, and I should be able to afford it. It's a lovely place with lovely grounds, hence why I daydream about living there someday.

I understand what you say about neighbours and community but isn't there a worry that that might not look the same in 40 years or so. That people will be more insular etc? Obviously I really hope not, and I will do my best to be a good member of my community and to care and look out for others too.

I think my worst nightmare is that I get dementia and there is nobody to notice and I wander out into a road one day. Or that my health fades and I spend my days alone at home with random carers popping in for 10 minutes at a time. If in the retirement village, at least I would have company all the time.

Sorry, just rambling really and putting some of my worst fears into words.

I don't want to derail this thread as I know you've posted a lot about this and I think professional support is what you need. But having children isn't going to stop you have dementia and wandering into a road. It isn't going to stop you being on your own with just carers popping in.

I've had many many clients who have had children and dealt with the exact same situations you have described above. Having children doesn't mean you're somehow sorted for old age or you're going to avoid being lonely or all these catastrophic things you think will happen.
It would be very wrong to have children for these reasons. Would you have them and then demand that they stay with you for the rest of their lives so you're not lonely and they can look after you? What if they want their own family or want to move abroad?

Not everyone needs care or gets dementia, and in fact many people don't even live to old age. I've had many relatives drop dead suddenly at a young age. You're worrying about and catasphrosing about things that entirely outwith your control. And deciding to spend the next 30-40 years with a sense of panic and dread is frankly ludicrous when you could be out there living your life, making connections and getting proper support to help you live a meaningful life.

Not having children doesn't doom you to a life of lonelieness and no support. More and more women and men are not having children and I think this in itself will make people rely more on communities and external support which is a good thing. And as mentioned before I know many family friends in their 60s and 70s who don't have children and they are all happy, content and live full rich lives.

Ilady · 21/04/2025 13:02

You have pcos hypothyroidism anxiety depression and schizophrenia. That's a lot to deal with in your mid 20's. Along with this you need to consider that you have schizophrenia and you may not be able to take your current medication if you were pregnant. Then pregnancy is hard on the body and can effect you mentally even after the birth.

You need to consider your own health and then would you be able to care for a baby, deal with a small child and cope with a child at the horrible teen-age stage. I have friends with kids and being honest I am glad I am child free.

In your situation I would work on keeping as well as possible and lose some weight if your overweight. I would work on friendships and go on days out and have holidays.

Woman can and do have good lives been childfree. I know a lady who is now in her 70's who never had kid's. She kept up her friendship groups, kept in contact with family and relatives . She has her own home and has a nice lifestyle. She has travelled a lot in the past and still goes on holidays. She sees her family and relatives on a regular basis and they call to see her because they like her. She is generous to people who are good to her. She also cut a few people out when she realised they find her if they needed something but ignored her the rest of the time.

It easy for other people to say that a woman should have kids but it not them who have to get pregnant and then have to bring up a child. I also think it not fair to have a child unless it's something that you really want to do. You also have to consider your own physical and mental health and you don't want to pass health issues on to them.

Strawberriesandpears · 21/04/2025 10:47

Evaka · 21/04/2025 10:39

Mid 40s, child free with a lovely partner and a sweet cat. Couldn't be happier with my lot. Similarly to PPs, I am so relieved not to be navigating this bonkers world on behalf of a little one.

Whilst I am sad not to have children, I also feel relief that I don't have to guide anyone in this mad world!

Evaka · 21/04/2025 10:39

Mid 40s, child free with a lovely partner and a sweet cat. Couldn't be happier with my lot. Similarly to PPs, I am so relieved not to be navigating this bonkers world on behalf of a little one.

Strawberriesandpears · 21/04/2025 10:34

@Surferosa Apologies, I hope my reply didn't sound ungrateful. I am not! Thank you for sharing your thoughts and experiences. I definitely agree that people should not have children to avoid loneliness or for their old age care, and you are right - some adult children do seem to be very demanding around things like childcare.

Strawberriesandpears · 21/04/2025 10:30

Surferosa · 21/04/2025 08:39

I don't mean to burst your bubble but you're looking at what these retiring villages are offering now. By the time you will need that sort of care, the type of support and care these retirement villages will be different, eligibility criteria and funding will be different and a lot of these places won't exist and will be replaced by something new. I'm not saying this to be gloomy just that the landscape of social care is always changing and it seems pointless to be so so fixated on something that may or not exist in about 40 years.

And aren't all older people orphans of some sort? I'd find it extremely rare to find someone of elderly age still with parents about and many people have already found their siblings have died off too.

Absolutely no one should have children so they won't be lonely or have someone to care for them when they are older. It's a terrible and enormous burden to place on children. People should have children because they want them. Not to held stave their own existential crises or as some sort of solution to their own anxiety.

As I said before, I really cannot emphasise the benefits of community and neighbours. From my own work, children and families make no difference to whether a person will be lonely when they are older and in so many cases, they create so much more many problems than they solve. I have a son but I 100% understand and agree with the reasons why people don't want them! You only have to read posts on here from adult children who state they won't help their own parents in old age unless they get help with childcare. Who call their retired parents selfish for wanting to go on holiday or spend their retirement how they please. There seems to be this expectation that once you have children, you must then spend the remainder of your life in absolute servitude for them, that even as your children grow older and have families of their own, the grandparents are still expected to put all their own health, wants and wishes aside.

No wonder people look at the above and think "no thanks". People should be absolutely free to make choices and life decisions with no judgement. As I mentioned before I know many family friends in their 60s and 70s with no children and some even with no nieces or nephews. And far from being lonely or sad, I actually think they have enormous peace and contentment from living a life that they can dedicate to themselves without burning themselves out providing care to children and grandchildren.

Thank you. I think it's understandable and reasonable for me to want to try and plan ahead and imagine myself living in a place with companionship and care. The retirement village I have been looking at is celebrating its 100th birthday soon (it hasn't always been a village - it has been just a care home too) and it has also undergone some development lately, so it seems like its future is relatively certain? Currently it's all privately funded. It doesn't accept LA funded residents, and I should be able to afford it. It's a lovely place with lovely grounds, hence why I daydream about living there someday.

I understand what you say about neighbours and community but isn't there a worry that that might not look the same in 40 years or so. That people will be more insular etc? Obviously I really hope not, and I will do my best to be a good member of my community and to care and look out for others too.

I think my worst nightmare is that I get dementia and there is nobody to notice and I wander out into a road one day. Or that my health fades and I spend my days alone at home with random carers popping in for 10 minutes at a time. If in the retirement village, at least I would have company all the time.

Sorry, just rambling really and putting some of my worst fears into words.

Surferosa · 21/04/2025 08:39

Strawberriesandpears · 20/04/2025 22:20

Thank you for taking the time to reply to me. It's very kind of you. I am really pleased to hear that through your work you have found those that make an effort to stay connected are less lonely than those who are fully absorbed in their nuclear families.

I can definitely see how that could well be the case, and it definitely offers me hope. I would also like to live in a retirement village where there will be plenty to keep me occupied, friends to be made and care on site if needed (the one I have indentified has on site residential, nursing and dementia care if needed).

So I am probably well set for a decent old age, but then sometimes I will read a thread or article about lonely old people with no family or 'elder orphans' and it sets me of panicking again!

I don't mean to burst your bubble but you're looking at what these retiring villages are offering now. By the time you will need that sort of care, the type of support and care these retirement villages will be different, eligibility criteria and funding will be different and a lot of these places won't exist and will be replaced by something new. I'm not saying this to be gloomy just that the landscape of social care is always changing and it seems pointless to be so so fixated on something that may or not exist in about 40 years.

And aren't all older people orphans of some sort? I'd find it extremely rare to find someone of elderly age still with parents about and many people have already found their siblings have died off too.

Absolutely no one should have children so they won't be lonely or have someone to care for them when they are older. It's a terrible and enormous burden to place on children. People should have children because they want them. Not to held stave their own existential crises or as some sort of solution to their own anxiety.

As I said before, I really cannot emphasise the benefits of community and neighbours. From my own work, children and families make no difference to whether a person will be lonely when they are older and in so many cases, they create so much more many problems than they solve. I have a son but I 100% understand and agree with the reasons why people don't want them! You only have to read posts on here from adult children who state they won't help their own parents in old age unless they get help with childcare. Who call their retired parents selfish for wanting to go on holiday or spend their retirement how they please. There seems to be this expectation that once you have children, you must then spend the remainder of your life in absolute servitude for them, that even as your children grow older and have families of their own, the grandparents are still expected to put all their own health, wants and wishes aside.

No wonder people look at the above and think "no thanks". People should be absolutely free to make choices and life decisions with no judgement. As I mentioned before I know many family friends in their 60s and 70s with no children and some even with no nieces or nephews. And far from being lonely or sad, I actually think they have enormous peace and contentment from living a life that they can dedicate to themselves without burning themselves out providing care to children and grandchildren.

Strawberriesandpears · 20/04/2025 22:31

Coatsoff42 · 20/04/2025 10:14

I feel for you with the sadness and fear. But tbh goodness only know how long you will live, we neither of us might get to old age. Don’t waste too much of your youth worrying about it. The world seems increasingly unstable, we probably will be old people, but we might not, either way let’s just be happy now and then at least we can look back on some good memories.

And you don’t know how life will pan out, or who you will meet. You could meet other people in the same boat as you and make a collective, you could meet someone with children already and have a network there, either a lifelong friend, or a partner. I’ve met people who’ve been honorary aunties and been cared for by ‘nieces and nephews’ that way.
There are ways of meeting people who would rely on you, and you can rely on them. It takes years to make that sort of deep friendship though. But you have years!!
Have you always lived in the same place? Do you know anyone from school still?
Are you involved in much community stuff like parish councils or charities or volunteering? Once you get involved with one of these networks you meet a lot of people most of whom are kind and friendly.
Do you feel strongly about any issues or activities? There’s always groups looking for people to help out and run events.

If you don’t have a ready made family it takes years to make a really strong friendship, but maybe that’s what you need.

I hope you have a better day today, you’re in a dark place right now.

Thank you very much for your kind message too. You are right - life is so unpredictable. Bad things can happen, but good things can happen too! I think I was very isolated in my 20s due to having a shy personality and also due to having a job which I hated and left me very depressed and run down. Then in my early 30s, Covid hit which again left me isolated. In more recent years, I have been doing a lot better for friends and connections. Thank you again.

Strawberriesandpears · 20/04/2025 22:20

Surferosa · 20/04/2025 10:08

How can you have no other way of being in a network apart from having a child or siblings? Some of the most well connected and socialable people I know either are only children or don't have kids.

I work in adult social care, assessing those care packages. By far the least lonely elderly people I've met are the ones who have been involved in their community, churches, hobbies, groups etc and many of these don't have children either. It's the ones that have completely absorbed themselves into their nuclear families with no other connections outside it that are the most lonely as their children are either working full time, busy with their own commitments or have moved away.

And the overwhelming abuse of older people comes from family themselves. You just don't hear about it.

You've posted many posts about it. You have no idea how your life will pan out, you may not even need care when your older. You could get run over by a bus this afternoon. The only thing that is sure that if you do get older, you'll completely regret wasting life feeling scared and sorry for yourself than actually going out there and living it.

You only get one shot at life. It's up to you how you want to live it.

Thank you for taking the time to reply to me. It's very kind of you. I am really pleased to hear that through your work you have found those that make an effort to stay connected are less lonely than those who are fully absorbed in their nuclear families.

I can definitely see how that could well be the case, and it definitely offers me hope. I would also like to live in a retirement village where there will be plenty to keep me occupied, friends to be made and care on site if needed (the one I have indentified has on site residential, nursing and dementia care if needed).

So I am probably well set for a decent old age, but then sometimes I will read a thread or article about lonely old people with no family or 'elder orphans' and it sets me of panicking again!

Goody2ShoesAndTheFilthyBeast · 20/04/2025 22:20

Nah. We're not an endangered species or anything. People should only have children if they 100% want them and can appropriately care for them and support them.

Flutterbyby · 20/04/2025 22:19

TheHerboriste · 20/04/2025 12:50

Yeah, woe is us having a lie in whenever we want, clean peaceful homes, money for interesting holidays, time to learn/read/think, time for self-care.

Someone needs to get on that ASAP.

To be fair, I've most of that and I've got loads of kids 🤷‍♀️