Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To respond this way to sister criticising my diet?

221 replies

ByOpenRubyReader · 19/04/2025 13:03

I've been a vegetarian since 10 years old, now 35. My mum/dad have been supportive since the start but the same can not be said for my sister who constantly asks how I'm getting my protein, B12, nutrients etc and has since I've been a teenager.

She did it for the 1,000th time while we were out at a restaurant and instead of explaining for the 1,000th time I just asked her if there is any sort of nutritional/developmental deficiency why am I 6" taller than her, in far better shape than her and a multimillionaire while she regularly relies on our parents for money.

She didn't say anything for a second then raised her voice, asked what was wrong with me and stormed out. DF tried to get her to come back in but was unsuccessful and told me I shouldn't have said that but it was a long time coming.

AIBU to think this was a reasonable way to respond, keeping in mind I have told her over and over again to stop commenting on my diet?

OP posts:
blueleavesgreensky · 19/04/2025 21:22

Growlybear83 · 19/04/2025 19:39

I was going to agree that your sister was wrong to comment on your diet until I saw your incredibly nasty comment about being a multimillionaire and her relying on your parents for money. You were very very spiteful to brag about year wealth and rub your sister’s nose in it. I would have walked out too, but would probably have poured my drink over your head before I did so.

So bragging about being taller and healthier are ok but not about being wealthier?
why?
such a British attitude
In fact the OP can take credit for her money unlike her height

BobbyBiscuits · 19/04/2025 19:42

Haha...I can see why you said it.

But the thing about being a multimillionaire made me laugh.

I guess you've saved loads of money by not buying meat? Otherwise it doesn't have much to do with your vegetarianism surely?

Growlybear83 · 19/04/2025 19:39

I was going to agree that your sister was wrong to comment on your diet until I saw your incredibly nasty comment about being a multimillionaire and her relying on your parents for money. You were very very spiteful to brag about year wealth and rub your sister’s nose in it. I would have walked out too, but would probably have poured my drink over your head before I did so.

Calliopespa · 19/04/2025 19:00

They sound like the sisters in Cinderella.

PhilomenaPunk · 19/04/2025 18:58

NamechangeJunebaby · 19/04/2025 18:17

This. If she’s been making barbed comments and picking at your lifestyle for years I completely understand why you said it all - to make a point. Slightly ducking commenting on the funds but as she’s been constantly picking apart your lifestyle choices it was your equivalent response to her.

People who constantly criticise or ‘banter’ usually can’t take reciprocal responses. I had a friend who spent years making comments she thought were funny about my sex life (actually I was going through a marital split due to his infidelity so they were actually really hurtful). One day I’d had enough and made a similar barb back at her and she actually started screaming at me in public. If they can’t take the ‘bantz’ they shouldn’t give it out.

I bet she behaves like the biggest victim bullied by her very meanest of mean sister.

I definitely think the money comment was justified if the OP’s sister has been making barbed comments about brain development for 25 years.

PhilomenaPunk · 19/04/2025 18:55

I think you did the right thing OP. If this has happened multiple times over 25 years then you were going to reach your limit at some point. And I do think the millionaire comment is perfectly justified if she had been making digs about vegetarianism having some sort of impact on mental acuity. And making snide remarks about your partner? She sounds thoroughly unpleasant.

She will think twice before making comments in the future.

UnstableZebra · 19/04/2025 18:49

blueleavesgreensky · 19/04/2025 18:22

Unhinged? Oh get over yourself. It was slightly snarky at best and tbh the woman had it coming. Sometimes when reasonable responses aren’t landing you have to try a different tack

You don’t ”have to” do anything like OP did at all actually.

5128gap · 19/04/2025 18:31

B12 deficiency can impact communication skills. A test wouldn't hurt.

Dita73 · 19/04/2025 18:28

You had a point up until you mentioned money so ultimately you’ve made yourself look a right tit. Embarrassed for you

Calliopespa · 19/04/2025 18:24

blueleavesgreensky · 19/04/2025 18:22

Unhinged? Oh get over yourself. It was slightly snarky at best and tbh the woman had it coming. Sometimes when reasonable responses aren’t landing you have to try a different tack

You actually don’t “have” to; you can always just ignore comments.

blueleavesgreensky · 19/04/2025 18:22

UnstableZebra · 19/04/2025 18:18

Which could have been simply telling the sister to seriously stop questioning op’s choices or she might stop contact.

What op said was unhinged, and says a lot about what she really thinks.

Unhinged? Oh get over yourself. It was slightly snarky at best and tbh the woman had it coming. Sometimes when reasonable responses aren’t landing you have to try a different tack

blueleavesgreensky · 19/04/2025 18:21

LadyKenya · 19/04/2025 13:06

What has how much you are worth, anything to do with this?

Well it suggests there isn’t some lack of intellectual development or energy levels due to her diet

Calliopespa · 19/04/2025 18:20

UnstableZebra · 19/04/2025 18:18

Which could have been simply telling the sister to seriously stop questioning op’s choices or she might stop contact.

What op said was unhinged, and says a lot about what she really thinks.

I’m afraid I slightly agree with this last sentence.

I suspect it comes across and it’s what the sister has been needling at.

andtheworldrollson · 19/04/2025 18:19

Unhinged is what you get when you have bashed your brains out on a ( metaphorical) brick wall for years. of course OP went mad. People go mad when tortured. The drip drip drip. Don’t blame the OP for being human .

UnstableZebra · 19/04/2025 18:18

Gymnopedie · 19/04/2025 18:11

You were nasty. It was unnecessary. I can see that her comments are irritating but you could have just said something like "Oh, not this again. I’ve told you all this loads of times before."

But it sounds like that's exactly the sort of thing the OP has been saying. For a long time. And it hasn't made any difference, it hasn't stopped the sister having digs. So it was time to try a different approach.

Which could have been simply telling the sister to seriously stop questioning op’s choices or she might stop contact.

What op said was unhinged, and says a lot about what she really thinks.

NamechangeJunebaby · 19/04/2025 18:17

CoraPirbright · 19/04/2025 13:17

Totally understand why you are at the end of your tether with this. It must be so bloody tedious. However you did lose the moral high ground with the money bit. Just the height/physical condition probably would have sufficed. However she sounds like an insufferable know-it-all so you still may not have made an impact sadly.

This. If she’s been making barbed comments and picking at your lifestyle for years I completely understand why you said it all - to make a point. Slightly ducking commenting on the funds but as she’s been constantly picking apart your lifestyle choices it was your equivalent response to her.

People who constantly criticise or ‘banter’ usually can’t take reciprocal responses. I had a friend who spent years making comments she thought were funny about my sex life (actually I was going through a marital split due to his infidelity so they were actually really hurtful). One day I’d had enough and made a similar barb back at her and she actually started screaming at me in public. If they can’t take the ‘bantz’ they shouldn’t give it out.

I bet she behaves like the biggest victim bullied by her very meanest of mean sister.

Gymnopedie · 19/04/2025 18:11

You were nasty. It was unnecessary. I can see that her comments are irritating but you could have just said something like "Oh, not this again. I’ve told you all this loads of times before."

But it sounds like that's exactly the sort of thing the OP has been saying. For a long time. And it hasn't made any difference, it hasn't stopped the sister having digs. So it was time to try a different approach.

Ihatelittlefriendsusan · 19/04/2025 17:48

The money comment was bitchy and unnecessary. Yabvu for that part.

LillyPJ · 19/04/2025 17:40

I'm not sure that was the right way to respond (what has being taller or a millionaire got to do with your diet?) but she is unreasonable to keep bringing the subject up.

Calliopespa · 19/04/2025 17:36

I would say to both of you never be too smug: either of you could find you are suffering from something any day.

The “I’m in better shape than you” boasts can go awfully wrong. I’ve seen this first hand - most dramatically with a woman who was lording it over a overweight friend that she was so fit and healthy she needed to plan for a long retirement. She more or less said at a dinner party that our larger friend was “ lucky” ( tinkly laugh 🙄) that her weight meant she probably wouldn’t have lots of care home fees.

I think it was the following week that the health fiend was diagnosed with advanced breast cancer.

AgnesX · 19/04/2025 17:35

You shouldn't have no but it sounds like typical stupid sibling stuff.

Now she knows though, if she didn't before.

ohdearagain2 · 19/04/2025 17:32

ByOpenRubyReader · 19/04/2025 13:10

I only mentioned money because she often comments on stuff related to brain development, dementia etc quite regularly and if I'm being honest I was just pissed off at hearing this for the 1,000th time.

That isn't to say I think rich = smart or poor = dumb because I know it's much more complex than that, but I do feel like it was justified in this case.

Edited

Well it sounds like you wanted to both hurt her and boast about your circumstances - well done goal achieved I guess!

LBFseBrom · 19/04/2025 17:32

PowderMonkeys · 19/04/2025 13:05

Completely unreasonable. Just say ‘Same as the last 1000 times you asked, Linda. Shall we order?’

Yes! She needs to shut up, once is enough.

PS: Are you really a multimillionaire or was that hyperbole?

Shubbypubby · 19/04/2025 17:23

Good on you. She’s been poking away at you for years and it sounds like you’ve finally had enough. Yes what you said was mean but she needs to learn this is what happens if you keep harping on at people. She shouldn’t dish it out if she can’t take it.

PeggyMitchellsCameo · 19/04/2025 17:23

While you may have been deemed unkind, there is something going on here.
Sibling relationships are complicated.
She already knows you are taller, in good shape, and have done well in life so your diet is the last frontier - the one thing she can needle you about.
I think she’s been out of order for a long time.
She will have the hump.
But maybe it will stop her going it again.
And…. you could have said far worse!!!

Swipe left for the next trending thread