Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Second child doubts

30 replies

MaybeBabyMaybeNo · 18/04/2025 22:34

DH and I have been very happily married for five years, together for eight. He’s 36 and I’m 40. We have one DC, who is two years old.

I have never been particularly fussed about having kids. It wasn’t something I really considered at all until I met DH, who had always wanted them (lots, if possible) but was willing not to have any if I didn’t want them. I honestly didn’t feel particularly strongly about it, so we had DD - and she’s truly fantastic. An absolute joy.

However, I found the first year quite hard. My life has changed, my body has changed, I had anxiety for the first six months, struggled with breastfeeding and DD has never been a good sleeper, so haven’t had a decent night’s sleep in two years. DH more than pulls his weight in all areas, but it hasn’t been easy.

Now, to my question. The plan was always to have two kids (if we were to have any at all). There’s obviously nothing wrong with being an only child, but it feels important for DC to have a ‘life buddy’.

But, I feel like I’m finally emerging from the fog of babyhood to delightful toddlerhood. I enjoy DC, have time for myself (she goes to nursery a few days a week), I can read and work out and see friends. I can spend time with my husband. I can go back to work (I haven’t, yet). The idea of reliving the first year of babyhood really doesn’t appeal.

But (so many buts!) will we regret it if we don’t have another? Is it fair to DC? Is it fair to DH? Am I being massively selfish? I’m 40, so it’s not like I have oodles of time to change my mind.

If you’ve made it to the end of my opus, thank you. I want to emphasise that, I know nobody can tell me what to do. I’m interested in hearing your thoughts on the above and what you would do (or have done) in the same situation.

YABU: I’d have another baby
YANBU: I wouldn’t have another baby

Also, we are extremely financially comfortable, our home has room for multiple kids, and so on. None of those things are factors.

OP posts:
Scottishskifun · 18/04/2025 22:45

I would say the transition for me from 0-1 was much much harder then transition from 1-2. DS2 just slotted in, I knew what I was in for with sleep disruption and honestly had a far more enjoyable and chilled mat leave with DS2 then DS1.

Now one is 6 and the other is 3 and they entertain each other, so DH and I get more downtime or ability to do things.
You never know what you will get for us it was the right decision to have a second.

pitterypattery00 · 18/04/2025 22:43

We stuck at one - overall I feel I am a much better mum to one than I would be to two. But the important thing is to have another child only if you and your husband want another. Don't have one for your existing child - a second child is definitely not a guaranteed lifelong 'buddy' for them. They may get along well but they may not get on at all. I know many people who are not close at all to their siblings.

BlueMum16 · 18/04/2025 22:42

I had a second as first DC had t got to the easy todldler bit. If he had I probably wouldn't have bothered.

I love my second DC wholeheartedly and can't imagine life without them but it was so much harder.
DC1 wasa good baby, slept ate etc
DC2 only started sleeping at 14 years! I was almost 40 having her.
IDH and I worked full time and used a nursery.

In your circumstances I probably wouldn't.

tealandteal · 18/04/2025 22:41

Well really the only question is, do you want another baby? If those things weren’t an issue, would you want another child? Try and figure out in your head how you feel about that and that will help you to make your decision as you are right, no one can decide for you.

For what it’s worth, I had the same worries as you. DS1 has ASD and so never slept, had silent reflux (also doesn’t help sleeping) and I had PPA and a PPH. It took me so long to feel like a normal human again that there is a 5 year age gap between the boys. However, DS2 was a dream baby, we did shared parental leave so I went back to work a bit sooner and I went back full time and DH does compressed hours and actually it was a completely different experience. I cherished my maternity leave which sounds so corny!

skinnyoptionsonly · 18/04/2025 22:38

I wouldn’t in your shoes.