Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think drivers (more so elderly) need to be retested?

277 replies

ayonoosh · 15/04/2025 09:33

I know I'll probably get lumped with being ageist here. I want to preface I think all drivers should be tested after perhaps 10 years but once at retirement age or 70s, every few years?

I live in a town that's predominantly one way. In the past 7 days I have seen 2 elderly drivers run red lights. One elderly driver go the wrong way up a very well signed street, with other drivers beeping and flashing and they just kept going, one elderly driver driving on the opposite side of the road going onto a short duel carriage way (!!) and an elderly driver drive down the middle of the bollards in Tesco.

this isn't an unusual amount of it too, there are so many posts on the local community pages with cars and registrations and people posting about it. It is so incredibly dangerous. We have a uni in town too and have our fair share of young drivers, I do see them hurtling around town at stupid speeds but they aren't as common as the elderly drivers reported.

I know young drivers cause more crashes, but elderly people tend to have low mileage bias, I think if they drove mile for mile the stats may differ. Elderly drivers responsible for deaths have increased by 42% in the last decade.

AIBU to think mandatory testing for all, especially for elderly should be implemented? I know the money, time, stubbornness, etc etc make it unrealistic, and there are terrible drivers of all ages of course. But if age related reaction times are something that doesn't apply to you, then surely it's a tick box activity and back to driving?

im seeing increasingly more elderly pootling at 50 in the middle lane on the M25, as well as stupid taxi drivers doing it too. they ought to be retested too.

what's everyone's thoughts?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Lovelysummerdays · 15/04/2025 09:40

I’d agree. I know an elderly lady who dragged her car along the side of another they had just pulled in to check direction and weren’t properly parked. She didn’t even notice! Family have banned her from driving which she has accepted but honestly could of killed someone

scalt · 15/04/2025 09:39

This question comes up regularly, along with "should the minimum age be raised to 18", and "should we ban all cars", as Ken Livingstone so wanted to do? In an ideal world, maybe there is a case for retesting not just the elderly, but any drivers.

However, in the real world, it's still a wait of months and months and months for learners to get a driving test, never mind the elderly who keep living longer and longer. We don't have the examiners to carry out the tests, the police to enforce this, and the prison places for the elderly drivers who will repeatedly ignore the rules, and will say to the police arresting them "I've been driving since before you were even thought of".