Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be fed up of being on a good income but always skint?

620 replies

Justonemorecurlywurly · 14/04/2025 00:09

I know I’m going to get flamed, lots of “boo-hoo, poor you”, and that there are people far worse off but -

Our household income (family of 4) is roughly £110-120k. DH earns about £100k of that, I’m self employed and part time so my income fluctuates. I think that’s pretty good money but it feels like we can never afford to do anything.

No holiday for 2 years.
1 car
Very few clothes
Modest house

If after paying bills, we ever buy something non-essential like a meal out, or maybe one or two items of new clothes, birthday present, that’s it, we’re out of money for the month. And we have no savings. It’s ridiculous!

We did try to move a few years back but couldn’t afford it so remortgaged instead to extend the house a little. We got the best deal we could and borrowed only as much as we were comfortable with (even though it meant we couldn’t do as much work as we needed). But unfortunately we made a mistake fixing the new mortgage for only two years and when that time was up, rates had shot to which has made our repayments considerably more expensive which really hasn’t helped.

I’m so fed up of it. I honestly feel like we felt so much better off about 10 years ago when we were earning A LOT less.

Does anyone else feel like this? Is it just that everything is so expensive now??

I know some people will say I should work full time but for reasons I won’t go into, I need to be available for my DC so me being p/t works much better for the whole family.

OP posts:
Sofiewoo · 14/04/2025 08:31

Napface · 14/04/2025 08:21

I have no idea what the take home would be on £120k but ours is about £39k

So you don’t understand take home pay but are quick to proclaim how much less you have?
The take home is 5k for the DH and around 1.2k for the OP.
Then there’s the child benefit you are entitled to which the OP isn’t, so another £200 odd inflation your income with 2 kids. Then nursery funding which the OP isn’t entitled to. In many cases lower incomes are entitled to a UC top up, particularly if renting.
All of a sudden your smaller income starts to creeper closer and closer to the OP’s in terms of spending power.

AquaPeer · 14/04/2025 08:31

Fleurchamp · 14/04/2025 08:26

Because you bought your house 15yrs ago? It is probably 50-100% more expensive now and interest rates have doubled.

I could barely afford my house if I tried to buy it now.

This poster paid off a large mortgage before 70, spends £30k a year on private school (you need to earn £60k alone for that) and is so daft she thinks it’s down to buying a massive doer- upper a mere 15 years ago?!! 😂😂😂

poster- I bought a tiny doer upper 15 years ago, it cost £300k and I had to earn £60k and have a £45k deposit for it. I sold it for £500k and now live in an average 4 bed detached. Where did I go wrong? Why aren’t my kids on private school? Heeelpppp

towelonfloor · 14/04/2025 08:29

and my employer pays 12.5%

that's another example of how things have changed pension wise, it's not a great contribution. It's why i moved to the public sector.

ioioitdj · 14/04/2025 08:28

CleverButScatty · 14/04/2025 08:24

You can't have a nearly 400k me mortgage and only pay 450pm... Break that down for us. .

Yeah I need the figures on this, and the number for the mortgage broker wizard that sealed the deal…

Silverstars21 · 14/04/2025 08:28

It's the old story. The bigger the income generally means a bigger mortgage, better car, better food & on it goes. That's why it's a myth those couples with children on relatively huge incomes compared to others are better off. They just appear to be.

cakeandteaandcake · 14/04/2025 08:27

Still waiting for you to actually share your outgoings OP.

REDB99 · 14/04/2025 08:27

You cannot be good with money if you feel like that isn’t enough. I am a single parent whose household income is less than yours and I manage holidays, meals out, I pay £250 a month for wraparound child care as well!
Time for a serious look at what you’re spending your money on. You may not be able to afford the lifestyle you want but you make choices based on what you can afford. If you want a holiday then prioritise saving for one, it’ll mean you don’t spend money on other things though.

towelonfloor · 14/04/2025 08:26

@Whatsitreallylike but how is your take home 5.7k then?

Fleurchamp · 14/04/2025 08:26

Newusername3kidss · 14/04/2025 08:20

I’m genuinely baffled by posts like this - we have a similar income and have a big house with no mortgage, go on multiple holidays a year and kids are in private school.

however we did buy a proper do-er upper house 15 years ago when we were not as wealthy and have extended and refurbished over the last 10 years. We are extremely frugal in other ways and know how every single penny is spent. Our priority was always paying off the mortgage as soon as possible and we did loads of the work on the house ourselves. I don’t understand how you are spending your money.

Because you bought your house 15yrs ago? It is probably 50-100% more expensive now and interest rates have doubled.

I could barely afford my house if I tried to buy it now.

Whatsitreallylike · 14/04/2025 08:25

towelonfloor · 14/04/2025 08:21

@Whatsitreallylike why don't you pay into a pension?

I pay 2.5% and my employer pays 12.5% … I have 15% total pension conts which I’m happy with. But thanks for checking 😘

CleverButScatty · 14/04/2025 08:24

curious79 · 14/04/2025 07:18

I’ve got £390k mortgage and pay £440pcm - people need to do a lot more shopping around and use mortgage brokers. Yes you pay c£1,300 for the privilege but then you more than make it back

You can't have a nearly 400k me mortgage and only pay 450pm... Break that down for us. .

EmeraldShamrock000 · 14/04/2025 08:24

You are in a position to clear the debt. It is unbelievable irresponsible that you have stretched your finances so far, that earning 120,000 per year is not cutting it.

Try buying nothing but essentials for a year, update children's wardrobe from a charity shop.

Is your DH gambling?

Sofiewoo · 14/04/2025 08:23

towelonfloor · 14/04/2025 08:19

You're quite 'over mortgaged' for your income.

Based on what?

These are also the funniest sorts of comments because it shows how utterly out of touch come people are.
A couple earning £120k a year must not borrow more than the equivalent of a £1,200 per month payment or they are over-mortgaging themselves?
A £250k budget doesn’t buy you a small family home in huge parts of the country!

towelonfloor · 14/04/2025 08:23

I’m genuinely baffled by posts like this - we have a similar income and have a big house with no mortgage, go on multiple holidays a year and kids are in private school.

This is wild but it's probably your lack of mortgage...

Presumably cheap private school too as it would be 30k a year per dc where I am so even without a mortgage 2 would be hard on 100/110k.

CleverButScatty · 14/04/2025 08:22

Londonwaiting · 14/04/2025 06:47

This is ridiculous OP. You are just really bad with money.

A few years ago our income was half yours and we had a better quality of life than you do. And a mortgage only £650 a month less than yours. And we had two kids and ran two cars.

You are wasting an awful lot of money somewhere.

How rude!

AquaPeer · 14/04/2025 08:22

Listing outgoings isn’t quite the flex people like to think. At the end of the day you chose where to spend and the big things are the big things.

i put £1k a month into my pension. Immediately the “live in a one bedroom flat and drive a 17 year old car” brigade would tell me to stop doing that. But who is going to pay for my old age if not me? Why shouldn’t I take advantage of a good pension scheme my employer offers?

the OP is why can’t high earners do basic things like this? Isn’t that the dream, the social contract of being a high earner?

and the answer is COL has broken the social contract. The middle classes are over.

Napface · 14/04/2025 08:21

Sofiewoo · 14/04/2025 08:15

I bet your take home is not actually less than half though.

I have no idea what the take home would be on £120k but ours is about £39k

ioioitdj · 14/04/2025 08:21

It’s a good household income but as I’m sure has been raised when it’s disproportionately earned you get rinsed in tax, so the take home won’t be as impressive as a household earning £120k more evenly.

IndieRocknRoll · 14/04/2025 08:21

I would say that’s a large mortgage, not a modest mortgage. That is where most of your money is going.
which part of the country are you in? If it’s the south then obviously the cost of living will be higher.

We have a similar income to you and can afford holidays, eating out and to put some away for savings. We have a mortgage of around £200k though and no loans or car finance - We drive around in two old cars.

towelonfloor · 14/04/2025 08:21

@Whatsitreallylike why don't you pay into a pension?

Newusername3kidss · 14/04/2025 08:20

I’m genuinely baffled by posts like this - we have a similar income and have a big house with no mortgage, go on multiple holidays a year and kids are in private school.

however we did buy a proper do-er upper house 15 years ago when we were not as wealthy and have extended and refurbished over the last 10 years. We are extremely frugal in other ways and know how every single penny is spent. Our priority was always paying off the mortgage as soon as possible and we did loads of the work on the house ourselves. I don’t understand how you are spending your money.

Bjorkdidit · 14/04/2025 08:20

Daisydiary · 14/04/2025 08:18

I get you, OP! We’re similar to you but there’s always a bit of a juggle and I have to plan. All essentials, including monthly savings towards next year’s big bills, amount to almost £5K. £2K of that is mortgage and council tax. About £1K each month for food/shoes/clothes/haircuts etc. The other £2K is bills, savings towards next year’s bills. Essentially, on the salaries we’re on, I would expect more spare cash. But the cost of everything has gone up so much, it’s crazy. Any pay rise is way behind the amount our bills increase by annually. We do save some that is over for holidays but again, they’re a lot more than they used to be. A £3K family holiday three years ago is now £5K! I am always creative but I’m having to be very creative these days!

So are we talking about the MN definition of struggling/skint, ie unable spend on anything you want without thinking rather than actual skint ie looking down the sofa for coins to buy bread and hiding from the bailiffs?

towelonfloor · 14/04/2025 08:20

I know on MNs it's normal to earn 100k but only borrow twice your salary mortgage wise but for many in the real world that's unrealistic and again often it's cheaper to pay a mortgage than rent.

Whatsitreallylike · 14/04/2025 08:20

fuzzybrains · 14/04/2025 08:15

That net income sounds too high- have you checked it?
You need to do each separately- tax on the highest earner, and the lowest. I don't think it's anything like £7K net.

Yes I have. It helps that I earn £100k a year and my take home is £5,700. Assume a bit over a grand for the OP and you’re not far from £7k.

Fleurchamp · 14/04/2025 08:20

And I don't think lower earners quite understand the tax/ benefit implications for high earners - they see a headline six figure salary and automatically think "rich!".

Someone with two kids earning earning £50k/ year will take home almost 50% of someone in the same position earning £150k plus they get tax free childcare.

Higher earners prop up the welfare system and at the moment they just don't feel the benefit of working harder - the £100k tax trap for example, loads of my friends contort their salaries (work PT, take unpaid leave, make huge pension contributions) to avoid the 60% marginal rate and loss of tax free childcare. How does that make the economy grow?