Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Most shops are just landfill waiting to happen.

894 replies

SummerDaytoNight · 13/04/2025 10:47

I mean, all are to a point, but I’m talking about the non essential ones.

Our society is engineering its own collapse. We only need food, health, house basics and clothing. And I suppose, technology.

Fast fashion could go. Housing should just be the essentials.

My friend took me into a shop called sostrene grene. It was lovely, but nothing was essential. Most shops are like that.

The horse has bolted, but I wish we could limit the unnecessarily stuff and just have the basics. Im not talking Amish level, but there’s no need for all this waste. It would be so much better if only the essentials were produced.

At the point of production, it’s already basically landfill.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
SonoPazziQuestiRomani · 13/04/2025 14:38

SonoPazziQuestiRomani · 13/04/2025 14:20

Is it really, though (compared to the past, i mean)? I think part of the problem is how much stuff people think they "should" be able to afford on a particular salary. People then take that a step further by buying less good quality versions so they can have even more of it.

I will add to this - another problem is the capitalist need for year-on-year growth. If you sell "N" products for £X in year 1, to get growth you need to either sell N+P products or sell them for £(X + Y), or ideally both. But to sell mire products you need a wider audience, some of whom might not want to pay even £X. So you lower the quality a bit, not enough to put off last year's customers, but enough to attract this year's new customers. And on and on it goes until what was (say) a respected clothing retailer is now selling polyester tops and acrylic jumpers made in China, that look like rags within a year (which conveniently will make people buy more to replace the old ones), instead of organic cotton and merino wool made in the UK that will look great for years.

EleanorReally · 13/04/2025 14:37

what i want to know is, if you are against tat and your dc has a birthday party
what are his friends meant to be buying him that meets your approval?

Evaka · 13/04/2025 14:37

We are utterly fucked. Hilariously, Trump's tariff policy might actually dampen the hyper production of shite no one needs. Imagine if he was the environmental hero no-one saw coming.

quantumbutterfly · 13/04/2025 14:37

SaladSandwichesForTea · 13/04/2025 14:27

Why stainless steel over aluminium out of interest? X

Some concerns about ingesting aluminum from various sources (cooking pots, foil, deodorant - it is known to be found in neurofibrillary tangles in the brains of alzheimers patients and the incident at Camelford highlighted some issues with it's ingestion. Though I confess I haven't kept up with latest developments)

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8150251/

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Camelford_water_pollution_incident

Aluminum and Tau in Neurofibrillary Tangles in Familial Alzheimer’s Disease - PMC

Familial Alzheimer’s disease (fAD) is driven by genetic predispositions affecting the expression and metabolism of the amyloid-β protein precursor. Aluminum is a non-essential yet biologically-reactive metal implicated in the etiology of AD. Recent ...

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8150251/

14680345L · 13/04/2025 14:36

My grandparents and parents fridges, washing machines lasted for YEARS. This was only in the 60’s, 70s and 80’s.

In my last house the boiler was 35 years old. When a component broke the gas engineer said fix it, it’s great, you will only get 10 years from a new one.

If the government really gave a crap about Net Zero they would force companies to create products that last 15 years minimum.

This has now made me think net zero is more about encouraging us buying new things than the planet. My local garage said gear boxes are binned rather than fixed. This is stupid. If we are serious about the environment - the gov should fix this issue.

My last washing machine - Bosch - lasted 5 years. This time I bought the cheapest I could find (basic very limited tech) as I imagine it will be binned in 4-5 years.

Langdale3 · 13/04/2025 14:36

Agree With the OP.

But I don’t think it means we can’t have nice things. Buying less but better quality, and repairable items, is a sound strategy.

florasl · 13/04/2025 14:35

We’ve used Sostrene Grene for years! They sell excellently priced craft supplies for children, dolls house furniture and kitchen utensils. I have ceramic Christmas decorations from them that are 10+ years old, still in excellent condition and cost £0.97 each. The children’s toys are all wooden, I can’t think of a single thing they sell that is single use plastic!

You’d be better singling out Poundland, B&M or Home Bargins for disposable, single use items.

TheFatCatsWhiskers1 · 13/04/2025 14:34

Shcab · 13/04/2025 14:22

I’m with you, OP. B&M concerns me - it is just a vast store filled with pointless tat. And the fast fashion brands like Shein and Temu are extremely worrying. I don’t buy fast fashion or tat but am very aware that the majority of people do and I have no idea what the solution is. Season crap is particularly bad these days - you used to buy Christmas decorations and bring the same ones out every year, occasionally adding something new. Now people are changing their decorations all the time to new colour schemes or whatever. And then there’s valentines shit and Easter shit and Halloween shit - it’s never ending.

I'm still using the poundshop baubles I bought coming up to 20 years ago - the first and last xmas decorations I've ever bought! Some of the strings fell off so I replaced them with thread, and the top bits on a couple came off so I glued them back on. When I was growing up, most of the decorations were 25+ years old. It was like going back in time.

70isaLimitNotaTarget · 13/04/2025 14:34

SonoPazziQuestiRomani · 13/04/2025 14:06

Yes, and Autumn decorations too. It's like the retailers have realised we've reached peak Christmas in terms of the annual volume people will buy and so are expanding into other seasons too.

I like to put a few decorations up , I have a floral door wreath for Easter and a pre lit wreath for Christmas , both years old .

I have cushion covers - Christmas/ some rather creepy Halloween ones (skulls and ravens not killer clown or zombie) and my favourite which have a picture of a hare for Easter.
Re-used every year , useful and I like the .
Also helps to mark the new season even though it reminds me time is passing and my Christmases and Easters are numbered

MrsMitford3 · 13/04/2025 14:32

Aww I love Sostrene Grene.
I don't object to them-lovely things and ppl like having nice things in their homes.
I do try and use charity shops and save clothes and furnishing forever.

I agree there is too much social media posting about outfits bought for a day racing or whatever and I do think social media fuels the rampant consumerism.

I feel like there are many worse culprits Sostrene Grene.

The fast fashion and the Shein, Temu, tiktok shop etc are much worse!!!

typicaltuesdaynight · 13/04/2025 14:29

i try my hardest to buy everything I can 2nd hand , we’ve just replaced out 30 year old carpets as they had holes in them. We hate waste . I do have some Halloween stuff from home bargains but I’ve had it for 17 years and bring it out every year .
i was speaking to a colleague about this recently and he said what’s the point it’s a piss in the ocean me trying to be green and mindful. I told hi. What a terrible attitude to have. It’s all the people at my work that vape especially the disposable ones , such a huge environmental issue

SaladSandwichesForTea · 13/04/2025 14:27

quantumbutterfly · 13/04/2025 13:54

You'll also avoid the potential for BPA if you use a metal bottle, though opt for stainless steel rather than aluminium.

Why stainless steel over aluminium out of interest? X

ThisFluentBiscuit · 13/04/2025 14:26

JillAndJenTheFlowerpotMen · 13/04/2025 10:49

This. Particularly “seasonal” merchandise. I look at Christmas and Valentines tat and see every single thing in a massive pit with veg peelings.

I keep my seasonal decs for many years though.

But I see OP's point. Even if things are used and reused and donated and reused, ultimately they're still destined for landfill. It's depressing. Or maybe it's burnt.

Gwenhwyfar · 13/04/2025 14:25

SummerDaytoNight · 13/04/2025 11:02

I was shopping yesterday and was just getting depressed. We're planning an event (hence my friend taking me to that shop), but I just don't want any of our anymore. Why do I need to buy tat? We just need food. Decorations can be natural (flowers) or not at all. I'm over paying today for tomorrow's landfill.

Why do you need an event? Why do you need anything?
Why not just sit in a cave with bread and water?

Shcab · 13/04/2025 14:22

I’m with you, OP. B&M concerns me - it is just a vast store filled with pointless tat. And the fast fashion brands like Shein and Temu are extremely worrying. I don’t buy fast fashion or tat but am very aware that the majority of people do and I have no idea what the solution is. Season crap is particularly bad these days - you used to buy Christmas decorations and bring the same ones out every year, occasionally adding something new. Now people are changing their decorations all the time to new colour schemes or whatever. And then there’s valentines shit and Easter shit and Halloween shit - it’s never ending.

Whatflavourjellybabyisnice · 13/04/2025 14:21

I remember as a uni student when my house mate told me I needed to contribute £20 to buy plastic crap we weren't going to use twice for the Halloween party we were going to have in the house. Other than spending a stupid amount on absolute shite she was a right controlling cunt that didn't allow me to invite alot of my friends.
I luckily was able to decline after alot of hostility.
I think in many households, some but not enough people are thinking about landfill and the environment and won't buy it.

Catrionablocke · 13/04/2025 14:21

Why do people buy new Christmas decorations every year? I mean tree baubles and tinsel, then throw it away and buy new next year. It never used to be something people did, as far as I'm aware. They did like I do, hang things we've had for years, including ornaments DC made at nursery. It's half the fun decorating the tree and remembering days out/holidays when we bought things.
Nothing matches but who cares? As long as the lights work I'm happy.

SonoPazziQuestiRomani · 13/04/2025 14:20

Bryonyberries · 13/04/2025 14:15

Part of the problem is how expensive compared to wages the decent stuff is. If you don’t have much money you may have to buy the cheap version of what you need knowing it’ll break and need replacing within a year but you need it now not in six months when you’ve saved up enough for the good quality one. Then the cycle repeats on all the items you need.

Is it really, though (compared to the past, i mean)? I think part of the problem is how much stuff people think they "should" be able to afford on a particular salary. People then take that a step further by buying less good quality versions so they can have even more of it.

Ariela · 13/04/2025 14:16

In my mid 60s, and I am reading this wondering who buys all this tat, because it certainly is not me! Now the kids are adults I don't even buy Easter eggs, or even chocolate come to that.
Is it so unusual to buy most stuff secondhand but buy quality?

Bryonyberries · 13/04/2025 14:15

Part of the problem is how expensive compared to wages the decent stuff is. If you don’t have much money you may have to buy the cheap version of what you need knowing it’ll break and need replacing within a year but you need it now not in six months when you’ve saved up enough for the good quality one. Then the cycle repeats on all the items you need.

FiveWhatByFiveWhat · 13/04/2025 14:15

SnoozingFox · 13/04/2025 11:02

Completely agree. You will get the people on here shortly though saying that unless you are living in a cave eating grass and drinking rainwater you have no right to comment. Which is plainly nonsense but a trite argument they use to justify buying from tat merchants like T8mu and shitty Shein.

I like to think I'm a mindful consumer. Yes I have a phone and my most recent purchase online was a new custom made roman blind. At least 50% of my wardrobe is Vinted or charity shop and that's increasing all the time. The sofa I am sitting on is 22 years old and was restuffed and repaired last year rather than chucked to buy new. We do the whole banning on single use plastic thing.

But there is a growing trend to disposable - changing a roman blind every year rather than every decade, a new outfit for every occasion, buying stuff to celebrate everything from spring to Halloween and adding to that stash every year because most of what you buy is cheaply made and won't last.

I don't think plastic in and of itself is bad, things like Tupperware boxes can be reused for decades, plastic toys like Lego or Playmobile likewise, and can be sold afterwards. It's the poorly-made fast fashion and homeware/celebration utter shite which you find in B&M or Home Bargains or in the aforementioned chinese shite merchants which are the problem.

Yeah I'm with you on this! No one can be "perfect" and I get wanting an occasional "just because" nick nack if it's a theme you love or whatever. But it really is just everywhere.

We try and do a balance. Furniture lasts ages, we only buy tech when things die a death. We never use shein, temu or Primark - we do shop high street shops, mostly Next and Asda/George. We just try to pick a few we fully know are awful and avoid them.

We have one DS and he's ot Playmobil and Lego from when me and DH were kids that is like new and he loves it. He's also had many a Christmas gift from FB marketplace like paw patrol and happy land stuff, that we in turn sold on later on. But saying that he also got some tat from the works just this afternoon 🤦 But like I say, nobody is perfect, it's more about trying to be more mindful where you can. If everyone did that, I think it would make a big difference.

lifeonmars100 · 13/04/2025 14:14

Matronic6 · 13/04/2025 13:52

I completely agree. What's even more frustrating is poor recycling awareness, habits or people just not caring. We live in a flat so have shared waste disposal and the level of cross contamination is shocking. People chuck food waste in with recycling or small electrical items just chucked in the rubbish.

Where I live people can't even get their heads around how to use the brown recycling bins, they just shove general waste in them then of course they don't get emptied and sit there out on the pavement forever

HelloCheekyCat · 13/04/2025 14:14

WithManyTot · 13/04/2025 11:26

The film Wall-E becomes more and more of a "fly on the wall" documentary every day. There is already a shop to "Buy & Large" in the film, it's only 1 letter away from "B&L", I await the building of the Axiom..

WALL-E and the film Idocracy are feeling more prophetic all the time!

ChopstickNovice · 13/04/2025 14:14

I do sometimes want a bit of new Easter or Christmas decoration and when I do, I hit the charity shops. Last year 10 baubles for £1! Also a beautiful hardly used musical carousel ornament for £4!

DelphiniumBlue · 13/04/2025 14:14

We could all do more.
My mum is a war baby, and never throws anything away that might one day be useful. I think she probably takes it a bit too far, but she was able to instil in us the practical skills needed to make do and mend. So making clothes, mending broken items, creating our own birthday and Christmas cards, reusing wrapping paper and ribbons, making decorations and clothes for dress-up days.
My DC always saw making their own halloween outfits as a big part of the fun.

I think schools can help children recognise what they can do that will make a difference, and help change attitudes. My own DC, and their friends, who are now adults, have a very different of view of the world compared to what was acceptable when I was young ( eg not using racist or homophobic vocabulary) and I think that is largely down to ongoing, continuous efforts put in by their schools. Most schools now do teach children about environmental issues and hopefully going forwards the younger generations will be much more aware. My DC already don't buy plastic and will always look for other options. (However that hasn't stopped them buying takeaways in plastic containers, that's our next step!)

The single use plastic bag campaign has worked really well, their use has been reduced by over 80%, I believe. We can do more along these lines. Some places are now introducing rewards for returning empty bottles ( as was standard practice 50 years ago): this is something we could easily do nationally.
We are making improvements, we just need to do it more and for everyone to feel they have a stake in the future.