Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who will look after MIL after this avoidable cock up ?

233 replies

Souredgrapes · 10/04/2025 14:01

DH and SIL both provide a lot of home support for MIL . One of them see her every day . Shop , prepare food, supervise meds , take her out . Without this support she would need professional carers for sure . Despite this help , MIL texts DH several time a day / evening with very emotive messages . Says she’s in pain , lonely , hungry, can’t find the remote. All of her needs are being met so these texts really are not on but forgivable as she has early dementia and lives alone. When we do pop in after such a text ( 17 miles away) she’s always ok . We also have cameras on her so we know she’s fine .

DH and I booked a special holiday at the end of last year and gave SIL the dates . We have only been able to take 2 previous holidays abroad in the past 11 years so this is a big deal for us. It’s not quite “trip of a lifetime” , but alone those lines. We go at the end of this month for 10 days .

SIL has now booked a holiday abroad for exactly the same dates ! She found a deal she couldn’t resist apparently .

I have suggested to DH that professional carers are brought in as MIL is unlikely to be safe in her own home without their support .

DH isn’t listening to my concerns as he thinks I’m being driven by the selfish thought that Mils endless texting and calls during our holiday are going to spoil it . He’s not wrong to be fair , because this is exactly what will happen at best . At worst , MIL will have an accident and then DH will likely fly back . I’ve already said I won’t leave early . As you can image these conversations are tense as I’m coming across badly in his opinion .

I can’t believe the idiocy of the situation which was totally avoidable. I honestly thought SIL would cancel her holiday given the amount of care they both put in and that our holiday was booked first and is a big one . Sil holidays 2 to 4 times a year and this isn’t a particularly special holiday for her.

AIBU to now approach SIL, voice my concerns and ask her to come up with a care plan that doesn’t rely on goodwill from friends and neighbours.

OP posts:
CaptainFuture · 10/04/2025 20:21

Souredgrapes · 10/04/2025 20:02

Hi . No one is refusing to pay thankfully , the money is there . Any of us can and would but MIL does have the funds . Yes , I do believe SiL physically helps MIL to wash her hair and supports her to wash and dry her own body . SIL is a nurse . When Mil comes here to wash , DH picks them both up and takes them home again.

Why is she going to your house for SIL to wash her? I can't see how this is sustainable, especially for sil! Physical job of.being a nurse, plus being the personal carer for her dm. What tasks does her son do?

NewsdeskJC · 10/04/2025 20:21

With my mum I arranged a care agency "to help with housework once a week".
Mum liked them. She now has them twice a week, the second visit is for 2 hours to take her out to the shops and to Marks and Sparks for lunch. It's added hugely to her life, meeting different people, chatting about their kids and stuff.
I've just started getting them to take her to doctors appts.
Honestly I am stressed about her deteriorating but at least spending her money on this helps.
I really want to go abroad for a couple of weeks and might do if the carers can come regularly.

Souredgrapes · 10/04/2025 20:11

I’m home now and have more time to read your advice and of your own caring experiences. Thank you for sharing them . I’m reading them all . it’s a heavy burden . I’ve done it myself for my parents so I know . X

OP posts:
Souredgrapes · 10/04/2025 20:02

CaptainFuture · 10/04/2025 19:27

If there is money for respite/cover carers then that's what needs to be done!
Or is MIL refusing to pay? SIL physically washes her DM is she washing independently in your shower?

Hi . No one is refusing to pay thankfully , the money is there . Any of us can and would but MIL does have the funds . Yes , I do believe SiL physically helps MIL to wash her hair and supports her to wash and dry her own body . SIL is a nurse . When Mil comes here to wash , DH picks them both up and takes them home again.

OP posts:
WearyAuldWumman · 10/04/2025 20:00

Re: respite care.

Before my husband had his stroke, Mum's social worker organised respite for her so that DH and I could go on holiday abroad.

The morning we dropped Mum off at the home, the (local authority) home manager asked where we were gong. I told her.

"Oh no! That's unacceptable! There must be a contact in this country."

"But I'm an only child. That's why I need the respite..."

"No. You can't go if there's no one here."

I phoned a cousin in England. She was about to leave on holiday that morning...

"Give me ten minutes..."

God bless her, she phoned her daughter and the daughter agreed to be the contact.

Just mentioning this in case anyone else experiences the same.

StrangerThings1 · 10/04/2025 19:55

Souredgrapes · 10/04/2025 18:37

Hi , thanks for all the replies . All lovely ( well I see a few deleted but hey ho ) . To answer a few questions.
I do stay out of any care arrangements for MIL , as I have my own set of responsibilities that I happily take on and manage. So approaching SIL would not be a normal thing for me to do . I would definitely look “out of order” .

SIL is lovely and I don’t believe she double booked the holidays deliberately. Her and DH split the care as equally as possible . DH works full time including nights but gets a lot of time off . SIL works 1 or 2 days a week . Other than DH , we are a family of Drs, Nurses , pharmacists and other health providers so pretty switched on to care requirements usually .

DH and SIL have time to look after MIL and do so because they love her . It doesn’t often reach a point of crisis but I do know that on a recent mini break for SIL she was reduced to tears as a result of some of MILs texts . Just after Xmas , I did ask my DH to go and stay with MIL for a few days as honestly all our plans for a family time went out the window due to her acute needs ( and behaviour ) .

MIL has been assessed by social service and deemed fit to live alone in her own home without a care package. This beggars belief as she currently sleeps downstairs with no downstairs bath or shower . She can’t walk upstairs so she is brought to our house a few times a week to use the walk in shower. SIL washes her other days . I kid you not , SS deemed it ok for MIL to stand at her kitchen sink and wash . That’s a whole other thread .

MILs dementia is mild at present . She has had some recent tests which confirmed this . I think there is a fine line between what behaviours are down to the dementia and what is in her nature to need to be looked after . Again, this is an unpopular opinion of mine and one DH disagrees with .

MIL was in respite care following a fall and broken hip . She “kicked off” spectacularly and had SIL and grandchildren in tears . She texted anyone and everyone to get her out . Telling people her children had abandoned her . It was awful . DH and SIL were getting concerned calls from so many people wondering what was going on . SIL brought her home before the respite period was over . MIL will not entertain going into such a facility again.

This may explain why DH / SIL haven’t organised this level of care .

There is money to spend on carers coming in daily so that’s not an issue either . Which is why I am at a loss this scenario is being left to play out .

Tell her now she will be going into respite care later in the year as ye all need a well earned holiday and let her get her head around it in the next few months

WearyAuldWumman · 10/04/2025 19:52

birdglasspen · 10/04/2025 19:31

I don’t think you have a MIL or a DH problem. The problem is your SIL. She knew but she went ahead anyway. Does she have some sort of power over your DH.

Personally I wouldn’t leave MIL in the care of strangers unless I trusted them. She needs help. Can you imagine yourself in years to come?

I can’t believe how many people feel a holiday comes before family. And no she’s not your mother but she is your DHs and that should mean something.

we all get old one day. Would you spend it with family or shutting a care home for convience sake?

your SIL is the only dick here.

What a horrendous thing for you to day.

My caring duties began when I was 36 yrs old. They ended when I was 60. For some people I know, their experience as a carer was longer.

Carer burnout does no one any good.

At the point where I was caring for one adult with physical problems and dementia and another with stroke related conditions, a HCP loftily informed me that it was no different from her situation - working full time (as I did until I was 58) and looking after two (healthy) children. Believe you me - it's very different.

Healthy children generally become more independent. Frail adults do not.

ThisIsMyYearToFindMyself · 10/04/2025 19:48

How about your DH and his sister getting private carers in for 4 visits a day? In reality if your mil doesn’t want them they can go away. If she needs them, they will have the legal stuff in place to let themselves in, call an ambulance, things like that.

The very best scenario would be you all come back from your holidays and the care company say ‘we knocked on the door four times a day, she told us to go away’. But she’s safe. And if she’s not safe they do something.

ThisIsMyYearToFindMyself · 10/04/2025 19:44

If something happens when you are away, under what circumstances will your DH fly home? If she falls, someone needs to call for an ambulance. What can he do by flying back? What sort of situations might happen? Are there any other relatives who can be on call eg grandchildren?

PlayingDevilsAdvocateisinteresting · 10/04/2025 19:42

Apologies again @Souredgrapes, having started to work backwards from my post above, I can already see on this page the extra difficulties you all face (of course I include you, you are hardly living in a vacuum, and not personally effected by all of this!). As I haven't even got as far as the top of this page - page 5 - yet, I wonder if your DMiL wears one of those emergency call buttons around her neck? I also wondered if she could manage on a stair lift independently, even if not, she might prefer to have one installed so that she could still bathe in her own bathroom, and potentially still sleep in her own bedroom? Sorry again if this has already been covered... 💐

AlanShore · 10/04/2025 19:41

Moveoverdarlin · 10/04/2025 15:30

I think I would say to SIL ‘Chris is beside himself with worry about your Mum for the week we’re away. I’m worried he won’t be able to relax on this holiday. This is our second holiday in 11years and is costing us an arm and a leg. I have to say I’m astounded you’ve booked the same week. One bloody week, out of the whole year!

Why? Is DH unable to talk to his sister?

WearyAuldWumman · 10/04/2025 19:38

I cared for both my parents and my husband. Believe me, some form of respite is essential.

Topseyt123 · 10/04/2025 19:36

birdglasspen · 10/04/2025 19:31

I don’t think you have a MIL or a DH problem. The problem is your SIL. She knew but she went ahead anyway. Does she have some sort of power over your DH.

Personally I wouldn’t leave MIL in the care of strangers unless I trusted them. She needs help. Can you imagine yourself in years to come?

I can’t believe how many people feel a holiday comes before family. And no she’s not your mother but she is your DHs and that should mean something.

we all get old one day. Would you spend it with family or shutting a care home for convience sake?

your SIL is the only dick here.

Sounds like you have never been in the position of having to care for an adult with increasing and complex health needs.

I absolutely can imagine myself in this situation in years to come and absolutely don't want to be a burden on my children. I'll have carers or use respite care so that they can have their lives without having to wash me and wipe my arse.

Many of us on here have been in that very difficult situation (including me). Sometimes a break is absolutely essential to preserve sanity and that is where carers or respite care come in, even if they might not be known to the person.

WearyAuldWumman · 10/04/2025 19:36

AprilBunny · 10/04/2025 19:28

When I worked for a care agency I visited many elderly people who arranged their own care (well normally their adult DC did ) and didn’t go via social services.

Edited

Yes. We organised extra carers for my late mother. We used the same agency that was subcontracted to the local council/SS.

In my relative's case, I think there's denial on her part as to how well she can manage at home. Fortunately, her injury will heal - but in her place I'd have booked myself into a care home. (I'm in my 60s and widowed.)

I've already told my relatives that I'm happy to go into respite care if the need arises.

Tiswa · 10/04/2025 19:36

birdglasspen · 10/04/2025 19:31

I don’t think you have a MIL or a DH problem. The problem is your SIL. She knew but she went ahead anyway. Does she have some sort of power over your DH.

Personally I wouldn’t leave MIL in the care of strangers unless I trusted them. She needs help. Can you imagine yourself in years to come?

I can’t believe how many people feel a holiday comes before family. And no she’s not your mother but she is your DHs and that should mean something.

we all get old one day. Would you spend it with family or shutting a care home for convience sake?

your SIL is the only dick here.

Yes I can and I will not become a burden to my children, I will not enforce myself onto their life so they don’t feel able to go away on holiday or have a break from me.
I want them to spend time with me not caring for me, I don’t want a house falling apart around me because I can no longer look after it making it difficult to sell.

There are in between options, some really good residential flats that offer support and own space that I will go to

EmeraldRoulette · 10/04/2025 19:35

Souredgrapes · 10/04/2025 19:32

I absolutely do not believe SIL engineered this situation . It’s not like her at all . She loves her Mum and she and DH get alone great. It’s like it happened so everyone’s gone Hey Ho , let’s roll with it .

And everyone was stunned when I had a nervous breakdown caring for mum. Including me.

actually "roll with it" is a great idea if care is put in place.

Souredgrapes · 10/04/2025 19:32

I absolutely do not believe SIL engineered this situation . It’s not like her at all . She loves her Mum and she and DH get alone great. It’s like it happened so everyone’s gone Hey Ho , let’s roll with it .

OP posts:
birdglasspen · 10/04/2025 19:31

I don’t think you have a MIL or a DH problem. The problem is your SIL. She knew but she went ahead anyway. Does she have some sort of power over your DH.

Personally I wouldn’t leave MIL in the care of strangers unless I trusted them. She needs help. Can you imagine yourself in years to come?

I can’t believe how many people feel a holiday comes before family. And no she’s not your mother but she is your DHs and that should mean something.

we all get old one day. Would you spend it with family or shutting a care home for convience sake?

your SIL is the only dick here.

Patterncarmen · 10/04/2025 19:28

Yes, my MIL did the endless phone calls that last few months with us. OP, you have to get respite care, and please go on holiday with your DH and take a break. It is really essential, as caring is really a difficult job.

. It is also possible to get a plan where carers will pop by a few times a day to make sure meds are being taken, there is lunch, that sort of thing. We did this because otherwise it would have been impossible for MIL to stay in her own home where she was happiest. Your DH and SIL cannot think they can care for your MIL forever, particularly as her dementia gets worse.

AprilBunny · 10/04/2025 19:28

WearyAuldWumman · 10/04/2025 19:24

A relative who lives in the north of England is perfectly compos mentis, but has been discharged home after an ankle and foot injury.

Her bed and a commode have been placed in her living room.

I found out yesterday that she had to phone the next door neighbour to come and lift her after she fell off the commode that SS supplied. It has been deemed that she can cope with the help of neighbours and with carers popping in with food during the day.

She does have two adult children, but they both live many miles away.

When I worked for a care agency I visited many elderly people who arranged their own care (well normally their adult DC did ) and didn’t go via social services.

Genevieva · 10/04/2025 19:27

We have done this. Professional careers or a temporary ‘holiday’ to a care home. Absolutely essential. It’s basic safeguarding, so you know she has immediate support if she has a fall or any other problem. He’s negligent to think he can help her from a distance.

CaptainFuture · 10/04/2025 19:27

If there is money for respite/cover carers then that's what needs to be done!
Or is MIL refusing to pay? SIL physically washes her DM is she washing independently in your shower?

PlayingDevilsAdvocateisinteresting · 10/04/2025 19:24

Sorry @Souredgrapes, I have done something that I hardly ever do, and it is definitely frowned upon by a lot of Mumsnetters - including me - I have only read your opening post, so I don't know if anyone else has already suggested what I am about to suggest!

Anyway, to my comment: When we had my wonderful Mum move in with us because she was bedridden and disabled, and I really didn't want her to go into a home - she had gone way beyond what any mother could be expected to do for their adult child, when I had gone through a very difficult time when one of my children was a newborn and their Dad left us - So I contacted my DM's Social Worker as my D2ndH and I really needed a week off, two or three times a year, which was always in the UK as it was more about us recharging our batteries than anything else.

My DM's Social Worker could, and did, arrange for my DM to go into respite care for the week. It was in a very nice nursing home, and the local council paid for the respite care as my Mum needed 24 hour care, and we couldn't have afforded the care home prices ourselves. So, please ask your DH or DSiL to register their DM with her local Social Services Senior Care Social Worker, if she isn't already, and see if that service is still provided - this was about 17 years ago when the Country was going through a previous financial crises. Good luck OP, it sounds like you and your DH really need and deserve your holiday, so I really hope that you can convince your DH, even though I did find it really difficult to leave my Mum at all, but please reassure him that it will get easier 🙏 xx

NB: It was cheaper for the Council to pay for 2 or 3 weeks respite care a year, than to have to pay for her to be in one full-time. By the way, my Mum did own her house - in her name only - but my DDad still lived in it, so she couldn't have sold it to pay for her fees even if she was in full-time residential care.

WearyAuldWumman · 10/04/2025 19:24

A relative who lives in the north of England is perfectly compos mentis, but has been discharged home after an ankle and foot injury.

Her bed and a commode have been placed in her living room.

I found out yesterday that she had to phone the next door neighbour to come and lift her after she fell off the commode that SS supplied. It has been deemed that she can cope with the help of neighbours and with carers popping in with food during the day.

She does have two adult children, but they both live many miles away.

Souredgrapes · 10/04/2025 19:16

@WearyAuldWumman . That’s exactly our position .

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread