Is this unflattering for a bridesmaid?

Not my cup of tea; bias cut is always tricky.

also it’s interesting, that colour reminds me of what I tend to call, erm, vulval pink.

ask your bridesmaids what they like. It kinda doesn’t matter what a bunch of randoms on the internet think, does it? & have a fab time together!

I think these are lovely , much more flattering. And would look great with navy suits.

Not saying you necessarily want to buy from here, but Nobody’s child have some different examples of slim fitting cut on the bias satin slip dresses, but without the bust detail:

Alternative but similar style bridesmaid dresses (there’s a picture with a bride and 2 different bridesmaids dresses, I couldn’t link that picture, this is linking to one of them)

I don’t like the bust detail on the dress itself, it makes it look like nightwear or at least very informal for what is a formal occasion.

Agree it looks just as good on both body shapes but would pick something else personally.

Personally I would forget about a “colour scheme” altogether. The whole concept is old fashioned looking these days. You could choose some dresses with better structure if you didn’t need to stick to this colour.

I think its the combination of the bias cut, the satin and colour - and then for whatever reason the arms cut in a way you can't wear a bra. Even sticking to that kind of satin bridesmaid look but just eliminating one of those factors brings up much nicer options
photo 1 - there's a reason multiways are popular for bridesmaids - easily get the colour you want, bridesmaids can style as works for them
photo 2 - satin and bias cut but navy
photo 3 - satin, putty coloured but more flattering cut - and even though strapless you could still wear a bra

@Froum what about something like this www.hellomolly.com.au/products/hello-molly-the-cleo-halter-satin-maxi-dress-dusty-pink?gad_source=1&gbraid=0AAAAADlRK_eLyYcV9YF55e060V6zLgGIG&gclid=Cj0KCQjw2N2_BhCAARIsAK4pEkXKH40yg4dXWZLoixbc61wagGKjLGU4sdVypAi4I9rTfdvyhke9w9EaAvAeEALw_wcB

I'm sorry as a slim body and big chest that is a no no and you can still get cellulite all the bumps still being slim. Have you tried the dress!? You might have the perfect body but it's not fair on everyone else to make them wear something unflattering uncomfortable that shows their flaws... That seam needs to go. maybe chiffon... To be honest i love satin as a bridesmaid dress but not the nightie type and not where your body parts have to sit in a particular area regardless of size. Sorry I know its not what you wanted to hear but they are right I wouldn't be able to get into something like that let alone pull it off. Ill attached a few pics once being something similar but no seams under the bust of needs must atkeasr they can use shapewear if need be

Totally shapeless and I think wld highlight any lumps or bumps. The bust bit is really weird looking too. I don’t think your bridesmaids will thanks you!

Why not just go to the shop - was it too far to travel?

We did. Rather than go to a shop and try them on for free we paid to do it at home. You then get money off it you buy. Worked amazingly well for us and definitely didn't consider it a rip off. 😁

I agree or from Shein or both.

Agree with you OP that look is dated now.

Navy bridesmaid dresses are so elegant. If you're having a posh wedding, then this is your answer. One of the most beautiful wedding photos I saw was a bride in white with a group of navy bridesmaids. At least have a Google because it would be way easier to find dresses in navy than the dusky putty colour.

That is the prettiest and most flattering dress you’ve posted, I know you don’t like it but it’s definitely the nicest

It is ugly and unflattering on the model, so unlikely to look nice on anyone else. The cheap shiny material will emphasise lumps and bumps on even the slimmest bridesmaids.

I'd keep looking if I were you.

You absolutely can’t ask bridesmaids to fake tan!!

I have to agree with pp, it's horrific.

Almost anyone would look dreadful in that.

It's weirdly bad for both large and small bust sizes. It's got a huge expanse of thin fabric over the entire midriff area so shows every line.

If I'd been asked to wear this, it would have been a flat no.

I was a bridesmaid for my sister and whilst the colour was lovely, it was awful on me. Didn't care, her choice, her day.

But if she'd required me to wear something that made me feel exposed and self conscious, I'd have been legit angry.

Depending on the light, you risk BM looking naked in the photos - not a flattering shape, material or colour im afraid

Why not ask them to vote, or have them choose between 2 designs in the same colour, or ask them for ideas? They're not dress up dolls, they should get a say in what they'll wear.

Unfortunately the first dress is only flattering if you are very slim with visible abs and tiny boobs. It frames the belly. I also don't feel it's particularly sleek or modern - bit 90s to me.

It looks like nightwear.

Your original dresses are beautiful. I love the colour. And as long as bridesmaids feel comfortable then go for it. Im sure they will look stunning x

Why are you asking them to fake tan? What’s so wrong with their skin? That would be like asking someone to lose weight. I would rethink that if I were you!

That one you've just posted looks as if it might be more flattering. Nice colour. Have the bridesmaids tried them on?

It looks like a nightie, horrible one at that.