Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS(8) not invited to party

562 replies

idontunderstandwhy · 09/04/2025 14:01

Dh used to compete and be a sports coach so we have a section of our garden built up and dedicated to that sport. He just teaches our dc and they play there now.

Ds has mostly had garden parties and then and on play dates his friends play there also.

Mum of one of his friends at a past play date mentioned her ds would love to learn do the sport and do something like this for his birthday but couldn’t find anywhere near.
Dh said that he’s welcome to come and practice whenever and actually could have party here if she couldn’t find anywhere else.

It was then agreed her ds could have his party in our garden and borrow equipment we had but that obviously over wise party organising is her responsibility. She has other entertainment, food arranged ect, party is quite soon.

She’s now said that she doesn’t think my DS should come as she’s worried the fact it’s his house/garden and he is good at the sport will take the shine of her DS and people will think it’s my DS’s day instead. And as it’s an out of school friend he would only know a few of kids anyway.

She never specifically said ds was invited we just assumed and we probably agreed based on that assumption.

I don’t think its fair to have ds locked in the house or taken out when his friends and boys his age playing in our garden and am shocked she thinks this is an okay suggestion.

AIBU it’s only fair ds goes?

OP posts:
Sapienza · 10/04/2025 19:14

MrsPositivity1 · 10/04/2025 18:34

What a cheek.

i would also be concerned if one of the kids had an accident. Would this be your responsibility?

The property owner has a duty of care to make sure her premises are safe for visitors. If a child is injured on the property—say due to poor supervision, unsafe play equipment, or other hazards—a personal injury claim could be made on the child’s behalf.

Hopefully, the OP’s home insurance policy includes public liability cover for third-party use, such as parties or events. If it does, the insurer would typically handle any compensation.

If not, the OP could be personally liable for any injuries that occur on her property.

Keyfob23 · 10/04/2025 19:14

Totally entitled behaviour.
Inconsiderate, and unfair to your son.

I’m surprised and taken aback at your suggestion that [DS] shouldn’t be at the party. I understand you want the focus to be on your son, but I’m afraid I’m not going to be unfair and exclude my [DS] from his own home and garden. It’s a space he usually shares with his friends and enjoys himself.

Given that you obviously think differently , it would be best if you find an alternative venue for the party. We were more than happy to help and lend the space and equipment on the understanding that it would be a friendly, inclusive gathering, but it doesn’t feel right for our son to be sidelined in his own home. I hope you understand.

suki1964 · 10/04/2025 18:56

That's not just cheeky fuckery, that is just the most basic lack of manners

I get my eyes opened daily on here over the pure selfishness of people

Yes Im older, but Im of a generation where a kid in the street was having a birthday party, not only their school friends were invited, the whole street was. Not one parent would turn away a child from a party, invited or not

user1472151176 · 10/04/2025 18:45

100% tell her to find another venue.
It's his home! Does she expect you to lock him in whilst his friends all play. Absolute cheek.

Hodnett32 · 10/04/2025 18:42

if you son is expected to stay in the house while the party goes ahead, say that's fine, but just in case the children get the wrong impression it's best they all stay in the garden for the duration of the party. so that means no access to the house, so no toilets, no hand washing etc, etc.. .

ChocolateAddictAlways · 10/04/2025 18:39

I’m still struggling to understand how the other mum thought her request/demand/suggestion was in any way reasonable. It feels way beyond cheeky and down into depths of vindictive. I’ll have my son’s party at your house but your child isn’t really invited. Wow. Just wow. (I appreciate she did a back track and implied that’s not what she meant but clearly she did mean that. She’s had an ogre moment and thought her child’s perceived enjoyment of the day was more important than being kind. Yikes)

MumWifeLife · 10/04/2025 18:38

Is she for real?? The nerve of some people actually astounds me, it's bad enough when a child is excluded from a friend's party, but when that party is in that child's house that's a whole new level of wrong.
Tell her to find a new venue

MrsPositivity1 · 10/04/2025 18:34

What a cheek.

i would also be concerned if one of the kids had an accident. Would this be your responsibility?

EMUKE · 10/04/2025 18:29

I’m sorry but no… no, nope, nah. How dare she be as rude as she has been! Second I think this really hasn’t been thought about. Other posts have mentioned if anything happens to any of the children/equipment/property you are not covered. Are you seriously willing to take on all the responsibilities for someone else party who isn’t even a close friend. IMO I would cancel, I u seat and about the backlash but nothing and no one comes above your peace and happy place (home) too many red flags.

Shotokan101 · 10/04/2025 18:29

Repeat after me "No Invite - No Party"

Nameftgigb · 10/04/2025 18:28

5128gap · 09/04/2025 21:26

In all honesty, she's probably right. It is a bad idea for her DS to have his party in the garden of one of his guests, and for it to involve an activity he's never done, could be rubbish at, and that your DS does well. I can imagine well how your DS could end up the centre of attention with the other boys and the birthday child be disappointed. But the time to think of that was before she accepted your offer, and then, realising she couldn't possibly expect DS not to attend, thank you and decline. Personally I'd be saying on reflection I agree it's a bad idea, and you should find somewhere else. If it goes ahead and your DS is there there's a good chance it won't go well, and I bet your DS will get the blame!

So how do you go about checking that every guest in your party is worse in an activity than your children, just so they can feel smug on their birthdays? Do you check there’s no tumblers on your lists in case of trampoline parks (my niece is an Olympic gymnast and would put most children in the world to shame)? No amazing footballers or swimmers for football or pool parties? No competitive horse riders for pony parties? Absolutely no one at all can excel in any activity at a party so that your children look better? What a poor way to raise a child

EstHall · 10/04/2025 18:23

idontunderstandwhy · 09/04/2025 14:01

Dh used to compete and be a sports coach so we have a section of our garden built up and dedicated to that sport. He just teaches our dc and they play there now.

Ds has mostly had garden parties and then and on play dates his friends play there also.

Mum of one of his friends at a past play date mentioned her ds would love to learn do the sport and do something like this for his birthday but couldn’t find anywhere near.
Dh said that he’s welcome to come and practice whenever and actually could have party here if she couldn’t find anywhere else.

It was then agreed her ds could have his party in our garden and borrow equipment we had but that obviously over wise party organising is her responsibility. She has other entertainment, food arranged ect, party is quite soon.

She’s now said that she doesn’t think my DS should come as she’s worried the fact it’s his house/garden and he is good at the sport will take the shine of her DS and people will think it’s my DS’s day instead. And as it’s an out of school friend he would only know a few of kids anyway.

She never specifically said ds was invited we just assumed and we probably agreed based on that assumption.

I don’t think its fair to have ds locked in the house or taken out when his friends and boys his age playing in our garden and am shocked she thinks this is an okay suggestion.

AIBU it’s only fair ds goes?

I think she has something very wrong with her. Tell her your son now plays at county for an older team and you are much too busy to have a party held at your property now

Marosanne · 10/04/2025 18:21

Totally agree, that's ridiculous, take back the offer!!!

croydon15 · 10/04/2025 18:18

Are you charging this cf ?

Trishthedish · 10/04/2025 18:16

idontunderstandwhy · 09/04/2025 14:08

Thankyou for the replies, I hadn’t yet replied but needed to check I wasn’t being unreasonable and missing something.

Party is very soon and would be putting her out a lot to cancel. I think the most reasonable option would be to just insist it’s only fair that ds gets to go and I think she would agree to that above cancelling the whole party.

”I think she would agree to that” too right she’ll agree. How rude and entitled of her. I would be delighted f someone would do this for my child and at the very least would arrive with bubbly for you. I’m so flabbergasted on your behalf.

croydon15 · 10/04/2025 18:11

Dollshousedolly · 09/04/2025 14:05

I’d be telling her that your garden space is no longer available for the party.

This

latobatele · 10/04/2025 18:05

I am mostly surprised you are even entertaining the idea. That woman is a low key bully. I think she is envious of your kid. That my dear is even enough to stay away ftom her

Lollylucyclark101 · 10/04/2025 17:59

idontunderstandwhy · 09/04/2025 14:01

Dh used to compete and be a sports coach so we have a section of our garden built up and dedicated to that sport. He just teaches our dc and they play there now.

Ds has mostly had garden parties and then and on play dates his friends play there also.

Mum of one of his friends at a past play date mentioned her ds would love to learn do the sport and do something like this for his birthday but couldn’t find anywhere near.
Dh said that he’s welcome to come and practice whenever and actually could have party here if she couldn’t find anywhere else.

It was then agreed her ds could have his party in our garden and borrow equipment we had but that obviously over wise party organising is her responsibility. She has other entertainment, food arranged ect, party is quite soon.

She’s now said that she doesn’t think my DS should come as she’s worried the fact it’s his house/garden and he is good at the sport will take the shine of her DS and people will think it’s my DS’s day instead. And as it’s an out of school friend he would only know a few of kids anyway.

She never specifically said ds was invited we just assumed and we probably agreed based on that assumption.

I don’t think its fair to have ds locked in the house or taken out when his friends and boys his age playing in our garden and am shocked she thinks this is an okay suggestion.

AIBU it’s only fair ds goes?

I’d decline the offer and just tell her to find somewhere else to have the party.

Cerealkiller9000 · 10/04/2025 17:57

idontunderstandwhy · 09/04/2025 14:01

Dh used to compete and be a sports coach so we have a section of our garden built up and dedicated to that sport. He just teaches our dc and they play there now.

Ds has mostly had garden parties and then and on play dates his friends play there also.

Mum of one of his friends at a past play date mentioned her ds would love to learn do the sport and do something like this for his birthday but couldn’t find anywhere near.
Dh said that he’s welcome to come and practice whenever and actually could have party here if she couldn’t find anywhere else.

It was then agreed her ds could have his party in our garden and borrow equipment we had but that obviously over wise party organising is her responsibility. She has other entertainment, food arranged ect, party is quite soon.

She’s now said that she doesn’t think my DS should come as she’s worried the fact it’s his house/garden and he is good at the sport will take the shine of her DS and people will think it’s my DS’s day instead. And as it’s an out of school friend he would only know a few of kids anyway.

She never specifically said ds was invited we just assumed and we probably agreed based on that assumption.

I don’t think its fair to have ds locked in the house or taken out when his friends and boys his age playing in our garden and am shocked she thinks this is an okay suggestion.

AIBU it’s only fair ds goes?

Take away the offer!!!

good lord how spiteful is she

laraitopbanana · 10/04/2025 17:55

Hi op,

yeah if your kids can’t come to the party in their garden, unfortunately, the party won’t happen. That simple.

I hope she feels baaaaaad when she receives your text. Excluding your DS while enjoying all of his stuff! What a horrible woman. Maybe she would like you to go out also so people don’t think it isn’t her house?

😳😳😳

Pettyasfcuk · 10/04/2025 17:51

I personally would let the party go ahead, you don't wanna be the reason all those children go home unhappy, however I would block that parent and her darling angel at the door and tell them they aren't welcome, then celebrate his birthday without him

Girlsjustwannahavefunno1 · 10/04/2025 17:11

You are being a pushover. Sorry.
It's not on you to correct others behaviour.
Why would any decent human being think it was ok ?!

FormerlySpeckledyHen · 10/04/2025 15:26

Is this resolved now @idontunderstandwhy ?

Chattie89 · 10/04/2025 14:00

I thought I'd heard it all on here but this takes the fucking cake.

You're nicer than me OP I would probably have just immediately told her the party's cancelled and she can fuck off.

The13thFairy · 10/04/2025 13:28

Were they planning on using your bathroom, too?