Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think of myself as a girl at 50? [Light-hearted]

144 replies

ThisFluentBiscuit · 09/04/2025 03:27

Well, I'm sorry, but I do. I don't think I've aged much at all - I don't look much different from when I was 28 I think, (🤭) and I looked girlish then. I'd rather be a girl, which has connotations of freedom and fun, than a woman, which has connotations of too much responsibility!

I think being called a girl is a big compliment. It means you look young. It's equivalent in the States to being called Miss instead of Ma'am. The dreaded ma'am!!!

This thread has been inspired by another thread where the OP says he's confused by a girl at work, who is 41. Some posters objected to any female over the age of 18 being called a girl.

Well, I'll still be identifying as a girl when I'm 80, probably!

Older celebrity women around my age who I think of as girls:
Kate Moss
Jennifer Aniston
Victoria Beckham

In my mind, the above and me are all still 28 but could pass for much younger. 😂😂😂

It's a good day when I'm referred to as a girl. 🤪 Also - and this is the most important part - even though my parents are dead and I'm post-menopausal, I FEEL like a girl!

So, AIBU??

OP posts:
MrsJoanDanvers · 09/04/2025 17:32

It definitely seems to be a girl thing to use fack, feck or f*ck when you really mean fuck!

ItGhoul · 09/04/2025 17:27

Corbusier · 09/04/2025 16:13

I think the true guage of if you really are viewed as a girl still is to see how others refer to you! You may think you’re this carefree “girl” not changed much since your 20’s but it’s quickly dispelled when the retail assistant/waiter/other reminds you “We’re closing soon madam!” & the delusion bubble is truly burst. I remember it all the more for some reason from times in France where I was (what felt like all of a sudden) no longer “ a madmoiselle” or “jeune fille” but “madam”. Even though I dislike the derogatory use of “girl” I still viewed & saw myself & others as that, when it suited me. Fairweather feminist that I am!

Haha, I was furious the time I got called 'Madame' in France after numerous holidays always getting called 'Mademoiselle'.

ItGhoul · 09/04/2025 17:25

GaspingGekko · 09/04/2025 03:54

Do you think of 28 year old men as boys too?

Can't speak for the OP, but I absolutely do. I'm 49 and at a pub quiz with some friends last week said to the quizmaster "That boy over there will come and give you our team's entry fee in a minute". The 'boy' in question is 30 years old and has a wife and a child.

My mum will often describe her peers as 'girls'. Eg 'Did I tell you I met up with my cousin Christine last week? It must be ten years since I last saw her. We had a great time, she's a lovely girl'. Mum and Christine are both 80.

Staringatthestars · 09/04/2025 17:00

Couple of years off 40.

I don't want to sound older than I am. My brain is appalled that my body hasn't stayed as young as it should have 😆

If I was dating, I'd want to be a girlfriend, not a ladyfriend. Urgh.

I don't understand the problem. I go out with the girls too, and not one of them has mentioned that we should change it to 'the ladies' or 'the women'.

I have actually grown up and have many responsibilities and a career, so I wouldn't assume somebody was infantising me. I don't need to prove myself to anyone.

I saw the same thread and couldn't believe how many comments were about the word 'girl'. It's a word. I am a female, woman, girl - they are all the same thing.

But we don't worry when people can decide they are now a robot (or whatever else you may fancy).

At least I am a girl 🤷‍♀️

ThisFluentBiscuit · 09/04/2025 16:55

@PositivityVibes and woman I can’t get Tarzan/caveman out of my head ‘me man, you woman!’

LMAO, yes, I know what you mean!

OP posts:
PositivityVibes · 09/04/2025 16:53

Words are funny old things and mean different things to different people.

I’m one of those who ‘go out with the girls’ however if someone asked me I’d say I was female and swerve both girl and woman!

To me girl represents young, which I’m not and woman I can’t get Tarzan/caveman out of my head ‘me man, you woman!’ Which makes me cringe.

I also hate that both female and woman have male/man in them, whereas girl has no male connotations. I’m also northern so use lads and lasses more often than not.

cariadlet · 09/04/2025 16:48

ThisFluentBiscuit · 09/04/2025 15:29

Isn't it a bit sexist to equate being a girl with being silly, superficial, and frivolous? Are all females under 18 so?

I don't see the word like that at all!

I don't equate actual girls as silly, superficial and frivolous.

But the whole premise of the thread is based on the stereotypes and those are phrases which come to my mind when I think of grown women who choose to think of themselves as girls.

Widowerwouldyou · 09/04/2025 16:45

I’m still a girl at 64 - feck those who judge!!

Corbusier · 09/04/2025 16:14

Oops that shld read Madame (with the e) in French!

Corbusier · 09/04/2025 16:13

I think the true guage of if you really are viewed as a girl still is to see how others refer to you! You may think you’re this carefree “girl” not changed much since your 20’s but it’s quickly dispelled when the retail assistant/waiter/other reminds you “We’re closing soon madam!” & the delusion bubble is truly burst. I remember it all the more for some reason from times in France where I was (what felt like all of a sudden) no longer “ a madmoiselle” or “jeune fille” but “madam”. Even though I dislike the derogatory use of “girl” I still viewed & saw myself & others as that, when it suited me. Fairweather feminist that I am!

FleaBeeBob · 09/04/2025 15:57

I’m the opposite I hate being reference to as a girl or the girls. I push back when it happens that I’m a grown up not a child

hey Ho each to their own

gingercat02 · 09/04/2025 15:56

It's just a figure of speech really.
Yes officially girls and boys are under 18, but my Nan went "out with the girls" twice a month until one by one they died or were incapable in their 70s and 80s.
My friends and I have girls weekends and nights out, we are all heading towards 60.
DH goes to Download with the boys or a night out with the lads. The oldest is a grandfather in his mid 60s.
Doesn't actually mean anything

WhereIsMyJumper · 09/04/2025 15:52

I am enjoying your energy OP!

One thing I have observed is that the females in my life who are in their fifties and definitely more girls than the females in my life who are mid 30s/early 40s (I fall in to the latter age group) makes me look forward to getting older tbh

PinkArt · 09/04/2025 15:49

Girls are young, immature, inexperienced, often naive. Because they are young.
Woman on the other hand are mature, experienced, wise. Because they are adults, who have been knocking around for a while. They are also fun, sexy, playful, joyful and a million and one other fabulous things, but they bring with it all that lovely depth of womanhood. Why would you want to minimise all of those years of experiences, memories, lessons learned to cling on to 'being a girl'?!

pimplebum · 09/04/2025 15:40

I think you are delusional to think you look 28
need photo! Also who cares , hate agism

5128gap · 09/04/2025 15:36

Its interesting and a bit sad that the word girl has such negative associations of silliness, being coqettish, coy, frivolous and so on. Its the word for our daughters and our young selves. If it conjures up for you visions of pink giggly fluff, wanting to attract male attention and light weight interests, then you need to check your stereotypes. It could just as easily mean feeling young, fit, vibrant, with possibilities and opportunities ahead.

ThisFluentBiscuit · 09/04/2025 15:29

cariadlet · 09/04/2025 15:27

I know that the OP wants this to be a light hearted thread but I think that it's a bit odd to want to think of yourself as a girl.

Like a pp, I'm ok with the terms girls night out and girls holiday. My 80+ year old mum talks about "meeting the girls" for coffee and that's fine.

But I would never want to think of myself as a girl. I equate it with being silly, superficial and frivolous. Fine if that's how others want to be/see themselves but I would hate it.

I don't see being a woman as being burdened with cares and responsibilities. I see it as being strong, fierce and independent.

I'm a middle aged woman and very content with that. Since becoming involved with women's rights campaigning a few years ago, I have met so many amazing women and the word has become very important to me.

Isn't it a bit sexist to equate being a girl with being silly, superficial, and frivolous? Are all females under 18 so?

I don't see the word like that at all!

OP posts:
cariadlet · 09/04/2025 15:27

I know that the OP wants this to be a light hearted thread but I think that it's a bit odd to want to think of yourself as a girl.

Like a pp, I'm ok with the terms girls night out and girls holiday. My 80+ year old mum talks about "meeting the girls" for coffee and that's fine.

But I would never want to think of myself as a girl. I equate it with being silly, superficial and frivolous. Fine if that's how others want to be/see themselves but I would hate it.

I don't see being a woman as being burdened with cares and responsibilities. I see it as being strong, fierce and independent.

I'm a middle aged woman and very content with that. Since becoming involved with women's rights campaigning a few years ago, I have met so many amazing women and the word has become very important to me.

ThisFluentBiscuit · 09/04/2025 15:23

Shirtless · 09/04/2025 08:09

Of course they ‘understand’. They just think that women who struggle with a word that presupposes their maturity and think that being infantilised is a ‘compliment’ might want to crank up their thinking muscles.

Crank up their thinking muscles! 🤣🤣🤣🤣

Hang on a minute - what thinking muscles? 😂

OP posts:
ThisFluentBiscuit · 09/04/2025 15:20

jellyfishperiwinkle · 09/04/2025 08:00

You sound delusional and and your worth is entirely embedded in your looks and whether men find you attractive.

I look great and am fit and healthy but definitely 49 and not 28 and I'm glad to look my age. It represents all the experience and wisdom I've gained in my life and the seniority and respect I am given in my professional life for my knowledge and skills. I absolutely love being and looking my age.

Edited

I am delulu, yes, and OBVIOUSLY my worth is in my looks! I mean, what else really matters? 😂

It's not true that my worth is embedded in whether men find me attractive though, how dare you.

It's also embedded in whether WOMEN find me attractive! 😂

OP posts:
ThisFluentBiscuit · 09/04/2025 15:12

TheaBrandt1 · 09/04/2025 10:30

We still say “girls nights” our group are 45-55 don’t really think about it. No one is so delusional as to think we still are like the under 40s though we stay current and are fit and active and do new things all the time.

If you have teens yourself you know the vast gulf there is between 16 and 50.

The thing that’s hard to watch is a 40 plus woman being coquettish, flirty and girlie - that’s absolute cringe. None of my friends would do that I’ve seen some of my mums acquaintances be like this - shudder.

I'm not coquettish and flirty. Not generally happy enough for that. I just feel 28!

OP posts:
ThisFluentBiscuit · 09/04/2025 15:10

TheCountofMountingCrispBags · 09/04/2025 07:33

Do you have long hair and wear 'girly' clothes?

I have long hair and will do until the day I die, and I don't wear girly clothes bc I'm overweight, but would dress in a more feminine style if I wasn't. I would say feminine rather than girly. Kate Middleton's style.

OP posts:
Terrribletwos · 09/04/2025 15:08

ThisFluentBiscuit · 09/04/2025 04:45

Oh Christ, I have all those things, except I'm too old to have to worry about the white trousers!

I think being a girl is a state of mind. It retains the essence of who you were before post-menopausal bladder issues, frozen shoulder, divorce, and gawd knows what else. It says, "I remain young inside!"

Oh really! I think you protest too Much!

I don't like being old. Its fucking horrible!

Who wouldn't rather being young again?

ThisFluentBiscuit · 09/04/2025 15:04

BitOutOfPractice · 09/04/2025 07:24

You know “cute” when you’re 50 is different from “cute” when you’re younger don’t you?

I like to think I’m girlish in some ways - energetic, open to new ideas, interested in clothes and always up for trying new experiences, ready to laugh at most things but I also like being a woman - experienced, interesting, respected at work, not afraid to be who I want to be.

Tbh op you sound a bit silly and not the kind of girl or woman I’d want to hand out with. Which would probably suit you fine as well.

Yes! I am cute and silly! So there! U are just a big grumpy meanie.

OP posts: