Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be fed up with in laws here all the time and hubby moving his sister in?

738 replies

Sp3849 · 06/04/2025 22:25

So a few months ago we bought our dream home. With a bit of land for our horse mad daughter to finally have her horse. It's been years in the making and to achieve it We had to relocate our whole lives We have both worked our guts out over the years.

However, since moving in our in laws have been making alot of effort to come visit etc. Now bearing in mind we now live 3 hours away. When we lived in the same town as them for 15 years we only saw or spoke to them if we visited which was a few times a year. They never called to ask about our kids. They had no interest at all. No birthday wishes no visit at Christmas nothing from them at all. Never even phoned to see how they were. Once we moved to Thier favourite place to holiday they started to visit us. At first I didn't care. My husband was happy his parents where making an effort and my kids had grandparents that saw them.

However a few weeks ago my husband comes home from work and says his sister who is 30 has handed in her notice and is moving down our way. She asked if she can put a static caravan on our land. I had no issue with this. We talked about how it would be nice for our daughter to have her auntie who was a horse loving riding instructor and a career in horse health and welfare to hand and how she could have company hacking together etc.

Next thing he comes home and she is moving in our house as she can't afford a caravan. I am like ok well I don't mind helping her get on her feet but it's not forever.

The last three weeks have been hell and she hasn't even moved in yet. We only have a Sunday off work together. My husband is off on saturday too. His whole family have been here every weekend all weekend. Preparing and decorating the spare room. Moving all her horse stuff down. My poor husband is run ragged as they want extra fences gates and all these things in place for her horse. They haven't paid for a single thing or even offered they just expect it and he delivers. I feel so uncomfortable in my own home. I have one day off work and I can't catch up on housework or spend time with my children. I haven't barely seen my husband as he works long hours in the week. We both eat tea and it's time for bed. Sunday has always been our day. I have told him tonight that we need boundaries. His family only want to know now because of what we have. I am happy to help his sis but there needs to be a time limit and if his mum dad and other siblings think they can come here to stay every weekend too then I will end up moving out.

I have told him how I feel we have had a very large row. Apparently I am unreasonable. I just know this is not going to end well. They have done some truly horrible things over the years to him and I feel like we are being used for our house!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
MsCactus · 08/04/2025 06:43

Fantastic update - well done both of you 👏👏👏

Roselilly36 · 08/04/2025 06:42

That’s too much OP, before you know it PIL will expect to move in too. Put your foot down. good luck

Notsosure1 · 08/04/2025 06:32

GravyDenier · 07/04/2025 23:31

As someone who loves having family and friends around all the time, this posts makes me feel strange

Instead of strange you should be feeling incredibly grateful

Swiftie1878 · 08/04/2025 06:29

Sp3849 · 07/04/2025 22:58

Well they weren't happy. His mother and sister did not take it very well. They basically tried to make out they were thinking of my daughter and how beneficial it would be for her having her auntie there to help her. With us both working. She could tutor her privately and take her to competitions and she could collect her from school and take her to the beach. My husband just said as lovely as that sounded if she wants to do those things in her spare time ofcourse she can we have always wanted for them to be involved in our children's lives but she doesn't need to live with us to do that. She has never ever bothered with her. We lived close by and she never even had the time to visit so yeah that went down like a sh!t sandwich. They continued to try but he stood his ground. They were going to have a chat his mum mentioned her funding the caravan if they can get planning. Hubby just said well if she can't she can go rent somewhere or stay home. Sis was whining about she had quite her job. Hubby pointed out that had she spoken to us about it first or even involved is in her plans then she would have known not to quit her job. It all ended quite awkwardly.

You and your DH (finally!) have handled this brilliantly!
Really, WELL DONE! xxx

DeathNote11 · 08/04/2025 06:29

Glad they've been told now, but don't drop your guard yet. Families like that don't like hearing the word 'no', especially from members who aren't meant to answer back.

Bettyfromlondon · 08/04/2025 06:22

Well done to your husband!!!

I suggest you go back to your post to use to prepare a large font bullet-pointed list to print and keep for reference!

If his parents abide by your rules, you should now have a run of 5/6 weekends to enjoy as a family and start settling in to your new area. I hope you have good locks and a door camera to deter uninvited visitors. The principle going forward should be that they ASK if they may visit and not just TELL you!

I am sure they are all furious with you both for thwarting their plans. GOOD! I hope the SIL is just too lazy to find a job and get things in place for a short time-limited stay at yours. No doubt his parents will regroup and try to wheedle/steamroller their way back to enjoy the fruits of your hard work but your husband's eyes seem to be open now as to their manipulations.

Re: the redecorated bedroom. Repainting it yourselves or changing it in some way would reassert your dominance and ownership of YOUR home.

There is glorious weather predicted for this coming weekend. I hope you all have a wonderful time together!

HomeTheatreSystem · 08/04/2025 06:02

That is great news OP! Ofc they won't like it and I expect will rain some more shit down on your heads but that is to be expected isn't it? If they were halfway decent people with genuine motives towards your daughter they'd have apologised profusely for overstepping and their lack of upfront communication but they're not so they didn't. He'll need to weather the storm but can rest easy knowing he's put his needs and those of his wife and children first.

Bingbopboomboomboombopbam · 08/04/2025 05:43

GravyDenier · 07/04/2025 23:31

As someone who loves having family and friends around all the time, this posts makes me feel strange

Why? Different people have different needs.

Eastertidings · 08/04/2025 04:29

I've thought some more and I've finally crystallised why I don't like what they're doing, beyond recognising the general fact they're taking advantage of you.

So here's a hypothetical situation, using figures I've plucked from the air at random. That doesn't matter, whatever the true figures are, my point still stands. Here goes:

You look around at properties, you decide you need 10 acres. You find one for £800k. You get a 100% mortgage. So you've paid £800k for a property that's exactly what you need, 10 acres.

Then SIL puts a horse and caravan on 3 acres. So now the situation is you've paid £800k and you've only got use of 7 acres, not the 10 you decided you needed at the start.

So,
if you'd known from the start that SIL wanted housing by you,
and there'd been a property for £700k with 7 acres,
would you have bought that instead?

And then also taken out an extra £100k on the mortgage, using it to buy a flat in the nearest town for SIL to live in? An option that would have been better for you than a caravan on your land, because it wouldn't involve feeling like SIL is in your personal space so much.

It would have left you in a similar situation, £800k mortgage, you with 7 acres and SIL housed. Just in a different format.

Because if you wouldn't have done that, then why are you letting her have some of your land to use for horse plus caravan living, indefinitely?

Whether she pays anything for rent and livery fee is irrelevant to this point I'm making here. Either way, you've bought a proportion of property you can't use because you're letting her use it.

If she was a much loved sister, perhaps with problems not of her own making, like your DDs situation, then I could understand the sacrifice. But for someone who's disinterested in you and taking the piss? That, I don't understand.

Mix56 · 08/04/2025 04:17

Your H must be feeling exhausted but vilified from making a stand.
He understands why he is at the crossroads, he has you & the life he has fought for.
Let them hunker down & blame you… its OK. Both you & DH know the truth.
& yes they will attempt flying monkeys & to corner him on his own.
Stand strong. Bravo

pollyglot · 08/04/2025 02:06

Do you really believe that she/they will keep her/their word on anything, OP?

It's a shitstorm waiting to happen. And it will.

I hope you will keep your word. About divorcing, I mean. That will, too.

Eastertidings · 08/04/2025 00:44

I'm so glad he came through for you OP.

I was thinking of their wording earlier. It was all quite deliberately planned. The constant visits to prepare and the forcefulness of what those preparations should be is typical of emotional abuse in that it's designed for the victim to have no time or space to stop and think for a second. I'm sure if it wasn't for you, DH would have been caught up in this so hard and it would have happened faster than he could blink.

When they said SIL is "moving down your way" that was calculated misrepresentation in order to manipulate. How could she have any plans to move down your way when she had no job there, no place to stay and had just quit her job, so no income so no way she'd pass the financial checks from any landlord?

"Moving down your way" looks like keeping her job, taking two weeks annual leave, asking to stay with you for that time (just her, no horse/dog/PIL) and spending the time securing a flat share, a livery place for the horse and registering with temp agencies as a minimum. So she could return, give in her notice, pack up and move and come start her new life. There's no need for a caravan on your land or her horse in your fields. That's not "moving down your way", that's moving in. I agree with you OP, I'll bet she doesn't come now.

As for a fresh independent start, if she wanted that she could have done it in her current area. Nothing to stop her making moves to be independent in her current town and yet she's never done it. She never needed to come to your area to be independent. Bit of a shock to the system leaving the parents she's been so reliant on too. You'd think she'd prefer to become independent gradually under the circumstances and do it with them close by.

If they're planning on moving to their favourite holiday town too, ostensibly so they can see you all more, then it makes far more sense for SIL to move with them and then start building her independence in the new area, since they're happy to support her it's more of a safety net for her that way.

None of it adds up. The only way their actions adds up is if the whole lot of them had planned, from the beginning, to move into your home permanently and take it over. The sense of entitlement you've seen from them before they've even moved in would have multiplied tenfold once they were established at yours.

So in future don't trust anything they say, watch their actions instead, pull it all apart and question everything, because you've just had a taste of how lying and manipulative they can be.

itsjustbiology · 08/04/2025 00:00

Oh OP why on earth have you agreed to this? OMG you have given them all a way in when you should have shut the door. I am so sorry but this is far from over but I guess you will find that out.

BreadInCaptivity · 07/04/2025 23:55

@Sp3849Well done both of you.

It had to be done and in a way I hope it’s made your DH reflect on his boundaries with his family.

There is no getting around the fact they have treated you both very poorly.

ihatethongs · 07/04/2025 23:51

No way! I couldn’t deal with this for a second.
First she was just going to be using your land to live in a caravan, then she decides she can’t afford it so she decides she can just move in?
She could just as easily turn one month into three months, or three months into three years.
I wish you luck.

2JFDIYOLO · 07/04/2025 23:46

Bloody well done both of you.

Now WRITE IT ALL DOWN.

Everything you said, everything that is going to happen.

And send it to them all. Keep copies.

Because there will be attempts to twist things from their end. 'Misremembering' what you said. Trying to coerce and persuade.

They will be going to him behind your back and trying to manipulate him.

He may need to reread the notes to remind him what actually happened.

He will need help to withstand this as they'll prey on his desperate need for everything he was denied as a boy.

They will attempt to make you the bad guy.

They will also be secretly badmouthing you to other relatives and friends and you may find flying monkeys deployed on their behalf.

Please help him to find therapy and some assertiveness skills training asap. He's damaged and unhappy which is not good for him or you and your child.

SavageTomato · 07/04/2025 23:43

You've both done amazingly well, so far. But I'd like to give you permission to go absolutely fucking nuclear. That's what I would do. Seriously, they've tried to hijack your home and lives because they see your husband as disposable and worthy only of sacrifice to his pathetic, fucked up sister. Not your problem. Neither of you should have to deal with this bullshit. Why don't you phone them up and TELL them none of these plans are going ahead? Take it out of your husband's hands and tell them to fuck off once and for all. It's your house too, right? Go nuclear. Now. What can they do if you do? Absolutely nothing.

Tinyrabbit · 07/04/2025 23:42

Amazing update and well done you for not enabling his toxic family.
I feel really sorry for your husband - as I'm sure you must too. I hope you both can have some lovely times together at the weekends now the threat of the dreaded in-laws descending has been removed. Stay strong, and maybe encourage him towards therapy?

GravyDenier · 07/04/2025 23:31

As someone who loves having family and friends around all the time, this posts makes me feel strange

ThisFluentBiscuit · 07/04/2025 23:29

Excellent move making SIL getting a new job a condition of moving in.

Evilspiritgin · 07/04/2025 23:23

Well done both of you, it must have been really hard for your husband to stand up to his mum and sister, especially as he’s trapped looking for love / approval from them. I’m really pleased that he did that

Squigglesandgiggles · 07/04/2025 23:22

Squigglesandgiggles · 07/04/2025 23:14

I can tell you now this sister will not move out.
You put your foot down or your marriage ends because you will resent him.

sorry op just read your update oops.

what a fantastic result! I’m really happy your dh came through x

Squigglesandgiggles · 07/04/2025 23:14

I can tell you now this sister will not move out.
You put your foot down or your marriage ends because you will resent him.

allthemiddlechildrenoftheworld · 07/04/2025 23:11

@Sp3849 brilliant updates!!! you both did very well to get your own lives back!!!

SociableAtWork · 07/04/2025 23:05

Nothing to add, except “bloody well done!” Hope you can both stick to your guns and they show you both the respect you deserve. You’ve sacrificed so much for this and deserve every happiness with your immediate family unit.

Seriously, and without meaning to sound patronising, your DH has done amazingly to stand up to them, it’s not easy for the scape goat.