Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Gucci or Goochi??

120 replies

SansaStark90 · 06/04/2025 04:47

Over the years I’ve collected handbags. I’ve been feeling down on myself so treated myself to a new Gucci bag. My friend came round with a similar style. She admitted to me it was fake! I put them side by side. Hers was slightly brighter gold. Otherwise, no difference! Am I unreasonable to now think a lot of people own fake and I’ve wasted my money and should maybe buy a fake for when I go on nights out so I don’t worry it gets ruined. I cannot believe the quality of fakes. I’ve never looked as my perception is off some market stall and terrible. Before people say they fund crime, all clothes come from sweatshops really and these are coming from China and the whole business is set up to replicate fakes. Feel naive and like I’ve wasted a lot of money

OP posts:
Wexone · 06/04/2025 16:51

I love my clothes and love certain brands. I buy them for the quality and style. I love my shoes and have paid alot for some. but I love them. I am not really a bag person I have a few designer ones but I do like them and they are practical for me to use. if you love your bag then don't worry about it. the fake market is shocking and people buying them are supporting money laundering operations sex trafficking and people smuggling. there are certain bags I wouldn't buy due to the amount of fakes I see. like the lv nerfull and the marc jacobs camera bag. don't buy stuff just to show people and be all on instragram. botegga actually doesn't have an Instagram page they are not on social media people buy cause of its quality etc. the row is another quiet luxery brand. buy cause you love and afford it

springbringshope · 06/04/2025 16:35

ConnieSlow · 06/04/2025 15:01

This, I think you can always tell a fake. Not always by the item, but by the person themself.

Then you don’t know many wealthy women. I know women with multiple Hermes. They dress in an understated way. Lori Piana, Bottega, The Row. Some of the bags are real. Some are fake. You’d never know.

SansaStark90 · 06/04/2025 15:23

AppleCelebration · 06/04/2025 15:05

I accidentally fell into the world of replicas on Reddit and I’m blown away to be honest. There’s cheap copies and then this is another level!

Do feel free to dm me and share! I would have scoffed before like I would never own fake. But when fake is this good, then I just feel silly for buying real

OP posts:
mugglewump · 06/04/2025 15:18

These are handbags, not works of art. To me a bag is a functional piece, like a coat or shoes. They need to be good quality, look good and do the job they are meant to do. Does it really matter if it is a fake or not if you like the bag and the quality is good? Brand boasting is so tiresome.

northerneast · 06/04/2025 15:14

Am I unreasonable to now think a lot of people own fake and I’ve wasted my money and should maybe buy a fake for when I go on nights out so I don’t worry it gets ruined.

YABU to have bought a bag for show.

if you wanted a Gucci bag you would still want a Gucci bag. Fact is you wanted to show off your Gucci bag, given you now realise lots are fake and most people don’t know.

Langdale3 · 06/04/2025 15:13

SansaStark90 · 06/04/2025 13:49

Can you share the brand please?

I thought about naming them, but I’m afraid I am reluctant to, because my bag is old! I’m worried that the quality of workmanship or materials could have deteriorated in the last few years. I don’t want to disappoint.

This article explains the problem well: https://bagsandthegirl.com/20-emerging-bag-brands-you-need-to-know/

Do inspect potential purchases in person if you can. Usuf Osman, a luxury leather crafter, has some good tips: https://youtube.com/@beingyusufosman?feature=shared

20 Emerging Bag Brands: The Best in Craftsmanship and Italian Leather You Need to Know - Bags & the girl

Discover with me a a new generation of bag designers who are staying true to the essence of what makes a bag luxurious: craftsmanship, premium materials, and attention to detail.

https://bagsandthegirl.com/20-emerging-bag-brands-you-need-to-know/

Growlybear83 · 06/04/2025 15:10

Toottooot · 06/04/2025 14:35

Don’t buy the fake - although you think there is no real difference you will always know it’s knock off and using it just won’t feel so good.

Although I can’t believe nobody has suggested you just cart your stuff about in a bag for life yet. Or better still buy a trumpet or a park bench - iykyk.

Edited

I think that if I cared about having a supposedly prestige brand and bought a good fake, I would get far more satisfaction from knowing that I’d saved myself a small fortune.

SchoolDilemma17 · 06/04/2025 15:10

SansaStark90 · 06/04/2025 13:23

I really don’t doubt that’s what happens. From being 18 to now in my mid 30’s the craftsmanship you used to get feels lost and they feel mass produced. The original loewe puzzle bag must have taken hours upon hours. Now they’ve dumbed down the design so they are easier to make. It’s like believing your chicken from M&S comes from a different factory to Aldi.

Id love to support young designers that’s a great idea. Your Jane Hopkinson bag has stood the test of time. I love that.

I used to work in fashion a million years ago and the same happens w clothes. Same place that makes bikinis for H&M makes them for Armani. Just different materials.

SchoolDilemma17 · 06/04/2025 15:08

ConnieSlow · 06/04/2025 15:01

This, I think you can always tell a fake. Not always by the item, but by the person themself.

Judgmental much?! I know some very wealthy women who happily buy fakes

SchoolDilemma17 · 06/04/2025 15:07

Even experts struggle to always identify good fakes

https://www.nytimes.com/2023/05/04/magazine/celine-chanel-gucci-superfake-handbags.html

AppleCelebration · 06/04/2025 15:05

I accidentally fell into the world of replicas on Reddit and I’m blown away to be honest. There’s cheap copies and then this is another level!

ConnieSlow · 06/04/2025 15:01

Tbrh · 06/04/2025 05:23

YABU. A fake is fake who would want that. Either have the real thing or not at all

This, I think you can always tell a fake. Not always by the item, but by the person themself.

Toottooot · 06/04/2025 14:35

Don’t buy the fake - although you think there is no real difference you will always know it’s knock off and using it just won’t feel so good.

Although I can’t believe nobody has suggested you just cart your stuff about in a bag for life yet. Or better still buy a trumpet or a park bench - iykyk.

Comefromaway · 06/04/2025 14:27

I don’t think Gucci handbags are that good quality. I certainly wouldn’t buy one although I am going to get a pair of their loafers. Dh says his Gucci shoes are incredibly comfortable. He also has a pair of LV. Too ostentatious for me, but he loves them.

I buy for quality & longevity. Two brands of handbags I love which get complimented and I think you can tell the difference are Bottega Venetta & Loewe. I also like my Mulberry handbag. I’d gone into Selfridges to buy a Demellier, but when I saw them in person I thought they looked and felt cheap. It was the hardware.

SansaStark90 · 06/04/2025 14:23

@AlloaintheMiddle @Blueuggboots I’m going to look into having one designed. Such a good idea, never thought of it before! I’d appreciate any links on insta I don’t follow any artisans

OP posts:
RaraRachael · 06/04/2025 14:22

Tbh I wouldn't know a designer handbag if it hit me in the face. I see people with bags that look nice but unless they have the designer name on it, it means nothing to me - and even then it could be a fake. When we went on a day trip to Turkey everybody, apart from us, came back laden with fake designer goods.

My work colleague put a picture on Instagram of her husband's birthday present to her - a designer handbag that had apparently cost £900. If it hadn't had the tag on it I wouldn't have a clue what it was.

I just don't get the designer stuff but each to their own.

SansaStark90 · 06/04/2025 14:16

Unpaidviewer · 06/04/2025 14:11

If you've bought it for the label then you may as well have got a fake. If it's for the quality and craftsmanship, or as an investment then it's worth the cost.

I think my feeling of being duped is that the quality and craftsmanship is gone now, unlike vintage pieces.

OP posts:
WindyWendyHouse · 06/04/2025 14:16

FuckityFux · 06/04/2025 13:29

Only mugs waste money on ridiculously expensive handbags just to impress others who probably don't care anyway.

However, I also wouldn’t buy a fake designer bag as I think they’re generally a bit dull looking and I prefer more interesting quirky designs.

I feel the same.

There's that saying, 'We buy stuff we don't need to impress people we don't know'

Unpaidviewer · 06/04/2025 14:15

There are some amazing fakes around. I read that cartier are refusing to give authentication for love bangles now as they cannot tell the difference between them.

Unpaidviewer · 06/04/2025 14:11

If you've bought it for the label then you may as well have got a fake. If it's for the quality and craftsmanship, or as an investment then it's worth the cost.

TwistedWonder · 06/04/2025 14:10

Tbrh · 06/04/2025 05:23

YABU. A fake is fake who would want that. Either have the real thing or not at all

Agree with this. I’m really not into designer items anyway but if I wanted one I’d buy the real thing.

Never really understood the whole moody designer gear thing even back in my younger days.

SansaStark90 · 06/04/2025 14:07

ConsuelaHammock · 06/04/2025 14:00

It’s green!

However, that cerulean blue, represents millions of dollars and countless jobs. It’s sort of comical how you think you’ve made a choice that exempts you from the fashion industry.

When I say love, I mean hours of work with quality materials. Our economy would fall if we all made things outta love and passed them on for free. But you keep on thinking it’s a frivolous past time to care what bag you carry.

OP posts:
wishiwasupahill · 06/04/2025 14:04

I wouldn’t buy either.

I just don’t understand it.

why pay more just for something to have a label on it?

I don’t believe all the “it’s better quality” garbage; as you say, they are all made in sweatshops.

Just buy what you like. Doesn’t have to be Gucci or fake Gucci. Designed stuff is all a con.

springbringshope · 06/04/2025 14:03

SurnameChanged · 06/04/2025 13:45

It’s about how it makes you feel. Would you get the same joy from a fake as the real thing? People who are happy with fakes are surely just about impressing others.

I just buy stuff I like. And avoid anything with an identifiable logo. The idea of a bag advertising a brand by displaying garish letters is way too tacky and blingy for my tastes.

I cannot understand why anyone would buy a fake. Give me a plain bag from H and M over a fake designer tacky creation any day of the week.

Except if it’s a mirror replica of a non tacky bag then it won’t be tacky.

springbringshope · 06/04/2025 14:00

landbeforegrime · 06/04/2025 05:10

I bought.a longchamp tote from Ebay- bnwt. It was about half the price of the ones from the longchamp website. When it arrived I did some research etc to check if it was a fake. It was. I bought one from longchamp.directly - they were so so similar. The fake didn't have real leather handles but this was difficult to tell and they needed to be side by side to see the difference. I sent the ebay one back. I see so so many longchamp totes these days and I presume a significant number are fake. I sometimes feel like a mug but also I wouldn't want a fake designer item. If you can't afford the original why do you want to pretend you can? It just seems like an unnecessarily silly thing to do, pretending to be wealthier than you are? Why? Just buy a bag you can afford that you love. Designer should be about quality. If it's not then you've probably been scammed or the company is more likely to take it back if it doesn't last very long or send a replacement. It's just a bit tacky to knowingly walk around with a fake.

If the handles were not even leather then that was a poor fake. Top fakes are impossible to tell by anyone but an extremely experienced expert. Even then they can be fooled. without deconstructing and seeing the lining, inner stitch quality etc. it’s almost impossible to tell
What does happen is the fakes don’t tend to wear as well. But sometimes they do.
some brands now have chips inbedded. The counterfeiters are even counterfeiting those though.