Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Anonymous noise complaint about my baby playing

196 replies

StressedOutMama15 · 02/04/2025 21:19

Hello!

I’m a new mum to a gorgeous 10 month old, happy, baby. She has just started making excited squeal sounds when she plays or if she wants my attention if I’m cracking on with chores and she’s playing independently. I always respond to her and distract her with a different toy and when I’m out and about and she makes these screaming sounds I always apologise to everyone around.

This evening when my partner came home, he found a letter in the hallway (from an anonymously neighbour) complaining about the noise my baby makes when she’s playing and claiming they “cant take much more”. This is the first complaint from any neighbour we’ve had. Our neighbours are generally quite friendly so this shocked and upset me as you can imagine.

Our DD sleeps from around 8pm until 9am solid and we spend most days out with friends or at my mums. I’m very upset by this letter and I feel like I’m now walking on egg shells in my own home! I live in a small terraced house on a busy main road so there’s usually a lot of noise anyway, I didn’t realise her shrieks were that disruptive.

Am I being the a$$hole..? Any advice on how to limit a baby scream when she’s excited? I feel bad telling her to “shhh” when she’s just trying to talk and doesn’t know how else to!

MNHQ removed photograph of note at request of OP as it was potentially highly identifying

OP posts:
SnowPinkLetters · 02/04/2025 23:13

I would say woman from the handwriting, and language, ignore, your child can’t make noise all day.
But they may work from home, so will here it all of the time.
I see you’ve guessed who it might be.

hopsalong · 02/04/2025 23:10

How is your hearing?

I mean this seriously. I have freakishly good hearing (also as blind as a bat). I can hear things that most people can’t, including quiet group conversations at some distance. That’s fine. I find loud music or shouting louder than most people would. I had an argument last year with my neighbours (who both have hearing aids) about their dog barking inside the house. We live in a semi-detached house and are not connected on that side. They truly thought I was bonkers, and I suspect they barely perceived the dog barking at all from upstairs in their own house. But my study is downstairs and it prevented me from being able to work.

It’s possible that your neighbour is mad.

Equally, it might be that you aren’t hearing how loud your baby really is.

northernsunshine · 02/04/2025 23:08

StressedOutMama15 · 02/04/2025 21:19

Hello!

I’m a new mum to a gorgeous 10 month old, happy, baby. She has just started making excited squeal sounds when she plays or if she wants my attention if I’m cracking on with chores and she’s playing independently. I always respond to her and distract her with a different toy and when I’m out and about and she makes these screaming sounds I always apologise to everyone around.

This evening when my partner came home, he found a letter in the hallway (from an anonymously neighbour) complaining about the noise my baby makes when she’s playing and claiming they “cant take much more”. This is the first complaint from any neighbour we’ve had. Our neighbours are generally quite friendly so this shocked and upset me as you can imagine.

Our DD sleeps from around 8pm until 9am solid and we spend most days out with friends or at my mums. I’m very upset by this letter and I feel like I’m now walking on egg shells in my own home! I live in a small terraced house on a busy main road so there’s usually a lot of noise anyway, I didn’t realise her shrieks were that disruptive.

Am I being the a$$hole..? Any advice on how to limit a baby scream when she’s excited? I feel bad telling her to “shhh” when she’s just trying to talk and doesn’t know how else to!

MNHQ removed photograph of note at request of OP as it was potentially highly identifying

That letter is completely unhinged, so sorry you have such a horrible neighbour who is clearly in a lot of mental pain. Enjoy your baby and those excited noises.

jamimmi · 02/04/2025 23:04

Another early 50's here to say nope wouldn't use wild that way but my teen would! Could it be the teen kids getting thier sleep disturbed. They take that very seriously 🤣. If so ear plugs! Your little one sounds very normal. I still refuse to speak to.our neighbour who complained about my son screaming at 3 months old. Summer baby, windows open. It disturbef her garden use. He had horrible cholic and is now 22! So feel your pain. I'd go with the post it back and ask them.to come forward method. If it is the teen Mum will recognise the handwriting and hopefully deal with it.

StressedOutMama15 · 02/04/2025 22:50

farmlife2 · 02/04/2025 22:46

True that. I'm early 50s and wouldn't use wild in that context either. There's also a clue that the note references 'we', so it's a household or more than one person.

The neighbour we suspect is in her late 40s/early 50s with two teenagers. The other side are a lovely retired couple that we feel would knock if there was a problem! I’m loving all of the sleuthing help!

OP posts:
farmlife2 · 02/04/2025 22:46

Obvnotthegolden · 02/04/2025 22:39

I agree with pp saying to copy the note and post it with your own note.

If I was a neighbour who didn't write the note I'd be round to yours asap to make sure you knew it wasn't me!

But then my DH has just said if he did write the note he'd be round to pretend he didn't.

Sorry, not much help.

Except we are grandparent age and wouldn't say "wild" in that context.

True that. I'm early 50s and wouldn't use wild in that context either. There's also a clue that the note references 'we', so it's a household or more than one person.

Fiftyfish · 02/04/2025 22:43

I’d be louder tomorrow.

Obvnotthegolden · 02/04/2025 22:40

StressedOutMama15 · 02/04/2025 22:35

A detached bungalow is now definitely on my mind! 😂

You should print off some nice detached houses and post them to neighbours with a cope of the letter 😂

Obvnotthegolden · 02/04/2025 22:39

I agree with pp saying to copy the note and post it with your own note.

If I was a neighbour who didn't write the note I'd be round to yours asap to make sure you knew it wasn't me!

But then my DH has just said if he did write the note he'd be round to pretend he didn't.

Sorry, not much help.

Except we are grandparent age and wouldn't say "wild" in that context.

caramac04 · 02/04/2025 22:38

The neighbour is nuts. I’d have no respect for a person who wrote an anonymous note even if they had got lovely handwriting.
Babies can be noisy as all humans can be noisy. If you live in a terraced house then you should expect and accept a certain level of noise. Perhaps the neighbour needs to buy a detached house.

StressedOutMama15 · 02/04/2025 22:35

Shitmonger · 02/04/2025 22:33

It’s not unreasonable in general, it’s a normal response to you being excited with her. It becomes unreasonable when you live in a flat with such awful sound insulation that you can hear your neighbours chopping vegetables. It’s wild that you can hear something like that; I don’t understand how these places get away with crap like this. Of course people will have issues with one another if they can hear their neighbours’ every sneeze! But it also explains why they are so overwrought about hearing your daughter’s shrieks all day.

Sounds like it might be time to start planning a move/upgrade!

A detached bungalow is now definitely on my mind! 😂

OP posts:
StressedOutMama15 · 02/04/2025 22:34

Justalittlehotpotato · 02/04/2025 22:29

I second this sort of approach, as the mother of a toddler who is slap bang into terrible twos. She is loud, she screams (and not in the cute adorable way that I am sure your 10 month old does), and frankly, there is little I can do about her occasional screaming paddies other than to try to distract her or ignore her until she calms down, as it is a normal part of development. Fortunately we have lovely neighbours, but yours sound as though this will not be the last time this comes up with the many child rearing years you have to come.

Ah yes I’ve been thinking also about how this neighbour will cope when we reach this stage! My dd is already pretty strong willed (has been shaking her head to say no since 7 months 😂) so I imagine we’ll get this quite early! We live in an extremely family friendly neighbourhood with multiple schools nearby and the neighbour has two teenagers so I hoped she’d be understanding

OP posts:
Shitmonger · 02/04/2025 22:33

StressedOutMama15 · 02/04/2025 21:54

Thank you for your responses! There are of course times where she’s playing and I tell her well done for pulling herself to stand or where she’s beginning to attempt animal noises. She’ll sometimes squeal with excitement when I congratulate her but is that unreasonable? 🥲 We often leave the house around midday latest or we both go stir crazy anyway!

It’s not unreasonable in general, it’s a normal response to you being excited with her. It becomes unreasonable when you live in a flat with such awful sound insulation that you can hear your neighbours chopping vegetables. It’s wild that you can hear something like that; I don’t understand how these places get away with crap like this. Of course people will have issues with one another if they can hear their neighbours’ every sneeze! But it also explains why they are so overwrought about hearing your daughter’s shrieks all day.

Sounds like it might be time to start planning a move/upgrade!

SwanOfThoseThings · 02/04/2025 22:32

If they can't put their name to the complaint, you shouldn't give it any credence.

StressedOutMama15 · 02/04/2025 22:32

I understand my idea of bad shrieking might be totally different to the neighbours understanding of bad shrieking and therefore has driven them
to writing the letter. Personally, I feel the noise coming from my house isn’t too bad as she could be up screaming the house down all night as some poor babies do! I work remotely from 9pm until 1am (laptop in bed situation so I can nurse her back to sleep straight away should she stir) so I have to ensure she’s asleep by this time anyway in order to meet my work hours

OP posts:
Justalittlehotpotato · 02/04/2025 22:29

StealthMama · 02/04/2025 22:14

Similar to others but slightly different sentiment.

Copy the letter and send it with a new letter to neighbours that states living in such close proximity and presence of neighbourly noise can be understandably frustrating, but you will not stop encouraging your child to engage in the world even if that means her response is noisy - around the hours where she is normally asleep or out. Everyone has choices and if they don't want to live next door to noisy children THEN THEY CAN MOVE.

Nip it in the bud or they'll be in you for the next ten years.

I second this sort of approach, as the mother of a toddler who is slap bang into terrible twos. She is loud, she screams (and not in the cute adorable way that I am sure your 10 month old does), and frankly, there is little I can do about her occasional screaming paddies other than to try to distract her or ignore her until she calms down, as it is a normal part of development. Fortunately we have lovely neighbours, but yours sound as though this will not be the last time this comes up with the many child rearing years you have to come.

224RainandSunshine · 02/04/2025 22:28

I wouldn't confront them as they are clearly NUTS. All babies go through a shrieking phase, there's really nothing you can do.

They should thank their lucky they don't live next to me. My baby screamed his head off for the first 3 months of his life.

StartAnew · 02/04/2025 22:21

The person who wrote that note sounds at the end of their tether. I'd be knocking on doors until you find who wrote it and try to have a calm conversation about exactly what they are hearing, when and from which rooms. Maybe they are hearing someone else's noise or if not, maybe something quite simple can be done to make their life easier.

NewmummyJ · 02/04/2025 22:21

If they think it's bad now, wait until she's a toddler and starts having tantrums! A few baby squeals will pale in comparison!

Pricelessadvice · 02/04/2025 22:19

Would someone bother writing a note if it wasn’t really bad though? Seems an over reaction if your baby is only making the occasional noise like you say.

farmlife2 · 02/04/2025 22:16

How loud can a ten month old possibly be? It's a phase, she'll grow out of it.

StealthMama · 02/04/2025 22:14

Similar to others but slightly different sentiment.

Copy the letter and send it with a new letter to neighbours that states living in such close proximity and presence of neighbourly noise can be understandably frustrating, but you will not stop encouraging your child to engage in the world even if that means her response is noisy - around the hours where she is normally asleep or out. Everyone has choices and if they don't want to live next door to noisy children THEN THEY CAN MOVE.

Nip it in the bud or they'll be in you for the next ten years.

Idontknowhatnametochoose · 02/04/2025 22:11

StressedOutMama15 · 02/04/2025 21:58

Thank you for the advice! This does seem like a good way to tackle the problem without ending up arguing at a neighbours front door!

It also means you can show you're not intimidated by the letter and want to deal with it in a mature and direct way. Unlike them!

Anyone too scared to sign their name is unlikely to want to speak in person. Possible, but unlikely.

StressedOutMama15 · 02/04/2025 22:02

Sleepington · 02/04/2025 21:59

I'm guessing if they can hear you 'encouraging' the shrieks, then they can hear what you describe as playing with her. Unfortunately this is probably due to poor insulation/inferior building. Can you hear the neighbours as well? I'd be worried your neighbours would 'retaliate' by playing loud music when your baby is asleep so you can hear how noise travels.

I'd be annoyed that the note is anonymous more than anything.

My DC went through a phase of shrieking at around that age and grew out of it fairly quickly. Hopefully yours will too.

I can imagine that me playing with her is what they can hear. We live in little Victorian terraces where we often hear neighbours moving about, chopping food in the kitchen, laughing etc but we understand that this is just normal terraced living. Before having our DD they probably didn’t hear a sound from us as we live a quiet life, rarely having friends over so it’s probably a bit of a shock for them!

I’m pleased to hear your DC grew out of the shrieking quickly - fingers crossed!

OP posts:
Sleepington · 02/04/2025 21:59

I'm guessing if they can hear you 'encouraging' the shrieks, then they can hear what you describe as playing with her. Unfortunately this is probably due to poor insulation/inferior building. Can you hear the neighbours as well? I'd be worried your neighbours would 'retaliate' by playing loud music when your baby is asleep so you can hear how noise travels.

I'd be annoyed that the note is anonymous more than anything.

My DC went through a phase of shrieking at around that age and grew out of it fairly quickly. Hopefully yours will too.