Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Don’t know what to do🫨🤯

492 replies

Plummutum · 31/03/2025 23:58

Hi everyone, needs some advice,

so, basically, long story short - my DH’s spouse visa is about to expire in less than 48 hours and although we’d managed to save some money for his visa extension, there’s still a large chunk left for the IHS and we’ve exhausted every other avenue so I thought that the last option would be perhaps asking my mum. I really didn’t want to explore this option but we really don’t have a choice so I asked my mum (and they don’t have the most watertight son/mum-in-law relationship) but she reluctantly agreed on the basis that my husband asks her directly and formally agrees to pay her back for X amount of months. She wanted a formal arrangement because sometimes DH would forget to pay her back on the early days of our marriage. My husband is point blank refusing (he’s got a lot of pride) but I don’t think now’s the time to have pride as his visa depends on it. I really don’t want him to become an overstayer 😭 do you think he’s being unreasonable for refusing to speak to her directly? Or is my mum being unreasonable for wanting the request to come from him?

OP posts:
WhereYouLeftIt · 01/04/2025 18:49

"I think it’s so easy for people to judge and make comments without actually knowing the full story."
We know as much of the story as you told us. For the rest - you know that old saying 'you can't see the wood for the trees'? That's how these threads work. You, overwhelmed by the situation (tree) and loving your husband (more trees), can't see beyond your immediate surroundings. Us, looking on from afar, not in the situation and to who your husband is a total stranger, can see the woods - which is to say, the wider view beyond your immediate situation. And that wider view encompasses your husband's arrogance (you call it 'pride' because you're standing right next to it), and all the ramifications that this arrogance has brought to your door. And this distance allows us to see you tying yourself in knots to try and stop his arrogance destroying your and your children's future.

To continue the analogy - you're not our of the woods yet. He has borrowed money that will have to be repaid. You don't know what terms he has borrowed it on, when it must be repaid and whether interest will be charged.

A big conversation MUST be had. The two of you need to talk through how you got into this fix, and what steps you're going to take to get out of it (because you're not out of it yet, that visa extension has still to be applied for and granted). You need to learn to plan for the inevitable - he was always going to have to deal with this visa! He needs to learn not to bury his head in the sand and dump this on you.

And you do need to talk money together. You mentioned "we already have debt and really don’t want to enter into anything more" when asked about formal borrowing from a bank / credit union / credit card. Wherever he got the money for the immediate situation, he has just increased the debt you are in. You need to know to who and how much.

As an aside, you posted "Yes, he is spoilt and I’ve (kindly) pointed this out to him before 🙈". How does an orphan get to be spoilt? That tends to be the result of overindulgent parents, not no parents.

Bluenan · 01/04/2025 18:39

He’s an arsehole!

2025willbemytime · 01/04/2025 18:19

Plummutum · 01/04/2025 15:06

Well, I think misogynistic and chauvinistic is a bit harsh. Why do people like to throw these words around like it’s nothing these days ? For what it’s worth, one of the friends who helped him out is female.

It's worse they are female. Looking at how he's annoyed you didn't fill in the application. Furious his MIL didn't give him the money.

See the common theme?

autisticbookworm · 01/04/2025 17:53

He’s not coming across great. Your mum was doing him a favour and he’s acting like she owes him something.

MoreChocPls · 01/04/2025 17:16

Your dh is a piece of work. He’d would have rather risked getting kicked out then ask for help. He’d rather lose his family than utter a few words to your mum. Seems like it’s a shame he got the money in the end.

Isthiswhatmenthink · 01/04/2025 17:03

Plummutum · 01/04/2025 15:03

So, if he had not tried to raise the funds someone will say something negative, and if he raises the funds, questions point to where he raised it from and how he’s now owing friends? Damned if you do and damned if you don’t.

He landed on his feet when he met you, OP. 🤦🏻‍♀️

Zucker · 01/04/2025 16:54

At least he hasn't ripped your mother off. Thats something I guess 😐

BigBoysDontCry · 01/04/2025 16:29

well that was very stressful and whilst you can be glad that in the end he did sort it out (albeit temporarily until the next time he has a crisis he expects you to sort for him), that was unnecessary stress to put on you.

I suggest that you give yourself a bit of time to cool off and then maybe take another look through some of the comments and your replies and reappraise where you want to be in life.

It's okay that the partners in a relationship have different skill sets and rely on each other, this needs to be done from a place of joint enterprise and in full openness and honesty.

I'd be wondering at which point he made you aware that he was in difficulty? Was it always his responsibility to sort this from personal funds rather than family money? Was he doing more than his fair share of contributing to the household which left him short and he was trying to protect you? What are your future plans and what is he doing about learning to manage his finances better to support that? Is he frittering money away that should be for the family? Does he take equal responsibility in other areas of life? Do you feel loved, protected and supported?

Only you can answer these questions but speaking from the other end of a long marriage, don't stay with him simply because he can drive you places and help with the housework or for your children. Your children will be fine, it sounds like you have a loving and protective family who would support you (and do at the moment). You say your partner is an orphan, did he have a good example of what a loving marriage should look like?

I think some long conversations need to happen but not done at the moment in the anger of the situation.

Good luck OP.

Brightanddrywithsunnyspells · 01/04/2025 16:26

I feel for you. You sound nice if a little naive. You are in debt, renting with small kids and another sulky child for a husband. From what you say, it sounds like he sees you as his mum, solving all his problems for him. Now you have another problem because he left it too late to think about how to pay a rather important debt. He didn't like your solution because he has to change his sulky behaviour to 'be grateful and nice' mode. This time instead of putting another plaster on his knee you've ripped it off and put it on him to solve. Good. Except it's not. His solution has added to your problems by creating more debt with another lender. I'll bet this woman ends up regretting lending him money too.
Never a borrower or a lender be. That is a saying for a good reason.
Can you really continue to live like this? Hand to mouth. Him storming out and not listening to reason but with no decent solutions himself. Letting your kids witness in this immature 'toxic' relationship: being rude to you and your lovely, kind, generous mum and family by not speaking or smiling or being welcoming, hiding upstairs, not getting on top of the debts, leaving important issues to the last minute for you to sort. This will continue for the rest of your life. Can you really bear that? OP you are at a crossroads. What do you really want? Luckily you're a woman. You can make it happen.

Thisisittheapocalypse · 01/04/2025 16:17

Plummutum · 01/04/2025 00:19

yes this is what I’m desperately trying to avoid. But his superior level of stubbornness is irritating

Ask Mr Superiority if he needs your help packing his things for his deportation. Because that's where things are headed if he doesn't get over himself and ask politely for some help with the situation HE's created for himself.

Alternatively, ask yourself, OP, if you really want to spend the rest of your life with someone whose 'pride' comes before common sense and everyone else ... I imagine this isn't the only example selfish, entitled narcissistic behaviour being called 'pride' wrongfully.

FinallyHere · 01/04/2025 16:14

Plummutum · 01/04/2025 01:41

I’ve tried very hard to speak to him about this but he feels that my mum should be fine with me asking in his behalf etc, but I tried to get him to understand that it doesn’t work that way, if you need help from someone, it’s just courtesy to actually ask them directly.

so thats how he feels, is it?

please have a think about how you would see this if it were your daughter in love with this man and trying everything to enable him to and him letting her, even expecting her to sort everything out for him, with no effort on his part.

how would you feel in that situation?

NoBinturongsHereMate · 01/04/2025 16:14

after his storming out I actually felt relief as opposed to fear and a little part of me just felt a calmness

Wait a few days for the immediate visa stress to go down, then you need to have a really, really good think about this.

Howmanyflags · 01/04/2025 16:09

Actions speak louder than words- if he overstays his visa and has to leave, that sounds like game over for your marriage, or at least life as you know it now. Your mum is being absolutely reasonable and very generous to consider lending money if it has not been paid back in the past (he forget isn't an acceptable excuse). So if he won't ask for the money because he values his pride more than he values your current life, and stability for you, then I think that tells you everything you need to know... A person is the sum of all their parts- and a small bit of bad can override an aweful lot of good...

Catsandcannedbeans · 01/04/2025 15:58

Your mum is being pretty generous. If that was my mum, she absolutely would not be lending him the money… and if he refused to speak to her directly… she would probably report him the second that visa expired. Your husband needs to give his head a wobble.

Bigcat25 · 01/04/2025 15:57

OP, do you have enough income to cover the loan repayments? I wonder if your husband has the avoidant type of adhd?

thepariscrimefiles · 01/04/2025 15:49

Plummutum · 01/04/2025 15:18

Thank you, I agree, this situation was very stressful for us both. I think it’s so easy for people to judge and make comments without actually knowing the full story. I think a lot of comments are more about how horrible of a person DH is as opposed to how things can be resolved - I was reading that a fee waiver could have been a last resort as that would have brought him more time even if his visa expires whilst he waits for the outcome. But instead, the comments are about him being deported etc. of course I know what he’s like, he’s not an angel, I’m sure none of us are perfect too. And yes, I’m being defensive of him, why’s that a bad thing? What happened to actually fighting for marriages? Yes, I know he left things last minute etc, but it’s the overall outcome that counts.

Edited

But he left it to the last minute because of his own stubbornness and pigheadedness and risked losing his wife, his children and his job. That is why people are judging him. He isn't suddenly the hero because he managed to get some money from a friend at really short notice after causing you all this stress and worry.

He may have some very good qualities but in this situation his behaviour is pretty unforgiveable and certainly not the behaviour of a kind and loving husband and father.

Digdongdoo · 01/04/2025 15:46

Plummutum · 01/04/2025 15:18

Thank you, I agree, this situation was very stressful for us both. I think it’s so easy for people to judge and make comments without actually knowing the full story. I think a lot of comments are more about how horrible of a person DH is as opposed to how things can be resolved - I was reading that a fee waiver could have been a last resort as that would have brought him more time even if his visa expires whilst he waits for the outcome. But instead, the comments are about him being deported etc. of course I know what he’s like, he’s not an angel, I’m sure none of us are perfect too. And yes, I’m being defensive of him, why’s that a bad thing? What happened to actually fighting for marriages? Yes, I know he left things last minute etc, but it’s the overall outcome that counts.

Edited

It's easy for others to say he should have planned better. But if he's been here a while, on numerous visas, that's a significant chunk of money on top of other expenses.
Some people just jump on any opportunity to rag on a foreigner.

Discombobble · 01/04/2025 15:43

If the loan is real, is he going to expect you to help repay it?

BigTubOfLard · 01/04/2025 15:42

I'm sceptical that he's managed to borrow so much money from several friends at the last minute. Sorry OP, but have you seen the evidence i.e. has he shown you text messages from these friends saying they will transfer the money, or has he shown you his updated bank balance?

My thinking is that he's just panicked and invented a story about having successfully borrowed the money, thinking that he can deal with the problem later. But of course the problem won't actually go away if the money isn't real.

Discombobble · 01/04/2025 15:38

Plummutum · 01/04/2025 00:05

Well, I understand, but what am I supposed to do? Just abandon him and let his visa expire? It’s tough because I know he’s in the wrong

It’s his visa, he should be sorting it not you. If he won’t speak to your mum, he’s obviously not that motivated to get it sorted, which speaks to how he feels about you

SporadicMincePieMuncher · 01/04/2025 15:33

Plummutum · 01/04/2025 00:05

Well, I understand, but what am I supposed to do? Just abandon him and let his visa expire? It’s tough because I know he’s in the wrong

Why do you think your only two choices are to support him in letting his ego and stubbornness get in the way of something as important as his visa, or to abandon him?

A supportive spouse can only go so far. You've led the horse to water, you can't make him drink it.

Refusing to ask your mum directly and refusing to put something in writing - especially when he's proven that he's unreliable in the past are both big old red flags. Being willing to let his visa expire is a big old red flag too. His behaviour is telling you a lot about how he feels about you, your relationship and how much he wants to stay in the country. Pay attention to it. xxx

Hoppinggreen · 01/04/2025 15:32

Ponderingwindow · 01/04/2025 14:41

So the best case scenario here is that he has been hiding money from you?

even if he stays, please do think about this relationship long term.

And worst case scenario he has borrowed money from somewhere with a crazy interest rate and/or from people who won't take kindly if he defaults on payments

MissDoubleU · 01/04/2025 15:31

Well, if he is reported for being an overstayer and faces whatever consequences come from that… at least his pride will be fully in tact.

Let him make his own choice, stop stressing, you have laid a path to avoid serious repercussions and he doesn’t want to take it. Thats his problem. If he can’t ask directly and be grateful for a loan to save his ass the he doesn’t bloody deserve it.

mummymeister · 01/04/2025 15:29

Plummutum · 01/04/2025 15:23

I’m not happy about it but the situation is urgent

why is it urgent when you have known this day is coming for years? How has it come to this? are you both low earners and unable to save? its £500 a year thats needed isnt it or £43 a month - less than a tenner a week so hardly a massive sum unless you are both on low wages I guess. you need to find out asap what his plan is to pay this person back. please dont just assume he has this in hand because clearly he wont have.

Plummutum · 01/04/2025 15:23

mummymeister · 01/04/2025 15:21

@Plummutum how do you feel about him now owing a friend several thousand pounds? what is his plan to pay this back? this money treats the symptom not the disease though doesnt it. the question is how and why did you get to this place with 48hrs to go. No one is saying he is the devil. but my concern now would be how he is going to pay back this very kind friend who has bailed him out. are you happy for people outside of the family knowing this much information about your finances and about his lack of financial planning?

I’m not happy about it but the situation is urgent

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread