Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that people pretend not to understand obesity

387 replies

Mezzoprezzo · 30/03/2025 08:49

After 30 plus years of failed diets I've recently started on mounjaro. Because I've placed an order and spent weeks searching stuff about weight loss medication, my Facebook feed is full of adverts from suppliers, many of which use vlogs from real clients who have lost weight. And the vast majority of comments are along the lines of, couldn't you just eat less, haven't you heard of exercise, why not just stop eating crap etc. Surely people are faking ignorance to have the fun of fat bashing. Obesity is rife! Everyone knows someone who struggles with their weight and who talks openly about it. I and every other obese person I know have tried every diet under the sun. Walk into any gym and you'll see a fair number of larger people trying bloody hard. And I know someone's going to reply to this post by talking about an obese friend who they once saw eating an entire packet of biscuits. Well numerous times I've given in to the overwhelming urge to do that too. And hated myself afterwards. It's part of the horrible condition. People have got eyes and ears and they seriously know full bloody well how hard obese people try to lose weight. They just pretend not to so they can have the fun of hating.

OP posts:
Winifredtabago · 30/03/2025 21:17

MsRumpole · 30/03/2025 21:16

No, lovie, I literally cut and pasted what it says and it does not say anything like what you've been saying about cravings or willpower.

Ok cut and paste all the wording

Winifredtabago · 30/03/2025 21:16

KnewYearKnewMe · 30/03/2025 21:14

@MsRumpoleit was worth a try.

but you know, some people are just in denial 😜😜😂😂

Your being childish.

MsRumpole · 30/03/2025 21:16

Winifredtabago · 30/03/2025 21:13

As evidenced by the fact you are ignoring the bulk of what that particular website says to just pick out the little bits that suit your narrative.

No, lovie, I literally cut and pasted what it says and it does not say anything like what you've been saying about cravings or willpower.

KnewYearKnewMe · 30/03/2025 21:14

@MsRumpoleit was worth a try.

but you know, some people are just in denial 😜😜😂😂

MsRumpole · 30/03/2025 21:13

5128gap · 30/03/2025 21:11

What's 'nightmarish' about it? Anyone who was a size 10/12 in the 80s/90s knows they now need to buy a size 8 or 6 if their size hasn't changed. It's hardly a difficult thing to understand and remember, is it? And if its too 'hit and miss' just compare your measurements to those in the size guides.

@5128gap I am horrified that you are refusing to engage with the unrelenting horror of having to adjust to buying 8/10 jeans instead of 10/12.

Do you not understand that this means that people who were a size 12/14 are now blatantly getting away with being a lower number?!

Winifredtabago · 30/03/2025 21:13

MsRumpole · 30/03/2025 21:10

I know, I just had this crazy hope that @Winifredtabago was able to read sentences on the NHS website like "the causes of obesity are complex" or "the environment plays a role" or "genes play a role" but I think they're literally just pretending that it says stuff it doesn't say ☺️

As evidenced by the fact you are ignoring the bulk of what that particular website says to just pick out the little bits that suit your narrative.

arcticpandas · 30/03/2025 21:13

ClawsandEffect · 30/03/2025 17:24

It isn't all about moderation though. I had to get down to below 700 calories a day to lose weight while in menopause which isn't sustainable long term. And even then, once I'd been doing that for a while, I was eventually unable to lose any weight. I did that for a year and a half with GP monitoring.

That isn't moderation. It's starvation.

Then you maybe didn't have to lose weight?

Winifredtabago · 30/03/2025 21:12

MsRumpole · 30/03/2025 21:10

I know, I just had this crazy hope that @Winifredtabago was able to read sentences on the NHS website like "the causes of obesity are complex" or "the environment plays a role" or "genes play a role" but I think they're literally just pretending that it says stuff it doesn't say ☺️

You are both just in denial. It's that simple. That's a big part of the problem.

5128gap · 30/03/2025 21:11

TheHateIsNotGood · 30/03/2025 18:59

This normalisation of being 'bigger' has also made buying clothes a nightmare now. I'd always be safe with a pair of 10 or 12 jeans, now I'm swamped in a size 12 and it's hit or miss with a size 10; not helped by me not liking skinny-fit because I prefer not to wear suction clothes filled with lycra.

10-12 were fine up to the end of the 90s and I can assure you I haven't lost weight or size since then.

What's 'nightmarish' about it? Anyone who was a size 10/12 in the 80s/90s knows they now need to buy a size 8 or 6 if their size hasn't changed. It's hardly a difficult thing to understand and remember, is it? And if its too 'hit and miss' just compare your measurements to those in the size guides.

MsRumpole · 30/03/2025 21:10

KnewYearKnewMe · 30/03/2025 21:06

@MsRumpole

i believe @Winifredtabagohas spent a large proportion of today pretending to be interested in the complex reasons behind obesity to goad and regurgitate the ‘fat people are fat because on the whole, they are weak willed and lazy’ trope. Bless him/her!

I’m no longer engaging with him/her.

lots of other good convos on this thread xx

I know, I just had this crazy hope that @Winifredtabago was able to read sentences on the NHS website like "the causes of obesity are complex" or "the environment plays a role" or "genes play a role" but I think they're literally just pretending that it says stuff it doesn't say ☺️

arcticpandas · 30/03/2025 21:09

ApolloandDaphne · 30/03/2025 09:28

I have a friend who is an endocrinologist. We have talked a great deal about obesity as we both struggle with weight gain/losing weight. She told me that research suggests that obesity is an endocrinological disorder in that same way that diabetes is. Some people are just predisposed to gain weight and have issues losing it. Medication like Mounjaro etc is now available to combat this issue.

But the only thing the medication help with is to not feel hungry so you eat less and you lose weight. So it's not like diabetes at all, obesity can be "cured" by eating less. It's just an appetite problem (and ofcourse the psychological/emotional problems that make you overeat) so when the appetite is controlled thanks to medication you lose weight.

KnewYearKnewMe · 30/03/2025 21:06

@MsRumpole

i believe @Winifredtabagohas spent a large proportion of today pretending to be interested in the complex reasons behind obesity to goad and regurgitate the ‘fat people are fat because on the whole, they are weak willed and lazy’ trope. Bless him/her!

I’m no longer engaging with him/her.

lots of other good convos on this thread xx

Youbutterbelieve · 30/03/2025 21:03

TheHateIsNotGood · 30/03/2025 18:40

Re: genetics - I have the same genetics as my siblings - they actually do choose to overeat (as well as smoke and drink, though not to excess) they also are a bit lazy and always happy for someone else to carry the 'load'. One actually admits to eating loads and proud of it, the other just thinks a smile and makeup will get her through. I smoke to excess.

We're in our 60s and probably all dysfunctional yet functioning adults. Funnily enough my siblings are far more judgemental than me.

But if there was a shot like MJ to cure my smoking addiction then I'd be first in line. But that ain't gonna happen as smoking addicts like me add far more to the public purse in taxation than the obese food addicts do.

There's currently studies on the use of glp1 meds on other addictions, they look promising

Middleagedstriker · 30/03/2025 21:01

TheHateIsNotGood · 30/03/2025 18:59

This normalisation of being 'bigger' has also made buying clothes a nightmare now. I'd always be safe with a pair of 10 or 12 jeans, now I'm swamped in a size 12 and it's hit or miss with a size 10; not helped by me not liking skinny-fit because I prefer not to wear suction clothes filled with lycra.

10-12 were fine up to the end of the 90s and I can assure you I haven't lost weight or size since then.

It sounds really traumatic. I hope you can cope with buying jeans with a different number on them.

Winifredtabago · 30/03/2025 20:51

MsRumpole · 30/03/2025 20:45

Please point me to the bit where it says that obesity is caused by a lack of willingness to resist cravings? Because that's what you've been saying.

Edited

The bits where it talks about eating too much etc. If you dont resist your cravings you will eat too much. Or eat too much of the wrong foods.

SummerDaysOnTheWay · 30/03/2025 20:48

I’m 3stone overweight op
i go to the gym
i eat fish, eggs, and vegetables
i have a couple of glasses of wine at the weekend

i dont eat crap
my skinny friends drink way more than me
i am 49 and really trying here… its just not budging.

people are fuckwits Ignore them!

MsRumpole · 30/03/2025 20:45

Winifredtabago · 30/03/2025 20:36

Right so we are in agreement then. I've never said that for every obese person its simply the most common things like eating too much, being inactive. Some people do have medical reasons for it.

Please point me to the bit where it says that obesity is caused by a lack of willingness to resist cravings? Because that's what you've been saying.

Winifredtabago · 30/03/2025 20:36

MsRumpole · 30/03/2025 20:21

I have and what it says about the causes of obesity is exactly what I said to you.

"Obesity is a complex issue with many causes. Obesity and overweight is caused when extra calories, particularly those from foods high in fat and sugar, are stored in the body as fat.
Obesity is an increasingly common problem because the environment we live in makes it difficult for many people to eat healthily and do enough physical activity.
Genetics can also be a cause of obesity for some people. Your genes can affect how your body uses food and stores fat.
There are also some underlying health conditions that can occasionally contribute to weight gain, such as an underactive thyroid gland (hypothyroidism), although these types of conditions do not usually cause weight problems if they're effectively controlled with medicines.
Some medicines can also make people more likely to put on weight, including steroids and some medicines for high blood pressure, diabetes or mental health conditions."

I was right about it being a waste of my time to engage with you.

Right so we are in agreement then. I've never said that for every obese person its simply the most common things like eating too much, being inactive. Some people do have medical reasons for it.

MsRumpole · 30/03/2025 20:21

Winifredtabago · 30/03/2025 19:37

Why dont you try looking at the NHS website

I have and what it says about the causes of obesity is exactly what I said to you.

"Obesity is a complex issue with many causes. Obesity and overweight is caused when extra calories, particularly those from foods high in fat and sugar, are stored in the body as fat.
Obesity is an increasingly common problem because the environment we live in makes it difficult for many people to eat healthily and do enough physical activity.
Genetics can also be a cause of obesity for some people. Your genes can affect how your body uses food and stores fat.
There are also some underlying health conditions that can occasionally contribute to weight gain, such as an underactive thyroid gland (hypothyroidism), although these types of conditions do not usually cause weight problems if they're effectively controlled with medicines.
Some medicines can also make people more likely to put on weight, including steroids and some medicines for high blood pressure, diabetes or mental health conditions."

I was right about it being a waste of my time to engage with you.

nhs.uk

Underactive thyroid (hypothyroidism)

Read about an underactive thyroid gland (hypothyroidism), which is when your thyroid gland does not produce enough hormones.

https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/underactive-thyroid-hypothyroidism/

Mylegishangingoff · 30/03/2025 20:17

I have mixed feelings on this tbh. I had no idea about the sheer quantities of food some people eat until I saw 'what I eat in a day' videos on tiktok. Baked potatoes with a slab of butter as big as the spud, huge portion sizes, eating out and take aways multiple times a week, just massive quantities of food really with large amounts of 'extras' like piles of cheese and butter. Lots of people seem to just eat whatever they fancy with no thought of their health.

Personally I believe most people if the ate less and moved more(the average number of steps people take in a day is ridiculously low) then they would see change. Yeah you will be hungry for the first few weeks if you are used to eating lots but your body will get used to it. Yeah you will think about food a lot, so do lots of people. You won't die from feeling hungry or thinking about food.

If people want to use weight loss drugs then more power to them though. I don't care, it's your money and your body.

DeepRoseFish · 30/03/2025 20:13

You’ve only got to walk down supermarket aisles to realise that they are stacked full of food that is not good for us.

Crap food is literally everywhere and trying to avoid it is extremely difficult. It’s cheap easy and addictive!

Whataninterestinglookingpotato · 30/03/2025 20:04

rosemarble · 30/03/2025 11:44

I think what some obese people don’t realise is that it takes the vast majority of people a lot of will power to stay slim

On what do you base "it takes the vast majority of people a lot of will power to stay slim"?

very few people over 30 can eat what they like, do no exercise and stay slim.

But keeping an eye on what you eat (I don't mean restricting or being obsessed, just putting good food into your body) and exercising shouldn't take mighty will power, these things should be the norm.

And what do you mean by 'eat what they like'? Over eating, or just eating what they fancy? I think there are plenty of people who follow their hunger (ie eat what they like), do little exercise and stay slim. They might not be particularly healthy, but their weight isn't a problem.

I base it on personal experience and the experience of the majority of people that I know.

if I ate whatever liked whenever I liked I would gain weight. So would most people.

it’s not about obsessing it’s about knowing that you cannot eat an entire packet of biscuits, even if you’d like to and having the will power not to do it. Most slim people are conscious of what they are putting into their bodies. They have to be or they would also be overweight. It’s very very easy to gain weight in our society.

when I was eating what I liked whenever (not excessive amounts) and just being generally active rather than doing a lot of exercise. I became over weight. I’ve lost weight but it’s taken a lot of effort and thought, along with an entire change of lifestyle to keep it off. It’s an effort, but it’s worth it.

MajorCarolDanvers · 30/03/2025 19:54

TheHateIsNotGood · 30/03/2025 18:40

Re: genetics - I have the same genetics as my siblings - they actually do choose to overeat (as well as smoke and drink, though not to excess) they also are a bit lazy and always happy for someone else to carry the 'load'. One actually admits to eating loads and proud of it, the other just thinks a smile and makeup will get her through. I smoke to excess.

We're in our 60s and probably all dysfunctional yet functioning adults. Funnily enough my siblings are far more judgemental than me.

But if there was a shot like MJ to cure my smoking addiction then I'd be first in line. But that ain't gonna happen as smoking addicts like me add far more to the public purse in taxation than the obese food addicts do.

I quit smoking taking champix tablets. They are the ‘shot’ to quit smoking.

it was genuinely easy and no withdrawal symptoms.

after years of trying to quit it took me a few days since snd seven years later ve never wanted another cigarette

prescribed by my GP

Bababear987 · 30/03/2025 19:38

I think what I struggle understanding is why people just dont buy the food- like realise you have a problem and just make a decision to change and stick to it.

I have been overweight most of my life and have moved from a size 20 to a 10 and am now at a more sustainable 14. So I can sympathise and I know that when I was bigger I was generally using food to fill a void. I did have an epiphany after a friend made a comment about her husband complaining about being fat constantly but eating huge portions and making bad choices with food, she said she has no sympathy for him and he needs to grow up and take control and at first I found it really harsh but actually she was right, I realised I needed to stop making excuses and start being responsible. I wanted a child and realised I needed to be better for them. I am still not at a weight I want to be at but I'm more realistic about what I eat and what I can eat before putting on weight, I don't kid myself other people eat as much crap as I do, I dont kid myself it's all genetics cause it's irrelevant frankly- it's not about anyone else or any excuse, i was fat cause i had poor self confidence, depression and ate too much.

Winifredtabago · 30/03/2025 19:37

MsRumpole · 30/03/2025 19:34

What leads to obesity in the immediate sense is a calorie surplus. What leads different people to accumulate (or not accumulate) a calorie surplus in the first place is driven by genes, environment and biology. Try this as a starting point. I don't know what you think your "gotcha" is here.

Why dont you try looking at the NHS website