Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL taking over Mother’s Day

193 replies

Pinkhat123 · 25/03/2025 19:07

This Is my first year as a mom of 3 and I was quite looking forward to spending some time with my DH and DC on Mother’s Day and do something special together like go for a meal, go for a nature walk etc (nothing OTT). I was also looking forward to my first lie in (realistically til 8am/9am) and a cup of tea in bed which I was promised.

However my DH just updated me that he is going to invite his mum and step dad for lunch out on Mother’s Day. Whilst I usually have no issue with this I can’t help but feel sad that “my” day is going to be completely over shadowed by the MIL and she it will be all about grandmothers! Therefore I won’t get a simple lie in (which I so desperately need) or a cup of tea as the MIL will arrive at 9/10am after a 3hr journey. She will make it all
about her own while I’m running around feeding them
and entertaining them etc. I feel she already had her time with her DC, this is my time now.

I’ll add last year she made a complete drama that she didn’t receive any gifts on Mother’s Day from her grandchildren or DC…. At 1pm the delivery man arrived with a bunch of flowers we had already planned for her.

And another note, my eldest had surgery today. (MIL is never is part of any childcare plan, she comes to our house whenever it suits her like every 2-3 months.) And on the phone MIL wants to come now, i blurted out “no thanks I need to keep DS infection free and away from people”. She looked at me in such an evil way like he’s her child she will do what she wants.

Before people ask- yes I know I can just ask my DH to cancel or not invite her but this will cause a load of agro and im just seeking an opinion as to whether I should stick to my guns-
its Mother’s Day not grandmothers day! DH thinks I’m being unreasonable.

AIBU- to be craving just a little me time and time alone with my own 3 children for the first time.

YABU- you should suck it up and it’s a day for her too.

OP posts:
Hufdl · 26/03/2025 09:32

Your husband sounds like a lazy useless man that is afraid of his mother.
Weak and so unattractive.

Saw no and mean it.
Go and spend time with your mother.
Put your foot down.

Orders76 · 26/03/2025 09:21

Situations and people like this rely on you not saying a word.
Speak up with your husband, change the lunch booking to somewhere half way between and meet there at the right time.
There's space for compromise here.

StMarie4me · 26/03/2025 08:50

Pinkhat123 · 25/03/2025 19:16

I haven’t really said anything yet. He has booked the restaurant and said we can adjust the numbers if needed. But he’s implying more that his MIL will come especially as she wants to see my DD after surgery this week. It feels like it’s all about her needs, I’m just pushed aside.

But you haven’t told him that you don’t want this. So he doesn’t know.
Talk to him.

Icanthinkformyselfthanks · 26/03/2025 08:33

saraclara · 26/03/2025 00:05

No.

I don't demand that mother's day is about me. But my DDs are kind enough to find time for me on MD as well as the one who's also a mother, having her special time.

So far it's worked (led by them, not me) that my DD is celebrated by her husband and kids in the morning, and then at some point later on the day, I get a visit and cards etc from both DDs and the grandkids.

Distance permitting, there's space for all the family mothers to have some special time.

Edited

@saraclara , you would think so wouldn’t you but it seems that there are some young women who absolutely cannot tolerate sharing even a beam of the spotlight. Aren’t we lucky to have decent DILs who love our sons enough to not create issues where none need exist?
Have a lovely Mother’s Day with your family.

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 26/03/2025 08:26

Or he can take you all out.

Icanthinkformyselfthanks · 26/03/2025 08:25

PyongyangKipperbang · 25/03/2025 23:41

That is very patronising and as the mother of adult children, I disagree. Women becoming mothers does not make us a gestalt entity!

DIL are not in charge of mothers day, and if they do take over and only see their own family then its on the sons for not pushing back, not on the DIL.

I cant help wondering if the way you are on here communicates to your sons "Well we have to see my mum on the same, otherwise you know what she will be like......" which of course you will deny but worth thinking about.

@PyongyangKipperbang , actually the arrangement we have is that my sons alternate between being with their MILs and me on the actual day but if they’re not with me on Mothering Sunday we get together to celebrate as close to the time as possible. My DILs mothers are also important.

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 26/03/2025 08:25

shellyleppard · 25/03/2025 19:09

I would let your other half do all the running around/cooking/ making endless cuppas
It's your day, not spoilt mother in laws.

This. Stay in bed. Relax. He can cook or order in. Mother’s Day isn’t a day for you to work hard to treat his mother, whilst he relaxes and entertains her.

doodahdayy · 26/03/2025 08:22

She had her time with young children. Does she have any other adult children she can impose upon? I think Mother’s Day is a bit of a fuss about nothing though. You should get breaks/a lie in other days of the year rather than make a ceremony out of one day

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 26/03/2025 08:12

Safxxx · 25/03/2025 19:45

Tell your husband to let you have your day on Saturday, breakfast in bed, flowers and a lie in....do something together outside and have a lazy evening with a movie at home with a take away. That way you will feel pampered and can deal with the next day...mother's day doesn't have to be celebrated on the day...it's ok to adjust as needed.

This is much too sensible for anyone to agree! ( though I do) .

If DH is actually a nice enough bloke( not the automatic MN villain) he will welcome the opportunity to please / placate his mother - and he will love you for it.

BeTaupeBear · 26/03/2025 08:10

Mother’s Day can be difficult when people have set expectations. My MIL wanted a full day out with DH and DS not sure she’d be bothered if I was there 😂
What we’ve offered is a walk in the morning to a lovely area with a play area for DS. Then home for DS nap and to my DM in the afternoon.
I think you need to make it work for you… you’ll meet at the restaurant not at 9am that’s crazy! And carry on with your walk afterwards and make it clear it’s for DH to host his mum.
Also Mother’s Day shouldn’t be the only day you get a lie in … I get one every weekend

ChubbyMorticia · 26/03/2025 08:03

My take on it is that it’s about priorities.

OP wants her husband to prioritize her WITHOUT having to ask. Which really isn’t unreasonable. As his wife, she ought to be his priority.

I find it interesting that it’s been suggested that OP celebrate a week later. Why couldn’t MIL wait a week instead? After all, plans had already been made for OP. I don’t see why she’s the one who has to change.

cardboardvillage · 26/03/2025 06:58

Be firm. Say they’re not to arrive before 11am

if you are going out for lunch, that’s alright isnt it? You not being asked to cook

DappledThings · 26/03/2025 06:48

Dearover · 26/03/2025 06:35

I do wonder if there is a relationship between the perceived importance of Mother's Day and family dynamics on the other 364 days of the year.

Also, thanks to SM, Mother's Day has become an opportunity to tell the world how much your partner (not children) value you. Their own parents seem to get in the way of that, turning everything into a competition.

I'm sure there is. I get treated well, with kindness and appreciation and full splitting of the work of parenting all year round. As such MD is a nice little thing where DC will want to make me breakfast in bed and make cards at school and that's all I need or want. I will be getting a lie-in but I get a lie-in every weekend.

We are going out for lunch this year with MIL as well. I have no desire to ring fence the day for myself because there's no history of shit behaviour DH has to make up for.

LivingLaVidaBabyShower · 26/03/2025 06:48

MissScarletInTheBallroom · 25/03/2025 19:11

I mean, a better option would be to say no to the whole thing, but if PIL do come, yes, OP should not lift a finger. Go out for a massage in the morning and float back in just as lunch is being served.

I mean this is what I’d do

enjoy your lie in get up and say hi as they arrive / you walk out the door and come back for lunch and then do for your planned nature walk with kids

ThankULord · 26/03/2025 06:46

Pinkhat123 · 25/03/2025 19:17

DH cooking would be the first… all he can cook is dippy eggs! ( and I hate eggs!!)

He can order in breakfast.

Dearover · 26/03/2025 06:35

I do wonder if there is a relationship between the perceived importance of Mother's Day and family dynamics on the other 364 days of the year.

Also, thanks to SM, Mother's Day has become an opportunity to tell the world how much your partner (not children) value you. Their own parents seem to get in the way of that, turning everything into a competition.

pelargoniums · 26/03/2025 06:09

MissScarletInTheBallroom · 25/03/2025 22:46

I think that part of the reason this is a big deal to the OP is that her husband is so useless generally that just having one day in the year where she can get a lie in and a cup of tea in bed is really important.

I don't care all that much about Mother's Day. If my husband remembers, which he might not, he'll buy a small bunch of flowers and get DS to give them to me.

But because he pulls his weight at home and shows me that he appreciates me all year round, I don't attach so much important to one day.

Perhaps the answer here is for the OP's husband to learn to cook basic meals, bring her a cup of tea every morning and let her have a lie in every weekend. And then Mother's Day wouldn't be such a big deal.

Completely this. I get a lie-in every weekend and a sacrosanct, protected and guarded by DP “leave me alone in silence, I’m having a cup of tea” moment frequently. He pulls his weight and I know from the frequent whispering and giggling with DD5 that Mother’s Day plans are afoot too.

In the same circumstances, if his mum visited at 9/10am, I’d still get my lie-in and tea, he’d wrangle the DC and host her while I got ready, and he can cook more than dippy eggs (though I am fond of a dippy egg).

In classic MN wisdom, it’s not a MIL problem but a DH one.

MissScarletInTheBallroom · 26/03/2025 06:05

nomas · 26/03/2025 02:55

Yes, he did initiate the plan and he needs to be the one to get out of it. But OP has also described some awful behaviour by the MIL as well.

And OP says ‘She will make it all about her own while I’m running around feeding them and entertaining them etc’. So there are expectations for more food. Could be at 9am when MIL arrives or after lunch.

Surely anyone with even basic social skills knows that you don't turn up at 9am when you've been invited for lunch.

nomas · 26/03/2025 02:55

saraclara · 25/03/2025 23:14

However my DH just updated me that he is going to invite his mum and step dad for lunch out on Mother’s Day

It was OP 's HUSBAND who initiated this plan. Not his mother. And he's arranged lunch out, so it's not OP who has to feed and water his parents.

Edited

Yes, he did initiate the plan and he needs to be the one to get out of it. But OP has also described some awful behaviour by the MIL as well.

And OP says ‘She will make it all about her own while I’m running around feeding them and entertaining them etc’. So there are expectations for more food. Could be at 9am when MIL arrives or after lunch.

BigHeadBertha · 26/03/2025 00:54

I do not think you're being unreasonable, first of all.

I see at least two separate issues here, though. First and most worrisome is that IMO the two of you should always be making plans together and agreeing on them before allowing anyone else to be brought into it. Instead, if I understood correctly, your husband promised you one thing, then changed the plans to include and focus on his mother instead, without your agreement. There was also the issue about the ill child that you apparently weren't consulted about by him first. That's a big problem. Or it would be to me. It should be the two of you always at the center, not him making unilateral decisions or opening the door to include his mother in those discussions.

He is also setting you and his mother up as opponents for his affection. (And careful there. I really think some spouses at some level like being fought over, even though it does cause them so much strife and chaos at the same time).

As far as the second issue, who gets to be special on Mother's Day. Well, first, there's nothing particularly sacred about that calendar date. And as you say, you weren't even planning to celebrate on that date anyway. Regardless, there is plenty of room for both you and his mother to have your special time and no need to compete for it. You don't have to divide up the day, either. One weekend day is hers and the other is yours or whatever.

I would first insist that he agree that from now on, the two of you discuss things and come to a mutually agreeable solution, before his mother or anyone else is included, as a firm standing rule of your marriage. And he also needs to stick by that agreement, not go changing it later, whether on his or with his mother involved. If he refuses, then marriage counseling pronto because that is just not going to work. Fortunately, you don't seem willing to just put your head down and submit to such poor treatment.

Then, as far as Mother's Day, it sounds like his mother is competing with you, instead of acting like the older and wiser person and saying, "You kids have your special day. I'll see you next weekend." And her demanding gifts, ugh. Many of us older people don't like our grown kids to spend their money on us. She doesn't sound particularly evolved. It's unfortunate that she's not more mature and/or doesn't remember what it was like to be a young mother. I think she should be supporting your family as a family elder, not competing and making demands.

But one great way to take the air out of her sails on that game imo is to just not compete back with her. That is not the same as you giving in and her "winning" the competition. It means you graciously insist that she have her Mother's Day celebration on Saturday and then your Mother's Day with your husband and kids is the next Saturday, or whatever. At the root of the competition is the fear of being forgotten or replaced.

When someone is in that tug-of-war mode, generously giving her what she wants might make her stop feeling like the two of you are fighting over your husband/her son's affection. And then, possibly, she'll relax and she'll stop. After all, there's no reason to jealously, defensively, fight to get something that is freely given.

Also, divide up that labor! It's not automatically your job to do everything when you have company. What he doesn't know how to do, he can learn the same as the rest of us had to do. Don't let him get away with acting helpless. He is not a child. Or he can find a way around doing the work himself, like getting takeout food and/or hiring a housecleaner. What would he do if he was single?

If this is a recurring problem, I highly recommend marriage counseling. A few sessions could probably straighten it out. Good luck.

saraclara · 26/03/2025 00:14

LePetitMaman · 26/03/2025 00:06

Well duh?

That's a totally different situation to what OP is talking about.

I know. I'm addressing the side issue that's been brought up in this thread.

The point in the OP is that the OP 's husband has given her no thought at all and arranged something for his mum without discussing it with his wife first. And early in the thread I responded to that, saying that he was well out of order.

The conversation has, however, moved on. As threads do.

ETA and yes, this: The MIL probably has no clue she's done anything wrong and is just going along with what her son suggested.

Sugarnspicenallthingsnaice · 26/03/2025 00:09

MissScarletInTheBallroom · 25/03/2025 22:15

Yes, OK.

So the point of this post is, the OP (who has three young children including a baby and is therefore deep in the trenches of motherhood at the moment) was looking forward to what sounds like the absolute bare minimum of special treatment on Mother's Day, and her husband has unilaterally decided that what she would actually like to do on Mother's Day is host his mother for him. (Including doing all the hard work, because he's strategically incompetent and "can only cook dippy eggs", apparently.)

When does she get to be worthy of respect and admiration for all she does for their family? When does she get to be celebrated?

She says in her post that she doesn't even think she'll get her lie in and cup of tea because her mother in law won't be happy with arriving for lunch at actual lunchtime, preferring to set off at 6am so she can monopolise their entire day rather than just the best part of it.

You're right but the problem is the sheer number of posters (including OP herself, I think) who turned this into a 'me vs MIL' thing.

It's actually her DH's responsibility to give it some thought and make sure his mother and the mother of his children (and HER mother) all have a nice day. But he's been lazy and OP hasn't even bothered to say anything, and the deeper resentments about the state of their relationship spilled out and suddenly two women are pitted against each other.

The MIL probably has no clue she's done anything wrong and is just going along with what her son suggested.

LePetitMaman · 26/03/2025 00:06

saraclara · 26/03/2025 00:05

No.

I don't demand that mother's day is about me. But my DDs are kind enough to find time for me on MD as well as the one who's also a mother, having her special time.

So far it's worked (led by them, not me) that my DD is celebrated by her husband and kids in the morning, and then at some point later on the day, I get a visit and cards etc from both DDs and the grandkids.

Distance permitting, there's space for all the family mothers to have some special time.

Edited

Well duh?

That's a totally different situation to what OP is talking about.

saraclara · 26/03/2025 00:05

LePetitMaman · 25/03/2025 23:57

You're really missing the point.

It's about saying,

  1. I have no kids yet, so I will celebrate my mother on mother's day.

  2. Now I have children, so I am a mother too. I deserve to be celebrated and I am now treated.

  3. Now my child has children, so she is a mother too. However, this doesn't matter, I'm still their mother, so mother's day continues to be about me being treated.

No.

I don't demand that mother's day is about me. But my DDs are kind enough to find time for me on MD as well as the one who's also a mother, having her special time.

So far it's worked (led by them, not me) that my DD is celebrated by her husband and kids in the morning, and then at some point later on the day, I get a visit and cards etc from both DDs and the grandkids.

Distance permitting, there's space for all the family mothers to have some special time.

Squarestones · 25/03/2025 23:59

MissScarletInTheBallroom · 25/03/2025 22:46

I think that part of the reason this is a big deal to the OP is that her husband is so useless generally that just having one day in the year where she can get a lie in and a cup of tea in bed is really important.

I don't care all that much about Mother's Day. If my husband remembers, which he might not, he'll buy a small bunch of flowers and get DS to give them to me.

But because he pulls his weight at home and shows me that he appreciates me all year round, I don't attach so much important to one day.

Perhaps the answer here is for the OP's husband to learn to cook basic meals, bring her a cup of tea every morning and let her have a lie in every weekend. And then Mother's Day wouldn't be such a big deal.

Agree with this as well! I see it as a nice excuse for.some special food or a bunch of flowers, or to force them to watch a film/play a game of my choosing. Love a card from kids, all that stuff. But in no way feel I have to make the whole day about only me, possibly because I feel appreciated and supported all the year.