Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to keep trying with the new kittens

110 replies

2222thatsme · 24/03/2025 14:10

We took home 3x 7 month old kittens a month ago from a rescue. We previously had an mature adult cat. We didn't do enough research and totally underestimated the impact of 3x kittens.

I keep having mental wobbles and thinking, "I can't do this." Each time I fall into a bit of depression but eventually come out of it, find a solution to whatever the new challenge is and tell myself, "nope, cats are a commitment".

My husband is doing and saying the same out loud. We're both prone to depression, but his is medicated. However, over the weekend, my husband broke down to his mum about finding it all really hard and not being able to cope. He then admitted to me that he now dreads coming home after work.

The things we're finding hard are:

  1. One of the kittens has also had illness during this time, which required trips to a vet far away, which has been an added stress. He's now on the mend.

  2. The kittens have destroyed a lot of parts of the house. Not from boredom scratching (they have so many toys including puzzle ones, scratching posts, I try to do interactive play with them when I can). The damage occurs just from them playing together. It's sweet to watch, they're bonded littermates, but through simply playing chase and pounce with each other, they've destroyed furniture and curtains. I started to price up buying replacements for the damaged stuff over the weekend, got beyond £1K, then stopped and just cried.

To minimise the destruction we have removed all curtains, rugs, an armchair (replaced it with a massive cat tree), and removed all ornaments.

Yesterday evening, my husband sat down next to me in the living room and said, "the room is cold and echoe-y. I don't like the lack of privacy. I'm going to my office." Five minutes later, he then left the office as it's so overcrowded with our ornaments (it's the only cat free room we can reasonably have, as our kids forget to shut the other doors). He says our house doesn't feel like our house anymore, it feels like a cattery with people inserted into it.

I asked an online cat forum and they recommended Jackson Galaxy. I watched his videos this morning and he said each cat just need 30-45 minutes strenuous play a day. Individual play needed as some cats dominate the play and prevent others getting attention. So for three cats that's 2 hours and 15 minutes play a day. I've managed 15 minutes and then ten minutes play with all three cats so far today, not done separate play yet. They mostly wanted to play chase and pounce with each other.

  1. The rest of my life has gone out of the window. I was told at the beginning of the year that I needed to lose weight as my heart health is bad (my dad died young of heart disease so it's a big worry for me). I started a strict diet and exercise routine and lost some weight. This all stopped with the cats, the weight is back on and I'm now stress eating again, although trying not to.

  2. Our kids (7 and 9), who are both diagnosed ND or likely ND, recently told me that I never pay attention to the anymore. I've tried to encourage them to join with me in playing with the cats, which occasionally they do and to be fair my 7 year old helped me build a new cat tree for them over the weekend, but mostly they don't want to and ask "can't we do something else?" They're also overwhelmed by the smell and mess, and chose to play in rooms away from the kitchen-diner, where the cats are based. I asked on a parenting ND children forum, and most people said pets helped their ND kids.

  3. The house cleaning has gone out of the window, which is another stresser for my husband. He likes a clean, immaculate house, which I never fully achieved, but I used to get close to. Now, there's food, litter and cat toys in lots of places. He's also likely ND and finds it overwhelming. My husband works FT, I work PT (3-6 hours a week, depending on need), so housework falls on me. He is picking up more household chores without me asking, but I can see it's adding to his stress levels.

  4. I made some pin money selling secondhand baby clothes, which had the bonus of decluttering the house and helping my husband's anxiety levels. That has also gone by the wayside.

  5. I keep forgetting to do stuff. I forgot to get my kid's uniform washed in time for today. I forgot we'd run out of food so couldn't do my son's packed lunch. I forgot the stuff my daughter needed for Brownies. My brain can't seem to remember the previous emotional load.

I can't do it all and at the moment, the cats take up most of my time. I'm suspected to have ADHD alongside depression, so it's an effort for me to focus on a task. Maybe if I could be more productive, then it would be easier. But it's beginning to feel like there isn't enough hours in the day.

So, at the moment I'm saying, lets keep going with the kittens, they'll grow out of it in a year or so, we can do this. But the rest of my family aren't feeling it and are either depressed (my husband) or highly strung (my kids - who pick up on their parents not being ok mentally by becoming more disruptive, fighting more, shouting and screaming more - so I'm trying to manage their behaviours on top of everything else).

My MIL says "get rid of the cats, your and your family's mental health is more important".

Have I made the wrong choice?

OP posts:
WinWhenTheyreSinging · 24/03/2025 14:56

2222thatsme · 24/03/2025 14:44

That's helpful to know, thank you. Yes, all vaccinated, sprayed/neutered and chips since six months old. The rescue said to wait 6-7 months until they were used to the house. That's given me hope that going outside helped you'd kitten. I wish I could harness their energy. I could power my house and others!

6-8 weeks seems excessively long to wait - particularly as of the three, they are not all likely to be huge adventurers. I'd be starting to let them out now, good and hungry, while you're about to see their comings and goings.

JanglingJack · 24/03/2025 14:53

2222thatsme · 24/03/2025 14:44

Sorry 6-8 weeks not months!

Spayed at 6-8 weeks?

FateReset · 24/03/2025 14:52

I'd re-home all 3 kittens. Family comes first, and it sounds like nobody is enjoying living in a house with so many cats, including yourself.

We all make mistakes, but trying to struggle on without accepting and fixing mistakes just leads to more chaos and stress for everyone.

I like cats but would not like them taking over my home. I would never put up with pets destroying my furniture, furnishings, or having to put everything into an office to keep it safe. The kitchen and lounge should feel like a clean, hygienic space for you and your loved ones to enjoy and spend time in. Why are you putting these kittens first?

It's easy to underestimate the impact of pets, especially 3 at once, but I don't think you can solve this issue by putting more time, energy, money and resources into these kittens. You have young children, a husband, health problems, a job that come first. These kittens sound like they'd suit someone with a big house, lots of time on their hands and experience with cats. Maybe a farm or a retired couple, or a single person could give them the time and attention they need.

Personally I would discuss this with your husband, then take the kittens back to where you got them from ASAP. Then you can focus on putting your home and life back together, bit by bit.

Sending you strength and wishing you well. Don't feel guilty about giving them back, sometimes pets are just incompatible with our lives and families.

Tdcp · 24/03/2025 14:51

I used to Foster cats and I've owned a lot of them too. You sound very overwhelmed and the cats are taking precedent over everything and everyone else, it's understandable but please take a step back for a bit. They are 7 months old and they are absolutely full of energy. I would seriously consider starting to let them out now rather than waiting another 2 weeks. Just sniffing around outside should wear them out a bit at this age. It also sounds like they have the run of the house, which is fantastic for them but if they're that destructive you should consider allocating a room or two to them until they're trained. It's far easier the train a cat that's in a room than a whole house. It doesn't have to be a permanent solution of course but it may help you feel more on top of things.
You absolutely should be playing with the cats but there are things you can do that aren't so intensive, throwing rolled up crisp packets for example, anything that rustles, let them chase it.
You mentioned the cat smell, are they properly litter trained? If they're having accidents or purposefully going outside the box this needs to be stopped, going back to the room allocation, calmly take them back to the box every single time you can, or they may take to going outside, mine don't have litter trays as they don't use them. I do honestly think letting them out could solve a lot of these issues.

They will grow out of it but it could be a few years before they properly settle down energy wise. If you don't feel as though you can cope, even with doing the above then they're at a good age to remove as a bonded trio. I don't usually advocate to rehome pets once you have them but sometimes it's okay to admit you have made a mistake.

Good luck op!

JanglingJack · 24/03/2025 14:51

2222thatsme · 24/03/2025 14:32

I should have added. Our adult cat has passed away. We have three kittens as the rescue wanted them to stay together as bonded littermates.

I took on two sisters. My god it was like having twin babies!
Up all night like the stairs were a racetrack, cleaning up shit and piss that had missed the litter. Not letting them out until 6 months until they'd been spayed.

I was the same when we got another kitten some years later. My word I love him.

I wouldn't have been without any of them. Ever.

I assume they're not going to be housecats? If so, you are bonkers.

Matsukaze · 24/03/2025 14:50

I think rescues can sometimes be a bit over cautious with the advice for letting cats out. They advised me to wait to age 6 months but it was just unfeasible so I did let him out before this (he had been neutered before I got him from rescue at 10 weeks). I supervised him closely for the first couple of weeks but then when he was going over the fence that was that! All cats are different and all circumstances are different too of course, I live on a quiet cul de sac and my garden overlooks some woodland, he was desperate to go out.

2222thatsme · 24/03/2025 14:50

I think my question, put more succinctly, is should I be putting the cats before my kids and husband, which I think is how they're feeling?

Put that way, I feel like I've made the wrong choice. But I also don't want to give up on the cats.

OP posts:
2222thatsme · 24/03/2025 14:47

ilovesooty · 24/03/2025 14:45

You admitted yourself that you didn't have experience of this and didn't do enough research.

Yes, I know that now, having starting to Google challenges. But the rescue interviewed us and said we were ideal adopters, especially previously having had a cat and me being home most of the week. It was your comment about why you thought the rescue should have realised we were unsuitable that confused me.

OP posts:
ilovesooty · 24/03/2025 14:45

2222thatsme · 24/03/2025 14:34

Why would the rescue consider us unsuitable? We'd had a previous cat. I am engaging with them, aiming for over an hour a day. My kids are occasionally but feel overwhelmed.

You admitted yourself that you didn't have experience of this and didn't do enough research.

2222thatsme · 24/03/2025 14:44

2222thatsme · 24/03/2025 14:44

That's helpful to know, thank you. Yes, all vaccinated, sprayed/neutered and chips since six months old. The rescue said to wait 6-7 months until they were used to the house. That's given me hope that going outside helped you'd kitten. I wish I could harness their energy. I could power my house and others!

Sorry 6-8 weeks not months!

OP posts:
2222thatsme · 24/03/2025 14:44

Matsukaze · 24/03/2025 14:42

I'd be putting them outside to play (assume they have been chipped, neutered/spayed and vaccinated). I've got an 11 month old kitten. Had cats before but this chap was absolutely mental. He was allowed out when he was old enough and it has really helped. He still has his moments but he is maturing a bit now anyway.

That's helpful to know, thank you. Yes, all vaccinated, sprayed/neutered and chips since six months old. The rescue said to wait 6-7 months until they were used to the house. That's given me hope that going outside helped you'd kitten. I wish I could harness their energy. I could power my house and others!

OP posts:
2222thatsme · 24/03/2025 14:42

Mancala · 24/03/2025 14:20

It sounds like you've got enough on your plate without this. It will improve I'm sure, but nobody seems that into the cats, and I think littermates are always going to be more into each other than you. Contact the rescue to see if they will take them back and learn from this experience - don't get any more pets, it doesn't work for you.

Edited

That's the thing. It worked perfectly with our previous cat. We played together for ten to fifteen minutes a day, she's mooch around the house and hang out with me and climb onto stuff and have evening zoomies, but without the destruction. I just didn't quite realise either how much energy and how much entrainment 8 month old kittens have and needed respectively.

OP posts:
Matsukaze · 24/03/2025 14:42

I'd be putting them outside to play (assume they have been chipped, neutered/spayed and vaccinated). I've got an 11 month old kitten. Had cats before but this chap was absolutely mental. He was allowed out when he was old enough and it has really helped. He still has his moments but he is maturing a bit now anyway.

gerispringer · 24/03/2025 14:42

I’d start letting them out. Have you got a cat flap? You should train them how to use it.

LoztWorld · 24/03/2025 14:40

I don’t think you should keep them when you’re only a month in. The longer you keep them the worse you’ll feel about rehoming them so just do it now.

Cats bond more to places than people so if you haven’t let them out yet now’s the time to re home, before they’ve fully got into the mindset that your area is their territory

2222thatsme · 24/03/2025 14:40

Pleatherandlace · 24/03/2025 14:24

Get a cat flap

That's the plan, once they've done the 6-8 weeks indoors the rescue asked for.

OP posts:
2222thatsme · 24/03/2025 14:39

HereintheloveofChristIstand · 24/03/2025 14:15

Why did you get so many?

The rescue ideally want kittens up go in pairs and they wanted these three to go together as bonded littermates.

OP posts:
2222thatsme · 24/03/2025 14:37

Gettingbysomehow · 24/03/2025 14:19

What on earth persuaded you to get three. One kitten is more than enough trouble. In fact I avoid kittens generally. Your existing cat must be pissed.
Absolutely bonkers.

The rescue wanted all three to go together as bonded littermates.

OP posts:
2222thatsme · 24/03/2025 14:36

NewNameBridget · 24/03/2025 14:20

Three is a lot.

We got one adolescent cat last year (10 months old) and BOY did we regret it for a while, she was wild, scratched furniture to smithereens, would eat everything and anything (ex stray, so a scavenger), including string (three days of poo mashing until it came out). She single handedly (pawedly) destroyed the Christmas tree...

And this was despite regular playing, games, puzzles, etc.

It all changed when she started going outside on her own. She's now 15 months old and is a different cat, she'll still try to eat a bunch of roses, but the scratching and general wildness had passed. She's a lovely snoozy, sociable, little thing now.

Thank you. Some of these posts are giving me hope that going outside will help burn off some of their energy.

OP posts:
2222thatsme · 24/03/2025 14:35

TightPants · 24/03/2025 14:24

Are you going to let them out OP? As other posters have said, this will make a huge difference to their behaviour.
My kitten was exactly like yours (and one was enough to deal with, so I can’t imagine 3 in one go!)
But a few weeks after she was spayed and vaccinated we’ve started letting her out. She’s a changed cat, so much more chilled and back to being a sweetheart again (most of the time anyway!)

Yes. The rescue said to wait another two weeks, but that's the plan.

OP posts:
2222thatsme · 24/03/2025 14:34

ilovesooty · 24/03/2025 14:22

I'm surprised that the rescue considered you suitable owners in the first place. Given that no one in the house is going to engage properly with them, perhaps you'd better admit you made a mistake and return them - all of them as they're bonded. Hopefully they'll be young enough to be rehomed quickly and not be damaged too much by the experience.

Don't feel tempted to get any more animals either.

Why would the rescue consider us unsuitable? We'd had a previous cat. I am engaging with them, aiming for over an hour a day. My kids are occasionally but feel overwhelmed.

OP posts:
2222thatsme · 24/03/2025 14:32

Gettingbysomehow · 24/03/2025 14:19

What on earth persuaded you to get three. One kitten is more than enough trouble. In fact I avoid kittens generally. Your existing cat must be pissed.
Absolutely bonkers.

I should have added. Our adult cat has passed away. We have three kittens as the rescue wanted them to stay together as bonded littermates.

OP posts:
Pleatherandlace · 24/03/2025 14:24

Get a cat flap

TightPants · 24/03/2025 14:24

Are you going to let them out OP? As other posters have said, this will make a huge difference to their behaviour.
My kitten was exactly like yours (and one was enough to deal with, so I can’t imagine 3 in one go!)
But a few weeks after she was spayed and vaccinated we’ve started letting her out. She’s a changed cat, so much more chilled and back to being a sweetheart again (most of the time anyway!)

ilovesooty · 24/03/2025 14:22

I'm surprised that the rescue considered you suitable owners in the first place. Given that no one in the house is going to engage properly with them, perhaps you'd better admit you made a mistake and return them - all of them as they're bonded. Hopefully they'll be young enough to be rehomed quickly and not be damaged too much by the experience.

Don't feel tempted to get any more animals either.

Swipe left for the next trending thread