Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What’s it like to really need your own space?

39 replies

Extraverted · 24/03/2025 08:49

I don't need alone time. I like company and busy-ness, but I understand my partner really does need alone time. He likes solitude and communicates less during these days, which I totally respect and give him space, even though it's not intuitive for me. It’s only ever for a day so it’s no drama.

I’m always very busy too, so although I don’t empathise with it, I’m happy to accommodate it.

Recently, he went into "hermit mode," and I had a minor car accident. I chose to call a friend instead of him, as I knew he was having an alone day and (if I’m honest) didn’t really feel comfortable disturbing him. When I told him about it the next day, he was really upset I didn't reach out to him and quite hurt. He emphasised that I absolutely can pick up the phone any time, emergency or not, and he’ll be there. That was lovely to hear, of course, but I still dont think I’d do that.

It’s been on my mind a lot since then. I'm curious about how it feels to need space and how best to respect it. Are there others who can share their experiences? I've asked my partner, but I'd love more insight since it's unfamiliar to me to want to be away from someone, unless I'm annoyed with them.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
toffeeappleturnip · 25/03/2025 16:40

I could never ever, ever have people stay over at my house - hence I will never create a spare bedroom (obv in an emergency all are welcome) and I could never go on holiday with a group of friends and all our kids. It would send me over the edge. And don't get me wrong, I'm very sociable (once a month) and always the last person to go home at a party - but if someone offers me the spare bed for the night I never accept as it would just ruin the night having to brush teeth, wake up, eat breakfast and talk to other people. Urgh I can't think of anything worse 😄

mewkins · 25/03/2025 13:24

I need time on my own. So do my kids and, looking back, my mum certainly did. She tried to carve out a day on her own occasionally and I do the same. On holiday I sometimes just volunteer to go to the shops on my own so that I can just have some silence or time with my own thoughts. I never mind of someone calls though, it's more like always being in the vicinity of someone else is a bit taxing. As a ppl said, being around others can be a chore. You have to think about what you say, explain why you've chosen to do something etc.

BoredZelda · 25/03/2025 13:06

Extraverted · 24/03/2025 10:31

Thanks all. A further question if you don’t mind. What do you expect of your loved ones during this time?

OH is very very chatty when he’s not needing space. He’s the sort of man who’ll call me randomly to update me that his knee itches or he sneezed weird or he saw a really funny looking dog (I’m exaggerating of course, but you get the point).

Therefore I’m quite used to us connecting in a no-holds-barred way, and have to proactively “code-switch” when he’s quieter, to not contact him about things I would, during our “normal” time, which is why I ended up not contacting him after the car accident.

Edited

I expect them to bugger off and leave me to it. All day. I don’t do it often but sometimes I just need the day to myself.

InWithThePlums · 25/03/2025 13:05

God, I’m a person who needs time alone (like most people probably) but I would absolutely be at the end of the phone and coming to help if one of my family had a car crash!

Ponderingwindow · 25/03/2025 12:59

i Need alone time because the act of holding a conversation is just exhausting. Sometimes even just the possibility of a conversation is exhausting. I need to be able to sit in odd positions, fidget to my hearts content, and just not worry about other people.

if my spouse didn’t contact me in an emergency just because I was having a quiet day, I would think there was something wrong with our marriage. I want to be his support person and want to be able to trust that he will call on me when needed.

Also, me taking time for myself shouldn’t be such a rare or special event that an actual emergency can’t break through. I try to have some time every day.

ChanceMet · 25/03/2025 12:53

Agix · 24/03/2025 09:09

People are a chore. I can think more clearly by myself. I can be myself without worrying about someone else's feelings in that moment. I can concentrate on what I need or want to do.

When I'm with someone else, I automatically put them first. My very existence is purely for their benefit. I modify every part of myself for their pleasure and comfort. It's automatic and I can't exist any differently. It's nice to not have to do that for a while. It's nice to switch off and just be a person.

My partner is an exception to this - and the fact that I feel more myself around him and can relax with him is why he's my partner. I don't need to modify myself for him, we're very similar and comfortable in each other's company. He wouldn't be my partner if I couldn't fully relax around him, because I couldn't live with someone without even more strain on my mental health if I absolutely needed alone time from them - don't get me wrong, my partner and I still have alone time... He plays video games, I watch my shows. But I don't need it so strictly like I do from other people.

Edited

Well, that's learned behaviour you can work on, rather than dealing with the choice of either existing purely for the person you're with or being alone, or in the modified case of being with your partner. My mother was like this, and I and my sisters were brought up to be like this. But, with work, we've all managed to shed that particular script, which is spectacularly unhelpful and unfits an individual for everyday life.

DancingLions · 25/03/2025 12:02

When I'm with someone else, I automatically put them first. My very existence is purely for their benefit. I modify every part of myself for their pleasure and comfort. It's automatic and I can't exist any differently. It's nice to not have to do that for a while. It's nice to switch off and just be a person

This really resonated with me. I've never been able to put it into words before. But I think it's one of the reasons that romantic relationships haven't worked for me.

The only people I'd say I genuinely enjoy being with are my adult DC, as I can just fully be myself with them. Even then I would still need some time alone to recharge, but they're the same so it works well.

It's nice that you're so understanding OP. But yes, in an emergency I would be there for someone regardless of whether I was having alone time. I can "power through" when necessary.

offmynut · 25/03/2025 11:39

I love my own time my own space so much i stay single.
Its peaceful i can recharge restart relax.
I see a lot of people but when i come home and shut my front door its blissful.
No pets no man no kids no chores just shower coffee pjs book its heaven tbh.

RuffledKestrel · 25/03/2025 10:51

Extraverted · 24/03/2025 10:31

Thanks all. A further question if you don’t mind. What do you expect of your loved ones during this time?

OH is very very chatty when he’s not needing space. He’s the sort of man who’ll call me randomly to update me that his knee itches or he sneezed weird or he saw a really funny looking dog (I’m exaggerating of course, but you get the point).

Therefore I’m quite used to us connecting in a no-holds-barred way, and have to proactively “code-switch” when he’s quieter, to not contact him about things I would, during our “normal” time, which is why I ended up not contacting him after the car accident.

Edited

I don't think I expect anything from my loved ones when I need my own time. I ask that they don't take it personally, and don't try to punish me for needing the time though - I had an ex who used to try and convince me that however many hours I need to recharge was then "owned" to do things with him. 🤷‍♀️.

Thankfully my current partner is much more understanding, mostly cause he needs time on his own too. However we have found that we can both recharge just fine while physically being in the same room, just doing different things - painting, drawing, reading, crochet, playing games etc. we just are "low contact" for a while. Little conversation and our own physical space around us. We'll still share any important news we get during these times, or if we suddenly remember something. We also still bring tea/food to each other. It works well for us.

GreyCarpet · 24/03/2025 21:59

I stip being able yo process what others are saying. I lose the ability to speak in sentences. My words come out jumbled or missing and sometimes I can't find the words I need to say.

I feel tense and agitated. You know the Star Wars trash compactor? I'm in that mentally.

I feel.exhsusted. I can't focus or concentrate.

I need a lot of time to myself.

Eldermilleniallyogii · 24/03/2025 21:57

It depends whether he is simply introverted or ND or something else but it can feel exhausting someone being in your company or having to think about someone else or them talking to you. I'm sure he wouldn't have minded you calling if you needed him.

SallyWD · 24/03/2025 21:54

I love being with people but get exhausted by it very quickly. If I don't gave time to myself I just feel so completely drained, like I'm running on an empty tank. I need it to be able to function.

TheeNotoriousPIG · 24/03/2025 20:52

I like certain people very much. However, I cannot bear to be with people at all times!

If I have to endure enforced socialisation, it's effectively like you're draining my personal battery. Things like funerals and Christmas festivities are terrible for this, because you're expected to be around people ALL DAY. Being around people at all times is claustrophobic and anxiety-inducing... to the point that I start counting down to bedtime, when I can be alone! The fact that I am a terrible sleeper is irrelevant.

I get very peeved and, when pushed, grumpily annoyed and snappy with the other person. Then, because I am stressed, I get a headache, tight muscles and generally feel rubbish. I also feel bad because I've been snappy with other people.

I just need a bit of time to myself to be calm, relaxed and unsupervised, without being expected to make conversation or entertain anyone else. That way, I can recharge my batteries and be nice to my human company at some other point in the day.

Cantbebotheredwithausername · 24/03/2025 19:57

I think the batteries analogy is good. It just feels like I've usedup my batteries and need to recharge. If you don't leave me to it, I'll get exhausted and grumpy. I also have a chronic migraines, and get in a bad way if I'm too exhausted - both with migraine, fatigue and cognitive impairment.

However, I do have a spare "emergency battery". I will absolutely use it if a loved one needs me to, and I'd be devastated to not be contacted if someone needs support in an emergency - even if they're not badly injured or very ill. It does come at a price and I don't want to use it to take on extra tasks at work or hear about somebody's itchy knee. I do need to rest and recharge my mental batteries, but not if someone I love has been in an accident - even if it's minor. Or needs support in another way. I'll overrule my need to rest and recharge. It sounds like your DH is able and willing to overrule his need for solitude if you need him, too. That's a good thing.

SnoopyPajamas · 24/03/2025 19:09

DysmalRadius · 24/03/2025 11:46

But if he's allowed to set his boundaries about when he wants 'regular' contact with the OP and when he needs quiet time, why isn't she allowed to decide how she will accommodate that?

He doesn't feel comfortable being 'on' all the time, and the OP is not supposed to take that personally, but you think it's reasonable to consider it a 'punishment' if the OP chooses to deal with a car accident in the way she felt most comfortable with at the time.

Being an introvert or needing alone time doesn't negate the fact that others around you also have needs. The OP was in a stressful situation and she turned to the person she thought would support her best at the time. She is already doing her best to accommodate her partner - does she really have to prioritise his feelings when she's been in a car accident?

Time alone is a preference OP is accommodating. There's not some sort of "don't speak me during alone time, ever" order her partner insisted on. This was an emergency. There is obviously a difference, as he said himself. So yes, refusing to let him know about it does come across as punishing. Especially now, when he's flat out told her he'd want to know, and she's still saying "oh I probably won't".

It's as if OP is saying that it's all or nothing with her. If her partner wants a day alone to recharge his batteries, that will come with a price. Apparently OP is an extreme extrovert who never craves alone time, ever, but for most people this would be an easy decision. It's one of those things like when to call your partner at work or when to interrupt a girl's night out. "I just wanted to chat about my day" = save it for later. "I was in a car crash" = pick up the phone.

toffeeappleturnip · 24/03/2025 16:53

I get a feeling a bit like claustrophobia or anxiety - like a heavy feeling on my chest like I can't breathe or think or relax.

As soon as I'm in peace and quiet for at least 10 minutes with no people, it subsides and i feel completely relaxed again.

This is even with loved ones and people whose company I absolutely enjoy

HamptonPlace · 24/03/2025 16:41

get along well (not) together 😂

threeIsNewSeven · 24/03/2025 11:50

In normal mode, we communicate as we go about both the important and the unimportant stuff.

In giving space mode we limit the random chatter/random disturbances, and we agree timing for the things which need shared attention (dinner at 8 and than we will spend half an hour on X).
Really urgent matters have priority as usually.

Just a note, this can't be only about you adjusting to his wants and needs, it needs to be mutual. Sometimes the needs can be clashing, it can even happen that one needs company and the other needs space, and it needs a plan/shared solution. Neither of those needs is more important than the other.

DysmalRadius · 24/03/2025 11:46

SnoopyPajamas · 24/03/2025 11:18

I'm not surprised your partner was hurt about the car accident thing, by the way. If I was him, I'd feel like my partner was trying to punish me, by withholding that kind of information from me. Especially given that your view of alone time is "I'd only ever need it if I was annoyed at someone". He probably suspects you're taking his need for space more personally than you pretend.

If I was him, I'd also feel pretty uncomfortable wondering how you painted me to the friend you called to help you instead.

But if he's allowed to set his boundaries about when he wants 'regular' contact with the OP and when he needs quiet time, why isn't she allowed to decide how she will accommodate that?

He doesn't feel comfortable being 'on' all the time, and the OP is not supposed to take that personally, but you think it's reasonable to consider it a 'punishment' if the OP chooses to deal with a car accident in the way she felt most comfortable with at the time.

Being an introvert or needing alone time doesn't negate the fact that others around you also have needs. The OP was in a stressful situation and she turned to the person she thought would support her best at the time. She is already doing her best to accommodate her partner - does she really have to prioritise his feelings when she's been in a car accident?

CocoPlum · 24/03/2025 11:33

I absolutely need alone time. It's one of the reasons I don't want to live with my partner! To me it feels like a build up of pressure inside as well as a draining of energy.

However even on the days I have alone at home I'm usually in plenty of contact with DP, messages flying back and forth. And if there was an emergency he would call me, I'd be really hurt if he didn't think he could.

MrsSunshine2b · 24/03/2025 11:30

I really do need alone time or I get sensory overwhelm being around people all the time. Even just having someone there, breathing and existing, starts to get to me after a while. That doesn't mean I'm not contactable in an emergency though and if a loved one needed me during time I wanted to be alone, I'd rather be there and suck it up! It's not kidney dialysis, I won't die if I don't get it, I'll just be a bit tired and grumpy.

SnoopyPajamas · 24/03/2025 11:18

I'm not surprised your partner was hurt about the car accident thing, by the way. If I was him, I'd feel like my partner was trying to punish me, by withholding that kind of information from me. Especially given that your view of alone time is "I'd only ever need it if I was annoyed at someone". He probably suspects you're taking his need for space more personally than you pretend.

If I was him, I'd also feel pretty uncomfortable wondering how you painted me to the friend you called to help you instead.

Yeoldlondoncheese · 24/03/2025 11:13

A further question if you don’t mind. What do you expect of your loved ones during this time?

Ask your partner. Everyone will have different expectations.

SnoopyPajamas · 24/03/2025 11:04

It's like listening to music. You can really enjoy it and sometimes it's great, but you can't listen all day non-stop everyday.

After a while you need to tone it down, change the song, or turn it off completely and enjoy the quiet for a while. Otherwise the constant stimulus would break your brain.

ChanceMet · 24/03/2025 11:04

summersingsinme · 24/03/2025 10:58

You are clearly kind and trying to be very respectful of his boundaries but (gently) you might be taking it a bit far and martyring yourself for his (perceived) comfort.

He's told you he is available to you, even when he's in one of his less communicative phases. But you say you won't reach out to him, even if it is an emergency - why is that? It sounds like you are almost punishing him in some way - you withdraw from me, so I will withdraw from you. It doesn't sound like you are really okay with giving him space and actually it is troubling to you (you mention "code-switching"). It doesn't sound like he wants his comfort to come at your expense, and it definitely shouldn't.

Yes, I think that's a fair point. Though what struck me was that the OP thought that her partner's solitude was more important than her car accident, and called a friend instead because she 'didn't feel comfortable' disturbing him on an 'alone day'. To me, that's the issue here. I don't the most hermitty of introverts would take issue at being called in an emergency, even if it wasn't life-threatening, as long as they were a decent human being. Your boyfriend has said to contact him whenever you want or need to, even if he is having an 'alone day', but you still say you won't. Why not? Why aren't you taking him at his word?