Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would it be unreasonable to tell my housemate I won't help her anymore if she has another child?

117 replies

AmyCakeMaker · 23/03/2025 08:56

I have been friends with Jodie for several years and we have lived together for a while now and 2 years ago, Jo had her daughter (Susie). We get along and don't have any problems.

I have helped Jo with Susie a lot in different ways (distracting, playing, supporting with appointments etc). Susie's dad is not around and Jodie's family only help out occasionally, but because they have their own children, jobs, health etc they are not around as much.

Jo struggles a lot with Susie and can't handle temper tantrums, so I didn't mind helping Jo. However, as time went on, it became more helping out.

I am currently 5 and a half months pregnant and yesterday Jo said to me that she wants another baby and plans on getting pregnant soon (she didn't go into specifics about how she plans on doing it) because Susie should have a sibling. The thing is Susie is a jealous child and already I can see some jealousy problems from when my child is born.

If she did have another child, I won't be helping out because I will be focusing on my own child first and I won't have the time, energy for my child, Susie, Jo and another baby.

Although she hasn't said anything, but I wonder if she's hoping because I will be going on maternity in a few weeks that I will be around more and can support her with Susie and her pregnancy.

Would it be unreasonable to tell her that I won't support her if she has another baby?

Unfortunately, in this area I would struggle to find a suitable house/flat and would not be in a good place financially if I moved out, so that's not an option. I also don't have any close family and other friends don't have the space.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Emanresu52 · 26/03/2025 10:00

toomuchfaff · 23/03/2025 09:07

Where is babys father? Can you not go live with them as you're creating a family?

Wondering why your having a child when you live with someone and youre not financially stable, the person is treating you like their children's second parent and plans to extend that further.

Youre being very stupid bringing a child into the mix.

Absolutely, OP what are you BOTH thinking?!

bellocchild · 25/03/2025 10:56

Keep telling her that you are really looking forward to having her support - she will be able to help you with your baby like you did with hers.

MinnieCauldwell · 24/03/2025 23:15

Mere1 · 24/03/2025 19:50

All of these questions!

And so little answers...

justanotherimperfectmum2025 · 24/03/2025 22:56

YANBU to put your needs and your future
child’s needs first and she certainly can’t keep using you or expect you to be a substitute parent or fill the gap that the father would do if he was around. You need to explain how you feel and maybe Contact your local council children’s department or Citizen Advice Bureau for advice on what you or your housemate can do in terms of living arrangements if living together no longer works, but do not have family close by, or about to move out due to financial restrictions

Pippyls67 · 24/03/2025 22:41

Tell jo to go.

JHound · 24/03/2025 19:53

This sounds such a chaotic way to bring children into the world.

Poor kids.

Mere1 · 24/03/2025 19:50

MinnieCauldwell · 23/03/2025 09:03

Where is your baby's father in all this? Why is he not working on getting a place for you? Why are you having a baby if you can't afford to get your own place?

All of these questions!

Ally886 · 24/03/2025 19:30

So I'm really sympathetic to mothers who find themselves in hard times with children but I have nothing but criticism towards people who are already in a poor position and then think ooh let's bring a child into the world that's going to be deprived of a decent upbringing. Who brings kids into a bloody house share!?

Lovemeapickledgherkin · 24/03/2025 18:16

Why are you both bringing more kids into the world when already struggling with current situation? No mention of the respective fathers. This is baffling to me.

Silvertulips · 23/03/2025 21:18

The OP is not asking about how to get an absent dad to step up, she’s not given any details of her finances in this thread at least

Well we know she works, as she’s planning maternity leave and we know she is living with a friend, so has no ties to the property and we know she is struggling with a child in the house already.

OP has put herself in a poor position, hence the questions about the father and if there’s any chance he can help.

OP you would be better off seeking council accommodation, where ever that maybe and get yourself housed, at least you would have a secure tenancy, your friend can ask you to leave at anytime and you don’t have a leg to stand on.

Isthiswhatmenthink · 23/03/2025 14:32

You’re the one who went to hospital with reduced movements and got ‘told off’ by this woman with the child, aren’t you?

Those whole situation is fucked. You have to get out of it.

Radish81 · 23/03/2025 13:59

In 15 years time… this set up will no doubt be the focus of a disturbing Netflix documentary.

goldenretrieverenergy · 23/03/2025 13:28

That sounds like a very unhealthy dynamic to bring another child into!

I think your main focus should be on finding an alternative home for you and your future child.

It doesn’t sound like Jodie should have another child, but this is the least of your problems.

allthemiddlechildrenoftheworld · 23/03/2025 13:24

@AmyCakeMaker sorry but where are the fathers of all the children or children to be??? Is this an extremely fertile house you are both living in? whose flat or house is it??

Thebloodynine · 23/03/2025 13:20

Who are you having a baby with? Why aren’t you living with him?
You can’t have babies and live in the same home as someone without ending up pretty much doing it together like some kind of commune/blended family. The kids will be raised like siblings; you can’t avoid that.

If you’ve planned a baby then it’s time to move out and go live with whoever you planned the baby with.

AthWat · 23/03/2025 13:05

nutbrownhare15 · 23/03/2025 13:01

Are you living there free in exchange for childcare. This is the kind of arrangement that could be great if you are both willing to help each other out. Does she help you at the moment in any way? Will she help you when the baby is born? Maybe how she treats you then might help determine whether or not you need to move out.

I read all the way through this thread wondering when somebody was going to ask this.

Providing a place to live in exchange for childcare isn't "taking advantage" of anyone, it's a simple and equitable transaction. As things change, of course, both parties may need to revisit it and see if it still suits them.

OriginalUsername2 · 23/03/2025 13:03

Getitwright · 23/03/2025 11:10

I bet the house is called Cuckoo’s Haven. Bloody hell, what a life for the children involved.

Glad it’s not just me! What the fuck is going on in this house?

nutbrownhare15 · 23/03/2025 13:01

Are you living there free in exchange for childcare. This is the kind of arrangement that could be great if you are both willing to help each other out. Does she help you at the moment in any way? Will she help you when the baby is born? Maybe how she treats you then might help determine whether or not you need to move out.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 23/03/2025 12:58

How have we got to a position in society where it’s considered good and feminist to use men for sperm and then declare there’s no need for them to be involved in a child’s life?

I’m all for not shaming women but the pendulum has now swung so far that we’re ignoring what’s best for a child.

I feel really old but wtf is going on these days?!

TrickyD · 23/03/2025 12:54

If other women find themselves unexpectedly pregnant then I don’t have an issue with taxpayers funding a reasonable level of benefits

Where does she say the pregnancy was ‘unexpected’? Sounds more like careless, hence my calling her and the fathers ‘feckless’.

isolate34 · 23/03/2025 12:54

I'm struggling to get my head around this op, why are you both living together but having children without partner involvement etc?? I must say I've never heard of anyone having that set up. Did you plan on being a single parent? As it appears your concerns would have been better to be brought up with your housemate before you got pregnant yourself, let alone the fact she also wants to get pregnant again?! Very odd

Bumpitybumpbumplook · 23/03/2025 12:53

AmyCakeMaker · 23/03/2025 08:56

I have been friends with Jodie for several years and we have lived together for a while now and 2 years ago, Jo had her daughter (Susie). We get along and don't have any problems.

I have helped Jo with Susie a lot in different ways (distracting, playing, supporting with appointments etc). Susie's dad is not around and Jodie's family only help out occasionally, but because they have their own children, jobs, health etc they are not around as much.

Jo struggles a lot with Susie and can't handle temper tantrums, so I didn't mind helping Jo. However, as time went on, it became more helping out.

I am currently 5 and a half months pregnant and yesterday Jo said to me that she wants another baby and plans on getting pregnant soon (she didn't go into specifics about how she plans on doing it) because Susie should have a sibling. The thing is Susie is a jealous child and already I can see some jealousy problems from when my child is born.

If she did have another child, I won't be helping out because I will be focusing on my own child first and I won't have the time, energy for my child, Susie, Jo and another baby.

Although she hasn't said anything, but I wonder if she's hoping because I will be going on maternity in a few weeks that I will be around more and can support her with Susie and her pregnancy.

Would it be unreasonable to tell her that I won't support her if she has another baby?

Unfortunately, in this area I would struggle to find a suitable house/flat and would not be in a good place financially if I moved out, so that's not an option. I also don't have any close family and other friends don't have the space.

Flatmate needs to choose a dorm donor willing to support her and child so she can’t have his help … or money.

Relying on you is foolish for both of you. Unless she pays you. And you agree terms.

Heronwatcher · 23/03/2025 12:46

TrickyD · 23/03/2025 12:38

Nobody is shaming these woman/OP - in 2025! It is reasonable to expect the father to step up and help raise the child, provide support and pay 50/50 in costs etc plus any emotional support needed.
If he’s not around then shame on him!

I think the lot of this feckless crew deserve shaming.

What “feckless lot” are you talking about precisely? And how would “shaming” them help either the mother or the child?

The OP here seems to be in a private rental and mentions maternity leave, so I’ve assumed she’s working. If other women find themselves unexpectedly pregnant then I don’t have an issue with taxpayers funding a reasonable level of benefits so that they don’t end up on the streets, are forced into unsafe living arrangements or have to give up their child.

Goody2ShoesAndTheFilthyBeast · 23/03/2025 12:44

Silvertulips · 23/03/2025 12:02

It’s just a lazy way to put women, often young and lower economic status, back into their boxes by shaming them

Nobody is shaming these woman/OP - in 2025! It is reasonable to expect the father to step up and help raise the child, provide support and pay 50/50 in costs etc plus any emotional support needed.

If he’s not around then shame on him!

Absobloodylutely!
It is not unreasonable to believe men should be equally responsible for the children they father.

I'm not going to sing some sisters are doing it for themselves bullshit when there's men out there not supporting their children.

Isometimeswonder · 23/03/2025 12:43

Are there any dads here? Or are you and her both having babies as single mothers?

Swipe left for the next trending thread