Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sons Ex wont let him have access to his baby

720 replies

LolaJ82 · 21/03/2025 03:14

My son, who is only 19 has had a baby with his ex girlfriend. Its all turned messy and as usual hes asked me to sort things out. They are refusing to speak to each other and I am now the go between, to make matters worse, I don't/didnt know this girl, and before she had my grandson I had met her maybe twice 🤦‍♀️

My son and I fought like cat and dog over this as its apparent that his money (even though he is only 19, he has a really good job) was the main driver, to the point where the baby and the girl wanted for nothing, which for the baby is rightly so.

The issue that we have now is, the baby is 6 weeks old, and my son has seen him approx 4 times. The girl is refusing us access, unless its with her, in her house. Now my son, wants to be a good father, and eventually wants 50/50 access to the child, with him staying with us half of the time, now I know that is a way off, he is a new born after all, however, all we are asking for is a few hours at the weekend, to bring him to our home, so that my son can bond with him, and learn how to be a good dad, without the awkwardness of having to sit in her house, with her watching his every move.

So my long winded question is, AIBU to ask for the baby to come to us for a few hours on a weekend?

OP posts:
ElizaDolittle4321 · 22/03/2025 02:15

Gloriia · 21/03/2025 17:19

'As a mother yourself, you ought to understand that the baby needs to stay with its mother at this age.'

Or father.

Honestly we see so many threads that some women won't leave their dc with the father to even go shopping. Here the father is offering to have it for a few hours, it's is bottle fed and it has a dgm as support.

Carry on encouraging contact with the your ds/the father at your own home not at his ex's.

No, mother and father are not interchangeable at this stage, @Gloriia . If you had even been a birth mother yourself you would know this. It's the fourth trimester, the baby still feels itself as an extension to the mother, and barely knows it is out of the womb. It has been proven it needs the mother's heartbeat and scent. Baby will be using her body to regulate its own. Without her there it’s little body will flood with stress hormones like cortisol and adrenaline.
It is 6 WEEKS OLD. Not 6 months old or 1 year old.

ElizaDolittle4321 · 22/03/2025 02:08

24namechange · 21/03/2025 15:27

I’m with you here OP. Your DS should be able to have his own time and space to bond with his baby and, as you say, learn to look after him. She is currently denying him that right and that’s not acceptable or fair.

Unless you’ve got dangerous animals or major health risks in your home then there is absolutely no reason why the baby shouldn’t be allowed come visit you there. Start as you mean to go on. Baby deserves to bond and spend time with both sides of his family.

If I were you I would the wheels in motion now and seek legal advice. Document all of your attempts to have time with the baby and any rebuttals.

Good luck!! X

Um, @24namechange you don't take a 6 WEEK old newborn baby from it's mother to a strangers house for hours/weekend. It is 6 WEEKS OLD! Did you even read the OP's posts at all? NO legal advice in the land will say the father should have overnights with a 6 WEEK OLD NEWBORN BABY!! He can bond with the baby at it's mother's house.

ElizaDolittle4321 · 22/03/2025 02:03

Ihopeyouhavent · 21/03/2025 15:04

What im getting from these responses is that your son's only job is to pay for it and accept limited access when she deems it.

You clearly haven't even READ the OP, @Ihopeyouhavent . The son has free and unlimited access at the mother's house. Are you really saying it's unreasonable to saying no to taking a 6 WEEK OLD BABY to a strangers house, for hours/weekends away from it's mother?!???

I swear people like you just skim OPs and don't even bother reading. Because no stable, sane human being would agree to taking a 6 week old away when he can SEE IT AT HER HOME.

ElizaDolittle4321 · 22/03/2025 02:00

Ihopeyouhavent · 21/03/2025 15:03

I cant believe some of these replies. Get a solicitor ASAP and sort the access.

He's be shit on if didnt want access and is still shit on for wanting proper access.

This is why i tell my boys to always use protection. I feel for your son :(

Have you even bothered to read what this is about, @Ihopeyouhavent the sone is able to have free access to his son, and visits. And so is OP.

They just can't take a 6 week old baby for WEEKENDS or for hours to a strangers house.

That is MORE than reasonable. And a solicitor would tell him this.

ElizaDolittle4321 · 22/03/2025 01:54

AshKeys · 21/03/2025 14:35

Probably because the GF doesn’t want OP there.

OP has said she too is allowed to visit.

ElizaDolittle4321 · 22/03/2025 01:49

Katypp · 21/03/2025 13:33

I have three children

Then you should KNOW that taking a 6 week old newborn baby from it's mother for hours and weekends is a bad idea, @Katypp . And OP's son seeing the baby at the mother's house freely is a good thing.

ElizaDolittle4321 · 22/03/2025 01:47

Katypp · 21/03/2025 13:29

I've only read the first three pages, but as soon as I saw the title, I knew this would end up in a pile-on.
OP, welcome to MN. The rules are:
The mother is always, always right and her feelings and wants, no matter how ridiculous, overrule anyone else's. Regardless of the fact that people have been having babies since time began, the mother has done something breath-takingly amazing and everyone else must admire her in awe
The father is always wrong, no matter what he does or doesn't do. His wants and needs do not count at all
Children are a extension of the mother, so although you will get posters saying somewhat piously it's all about the child's needs, what they really mean is it's all about the mother's
You are a grandmother count for nothing. The fact this is your grandchild is irrelevant.
Modern parenting decrees the baby is surgically attached to the mother for as long as she wants and this can be used to control the entire family when it suits her.

I sound bitter, I am. I am also projecting, I know.
I have still not forgiven the poster who called my DH of 20 years a 'Prince among men' for giving up fighting to see his children after three years of family courts, £20,000 legal fees and two CAFCAS reports in his favour, yet still his ex refused to facilitate contact.
I am usually accused of lying at this point too.

Would you have wanted your 6 week old baby taken to a strangers house without you for hours and for weekends? At 6 weeks? @Katypp

ElizaDolittle4321 · 22/03/2025 01:45

Golden407 · 21/03/2025 13:28

Maybe he feels she's not being fair to him for whatever reason? Asking his mother to meditate maybe the most sensible option

No, it is not at all a sensible option to run to mummy. All that would do, common sense tells one, is make the mother feel ganged up on. OP said 'as usual' he has asked me to sort it out. Clearly this immature boy can't speak with the mother of his child like an adult.

ElizaDolittle4321 · 22/03/2025 01:43

Golden407 · 21/03/2025 13:26

"He needs to grow up quickly". What has he done to suggest he's immature?

Needing his mummy to sort out his problems, for one, @Golden407 . Not being able to withstand awkwardness at the mother's home in order to spend time with his son, another.

ElizaDolittle4321 · 22/03/2025 01:37

theriseandfallofFranklinSaint · 21/03/2025 11:48

Did none of you leave your 6 week old babies at all? Not even for an hour?
Some of you are even saying you don't let your husband's take the baby out of your sight for more than 5 minutes? 😮

Have you ever had a baby, @theriseandfallofFranklinSaint ? It doesn't sound like it.

We're talking about a son who wants to take a 6 week old baby to a strangers house for hours/weekends. Not remotely the same as your husband who lives with you taking the baby out in the garden.

ElizaDolittle4321 · 22/03/2025 01:24

LolaJ82 · 21/03/2025 11:28

Shame on all of you for these responses, but im the awful person 🤣

If you still think it's ok to take a 6 week old baby away from it's mother, yes, shame on you!

ElizaDolittle4321 · 22/03/2025 01:20

JudgeJ · 21/03/2025 10:19

The OP is listening, it's just that the majority are totally biased!

Biased because we say it's wrong to take baby of 6 weeks to a strangers house for hours and weekends? A baby of 6 weeks? When he can visit the baby and spend time with it at her house? Did you even bother to actually read the OP, @JudgeJ ? The son is able to visit the baby whenever he wants! Just not take it to his house. That's all!

ElizaDolittle4321 · 22/03/2025 01:16

JudgeJ · 21/03/2025 10:17

This site will almost always take the mother's side, whatever she does. If she is withholding his rights as a father then he should be withholding a proportion of any financial support he's giving until she allows him a fair access. 4 times in 6 weeks is appalling behaviour towards a father who has been supportive through the pregnancy.

@JudgeJ You're assuming she has stopped him, instead of him only choosing to see the baby 4 times. It sounds like he hasn't been bothered.

mathanxiety · 22/03/2025 00:57

beAsensible1 · 21/03/2025 22:23

He is not a stranger he is the father. All parents are strangers until the baby is born. And they will.

little and often is few hours a couple of times a week. She cannot demand he needs to be supervised unless she has concerns and the court would not allow that either.

Nonsense.

The baby has known the mother since conception, and vice versa. The baby can recognise its mother's voice and face minutes after birth. The baby can smell its mother from day one.

The father is, in fact, a stranger, and does not have the deep physical bond the mother has with the baby, and vice versa.

The first three months are not called 'the fourth trimester' for no reason.

mathanxiety · 22/03/2025 00:53

You are being massively unreasonable, and putting horrible pressure on a new mother to part with her baby, no doubt causing her to feel stressed out and extremely anxious.

And you need to get over yourselves wrt the money your son has given toward the baby. He's no hero, and it's not a pay to play situation.

Stop pressuring the young mother. Go to her house and see the baby on her terms.

FFS Angry

OhCrumbsWhereNow · 21/03/2025 23:47

beAsensible1 · 21/03/2025 22:23

He is not a stranger he is the father. All parents are strangers until the baby is born. And they will.

little and often is few hours a couple of times a week. She cannot demand he needs to be supervised unless she has concerns and the court would not allow that either.

No court will demand that a 6 week old baby is handed over so the father that has seen the child 4 times and the grandmother can take them off for hours at a separate location.

The most they will want is regular contact for the father with the child at the mother's house with her present and gradually building up to having time alone over many months.

Breast fed babies often don't do overnights away from mother for several YEARS.

If the father and grandmother want a good relationship they will work with the mother, not against her.

Masmavi · 21/03/2025 22:56

YABU. A baby of 6 weeks is too young to be away from the mother 'for a few hours' in.a different environment.

Simplynotsimple · 21/03/2025 22:50

beAsensible1 · 21/03/2025 22:23

He is not a stranger he is the father. All parents are strangers until the baby is born. And they will.

little and often is few hours a couple of times a week. She cannot demand he needs to be supervised unless she has concerns and the court would not allow that either.

Do you not know basic biology? The mother of the baby isn’t a stranger at all. The baby knows its mother as an absolute, and to take a newborn away from its mother for longer than necessary is physically traumatic and should only be done under extreme circumstances. This is not that, the father can visit and build that relationship with his child but it will be weeks, likely months, before it’s reasonable to expect mum to hand the baby over for ‘dad time’ alone.

beAsensible1 · 21/03/2025 22:23

ElizaDolittle4321 · 21/03/2025 08:15

He already has contact, at the mother's house, @beAsensible1 . No legal court in the land is going to separate a 6 week old baby from it's mother and send it to strangers.

He is not a stranger he is the father. All parents are strangers until the baby is born. And they will.

little and often is few hours a couple of times a week. She cannot demand he needs to be supervised unless she has concerns and the court would not allow that either.

Calliopespa · 21/03/2025 22:15

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I’m not endorsing op’s approach, but wanting contact with your grandchild is hardly living vicariously.

This post is quite harsh.

SavageTomato · 21/03/2025 21:53

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Calliopespa · 21/03/2025 21:36

TheAmusedQuail · 21/03/2025 20:29

OP - Am I being unreasonable?

Other posters - Yes.

OP - Shame on you for saying that.

To be fair, op is not the first and won’t be the last op to start an AIBU thread then get offended if posters say yes, actually, you are BU.

I think she’s probably feeling a lot of emotions at this time. It isn’t the ideal circumstance to become a grandmother, and, while it’s infinitely more about the baby than her, I can understand she probably feels anxious about being shut out of the life of a baby it would be perfectly natural for her to feel for. I can sympathise with her to that extent.

But she needs to step back and think how best to handle those feelings; going on the offensive won’t achieve much good for any of them - least of all the baby.

EmBear91 · 21/03/2025 21:22

Of course you’re being unreasonable. The baby is 6 weeks old. I didn’t want to let my little one out of my sight at that age. The poor woman is still deep in the trenches of postpartum & as you already said, barely knows you. She’s just carried & birthed this child - if your son wants to be a dad, he needs to suck it up, respect her wishes, support her as the mother of his child & go to her house! Not to mention the fact that he also barely knows his child & the baby barely knows him - if he really cares about being a dad, he could go & visit the baby every day at his exe’s house. I wouldn’t be comfortable handing off my child to someone who has met them a handful of times, even if it’s their dad.

Tangerinenets · 21/03/2025 20:42

Honestly I’d take it one day at a time. Nor course the baby is far too young to be away from his mum at the moment but in the future of course your son isn’t being unreasonable wanting access to his son. If I were him I’d see the baby on her terms until he’s older and then broach the subject again. If she refuses he will have to go the legal route.

Freshflower · 21/03/2025 20:42

NotTheDebtDoctorWithTheHungryScalpel · 21/03/2025 18:36

If you look at the time on the posts you'll see I posted less than a minute after your response above, so you really didn't have to repeat it, you chose to.

I understand those responses anyway because op is winding things up, not sorting things out. If she's making things worse then she needs to step back.

Exactly, there is a difference between supporting her son to do the right thing , which is work with the mother of the child and build bridges whilst putting baby first and finding ways together that everyone is happy with for vists , not going against mothers wishes with a 6 week old baby to be with granny and her son at granny's house and granny doing everything 'as usual ' it's not going to work , I've seen this situation a few times and it ends badly. Granny needs to support of course but in the right way and step back

Swipe left for the next trending thread