Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sons Ex wont let him have access to his baby

720 replies

LolaJ82 · 21/03/2025 03:14

My son, who is only 19 has had a baby with his ex girlfriend. Its all turned messy and as usual hes asked me to sort things out. They are refusing to speak to each other and I am now the go between, to make matters worse, I don't/didnt know this girl, and before she had my grandson I had met her maybe twice 🤦‍♀️

My son and I fought like cat and dog over this as its apparent that his money (even though he is only 19, he has a really good job) was the main driver, to the point where the baby and the girl wanted for nothing, which for the baby is rightly so.

The issue that we have now is, the baby is 6 weeks old, and my son has seen him approx 4 times. The girl is refusing us access, unless its with her, in her house. Now my son, wants to be a good father, and eventually wants 50/50 access to the child, with him staying with us half of the time, now I know that is a way off, he is a new born after all, however, all we are asking for is a few hours at the weekend, to bring him to our home, so that my son can bond with him, and learn how to be a good dad, without the awkwardness of having to sit in her house, with her watching his every move.

So my long winded question is, AIBU to ask for the baby to come to us for a few hours on a weekend?

OP posts:
Preworkouttingle · 22/03/2025 23:18

Lots of good advice here. Agree with most, be patient. I remember never wanting to be a mum but then she was born and that first couple of months? The thought of my baby being out of my sight distressed me so much. It calms down. Let mum use her instincts and protect and learn her baby’s likes and sounds and dislikes. Once she has that studied and can explain it, she’ll be more comfortable and confident as we all were. It’s terrifying being a new mum. I was terrified! She must feel like that too.

emmaloo14 · 22/03/2025 23:07

SquashedSquid · 22/03/2025 22:40

You can't be serious, surely?

Completely serious, not all mothers are calm, nurturing and caring.

Chiefly10 · 22/03/2025 23:07

Sorry you are going through this. The baby has 2 biological parents and 2 sides to their family. The baby will be safe in the love and care of your family which is also the baby’s family. Babies are fine with their father and grandparents when well cared for. Just like they are fine with the mother and her family when well cared for. They don’t need to be with the mother 24/7, especially if not relying on the mother for food as they are bottle fed. You made a very reasonable suggestion to have the baby at yours for a few hours on the weekend. I think the responses you have received are awful and very unfair to the baby more than anything else,

JustAnotherManicMomday · 22/03/2025 22:49

At this age baby should be where mum is, if you dont want to go there she comes with the baby to you. At least until 6 months. No way would I have left my son with his father and parents at that age. He was 18 months before he w3nt over night and 12 months before he went all day alone. I stopped him going for a while when he came home after his second alone visit for a few hours and when I went to the car to get him out when he came back, they hadn't strapped him in the car seat or put the seatbelt round seat. You need to do things at her pace.

shehasglasses48 · 22/03/2025 22:48

This must be very painful for you but please remember this is his commitment for life. Whatever obstacles are put in his way, keep on trying to be part of that child’s life. It’s about to the child not your son.

SquashedSquid · 22/03/2025 22:40

emmaloo14 · 22/03/2025 22:20

But the baby would be with their father, why is the mother more important?

You can't be serious, surely?

OhCrumbsWhereNow · 22/03/2025 22:25

emmaloo14 · 22/03/2025 22:20

But the baby would be with their father, why is the mother more important?

It's a thing called biology.

The baby has been inside the mother for 9 months and is uniquely bonded to her smell, her heart beat, her voice.

Separating a young baby from that in the first 6 months of life can be deeply traumatic as the child uses the mother's scent, breathing and heart rate to regulate themselves.

The mother is full of hormones that will help her to protect her child and nurture it. It's why the sound of a baby crying can cause milk let-down.

The father wanting to bond with the baby is great - but should be done in a way that is best for both mother and baby. That is definitely NOT taking the baby round for a stranger to play with at 6 weeks old against the mother's wishes.

If he is intelligent and caring, he will work with the mother to prove he is capable of caring for the baby and gradually work up to having time away from the mother.

emmaloo14 · 22/03/2025 22:20

Masmavi · 21/03/2025 22:56

YABU. A baby of 6 weeks is too young to be away from the mother 'for a few hours' in.a different environment.

But the baby would be with their father, why is the mother more important?

emmaloo14 · 22/03/2025 22:19

LucyBee0ox · 22/03/2025 17:19

If he has a “really good job” at 19 years old why is he going for 50/50 custody? Also getting women pregnant at 19 he doesn’t seem like the most intelligent, classy man so I’m not sure I believe you.

Maybe because he takes his responsibility as a father seriously, would you say the same if a mum was asking for 50/50 care, or is the issue that you are a misandrist and are of the view that the male needs to go to work and provide for the little mother at home.

OhCrumbsWhereNow · 22/03/2025 22:16

emmaloo14 · 22/03/2025 22:14

Actually parental responsibility is a real thing.

That's what I said.

emmaloo14 · 22/03/2025 22:15

OhCrumbsWhereNow · 22/03/2025 18:32

Nope. The dad has responsibilities not rights.

The mother has offered for him to see the baby at her house - that is absolutely in the best interests of a 6 week old baby.

If the OP and her son had the child's best interests at heart they would realise that. It's not a toy to be passed around.

Bull shit, this is about mums needs, not babies as babies can bond with men as much as women

emmaloo14 · 22/03/2025 22:14

OhCrumbsWhereNow · 22/03/2025 18:27

Parents don't have rights. They have responsibilities.

Actually parental responsibility is a real thing.

JayJayj · 22/03/2025 21:33

Only seen the baby 4 times but wants to take the baby away from its mother! Are you both delusional.

he should be visiting way more. Every day or every other day. And even then a baby that young needs to be close to its mother.

I’m guessing they weren’t together for too long so she doesn’t really know him. Doesn’t know you. So why would she be happy for you both to have the baby when she is not there?!?

Freshflower · 22/03/2025 21:28

patq7691 · 22/03/2025 20:32

I am a man and have been through this , first thing to is make sure he is on the birth certificate
Keep a timed and dated record of any contact you or son has with her if it is not timed and dated it will not stand up in court
Best bit of advice I can give you is stay calm this woman is going to be in your lifes for the next 20. years, she can make your life hell and make access hard so bite your tongue
Would give her at least 6 months before you ask to baby out with out her
Would suggest to her that you could go round and help her out with cleaning or if she wants a nap. or get her shopping done
If she sees you as a friend not an enemy your life will be a lot easier

Good advice to make sure there is genuine friendship , so if both mum and dad are civil, it's more likely to go smoothly. However when you say this woman will be in your life... and can make things hard with access and make your life hell, sounds like you had some bitter times with your ex. I genuinely think if it's all done right with respect and understanding for eachother and both families putting the baby first, noone from either side will be making eachothers life hell. It's usually when there is disrespect , un reasonable expectations, no effort from father or negative interference from the grandparents , things go very wrong.

Bellyblueboy · 22/03/2025 21:18

OP are you going with him? Is that maybe part of the problem? You don’t really know this young woman. She is feeling vulnerable and emotional. You think she is a gold digger - and she probably knows form your son some of the things you said about you.

if you are accompanying your son when he goes to her house I can see how that would cause problems. It might be clear to her that you are the driving force behind this - so the baby would be cared for by you not the baby’s father.

LEWWW · 22/03/2025 21:15

Why doesn’t he regularly go round and watch the baby for a few hours while she catches up on some sleep etc? That would give him chance to bond without taking the baby away from mum. Don’t you think it would be better for everyone involved if he puts his big boy pants on and sorted this situation out himself instead of you doing it for him?

GhoulWithADragonTattoo · 22/03/2025 21:07

He should see the baby on the mum's terms for now. Doing nappies, formula, comforting baby as much as he can. She will realise he can be trusted for a couple of hours and she may agree to that at 4/5 months.

Calliopespa · 22/03/2025 20:38

patq7691 · 22/03/2025 20:32

I am a man and have been through this , first thing to is make sure he is on the birth certificate
Keep a timed and dated record of any contact you or son has with her if it is not timed and dated it will not stand up in court
Best bit of advice I can give you is stay calm this woman is going to be in your lifes for the next 20. years, she can make your life hell and make access hard so bite your tongue
Would give her at least 6 months before you ask to baby out with out her
Would suggest to her that you could go round and help her out with cleaning or if she wants a nap. or get her shopping done
If she sees you as a friend not an enemy your life will be a lot easier

Best advice op

Penny128 · 22/03/2025 20:35

A baby doesn’t even recognise themselves as a separate entity to their mother until they are 6 months old. Being separated is highly distressing for an infant. This is about the baby and no one else. In the UK you have responsibilities as a parent not rights. That baby needs to be with his/her mother constantly and the mother as the primary caregiver should be provided with whatever support she needs to give the baby what they need. A father is there as a support system to the mother for the first 18 months (to protect and provide) and then he’s useful to bond with the child for rough and tumble for example, otherwise that’s about it. Before anyone comments, do your research. Society would be in a much better state if people’s parenting was led solely by their child’s wellbeing and not their own selfish needs.

patq7691 · 22/03/2025 20:32

I am a man and have been through this , first thing to is make sure he is on the birth certificate
Keep a timed and dated record of any contact you or son has with her if it is not timed and dated it will not stand up in court
Best bit of advice I can give you is stay calm this woman is going to be in your lifes for the next 20. years, she can make your life hell and make access hard so bite your tongue
Would give her at least 6 months before you ask to baby out with out her
Would suggest to her that you could go round and help her out with cleaning or if she wants a nap. or get her shopping done
If she sees you as a friend not an enemy your life will be a lot easier

marcopront · 22/03/2025 20:14

Mumof3confused · 22/03/2025 19:38

Well, he has a good job by the sounds of it. He’s willing to be involved and wants to be present in his child’s life. He’s providing for mum and baby. I am
assuming these things based on the op.

We don’t know whether he’s been prevented from seeing baby more regularly by the mum. He’s tried talking to the mum and it’s turning into arguments - this is likely both of their fault, not just his.

You’re assuming he’s an arsehole but there’s nothing here to say that he is. I don’t agree that mum has monopoly and final say just by virtue of being the mother. His presence is equally as important for the baby.

Edited

You said he was capable.

I asked what you based that on
after acknowledging he had bought stuff.

You have said
he bought stuff
he has tried to see the baby
he has tried to talk to the mum

To me those are not indications of being capable

bubblybeth97 · 22/03/2025 20:13

Honestly knowing what things were like co-parenting my newborn with my ex (and I use the term coparenting very very loosely), the fact that he's allowed in her house is something! She is the one with primary care of this baby, so he needs to suck it up and do it on her terms for now. If baby becomes unsettled, he's going to want his mum and it'll be that way for a while! She is no doubt sleep deprived, terrified and probably emotionally exhausted as well and now she likely feels that her ex and his mum are pressuring her into things she isn't comfortable with which is only going to make her withdraw further here, whether that's your intent or not. They need to learn to communicate effectively and stay civil with each other, this baby's needs come first and sorry to say it, but as the one who's just given birth and is currently doing most, if not all of the care, the mum's needs are a very close second.

If your son intends to prove himself as being a good and devoted dad, then he's going about it the wrong way.

thepariscrimefiles · 22/03/2025 20:00

Playinwithfire · 22/03/2025 18:39

No, he is the parent! The parent has rights. The father has rights as well as responsibilities.
Why wouldn't he be on the birth cert if he wasn't the father?

Exactly the child is not toy. When a father is asserting his rights and responsibilities, the mother has a responsibility to respect that. Just like he is the rest of the days! He is respecting the mother, however, it is very fair to have his child a few hours each week without the mother.

As he isn't married to the baby's mum, he would only be on the birth certificate if he attended the appointment to register the baby with the mother of his child.

Even if he took the mum to court, it is doubtful that the court would rule in favour of such a small baby being taken away from its mum when she has said that she is happy for OP and her son to see the baby in her home.

Neither OP nor her son are showing much respect for the mother of the baby. Hopefully, her own parents are supportive.

mathanxiety · 22/03/2025 19:59

Snoringdogsfarting · 22/03/2025 19:39

Being on the birth certificate means nothing. Get advice and go to family court and if you can’t afford a solicitor get a McKenzie friend. There is lots of advice online on how to go about it all. Please remember though that the mother can say anything she dreams up about the father to stop him seeing the child, but will still be able to claim maintenance. Paying doesn’t mean you’re given the right to see the child. Courts are biased toward mothers .

If by "biased" in favour of mothers you mean "would laugh this impetuous young man who clearly has neither the welfare of his baby or the baby's mother at heart out of court", then yes, you are right.

Only the lowest bottom feeders among the legal profession would agree to take on his case.

This is because that approach would constitute emotional and psychological abuse of the mother.

MissScarletInTheBallroom · 22/03/2025 19:59

Playinwithfire · 22/03/2025 19:32

Also in the real world we have women traumatizing their children whilst their fathers are trying to get access to protect them. Or their mother's are exposing them to other dangerous people. No two situations are the same. You literally only get a snippet of what's going on here. And yet it is assumed the father isn't good.

Other women (or men) never want to assume that woman could actually be in the wrong. The mother may not be communicating with him. The mother could may well be controlling. There could be a list of things that may show the mother may not be responsible however, the OP has not been nasty about her at all. All she wanted was a way to know how to help her son to see his child.

Not sure what point you're trying to make here.

The point I was making is that, knowing what I now do, the chances that I would willingly give somebody the power to take my newborn baby away and not return them are approximately zero.

And that's what giving parental responsibility to your flaky ex (whose mother seems likely to egg him on regarding his "rights") means.