Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are you going to the USA? Just make sure you've not said anything nasty about Trump or your phone might get searched and you won't be allowed in

160 replies

cakeorwine · 19/03/2025 22:42

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/mar/19/trump-musk-french-scientist-detained

I wonder what he said in his private messages that were looked at when US Border Agents looked at his phone.

“I learned with concern that a French researcher” on assignment for the French National Center for Scientific Research (CNRS) “who was traveling to a conference near Houston was denied entry to the United States before being expelled”, Philippe Baptiste, France’s minister of higher education and research, said in a statement on Monday to Agence France-Presse published by Le Monde. “This measure was apparently taken by the American authorities because the researcher’s phone contained exchanges with colleagues and friends in which he expressed a personal opinion on the Trump administration’s research policy,” the minister added.

"Another AFP source said that US authorities accused the French researcher of “hateful and conspiratorial messages”. He was reportedly also informed of an FBI investigation, but told that “charges were dropped” before being expelled."

Clearly some people might need a burner phone. And be careful of your social media use.

French scientist denied US entry after phone messages critical of Trump found

France’s research minister said the scientist was traveling to Houston for a conference when his phone was searched

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/mar/19/trump-musk-french-scientist-detained

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
ColourlessGreenIdeasSleepFuriously · 21/03/2025 08:29

Are we banning senior academics and comics writers and expelling diplomats from friendly countries?

Mightymoog · 21/03/2025 08:23

cakeorwine · 21/03/2025 07:12

You agree they ask you for your social media details on the ESTA form.

Why do they ask for that?

You agree that they have the right to search your mobile devices when you want to enter the USA?

So if you had messages on your phone that were anti Trump and you were quite vocal on your social media about Trump - do you think that could cause a problem at border control?

UK customs also have the right to search your 'phoneand I assume most other countries

AlisonDonut · 21/03/2025 08:22

WavyRavey · 21/03/2025 07:31

Wait till you find out that any country can actually deport you for comments against their leader or government :O

The UK even jails its citizens for it.

rosemarble · 21/03/2025 08:06

AnyoneWhoHasAHeart · 21/03/2025 04:53

The responses to this are ridiculous.

There is clearly far more to this story than the edit are telling us. And let’s be honest here, people always claim they’ve done nothing wrong.

Customs aren’t stopping random tourists and asking to check their phones and anyone who has called trump a twat is being deported. For this man’s phone to have been checked he clearly already raised red flags and was found to have messages which amount to terrorism. Funny how the media haven’t published them to prove just how easily someone going to disneyworld is going to be deported. That’s because there are more to the messages than we’re being told.

As for all the hysteria over going to America, I absolutely wouldn’t want to live there, my DS’ GF is American and I absolutely don’t want him to live there either. But this notion of boycotting a country because you don’t like Trump is ridiculous. The man is a moron, but he and his cronies are likely to be in charge now for the foreseeable. And America is America. It’s not like the foreign office is advising people not to travel. The media are doing a good job of whipping up hysteria though.

What do you think about this: https://nationalpost.com/news/canadian-woman-speaks-out-about-her-treatment-in-u-s-detention

Canadian woman speaks out about her treatment in U.S. detention

"We were bound in chains that wrapped tightly around our waists, our cuffed hands secured to our bodies and shackles restraining our feet."

https://nationalpost.com/news/canadian-woman-speaks-out-about-her-treatment-in-u-s-detention

ThisAlertRaven · 21/03/2025 07:31

Lyannaa · 21/03/2025 04:47

I wonder how Americans genuinely feel knowing they now live under a fascist regime?

Vance is telling USA citizens that UK/Europe are dictatorships with no free speech and many in the US will believe him and think that they have it better... that is why Vance is constantly talking Europe down (also plays well for Putin, conveniently)

WavyRavey · 21/03/2025 07:31

Wait till you find out that any country can actually deport you for comments against their leader or government :O

TheCountofMountingCrispBags · 21/03/2025 07:26

ColourlessGreenIdeasSleepFuriously · 21/03/2025 06:25

This is a senior French researcher btw. It is not impossible he was up to no good but it would be like an Oxford don turning out to be a terrorist, highly unlikely.

Exactly! Oxford don more likely to be a spy than a terrorist!

TorroFerney · 21/03/2025 07:25

Arrivals4lucky · 20/03/2025 20:43

They can take your phone and ask for the password and the codes and for access to your SM and passwords at entry points to USA.
You can refuse, within reason, but you might find yourself on the way straight back home with a no fly marker on your passport for any return to the USA.
behold the land of freedom.

That’s not an America thing though is it checking phones, That’s a border security thing.

Ohthatsabitshit · 21/03/2025 07:24

I’m shocked they have the right to search your phone!

TheCountofMountingCrispBags · 21/03/2025 07:23

cakeorwine · 21/03/2025 07:18

And then sell your story to the Daily Mail with a sad face .

Almost worth the price of the flights?

Yes!

Isthisreasonable · 21/03/2025 07:19

britinnyc · 20/03/2025 20:59

I despise the President and live in the U.S. but there has to be more to this story than they just randomly searched his phone, he must have been somehow flagged for something. If you have ever flown into the U.S. there are barely enough people to even check passports let alone look through peoples phones and understand things that I am assuming were in another language. Concerning nonetheless but I do suspect a lot of these things have always happened we are just getting a lot of press coverage because of Trump’s crackdowns. The UK travel warning basically just says follow the rules so it isn’t like they are telling people not to travel

I suspect the majority of people from Western Europe would have negative comments about Trump on their devices so it wouldn't be difficult to find and make an example of someone who wasn't in awe of the dear leader.

cakeorwine · 21/03/2025 07:18

TheCountofMountingCrispBags · 21/03/2025 07:14

This is almost worth loading my phone with anti-tango man, anti gun law, and anti home boys statements, booking a flight to the states and making a fuss at border control so that they were forced to check it.
Banned from ever entering usa? Thanks, I'll take it!

And then sell your story to the Daily Mail with a sad face .

Almost worth the price of the flights?

OP posts:
TheCountofMountingCrispBags · 21/03/2025 07:14

Arrivals4lucky · 20/03/2025 20:43

They can take your phone and ask for the password and the codes and for access to your SM and passwords at entry points to USA.
You can refuse, within reason, but you might find yourself on the way straight back home with a no fly marker on your passport for any return to the USA.
behold the land of freedom.

This is almost worth loading my phone with anti-tango man, anti gun law, and anti home boys statements, booking a flight to the states and making a fuss at border control so that they were forced to check it.
Banned from ever entering usa? Thanks, I'll take it!

cakeorwine · 21/03/2025 07:12

AnyoneWhoHasAHeart · 21/03/2025 05:00

Links to the articles of holidaymakers who are routinely being deported for criticising trump? Oh wait. There aren’t any.

We’re talking about one person here. one person who was clearly up to no good if the article linked to above is anything to go by.

But the rabbit hole dwellers and the gutter press are anxious to whip this into a frenzy about how if you go and see Mickey Mouse your phone will be searched and if you’ve said anything anti trump you’ll be deported when there is 0 evidence to support that.

the people buying into this shit are akin to the Covid conspiracy theorists and the flat earth brigade.

You agree they ask you for your social media details on the ESTA form.

Why do they ask for that?

You agree that they have the right to search your mobile devices when you want to enter the USA?

So if you had messages on your phone that were anti Trump and you were quite vocal on your social media about Trump - do you think that could cause a problem at border control?

OP posts:
anotherside · 21/03/2025 07:08

I dislike Trump but don’t get the boycott stuff. Those Trump voters were there before Trump and will be there after him. Was GW Bush with his Iraq obsession much better? But there are tens of millions of decent, reasonable Americans who don’t deserve a boycott and who he doesn’t represent. Should the world have boycotted the UK when we elected the lying racist Boris Johnson? What about Theresa May with her obsessive targeting of immigrants and breaking up families? Unfortunately nasty politicians are the price of democracy.

KimberleyClark · 21/03/2025 06:48

This is fascism.

Valeriekat · 21/03/2025 06:46

Just don't go then!

ColourlessGreenIdeasSleepFuriously · 21/03/2025 06:25

This is a senior French researcher btw. It is not impossible he was up to no good but it would be like an Oxford don turning out to be a terrorist, highly unlikely.

ColourlessGreenIdeasSleepFuriously · 21/03/2025 06:17

StMarie4me · 20/03/2025 21:15

Terrorism is defined as using violence to change h to he fabric of society.

Sure sounds like what Musk and his stooge are doing

CharlieRight · 21/03/2025 05:57

A colleague of mine was stopped and had his phone taken away to be searched. Then he was questioned on the contents. It was quite grueling

Lyannaa · 21/03/2025 05:07

AnyoneWhoHasAHeart · 21/03/2025 04:53

The responses to this are ridiculous.

There is clearly far more to this story than the edit are telling us. And let’s be honest here, people always claim they’ve done nothing wrong.

Customs aren’t stopping random tourists and asking to check their phones and anyone who has called trump a twat is being deported. For this man’s phone to have been checked he clearly already raised red flags and was found to have messages which amount to terrorism. Funny how the media haven’t published them to prove just how easily someone going to disneyworld is going to be deported. That’s because there are more to the messages than we’re being told.

As for all the hysteria over going to America, I absolutely wouldn’t want to live there, my DS’ GF is American and I absolutely don’t want him to live there either. But this notion of boycotting a country because you don’t like Trump is ridiculous. The man is a moron, but he and his cronies are likely to be in charge now for the foreseeable. And America is America. It’s not like the foreign office is advising people not to travel. The media are doing a good job of whipping up hysteria though.

An American citizen was recently imprisoned for peaceful protesting against America’s support for Israel. His wife was 9 months pregnant and the Trump regime moved him from New York (where he is from) to a prison in Louisiana because they were hoping that a Louisiana judge would be more willing to imprison someone (illegally currently) for speaking out against the government.

This isn’t hyperbole.

Periodssuck · 21/03/2025 05:07

My partner was on a site saying it’s not left v right but rich v poor, and pointing out Musk and Trump are not about to help most people. He got permanently blocked off all Meta apps (fb, Wattsapp, messenger, Insta). All of Meta.
I don’t get on there anymore. I really miss Instagram but I value freedom more.

Remember - these social medias are owned by someone who is protecting their agenda. Go to a publicly owned app.

AnyoneWhoHasAHeart · 21/03/2025 05:00

Petuniaspetal · 21/03/2025 03:53

The US can no longer be relied upon to have any diplomatic leverage in relation to the UK, or anywhere else it seems. If you end up inadvertently on the wrong aide of the law while.on holiday ....well dont expect any special favours. They can easily access your social media and if you are not a trump supporter you're toast.

Links to the articles of holidaymakers who are routinely being deported for criticising trump? Oh wait. There aren’t any.

We’re talking about one person here. one person who was clearly up to no good if the article linked to above is anything to go by.

But the rabbit hole dwellers and the gutter press are anxious to whip this into a frenzy about how if you go and see Mickey Mouse your phone will be searched and if you’ve said anything anti trump you’ll be deported when there is 0 evidence to support that.

the people buying into this shit are akin to the Covid conspiracy theorists and the flat earth brigade.

AlisonDonut · 21/03/2025 04:58

HangryLilacGoose · 20/03/2025 22:15

If "express hatred toward Trump" can qualify as terrorism, then then it's not safe for someone who expressed hatred of Trump to travel there - not least given that there now seem to be a pattern of foreign nationals (even US greencard holders) being detained (quite possibly unlawfully) by ICE.

So you are saying it isn't safe for people who have messages that meet the criteria of terrorism, not for everyday people?

AnyoneWhoHasAHeart · 21/03/2025 04:53

The responses to this are ridiculous.

There is clearly far more to this story than the edit are telling us. And let’s be honest here, people always claim they’ve done nothing wrong.

Customs aren’t stopping random tourists and asking to check their phones and anyone who has called trump a twat is being deported. For this man’s phone to have been checked he clearly already raised red flags and was found to have messages which amount to terrorism. Funny how the media haven’t published them to prove just how easily someone going to disneyworld is going to be deported. That’s because there are more to the messages than we’re being told.

As for all the hysteria over going to America, I absolutely wouldn’t want to live there, my DS’ GF is American and I absolutely don’t want him to live there either. But this notion of boycotting a country because you don’t like Trump is ridiculous. The man is a moron, but he and his cronies are likely to be in charge now for the foreseeable. And America is America. It’s not like the foreign office is advising people not to travel. The media are doing a good job of whipping up hysteria though.