Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS works on a 15 hour min contract at Coffee shop- how available does he need to be every weekend ?

112 replies

Munichfam5 · 19/03/2025 18:20

DS has been working at a medium coffee shop chain for a month , 15 hour min contract
we have a big family wedding on 25-27 April in London and so he has requested this time off

his boss has said he can’t have it as other people have requested it off and so he needs to sort out swaps with other staff members

But DS he hasn’t even has his schedule for that week yet and he doesn’t know all the staff properly yet

How demanding Can a coffee shop be when DS is on a 15 hour per week contract ?

TIA

OP posts:
Agix · 20/03/2025 06:21

You are "meant" to be available all the time in part time retail work, I imagine it's the same for coffee shop chains.

Yes, they do expect you to be free to cover sickness and holidays every single day on the basis of a part time contract. My contract was only 10hrs per week at one point on retail, but I was not allowed to not be available every day. You have to keep yourself free incase you get called in.

It's stupid. Thank god I don't work retail anymore.

GRex · 20/03/2025 04:18

I had similar at uni requesting time off at Christmas (but working new year) and was told no, you must work Christmas Eve. That would have made it impossible to get home. So I gave them my last shift date, but let them know I would remain open to coming back from X date if wanted. After 2 weeks they caved in and it was suddenly official holiday. The reason I could stare them out was that there were tons of part-time hospitality jobs. It's the same now, loads of jobs and not enough staff. I would advise him to give his notice while politely explaining it's only because he can't work those specific dates. He keeps his reference and it'll give the manager a few weeks to consider what s/he wants to do about it.

KittenPause · 20/03/2025 03:16

This is normal. My DD who is still at school has to arrange shift swaps or shift cover for things like this. It annoying but normal and expected.

LouisaPesel · 20/03/2025 02:44

And why, if he's a graduate is he only working 15 hours a week? Surely Amazon, Lidl etc are looking for full time staff.
This is the problem today. He's not standing on his own 2 feet at 21/2. He's relying on the helicopter parents to deal with his life for him. Surely if he's got a degree he should have mentioned the fact he can't work then.

Don't be a twit.

autisticbookworm · 20/03/2025 02:08

Totally normal for hospitality he will be expected to be available within opening hours but will only be guaranteed 15 hours. The manager can refuse annual leave if others are already off or if not enough annual leave had been accrued. Had he have given the dates at interview he would have been given the time off. His options are see what he’s working and attempt to swap shifts/lose shifts, call in sick (could lead to termination) or refuse to work and risk losing his job.

TwoShades1 · 20/03/2025 01:45

If other staff have already booked this time off, there isn’t much he can do? It’s first in best dressed at my partners work for holidays/time. If people are booking a proper holiday there can be stuff on the calendar 6 months or more in advance. He really should have made sure go got the time off booked in as soon as he started as he obviously knew about it.

ParrotParty · 20/03/2025 01:37

I would suggest longer term he starts applying for supermarket jobs. They are generally more reasonable, and have a lot more staff for if shifts need switching.

ParrotParty · 20/03/2025 01:35

Munichfam5 · 19/03/2025 18:25

@shellyleppard yes that sounds like what’s happened
but , if a job only guarantees 15 hours per week is he meant to be available All
week waiting to be scheduled for 15 hours ?
that doesn’t sound fair ?
I know a lot of people that work there are students so they can’t be available at all times ?

Does anyone. what the procedure is in this type of job ?
thanks

His contract should include availability windows which he filled out, unfortunately if he's put all day every day he will be expected to be available, and that will likely have made them pick him over candidates who gave smaller availability windows.

Agapornis · 20/03/2025 01:28

Par for the course in 'starter' jobs - I've seen it in hospitality, retail, theatres, cinemas.100% flexibility expect from employee, 0% flexibility from employer. Then make it the employee's problem to sort any days off.

What he needs to do is tell them he will not be available on certain days. He can then expect to be 'punished' by not getting shifts for a while, or lots of split shifts. Maybe he'll get the odd call some mornings asking if he can work that day. On and on, until they realise they are now short staffed and no one else wants the hours, or the manager moves on so no one remembers the grudge.

HeySnoodie · 20/03/2025 00:43

He can just tell the manager which days he can work and which days he can’t work that week. It’s the same in care, management expect total availability and have no regard for work life balance, which is shocking considering the poor pay

Dutchhouse14 · 19/03/2025 23:59

These kind of contracts infuriate me, DS was on a similar one at McDonald's.
Truth is they expect you to be available 24/7, 365 days of the year with about 5mins notice.
It was impossible to book a dentist appointment, haircut, family birthday, it was a nightmare.
And if they scheduled him to work, often a lot more than 15 hours, it was his responsibility to find cover if he needed time off, and no one wanted extra shifts. He left in the end.
In the ideal world they'd give you regular working days/hours so you can plan and know where you are. My daughter worked at matalan and knew she'd be workingTuesday evening and all day Sunday every week - bliss, But sadly this arrangement is unusual nowadays for retail and hospitality roles.
My advice would be to get experience then look for a job with a regular working pattern.
Basically he can either do the shift, try and get cover, phone in sick(won't like that and a bit obvious!) or resign

KIlliePieMyOhMy · 19/03/2025 23:56

Sofiewoo · 19/03/2025 18:37

Why didn’t he give them the date he needed off before he started?

Why is his mum trying to deal with things like this for a man in his 20s?

Would you consider this to be helpful or kind?

CarpetKnees · 19/03/2025 23:48

@Velmy

Many people on zero hour contracts very much appreciate the fact they can swap shifts to fit round their lives. That's one of the advantages of the system. Not just students (although a lot are students), but people with caring responsibilities (elderly parents, spouses, as well as dc), people who are just topping up pensions, or income whilst they are a SAHP, people who go away with sports or hobbies, people who struggle to work full time, people who have illnesses that leave them unable to work when they have flare ups but capable when they don't, and just people who get invited out and want to go!

Velmy · 19/03/2025 23:12

Cakeandusername · 19/03/2025 19:28

Is there a group chat? My dc was McDonalds zero hours. You got your rota a week in advance and if you wanted to switch or drop a shift she had to sort it. If it wasn’t taken people would put money on so £10 to take my shift.

Wow, this is wild. So not only do they push the responsibility from management to staff to resolve staffing issues, they have people paying each other for the privilege!

What a racket! 😆

SpikyCoconut · 19/03/2025 21:19

Cakeandusername · 19/03/2025 19:28

Is there a group chat? My dc was McDonalds zero hours. You got your rota a week in advance and if you wanted to switch or drop a shift she had to sort it. If it wasn’t taken people would put money on so £10 to take my shift.

I told a company I couldn't work Saturdays once when I took an office job.

They put me on a Saturday-I really couldn't work it-but £10 is a bargain!I paid a woman £50 to do it and that was probably around 2012!

premonition · 19/03/2025 20:47

My DD has a zero hours contract and it states in her contract that she will have the rota the week before. It also states that as long as she tells her manager her availability before the rota is out, she has the right to turn down shifts if she’s been rota’d on her unavailable dates. I’m sure it even says she doesn’t have to accept any work offered.

Obviously zeros hours and 15 hours is different, but surely people can’t be expected to keep all day every day free for the foreseeable future because they might be rota’d to work?

LlynTegid · 19/03/2025 20:29

MugsyBalonz · 19/03/2025 18:42

But the manager hasn't done the rota for that week yet so, even if he can't give annual leave, he could just rota the DS in on days other than those three.

The manager may not have written down who does what shift, however the number of people not granted leave will be known. So no surprise if say four staff are needed on Saturday and there are only four to choose from.

Schoolchoicesucks · 19/03/2025 20:12

The son can't ask anyone to swap shifts as he doesn't know which shifts he has been assigned.

Expecting him to be available 100% of the time in order to work 15 hours a week is unreasonable.

I hope he can find someone to swap once the rota has been done or that the Manager asks for other staff willing to pick up additional hours to cover the shifts they would have rota'd your son on for.

VerySkilledFirefighter · 19/03/2025 19:58

MontanaPink · 19/03/2025 18:58

It annoys me when bosss put the onus on the staff to cover (swap) shifts. It should be the responsibility of the manager.

Presumably the manager said the other people could have time off not knowing OP’s son also wanted it off. What’s he supposed to do, cancel someone else’s leave to solve the problem caused by OP’s son? Absolutely not, it’s not the manager’s problem.

Littletreefrog · 19/03/2025 19:50

littleluncheon · 19/03/2025 19:47

Outrageous that a business will pay for 15 hours, but insist on 70 hours of availability.

They do it all the time. However if this company are employing students they must be working around lectures etc so I imagine if negotiated at interview some days or half days may be blacked out as unavailable.

littleluncheon · 19/03/2025 19:47

Outrageous that a business will pay for 15 hours, but insist on 70 hours of availability.

Jabberwok · 19/03/2025 19:47

Sofiewoo · 19/03/2025 18:37

Why didn’t he give them the date he needed off before he started?

Why is his mum trying to deal with things like this for a man in his 20s?

And why, if he's a graduate is he only working 15 hours a week? Surely Amazon, Lidl etc are looking for full time staff.

This is the problem today. He's not standing on his own 2 feet at 21/2. He's relying on the helicopter parents to deal with his life for him. Surely if he's got a degree he should have mentioned the fact he can't work then.

I despair

CarpetKnees · 19/03/2025 19:40

Doggymummar · 19/03/2025 19:35

That's Easter isn't it? One of the busiest weekends of the year. They will need all hands on deck

No, Easter is the weekend before.

Tangtasic · 19/03/2025 19:36

The chances are that if more than one person has already requested the weekend off work, all other staff will have to work that weekend and there will be no one for him to swap with.

Doggymummar · 19/03/2025 19:35

That's Easter isn't it? One of the busiest weekends of the year. They will need all hands on deck