Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you leave 14yo alone in the country for one night?

282 replies

iloveapplesandcakes · 19/03/2025 04:58

Single parent here, no family around here, no support network.

DC is 14, very sensible. They'd go to school, I fly out at lunch time, they come back home, reheat dinner, stay overnight and go to school in the morning, I return home before they are back from school, I'd be away for about 30 hours. DC is happy with this idea, they can manage. I'm concerned about emergency situation. I badly need to go to help a close relative abroad. Can't take DC with me for a number of reasons, mainly school but also family issue which is the reason for need to travel.

Voting:
AIBU: I wouldn't leave DC alone, no matter how sensible they are.
YANBU: it's ok for DC to stay for 30h alone given desperate circumstances.

OP posts:
T4Tango · 19/03/2025 09:10

User5274959 · 19/03/2025 07:57

I know it doesn't help now, but you need to build a network. Dc needs someone to call if you are taken ill or don't come home when expected (on normal days I mean)

I agree with this, and it is what I am doing, as a fellow single mum. There are now four of us, who will be there for each other in such a situation. Our children aren't especially besties, but would be ok in an emergency to hang out and sleep over. Absolutely build your local network, OP. (And other single mamas.)

In answer to OP, no, I wouldn't do it, and I have a sensible 14yo too (and also a younger child).

ohtowinthelottery · 19/03/2025 09:08

Absolutely not without a back up plan for anything that might go wrong - child gets scared, something unforseen goes wrong in the house that child wouldn't know how to deal with eg power cut, leaking pipe, gas leak or something happens your end meaning you can't get back as planned (flight delay).
Unless you've got a friendly neighbour willing to help out ICE or your DC can stay over with a friend then it's a definite NO from me.

Your DC probably says they're fine with it now, but once they're on their own and know you're out of reach, it might be a different story.

mindutopia · 19/03/2025 09:07

I would ask if they could have a sleepover with a friend.

That said, my mum used to leave me home alone from 12/13 for 3-5 days at a time when she needed to travel for work. I was sensible and I took myself to school and made my dinners and looked after the dog. This was pre-mobile phones and the only time I heard from her was when she called me, so I couldn’t have even reached her in an emergency.

It was generally completely fine and I was happy to get on with it, except there was one time I fell down the stairs and dislocated my knee. I spent the next 24 hours until she came home on the sofa with a bag of frozen peas before she took me to A&E. That said, while nothing really terrible happened, my mum is definitely not the sort of parent I want to be. 😂 I would organise a sleepover.

Seeline · 19/03/2025 09:06

Whilst 14 yo may appear mature, they are still very much children.

The OP has not explained the back-up situation - the lack of a friend to stay with is surprising, but there has been no mention of supportive neighbours and presumably no nearby family or the DC could stay there.

There are so many ordinary things that could happen which would panic a normal 14yo, not to mention the unlikely but possible.

School closed down for boiler issues etc
Burst pipe
gas leak
smoke alarm/CO monitor going off
power cut - some can be lengthy, especially in rural areas
loss of phone signal
Being spooked by strange noise, storm etc
Being ill/having an accident (easy to cut yourself, slip in the shower etc)
Fire

I don't think it is fair to leave a 14yo overnight. I don't think it's right.

If you really can't find someone to stay with them, or someone they can stay with, then you have to take them with you.

lowlight · 19/03/2025 09:05

I think it would not be the end of the world to leave them overnight. You need to have emergency procedures in place for them to follow if a problem arose.

Have you got a neighbour or anyone close to hand if there was an emergency?

You say you have no one to help - what would your child do if you got run over? Surely you must have discussed some sort of plan if an emergency ever happened in your daily life?

SunshineAndFizz · 19/03/2025 09:05

Sorry but I’d see if they could sleep at a friends house.

TheHerboriste · 19/03/2025 09:03

LavenderBlue19 · 19/03/2025 08:55

I actually think there's a big difference in maturity between 14 and 16. 14 year olds are generally pretty silly, ruled by their hormones and peer pressure. 16 year olds tend to have grown up a bit, are more responsible and self-sufficient. There's a reason 16 is the legal age for a lot of things.

Personally I think it's too young for overnight, OP. I understand it's borderline though. I would try to take him with me - could he spend time with other family or friends there?

Edited

Depends on the kid. I know mature 14 year olds and dimwitted, flighty people at all ages.

Odds are that everything will be fine.

AnxiousOCDMum · 19/03/2025 09:03

iloveapplesandcakes · 19/03/2025 04:58

Single parent here, no family around here, no support network.

DC is 14, very sensible. They'd go to school, I fly out at lunch time, they come back home, reheat dinner, stay overnight and go to school in the morning, I return home before they are back from school, I'd be away for about 30 hours. DC is happy with this idea, they can manage. I'm concerned about emergency situation. I badly need to go to help a close relative abroad. Can't take DC with me for a number of reasons, mainly school but also family issue which is the reason for need to travel.

Voting:
AIBU: I wouldn't leave DC alone, no matter how sensible they are.
YANBU: it's ok for DC to stay for 30h alone given desperate circumstances.

No they’re still a child. If it’s a genuine family emergency school should authorise leave. Can he stay with a friend ?

Digdongdoo · 19/03/2025 09:02

Why can't you ask a school friend? Agency childcare? 14 is too young, and even more so if there's no support to call upon.

Fioratourer · 19/03/2025 09:01

My child is 15 and I wouldn’t do it until 16 and finished school. But even that worries me how would they cope in an emergency etc. In your situation I would rather they stayed with a friend if that’s possible.

chickensandbees · 19/03/2025 08:59

I would do it IF I had an emergency contact, plan for if something went wrong. I think they need to be able to call someone who can be there within half hour max if something goes wrong. Having noone is really difficult. I have people in the village that I only know through bumping into each other when I walk the dog but I know if I said in an emergency could DC call on you they would be fine with this, as would I. It doesn't mean DC has to stay with them or even see them but they need someone they can call if disaster strikes. Most people are kind and would be happy to help out in an emergency in my opinion.

Samesame47 · 19/03/2025 08:58

Absolutely not, not in any circumstance. Surely they have a friend they can stay with?

BackinBlack24 · 19/03/2025 08:55

No way , could they not stay in a friends house over night and go home after school the next day ?

LavenderBlue19 · 19/03/2025 08:55

thatsfunnybecause · 19/03/2025 06:18

What do people think is going to magically happen between 14-16?
If they were happy with the situation I absolutely would, responsibility and trust is good for teenagers.
presumably they have a phone and know an adult they can go to in an emergency? I would let a friend relative know they were alone but wouldn’t make them go and be babysat at 14

I actually think there's a big difference in maturity between 14 and 16. 14 year olds are generally pretty silly, ruled by their hormones and peer pressure. 16 year olds tend to have grown up a bit, are more responsible and self-sufficient. There's a reason 16 is the legal age for a lot of things.

Personally I think it's too young for overnight, OP. I understand it's borderline though. I would try to take him with me - could he spend time with other family or friends there?

MinnieCoops · 19/03/2025 08:54

No

Jk987 · 19/03/2025 08:54

There must be a friend or family member who can help even if it involves travelling to see you! Just ask! People like to help each other.

The child must have friends too?

TheHerboriste · 19/03/2025 08:48

HerOopNorth · 19/03/2025 08:19

I think MN tend to be ultra cautious and not always flexible.

A sensible 14 year old should be able to look after themselves for just over 24 hours when they are in school for the day.

As a society I think we have lost perspective. On the one hand, children are allowed access to all sorts on social media and smart phones, which are far more dangerous.

Yet when you consider that not so many years ago they were working at 14 , getting themselves up, out of the house, and being independent, the notion of 'risk' has changed.

OP if you can keep in touch with your child and they have a neighbour to call in an emergency, I think they'd be fine. But you know them best.

You'd need to lay the law down like no visitors etc.

Overall, I agree with this. I stayed home alone at 15 or so and it was not a huge deal, but we were in a semi with neighbours on the other side of the wall.

I watched TV (this was mid 1970s, no devices) and sneaked my mother’s cigarettes.

OP how close are the nearest neighbours?

TeenageRooster · 19/03/2025 08:42

iloveapplesandcakes · 19/03/2025 06:13

OP is only asking because she's in a bind, she's not asking if she should go out on an overnight jolly.

It wouldn't ever occur to me to leave DC alone overnight for any other reason, but this is a challenging family situation. There are no friends/classmates to leave DC with. There are a lot of flights daily to the destination so unless airport shutdown the delay wouldn't be a huge issue. It's emergency situation I'm concerned about

It's still the unknown factors in what you're doing that would worry me. Sure, there are lots of regular flights. But you're counting on being able to do what's needed to resolve this 'emergency situation' within the 30 hours and get back as planned. What if you can't? What if your relative hasn't told you all the details and it's worse than expected?

My other thought is: you've said there is no support for your teenager locally, just you. Are you also the only person who can fix this emergency situation abroad? Are there no other contacts who can help your relative, is there no way of paying someone to do what's needed? Why does it have to be you?

If you're the only person who can be the support in both situations, then someone has to lose out. For me, that would not be my teenager.

Chesticov · 19/03/2025 08:41

Oddsocksanduglyshoes · 19/03/2025 05:55

Hire an overnight babysitter from an agency or send to a friends house

I wouldn’t be inviting an overnight babysitter i.e. unknown person into the house.

BogRollBOGOF · 19/03/2025 08:40

OVienna · 19/03/2025 08:35

Yes but then it really isn't realistic to leave themalone unfortunately. She needs to take the DC or pay for someone to stay the night.

I wasn't saying that she should leave them. I wouldn't, but my 14yo clearly isn't ready anyway.

My point is that there's been several replies of people being incredulous that there isn't friends or family local or trusted enough to leave a 14 year old overnight with as though it's highly unusual. It's not highly unusual and is a common situation for people with long-distance families to be in.

vivainsomnia · 19/03/2025 08:40

Depends on your neighbourhood. If close neighbours they could run to in a significant event, yes. Middle of the country with no other house for a mile, no.

PowerTulle · 19/03/2025 08:39

You can’t leave the child with no support or emergency contact. No way.

Can you afford an emergency nanny for one night? At least then you have a responsible adult with your child. And they will be registered and DBS checked.

TheHerboriste · 19/03/2025 08:39

It would probably be ok but how is it that between the two of you there is not a single person who could be asked to help? Even just to be available in emergency?

Is your home that isolated?

What about a hired nanny for overnight?

OVienna · 19/03/2025 08:35

BogRollBOGOF · 19/03/2025 08:31

It's very easy to not have a support network.

Neither DH or I are "local"
DH's family are in another country.
Mine are scattered around the UK. Not that they're of a life-stage to have the capacity to support from a distance.
I have got some local friends that I made in my 20s- they are the best support that I have, but the DCs would be loathe to stay with them.
I didn't make school-gate friends because first I was working, then DS1's autism became apparent and that inhibited socialising. Then the Covid years through junior school re-shaped school friendships.
DS1 has no friends beyond school life.
DS2 has friends, but we are all families with autistic children (be it the child or their sibling) affecting our family social capacity. Having friends over to each other's houses causes significant disruption to our autistic children's routines. They mainly game online together or meet in neutral places like the park.

When you start with a poor social network it's difficult to build and expand it. We've had chunks of years with no appropriate babysitter avaliable. It's mainly been Rangers/ Explorers from local Guiding/ Scout groups, but their window of being the right age is short. At one point DH and I went 5 years without a night out together.
Most people near us have local family support so it's difficult to exchange mutual support favours without venturing into Cheeky Fucker territory.

I have friends and local aquaintances, but that doesn't translate into being the right support that my teenagers are comfortable with in an emergency.

It's not a particularly unusual situation to be in, and I can easily understand OP's predicament.

Yes but then it really isn't realistic to leave themalone unfortunately. She needs to take the DC or pay for someone to stay the night.

CurlewKate · 19/03/2025 08:34

@iloveapplesandcakesI probably would have- but it’s a bit concerning that he has no school friends he could stay with. Or is it that you just don’t want to ask? Because it sounds as if you’ve got enough to worry about without worrying about him too.