Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People who described themselves as teachers when they’re actually teaching assistance or cover supervisor

318 replies

KarlWrenbury · 13/03/2025 19:18

This is a thing I’ve noticed recently. Is it because they can’t be asked to describe what they really do or is it slightly more disingenuous? For reference no I don’t think it’s a great amazing thing to be a teacher but it’s interesting that they do.

assistants *

OP posts:
lawyer199112 · 13/03/2025 21:04

@Nevertrustacop yes only Solicitor and Barrister are but I wasn't going to pick at that given my chosen title - interestingly Legal Counsel also isn't protected. I had someone once ask at a new role if I was qualified (I'm in-house and can't imagine being called a "solicitor" now)

Enigma53 · 13/03/2025 21:04

WhatNoRaisins · 13/03/2025 19:21

Given that TAs are often made to do the same job when the teacher is off I can't say I blame them. I mean if it quacks like a duck.

Yes! If it quacks like a duck, you can sure as hell believe that it will be expected to swim like a duck ( quite often actually!)

Gymrabbit · 13/03/2025 21:03

Pieceofpurplesky · 13/03/2025 21:01

We had Michael Gove as Education secretary. He allowed it in free schools, academies and private.

It is cheaper and schools, sadly, are businesses

To be fair, it’s not just because it’s cheaper. Sometimes it’s all that we can find.

Loveanewusername · 13/03/2025 21:03

I think it’s something that is actually encouraged in school- we often call all staff the ‘teacher’

I actually assumed it was to stop children thinking they could ignore/ disrespect the ta and only have to follow direction from the teacher

it also is just easier to say it …

Pieceofpurplesky · 13/03/2025 21:01

Neodymium · 13/03/2025 20:57

How are you allowed to have unqualified teachers teaching classes? Is there not any regulations? In Australia, you must have a teaching qualification to be in front of the class. Even cover teachers must be fully qualified and registered. This is in both state and independent schools.

that said, we very often have teachers in secondary teaching outside their subject areas. There is actually no rules to stop that. Particularly in the sciences often in less attractive schools that struggle to get staff, they will have humanities or pe teachers teaching chemistry or physics.

We had Michael Gove as Education secretary. He allowed it in free schools, academies and private.

It is cheaper and schools, sadly, are businesses

Gymrabbit · 13/03/2025 21:01

Neodymium · 13/03/2025 20:57

How are you allowed to have unqualified teachers teaching classes? Is there not any regulations? In Australia, you must have a teaching qualification to be in front of the class. Even cover teachers must be fully qualified and registered. This is in both state and independent schools.

that said, we very often have teachers in secondary teaching outside their subject areas. There is actually no rules to stop that. Particularly in the sciences often in less attractive schools that struggle to get staff, they will have humanities or pe teachers teaching chemistry or physics.

Nope. No regulations especially in academies and private schools.
In reality the vast majority of teachers in secondary have a degree and a teaching qualification.

ParaParaParaphrase · 13/03/2025 21:00

Happyher · 13/03/2025 20:56

I know and she doesn’t claim to be one. The school obviously think she can replace a teacher though. She gets annoyed as teachers get far more than her and she does their job. But this may be why some TA’s say they’re teachers because they effectively carry out teachers work

They do parent’s evenings, plan, attend staff meetings, mark books, assess and input data, write reports, phone parent’s after school, meet other professionals, fill in outside agency reports and work at least a 40 hour week?

If they do and they are being paid as a TA I suggest they talk to their union rep.

Iceache · 13/03/2025 20:59

GreengageSummer75 · 13/03/2025 20:54

Sport and practical subjects are the most likely lessons for children to be injured in. But sure, let the cleaner or the dinner lady teach these lessons, I’m sure it won’t harm anyone.

I’m actually terrible at teaching PE and I hold QTS and am very specialised in my area. I’m also not first aid trained so am less useful with injuries etc than many of our TAs and dinner ladies.

Pieceofpurplesky · 13/03/2025 20:59

noblegiraffe · 13/03/2025 19:23

Teachers are literally the coolest people on earth so why would anyone not pretend to be one?

I know I am very cool because a Year 8 pupil told me I was today. I was able to discuss the inner workings of a Jedi temple with him and he was so impressed.

I did want to point out that nerd was probably nearer to accuracy than cool!

As for the title, in Primary TAs do more teaching as TAs in secondary are more likely assigned a class or pupil, rather than a teacher and they move about a lot. Regardless many are bloody invaluable and can call themselves what they want.

Gymrabbit · 13/03/2025 20:59

GreengageSummer75 · 13/03/2025 20:58

Great, let them.

No one is suggesting we shouldn’t let them. I was responding to your silly commment that the alternative to a qualified teacher teaching PE was to have a cleaner do it.

lawyer199112 · 13/03/2025 20:59

@Cosyblankets - the OP said earlier in a response "I don't mean to sound snobby" then recited the fact she can sign passports but TAs can't as if that's an indication of being better than TAs.

As someone whose mum is a HLTA and sister is a teacher (and who works in a profession filled with snobbery) I've no room for that sort of hierarchy and I'd tell my sister to pack it in if she said that to my mum.

I wouldn't expect a TA to go round saying "I'm a teacher" but my point was the semantics of saying "I teach children" (or "they do") seems a safe space if people aren't sure.

GreengageSummer75 · 13/03/2025 20:58

Gymrabbit · 13/03/2025 20:56

Don’t be ridiculous. A qualified sports coach would not be a qualified teacher but would be excellent at teaching KS3 PE.

Great, let them.

Neodymium · 13/03/2025 20:57

How are you allowed to have unqualified teachers teaching classes? Is there not any regulations? In Australia, you must have a teaching qualification to be in front of the class. Even cover teachers must be fully qualified and registered. This is in both state and independent schools.

that said, we very often have teachers in secondary teaching outside their subject areas. There is actually no rules to stop that. Particularly in the sciences often in less attractive schools that struggle to get staff, they will have humanities or pe teachers teaching chemistry or physics.

Gymrabbit · 13/03/2025 20:56

GreengageSummer75 · 13/03/2025 20:54

Sport and practical subjects are the most likely lessons for children to be injured in. But sure, let the cleaner or the dinner lady teach these lessons, I’m sure it won’t harm anyone.

Don’t be ridiculous. A qualified sports coach would not be a qualified teacher but would be excellent at teaching KS3 PE.

Happyher · 13/03/2025 20:56

ParaParaParaphrase · 13/03/2025 20:32

That doesn’t make her a teacher.

I know and she doesn’t claim to be one. The school obviously think she can replace a teacher though. She gets annoyed as teachers get far more than her and she does their job. But this may be why some TA’s say they’re teachers because they effectively carry out teachers work

CatsLikeBoxes · 13/03/2025 20:56

I was confused too for a moment, but assume they actually mean "can't be arsed"

Nevertrustacop · 13/03/2025 20:55

ParaParaParaphrase · 13/03/2025 20:48

If you left your job as a lawyer and started a job as a receptionist in a law firm, I’m fairly sure your employers would have something to say if you introduced yourself as a lawyer.

Lawyer is not a protected title either and anyone can legally call themselves one.
What do you imagine qualifies someone as a lawyer? Same with councillors or therapists. All entirely meaningless.
It's quite possible to Google a list of protected titles UK and there is not that many.

ParaParaParaphrase · 13/03/2025 20:54

Iceache · 13/03/2025 20:47

I’m a teacher and have two TAs in my class. One covers my PPA. I refer to both of them as ‘teachers’ when talking to the children. Neither of them call themselves teachers but honestly it’s just semantics; our roles and pay reflect our job titles and I think both of them are fabulous so I’ve no ego over someone not qualified being known by my job title!

The problem lies with people playing down the role of a teacher. Teachers are qualified to a degree level. It is a skill. If, anecdotally, people say that their mate Jill with zero qualifications, that’s been working in a restaurant her whole life, is now a teacher in a school, when she is actually a TA, people start to lose respect for teaching and more and more people will not take up the profession, because it won’t be seen as a profession.

We all love TA’s. They are amazing, good people. They don’t do half the job or hours of a teacher though.

GreengageSummer75 · 13/03/2025 20:54

KarlWrenbury · 13/03/2025 19:44

The problem with this I suppose if you get to the physicians assistant kind of status. The parents think that the person teaching their child is a qualified teacher with all the training that that entails.

I would not necessarily want an unqualified teacher teaching my children unless they were doing sport or practical subject, I suppose? Maybe. I dunno

Sport and practical subjects are the most likely lessons for children to be injured in. But sure, let the cleaner or the dinner lady teach these lessons, I’m sure it won’t harm anyone.

lawyer199112 · 13/03/2025 20:53

If I moved away from law and went into being a receptionist at a firm, I wouldn't be so insecure as to say I was a lawyer to people coming into the office and I'd be happy being on reception.

I would (as I said) be entitled to say to people that I'm a qualified but non-practicing lawyer... as my sister could say she's a qualified teacher who now works as a full time carer for her son.

utterlyfedup2 · 13/03/2025 20:53

Nevertrustacop · 13/03/2025 20:50

Well no one can call themselves a registered nurse if they are not on the register. But there is no public register of qualified teachers. It's just not a thing. If a school wanted to employ a teacher with qualified teacher status obviously they could, but they could employ anyone to teach who they thought capable of doing the job. And lots do.

Yes.

There is.

All qualified teachers are registered with the department for education and have a teacher number.

Cosyblankets · 13/03/2025 20:53

lawyer199112 · 13/03/2025 20:45

I found myself chuckling at this thread as a lawyer with a primary school teacher sister and a HLTA mum.

When discussing both my sister and mum, I say they both "teach" in primary schools. Or if describing my mums role solely (say, she's given me advice) I'll say "my mum teaches in a school and always says ABC". I never say my mum is a primary school teacher, but as some have said here she takes one day a week lessons and having worked at the same school with the same teachers for years, shares the prep with them including reports etc. I've gone as far as to ask her whether work she was doing (a decade ago when I lived at home) was the teachers work and she said "we're all a team".... except the teachers get a bigger salary and disgustingly let her take some of their work load home with her.

On a separate note, my sister has had to leave the profession to care for her son and I still say (and tell her) she's a teacher as she's qualified, worked as one for several years and always will be. I'd feel the same if I left my profession, I'd still be a qualified lawyer, just not a practicing one perhaps.

Just to add a different view to it. And I believe OP you said you don't want to "sound snobby" because you're a profession that can sign things - I still advise people to use an accountant/lawyer etc. rather than nurse/teacher.... people in glass houses!

I was with you until the passports.
I sign loads of them as a teacher

Iceache · 13/03/2025 20:51

I will also say that, hands down, my TA is a better teacher than pretty much every ECT and supply teacher I’ve ever met. She might not have QTS but I would rather leave my class in her hands than most ‘teachers’

Halifaxgirl · 13/03/2025 20:51

Teaching assistants do an amazing job and often teach under the direction of teacher.So many schools are employing TAs as the teacher it is not surprising they should call themselves that .
Qualifications and pay are at risk particularly in primary where TAs are often job sharing in my experience .Parents are not made aware of the difference in qualifications and often the TAs have a wealth of experience, but it is another erosion of the requirement for teachers to be trained and well qualified.

Nevertrustacop · 13/03/2025 20:50

utterlyfedup2 · 13/03/2025 20:27

Lots of qualified teachers choose to work as TAs or cover supervisors because it's far fewer hours and it means they mainly get to do the parts of a teaching job they actually enjoy (working with the children).

In my experience as a qualified primary school teacher, TAs who misleadingly and deliberately tell people they are a 'teacher' when they aren't actually qualified are the type of TAs who are a real pain in the butt to work with, are often on a power trip and have a superior attitude. They often make the actusl teacher's job harder.

The vast majority of TAs are amazing and worth their weight in gold. They are absolutely essential and deserve a huge amount of respect and gratitude. They are also appallingly underpaid and under appreciated. This does not mean they do the same job as a teacher. They are not teachers. They do some of the same duties but it is not the same.

When it's acceptable for nurses to call themselves doctors or cabin crew to call themselves pilots, then I'll think it's okay for TAs to tell people they are teachers.

Well no one can call themselves a registered nurse if they are not on the register. But there is no public register of qualified teachers. It's just not a thing. If a school wanted to employ a teacher with qualified teacher status obviously they could, but they could employ anyone to teach who they thought capable of doing the job. And lots do.