Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

if I told you I wanted to socialise with my surgeon

105 replies

EustaceEustace · 12/03/2025 19:13

you'd tell me he couldn't because it was inappropriate and that I was unreasonable for asking right?

But if you are famous, you can get your surgeon to do an interview with you, a cosy photoshoot and say things like:

“We’re going to be friends for the rest of our lives,” McCall says to him. “We are going to go out to dinner with our partners! We are GOING TO DO IT!”

https://www.thetimes.com/article/1c160a07-3b88-4e58-8db0-f5624a5ac4f6

Davina McCall: My brain surgery and the doctor who saved me
When the TV presenter posted on social media in November that she had a brain cyst, she was already on the operating table. Now the patient and her neurosurgeon, Kevin O’Neill, reveal their powerful bond

(paywall but basically an interview with her and her surgeon (from which the above is a direct quote) and a photoshoot - the image below is just one picture. There is another where he's in a suit and she has her hand draped over him

don't know if this will link:

https://www.thetimes.com/imageserver/image//2f5253ea-1e0d-4e18-9ae9-0857a96ad44d.jpg?crop=3543,2834,0,663

Makes me think less of him that he agreed to do it in that way because I bet almost everyone who has successful brain tumour surgery whether malignant or benign feels a huge emotional attachment and overwhelming gratitude to their surgeon - which is precisely why the professional rules about non-professional contacts with patients are so strict. The BMA even prohibits accepting social media friend request from patients!

AIBU to think she shouldn't have done this (i don't mean an interview about her surgery generally, I mean this 'emotional bond'/out for dinner/cosy photoshoot with the surgeon) or said what she said and he shouldn't have done it either.
and he wouldn't have done the same thing for someone non-famous (I get that is why there was interest from the paper - but say you had a leading allotment gardener who wanted to do the same thing in allotments weekly or a company secretary in company secretary monthly). Other patients could look at this and think, well if she can try to go out with him socially why can't I?

Davina McCall: My brain surgery and the doctor who saved me

When the presenter posted on social media in November that she had a brain cyst, she was already on the operating table. Now she reveals her bond with her surgeon

https://www.thetimes.com/article/1c160a07-3b88-4e58-8db0-f5624a5ac4f6

OP posts:
BadgersGalore · 13/03/2025 09:52

I love Davina but I found the surgeon a little strange when I read the article, all the talk of being an 'empath', his 'fashion model' girlfriend and these two other quotes that I've attached. Doesn't everyone's career depend on their memory? Should he be worrying more about operating on a famous person? He definitely comes across as star struck and I wouldn't want him as my surgeon with all his 'feelings' woo.

I get the impression the journalist was a bit sceptical too.

if I told you I wanted to socialise with my surgeon
if I told you I wanted to socialise with my surgeon
okright · 13/03/2025 09:41

YANBU. Why is "everyone" so needy for attention these days. Makes us more reserved types look like the weird. 😄.

CalicoPusscat · 13/03/2025 09:37

I think he's got stars in his eyes and has been swept away by her enthusiasm.

Mmhmmn · 13/03/2025 09:34

I’m not interested enough to read the articles. I just find her a really tedious attention seeker who should spend some time OFF social media and out of the limelight.

TorroFerney · 13/03/2025 09:30

YourBestFriend · 13/03/2025 09:25

She fancies him, simple as that.

That’s a bit unfair, she’s probably trauma bonded to him, he’s saved her life effectively. She is always keen and very enthusiastic about stuff , he’s probably got sucked into that (am still totally appalled by him saying he is an empath though!).

whatever she’s promoting she does give her heart and soul to, challenge is she’s got form for jumping on bandwagons. No sugar/zoe etc etc. this is slightly different not a bandwagon.

YourBestFriend · 13/03/2025 09:25

She fancies him, simple as that.

Ponoka7 · 13/03/2025 09:07

ForTealBee · 12/03/2025 20:44

It's different, but my aunt has become very close friends with her grief counsellor, and now her sessions are over she'll be socialising with her.

As long as no professional rules are being broken, I don't see the issue with becoming friends with someone you get along with.

You need to keep an eye on that friendship. It's completely inappropriate and could easily become abusive/toxic. I hope your Aunt doesn't have money/property that she can be persuaded to hand over.
I can remember Diana, Princess of Wales, popping up in operating theatres etc and anyone who spoke out against it was shouted down. For most ordinary adults who get sucked into fame, it doesn't go well.

ForTealBee · 13/03/2025 08:59

Mellivora · 13/03/2025 08:50

I have met two medical professionals in my life who were brilliant and after long courses of treatment I did say I wish we had met under different circumstances and had just been friends, both women like myself. I bought them both gifts and I look back and hope they are doing well.

@ForTealBee that is unprofessional and the therapist could be reported to their professional body.

It's all been signed off.

It happens. It's life, life happens and people shouldn't be punished.

Mellivora · 13/03/2025 08:50

I have met two medical professionals in my life who were brilliant and after long courses of treatment I did say I wish we had met under different circumstances and had just been friends, both women like myself. I bought them both gifts and I look back and hope they are doing well.

@ForTealBee that is unprofessional and the therapist could be reported to their professional body.

DearBee · 13/03/2025 08:41

I've met Kevin O'Neill a few times. He operated on my late partner about a decade ago (NHS - Charing Cross Hospital). My late DP had glioblastoma, which is sadly a very aggressive brain tumour with low survival rates.

I knew him as a kind and dedicated doctor, and also a pioneering one - he performed the ops when the other surgeons wouldn't, and he bought him an extra year of life and relatively good health.

They did go above and beyond, in that clinic. We had their mobile numbers. His assistant surgeon (who was training with them) called me as soon as the ops were over. They helped me so much when he deteriorated.

Brain tumours are cruel. I imagine Davina is in shock, still. Unless you have been there, don't judge. I imagine Kevin is still trying to raise more awareness - he's been chair of a charity that does so for a number of years now.

To the poster wondering if he is also an empath to his patients who aren't rich and famous - can't speak for everyone but he was really kind to us.

PreciousRighteousTeacher · 13/03/2025 08:32

@LadeOde bit of an urban myth probably that Joan Crawford had some back teeth removed to emphasise her cheek bones and give that sort of ‘sunken in’ appearance.

TorroFerney · 13/03/2025 07:31

TinyRebel · 12/03/2025 19:39

“Today, there is a rapport between McCall and O’Neill that is like that of old friends. “I’m an empath,” O’Neill says. He is a million miles away from the stereotype of the brain surgeon with a God complex. “I have to have an emotional connection with my patients.”

Sorry, but I run a mile from anyone who describes themselves as an ‘empath’ as I find them rather weird, creepy and full of themselves.

Hmm yes. How do you get through the day if you are an “empath” you’d be too sad all the time. Better to be cold and clinical!

he is angling for a tv career.

how can such an (academically) intelligent man use the word empath?

LetMeGoogleThat · 13/03/2025 07:24

Having gone throughout the same surgery, for the same type of brain tumour, I wanted to kiss my bloody surgeon. Colliod cysts sit silently growing in the brain, there are no symptoms and when they go wrong, they do so without warning and most don't survive. The majority are only diagnosed during a post mortem.

So, no I'm not judging either of them, I welcome the publicity and if it saves one life due to raised awareness, that's good enough for me.

Bimblebombzle · 13/03/2025 06:13

This isn't a very female friendly comment but given that she made a living out of being a role model- remember then DMc fitness DVDs etc.- I wish she would put some weight on. I worry that a bout of flu and there will be nothing of her! Eat some carbs.

Lavenderandbrown · 13/03/2025 01:06

@WaffleParty I agree something about him in scrubs and her in cocktail attire.. strapless in one and short dress in other seems off putting. Like there’s a hidden message /vibe there. Sexying it up bit as opposed to her in blouse and pants or more business like dress. Also the posing..

AlertCoralRobin · 13/03/2025 00:55

HRTQueen · 13/03/2025 00:26

Agree op it’s strange and he sounds weird and Davina just had a need to be public about her whole life

Remember, coils don't hurt, don't need pain relief....

AlertCoralRobin · 13/03/2025 00:55

NoWordForFluffy · 12/03/2025 19:24

I thought this was bizarre and inappropriate. Can't imagine even considering this with my surgeon, who I've been seeing (medically only!) for 2.5 years now, so I know him quite well.

How do.you know him quite well

HRTQueen · 13/03/2025 00:26

Agree op it’s strange and he sounds weird and Davina just had a need to be public about her whole life

HRTQueen · 13/03/2025 00:21

ForTealBee · 12/03/2025 20:44

It's different, but my aunt has become very close friends with her grief counsellor, and now her sessions are over she'll be socialising with her.

As long as no professional rules are being broken, I don't see the issue with becoming friends with someone you get along with.

your Aunties therapist is extremely unprofessional

it’s certainly unethical as they do not have a friendship they have a therapist/client relationship your aunt does not know her therapist on a personal level

many of my ex clients wanted to stay in touch you work on this and many I would have loved to know how they are doing but I have to keep professional boundaries for their wellbeing (and mine)

i am sure the therapists supervisor will have something to say about this

Confusedmeanderings · 13/03/2025 00:09

I do wonder if they actually will socialise or whether it was simply said for the purposes of the interview.

On the other hand, I do kind of socialise with my former GP. He was my GP for about 20 years and then retired. Not that we are friends particularly, but we do have friends in common and so we often come across each other. It was a bit weird at first, but I'm used to it now.

MasterBeth · 12/03/2025 23:15

FondantFancyFan · 12/03/2025 19:27

Her face seems to have sunken in as if she's got no back teeth.

You sound nice.

LadeOde · 12/03/2025 22:51

PreciousRighteousTeacher · 12/03/2025 19:28

@FondantFancyFan ah yes the old Joan Crawford trick.

What is that, removal of ones teeth? seriously, it seems she's lost a huge amount of weight (she was already slim before) i think it might be the something to do with her condition/treatment.

Restlessinthenorth · 12/03/2025 22:50

Totally agree OP. I have seen this on numerous occasions with those in the public eye becoming @friends for life" with midwives who have delivered their children. So, so inappropriate. I honestly don't know how they get away with it. I know for a fact of o started socialising with payments my employer and my regulator would be all over it!

kungfoofighting · 12/03/2025 22:49

KimberleyClark · 12/03/2025 22:33

Buccal fat removal?

She’s almost 60. (And looks amazing.)

Restlessinthenorth · 12/03/2025 22:47

ForTealBee · 12/03/2025 21:10

@kungfoofighting it's been signed off by her supervisor.

If the professional duty has been discharged I do think it's normal for people to click and become friends.

Honestly, I suspect it hasn't. Either that or they are in a highly dubious practice. Massive professional ethics issue and totally inappropriate