Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you have hung up on me

261 replies

spanieleyes22 · 12/03/2025 12:38

So I posted before about a "break up" with a friend of over 15 years around October last. I found it very hard as she wouldn't talk to me or discuss anything she just blocked me on everything. I sent her a Xmas card but no response. Yesterday I was feeling down and lonely I've been sick with a flu thing and am just very down. I remembered last year when I was sick she was the only person I really told as I don't want to moan to family and she checked in on me - by text- and I rang her number withholding my number. I did try doing that a couple of times back when it happened but she never answered just a voicemail message would come on. I suppose I didn't expect her to answer and when she did I was happy and said hi it's spaniel eyes and then long silence and I said please don't hang up but before I finished the sentence she had hung up. I know it was stupid of me. I've been really upset but annoyed with myself too. I know it's time to forget her now she couldn't make it any clearer. I'd just love to know why she feels she has to do this. Whatever happened I don't feel warrants this: I feel it's actually cruel. But I know you all will tell me to stop wasting my time so I'm trying to do that. I id hope for a minute or so but quickly dashed.

OP posts:
HellDorado · 13/03/2025 13:19

While I agree with the posters saying that the OP’s previous threads provide very useful context, it’s worth stating that, even if you haven’t read those, it’s still a fact that her ex-friend has blocked her and made it clear she doesn’t want to be contacted. Whether OP, or indeed anyone else on this thread, thinks that’s right or “fair”, is ultimately irrelevant - it’s her choice.

A lot of people on Mumsnet are very anti-ghosting. It’s “cruel”, “cowardly”, “unfair”; people are “owed an explanation”. Because of this, a lot of posters side with the ghosted party automatically, whatever the context. I’ve seen it on many threads. Well, at the risk of sounding like a primary school teacher, life isn’t fair. People don’t always do what they should, or what we think they should. And whether OP or anyone here thinks she’s been treated badly or is owed a hearing, she isn’t getting one. Ex-friend has made that clear, as is her right.

Fountofwisdom · 13/03/2025 11:46

user9632579 · 12/03/2025 18:57

Are you the poster who sent her birthday present late?

That’s what I was wondering but another poster said not.

LilacPeer · 13/03/2025 11:43

melonalone · 13/03/2025 11:35

I’m sorry this happened to you.

I knew someone like the OP once and I totally agree with you that unless you’ve been in the situation it’s hard to appreciate just how smothering it is.

I find it incredibly irritating that the OP is still posting about being a victim. It shows she will never accept her role in this, and will continue to blame this other woman who really sounds like she was left with no other choice. (Also all she did was block someone who refused to reduce contact with her - which is what the advice would be to do on here if she had posted for help!)

I wouldn’t be surprised if the OP ends up in trouble with the law.

Yes, this this this!! People genuinely cannot understand how stifling it is. One of my friends was whatsapp, send me a message on instagram, email, message my kids/other friends if i didnt respons within an hour. I had to turn all my notifications off, locations and last online status' off too. It became crazy.

melonalone · 13/03/2025 11:37

Also all the “oh I’m a terrible person” comments are so disingenuous and manipulative. Maybe you ARE a terrible person. You seem to care more about getting your own way than you do about anyone else’s feelings.

melonalone · 13/03/2025 11:35

fitzwilliamdarcy · 13/03/2025 10:55

I've only ghosted one friend and I'll be honest, the main reason why was because she saw everything as a starting point for negotiation. In my view we'd grown apart; she had a baby and then everything became about parenting/child, she'd literally never talk about anything else and even when she knew I was seriously ill in hospital she'd be texting all day about what her child had been doing/saying and never asking about me. I had surgery which made me infertile around the time her child was born, which again she knew about, so it kind of felt doubly-difficult that she couldn't talk about anything else.

She was an intense person who would send a text, then if no response within an hour she'd whatsapp me, then another hour and it'd be a FB message. I knew that any conversation about us not being friends anymore would be like the Brexit talks and so it was just easier to not respond to anything and hope she got the message. Every so often she does send messages still and it's been a few years now, which makes me feel terrible, but unless you've dealt with someone like this it's really hard to understand why ghosting seems like the only good option.

Please just leave this person alone and explore your feelings in therapy, OP. It'll do you the world of good in making friends going forward.

I’m sorry this happened to you.

I knew someone like the OP once and I totally agree with you that unless you’ve been in the situation it’s hard to appreciate just how smothering it is.

I find it incredibly irritating that the OP is still posting about being a victim. It shows she will never accept her role in this, and will continue to blame this other woman who really sounds like she was left with no other choice. (Also all she did was block someone who refused to reduce contact with her - which is what the advice would be to do on here if she had posted for help!)

I wouldn’t be surprised if the OP ends up in trouble with the law.

LilacPeer · 13/03/2025 11:31

spanieleyes22 · 12/03/2025 14:06

It makes me sad that she must have hated me so much she had to block me. After so many years. But I have to accept there is something in my personality that she didn't like

I think part of the problem might be the way you interpret things. In no part of my comment did I say I hated either of the friends I'd distanced myself from. In fact quite the opposite, I loved them both dearly, but in the end, they were not friendships I could continue for my own wellbeing. I gave all of myself to these friends for years and years and in the end when at rock bottom, something had to give.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 13/03/2025 10:55

I've only ghosted one friend and I'll be honest, the main reason why was because she saw everything as a starting point for negotiation. In my view we'd grown apart; she had a baby and then everything became about parenting/child, she'd literally never talk about anything else and even when she knew I was seriously ill in hospital she'd be texting all day about what her child had been doing/saying and never asking about me. I had surgery which made me infertile around the time her child was born, which again she knew about, so it kind of felt doubly-difficult that she couldn't talk about anything else.

She was an intense person who would send a text, then if no response within an hour she'd whatsapp me, then another hour and it'd be a FB message. I knew that any conversation about us not being friends anymore would be like the Brexit talks and so it was just easier to not respond to anything and hope she got the message. Every so often she does send messages still and it's been a few years now, which makes me feel terrible, but unless you've dealt with someone like this it's really hard to understand why ghosting seems like the only good option.

Please just leave this person alone and explore your feelings in therapy, OP. It'll do you the world of good in making friends going forward.

ItGhoul · 13/03/2025 10:54

HarLace1 · 13/03/2025 08:03

Can I ask how old she is? Because her behaviour is pretty pathetic she could at least have the balls to say I don't want to be friends because 'you did this, you did that, I don't get anything from the friendship anymore" and so on. However, as much as it hurts and you are completely in the dark about why this has happened, would u really want to be friends with her again if this is how she treats people? Rather than actually have the decency to say to you why u aren't friends anymore? At least u would have had some closure on the friendship.

Please forget about her, you also don't want to look desperate which unfortunately you'll start to look like.

You might want to read the whole thread, and perhaps the many others the OP has posted about this, in which it is made clear that the friend actually did tell the OP why she was ending the friendship. The short version is that the OP kept pestering her for a level of contact which the friend couldn't keep up, the friend explained she was busy and trying to use her phone less and needed some space, and the OP then continued to contact her and sent her a 'nasty' message calling her cruel/mean for not messaging as often as the OP wanted. The friend then clearly told the OP that she was ending the friendship because the OP couldn't respect her need for some space, and blocked the OP. Ironically, the OP responded to that by repeatedly continuing to try to contact her after she had been asked not to.

Pherian · 13/03/2025 10:53

I’m not sure where you live, but all it takes where I live is 3 instances of unwanted contact and it’s considered stalking / harassment.

I don’t know what happened between you but it’s irrelevant. This person has made it clear they don’t want to speak to you.

You might want to get some professional help, like maybe a therapist to talk to so you can get help getting through that. It’s really important you respect peoples boundaries because as an adult there can be serious consequences In not doing so.

Im sorry this person is treating you this way, but they are not your friend any longer.

1989whome · 13/03/2025 10:17

You only want to talk to her just so you can have your say on why she shouldn't stop talking to you. I hate to say it but I have cut off a friend/relationship that I had for a long time coz i couldn't fucking breathe around this person! All about them, constantly! If you didn't show the attention they wanted, they would get visible emotional. It's coz he wanted someone to talk to not because I do, my feelings didn't even come in to it lol. It's draining, I had no desire to keep repeating what I'd been saying for ages, respect my boundaries you don't get to text me 20 times a day and demand my attention. So if you are the needy friend in this situation, that's whym. Because it's all consuming and no one has got time for that. Think about what others are going through not just your self.

ThisZanyPinkSquid · 13/03/2025 10:05

So I have blocked ex friends as something has happened or they are just too much toxicity and didn’t want to hear it when I brought it up. I would have hung up too in all honesty!! I cut them off for their toxic ways to protect my little family….for whatever reason you need to respect that it’s what she wants 🤷🏼‍♀️

Jumpingthruhoops · 13/03/2025 09:58

Ah, I see... thanks for explaining. That makes a lot more sense. Context is everything, eh?

ZebedeeDougalFlorence · 13/03/2025 09:36

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Oh, I didn't read the other threads. This makes me see this in a different way. However that doesn't stop me wanting to sympathise with the OP. She obviously needs to do some work at learning how to trust herself, build esteem and not be so dependent on other women.

I wish you the best of luck moving forward, op. I sincerely hope that in time you will find friendships which are mutually nurturing.

Spacehop · 13/03/2025 09:33

PeggyMitchellsCameo · 12/03/2025 14:18

OP I replied to one of your previous threads.
I am sorry you are upset you sound really distressed.
Yes, you’ve made a mistake but it’s not like you’ve run someone over or clubbed them around the head.
If you want to make friends, start with yourself.
If you can’t work out what’s happened with this friend, but then start calling yourself names, you are not going to make progress.
You could still be sitting here in a year ruminating about what happened with this friend.
I am a pretty decent person and I blocked a friend at some point. It was for repeatedly crossing a boundary but there was a constant background that I was her only real friend, her self esteem was very low, and it got too much for me. And yep if she called me now I would put the phone down.
I have been in your shoes and it was horrible but at some point I thought… no more. And it was hard pushing myself to try new things. I got some therapy. I made myself go out into the world.
Find something to be of service or be in a group. Help at a food bank. Join a choir. Do something to get out of your headspace and into the real world.
You have phoned this friend at a low point. She has sensed it and thought, no. Not again.
So it’s your responsibility to act. Nobody in life owes us anything and having a decent friendship means being a positive presence.
Start with you. The way you speak about yourself jumps from your posts. It’s not helping you.
You are clearly a great mum so start there. Go out there and find something to do, what it is doesn’t matter. And friendships need more than WhatsApp messages. When you meet people in person these confusions happen less.
So try be thinking…
I am good person and I made a mistake.
A friendship ended and it left me feeling hurt and confused.
I have been down and now I’m poorly. I’m going to make a hot drink, have a nice bath or shower and watch a TV show I like and enjoy which makes me laugh.
I am going to write a small list of little things I can do for myself - go to a nice bookshop, check out what’s happening locally, treat myself to a new lipstick.
One of the things that comes from helping others is that it lifts you out of yourself, and it bonds you to others. You will meet like-minded people.
I did this by going to my local church which is outside of my religion and they took me in. There is always something going on, I’ve met some lovely ladies, too.
Today do for yourself what you wanted this friend to do - be kind to yourself and give yourself a fresh chance

Edited

This is brilliant advice OP from someone who gets it totally. Follow it.

ZebedeeDougalFlorence · 13/03/2025 09:31

spanieleyes22 · 12/03/2025 14:06

It makes me sad that she must have hated me so much she had to block me. After so many years. But I have to accept there is something in my personality that she didn't like

Stop beating yourself up. There is nothing wrong with you. I have a different experience to @spanieleyes22. I have been blocked by at least 3 women in my lifetime (actually, this was before blocking as we know it existed). Two them eventually told me why they hated me: you won't believe this, but they both confessed that I was lovely and that they were jealous of me! I couldn't believe it. Me?! Who would be jealous of me?

The third hasn't told me why she is distancing herself from me but I know that she has been going through an extremely stressful time and took it out on me.

So, I would say that everyone's experience is different and you don't sound like an awful person to me. As others have said your friend has her reasons and they may actually have very little to do with you. You have to move on. You need to focus on how you can get your own needs met. This will enable you to make much stronger relationships in the future.

YourBestFriend · 13/03/2025 09:25

You need therapy urgently. Wishing you all the best.

OhCalmTheFuckDownMargaret · 13/03/2025 09:15

Tiredofallthis101 · 13/03/2025 08:00

Hmmm whilst I agree that you shouldn't have rung her and you need to work on being a bit 'needy' we have no idea why she is behaving as she is and I don't agree that it is necessarily about your behaviour. Who knows. I don't think you should take this 100% on your shoulders- personally I think it is cowardly to just block someone and not explain why or attempt to communicate in any way, as it leaves people feeling lost like you do. It makes life easier for the person blocking but is unkind to the recipient. So I wouldn't assume you are just a needy terrible friend and it is all your fault. I would though work on your inability to just let her go, and also think through the signs in the relationship that all wasn't well which probably were there, which could be her responses to your behaviour or could be that she was actually just not a very nice person and you missed that. Building better emotional intelligence can only be a good thing, even if you aren't at fault.

Read the previous thread. The friend was quite clear.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 13/03/2025 09:13

HarLace1 · 13/03/2025 08:03

Can I ask how old she is? Because her behaviour is pretty pathetic she could at least have the balls to say I don't want to be friends because 'you did this, you did that, I don't get anything from the friendship anymore" and so on. However, as much as it hurts and you are completely in the dark about why this has happened, would u really want to be friends with her again if this is how she treats people? Rather than actually have the decency to say to you why u aren't friends anymore? At least u would have had some closure on the friendship.

Please forget about her, you also don't want to look desperate which unfortunately you'll start to look like.

Read the thread, and OP’s previous ones. She does know why the friend dropped her - because OP was effectively stalking her and making demands on her time she couldn’t meet, she’s still stalking her now with anonymous phone calls and is heading for police involvement if she doesn’t get help.

Flamingoknees · 13/03/2025 09:08

So you tricked her into answering your call OP. That's really not good. Youe reasons for ringing her this time (for support) are probably a huge clue as to why she's gone NC. It was all about you.
She should of had the decency to end the friendship by explaining this, but she is being clear now,that she wants no contact.
It's hurtful, but you need to move on, and find ways to make new friends. You are wasting too much valuable time and headspace thinking about this woman.

Obsessedwithveg · 13/03/2025 08:41

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Floatlikeafeather2 · 13/03/2025 08:36

Please, all you people saying to OP, "oh you poor thing", have a look at her previous posts. She's not a young girl - she has at least one adult child. Her others may well be older than that. She does know what she's done because her friend has told her. She is persecuting her - she was asked to first give her some space and stop contacting her back in October. The friend blocked her number because she would not stop. The friend has clearly been pushed to this. In these circumstances, phoning from a withheld number is unforgivable and shows what little respect OP has for her. You are not doing her any favours with all the hand patting. Please have a look at her other threads to get the full history, which includes her sending "nasty" texts (her word) to the friend. She clearly needs psychiatric help and she should be guided in that direction, not told what a poor little thing she is. That's what she wants to hear and the next thing will be her turning up on the friend's doorstep to confront her "because that's what people on Mumsnet said I should do".

Obsessedwithveg · 13/03/2025 08:31

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

alwaysdeleteyourcookies · 13/03/2025 08:25

It would have been better if she had had the guts to tell you why she was ending the friendship but sadly people prefer to avoid the difficult conversation and just slowly back away, hoping the other person will get the message.

OP was told. There are previous threads, as OP has said. She wasn't ghosted. She just doesn't want to accept her friend's decision.

Ellabellahockney · 13/03/2025 08:22

There’s probably a lot wider picture at her end.

my being her was my bff had a nervous breakdown and I was her crutch and my mum got cancer, I needed a friend for lighter times and got used as an emotional punch bag still after saying time after time I couldn’t cope with
another’s difficulties.

Goody2ShoesAndTheFilthyBeast · 13/03/2025 08:19

It would have been better if she had had the guts to tell you why she was ending the friendship but sadly people prefer to avoid the difficult conversation and just slowly back away, hoping the other person will get the message.

It's often advised on here. And claimed to be an attempt to avoid hurting the other person which makes me laugh because that's bollocks.

That said, she has through her actions made it very clear she no longer wants you in her life. You must respect that. It's unfair that you don't know why (if you dont) but life has never promised us fairness. Or closure for thst matter.

I think you do know what the problem is. You just don't want to admit it, maybe even to yourself. Perhaps your friend did talk to you about your neediness or lack of boundaries in the past but you didn't understand what she was saying.

You come across as very intense, quite dramatic and some of your replies have been somewhat manipulative and passive aggressive. I'm not saying this is intentional but it is how you come across. I presume this is how you are in real life and if so, people will continue to pull away from you.

Which is sad because it will make you more intense, fearful, dramatic etc.

You need some sort of therapy and to build your confidence. See if you can talk to your GP and find out what is available.

You can use this painful experience to turn your life around.