Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if your car normally passes it's MOT.

180 replies

girlfriend44 · 10/03/2025 15:17

Car passed Mot today, and did last year too. I'm thankful.
Is this normal?

OP posts:
Toddlerteaplease · 13/03/2025 07:06

My three year old Hyundai i10 failed its first one! Fortunately it's still under warranty. It took 2 months to get a new part!

Beepbeepoutoftheway · 13/03/2025 07:05

megacat · 12/03/2025 20:21

@Beepbeepoutoftheway so in 12 years your car was not serviced and passed every mot, so it never had tyres? Brakes? Other general wear and tear? Tyres over 8 years old need changing regardless of wear.

Unless it never went further than the end of the road you're talking nonsense! The oil filter alone will have rusted to dust in that time without a change.

The tyres were replaced when they needed changing. The oil was never changed. I'm not sure why you think it's nonsense when it was my car not yours. Quite bizarre you're getting so annoyed by it tbh.

BlackeyedSusan · 13/03/2025 02:25

Mine's passed most years. Until this year. Big bill. 15 year old car. Had advisories and a few minor issues before but nothing major.

Tarkan · 13/03/2025 01:52

We have a 12 year old Mazda 3 (almost 13 I guess, it’s a 62 plate) and it’s only ever failed once, 3 years ago. It was an easy fix though so passed the next day after the work was done. We know the brake pads will need to be done before the next MOT though so we’re getting that sorted soon.

The Corsa we had before the Mazda was a nightmare in comparison. Every single MOT it needed work done and it cost us a small fortune every year. The woman who crashed into it and wrote it off while it was parked did us a massive favour to be honest.

MrsClatterbuck · 13/03/2025 00:37

Mine hasnt but when taking my dm car once it failed due to one tyre. Guy told me just to go and get it sorted and then come back. Which I did and it then passed. In NI so we have Mot centres. Due to a decision by the Minister who deals with MOT I got an exemption from my Mot for 1 year. It is an absolute nightmare trying to book your car for the MOT. If you wait for the letter to advise you it is too late.

CrispEater2000 · 13/03/2025 00:28

My car will be 13 years old this year. Previous owner was an older gent who had it from new.

I've owned it around ten years. I've had a friend give it a service and MOT almost every year. The service is nothing too expensive. Nowhere near what the main dealer charges.

The one year I did take it elsewhere for an MOT it was the main dealer and it failed due to the height of the headlight beam. As this is adjusted from a dial on the dashboard they set the correct height and retested without me knowing it had failed until it picked it up. The only fail it's ever had.

They put the tyres on advisory too but having measured tread depth myself I knew they were fine. They were just looking for an upsell. Makes me glad I can trust my friend.

angelspike · 12/03/2025 23:54

@Negroany yes? The car doesn't have to be serviced at the dealership, you can take it anywhere
It's no issue to me where you get it serviced or whether you do or not, but explaining to customers that no the warranty isn't valid and that engine management light isn't covered because they didn't have any service done on it isn't a fun time

We fix faults under warranty day in and day out, thousands of pounds worth

Negroany · 12/03/2025 23:26

angelspike · 12/03/2025 23:19

If it's new then no you don't have to get the car serviced but it will invalidate the manufacturers warranty
It would be really really stupid not to service a new car while it's still under that
(I work for a dealership so deal with this stuff daily)

As an example that has happened, you buy a brand new car and miss the first service. Engine goes at 18 months old. You've invalidated the warranty so now facing a 15k repair bill
Or you had the service and it's all covered

And you work for a dealership you say........ 🤔

angelspike · 12/03/2025 23:19

If it's new then no you don't have to get the car serviced but it will invalidate the manufacturers warranty
It would be really really stupid not to service a new car while it's still under that
(I work for a dealership so deal with this stuff daily)

As an example that has happened, you buy a brand new car and miss the first service. Engine goes at 18 months old. You've invalidated the warranty so now facing a 15k repair bill
Or you had the service and it's all covered

Negroany · 12/03/2025 23:15

Badbadbunny · 12/03/2025 07:52

@Sw1989

I can't believe the amount of posters on here saying they don't service their cars, that's just asking for expensive problems later down the line.

Amazes me too. But then again it may explain why people think the only way to have a "reliable" car is to always buy new on 3 year leases. No wonder they end up breaking down and having huge repair bills on older cars if they can't be arsed to have them serviced and look after them. They're probably the ones who drive badly too, i.e. bouncing up/down kerbs to park, heavy acceleration and braking, bouncing too fast over potholes and rough tracks, etc.

Weird.

I've never had a lease car nor bought new. My car is nine years old, over 100k and has never broken down. My last car did 220k miles, never broke down, never didn't start.

I'm not sure who is getting these "huge repair bills" but it's not me. I did just pay £600 for new brakes and discs, but they are consumable items so need replacing now and then. Not a "repair bill" as such.

I've not noticed myself bouncing up and down or over kerbs. I'm not sure how that follows at all. As I don't get my car serviced surely I'd drive more carefully if anything?

Negroany · 12/03/2025 23:07

Catza · 12/03/2025 21:55

Because you have to. Your car manual specifies how often your car should be serviced. If you have a new car and don't get it serviced, it completely invalidates your warranty. Even if you don't drive your car a lot (mine does fewer than 4k miles a year) you should still do full service annually or at the very least top up fluids, change oil, power steering fluid intermittently.

You quite simply do not "have to" at all. I've never had a new car, so never had a warranty to invalidate (a total scam anyway!) as they don't transfer to new owners.

But even if you do have a new car, you still don't "have to" get your car serviced.

Catza · 12/03/2025 21:55

girlfriend44 · 12/03/2025 21:47

Cars can still be OK without services etc.....
Last two cars never had them and were fine.
Why pay out more money unless you have too.

Because you have to. Your car manual specifies how often your car should be serviced. If you have a new car and don't get it serviced, it completely invalidates your warranty. Even if you don't drive your car a lot (mine does fewer than 4k miles a year) you should still do full service annually or at the very least top up fluids, change oil, power steering fluid intermittently.

girlfriend44 · 12/03/2025 21:47

Badbadbunny · 12/03/2025 07:52

@Sw1989

I can't believe the amount of posters on here saying they don't service their cars, that's just asking for expensive problems later down the line.

Amazes me too. But then again it may explain why people think the only way to have a "reliable" car is to always buy new on 3 year leases. No wonder they end up breaking down and having huge repair bills on older cars if they can't be arsed to have them serviced and look after them. They're probably the ones who drive badly too, i.e. bouncing up/down kerbs to park, heavy acceleration and braking, bouncing too fast over potholes and rough tracks, etc.

Cars can still be OK without services etc.....
Last two cars never had them and were fine.
Why pay out more money unless you have too.

OP posts:
YourBestFriend · 12/03/2025 21:26

In 17 years, I have failed MOT only once. 10 of those years I have owned two cars. So yes, fairly normal.

TiredEyes25 · 12/03/2025 21:18

Shade17 · 10/03/2025 18:17

It’s completely standard to MOT first then service if both are being done at the same time. It’s called “test as presented” by the DVSA and it gives a more accurate picture of the failure rate of cars on the road.

There are other benefits as well, it means only one visit to a service ramp rather than having to visit again after MOT to fix any issues. It also prevents cars which might be scrapped from running up a service bill first, if I carry out a £300 service to your car then MOT it and you decide to scrap or sell it as a non-runner then you’ll still be paying the £300 bill.

Yes this.
We've had this before with customers

TiredEyes25 · 12/03/2025 21:14

We also service it every year. Basic oil and filter one year. Major sevice, all filters. Gear box oil change and whatnot, the following and so forth.

TiredEyes25 · 12/03/2025 21:11

Yes never had a failure and 2 advisories in 10 years

megacat · 12/03/2025 20:21

@Beepbeepoutoftheway so in 12 years your car was not serviced and passed every mot, so it never had tyres? Brakes? Other general wear and tear? Tyres over 8 years old need changing regardless of wear.

Unless it never went further than the end of the road you're talking nonsense! The oil filter alone will have rusted to dust in that time without a change.

StrawberryWater · 12/03/2025 19:45

Passes most of the time. It's sailed through the last 3 MOTS with no advisories. Not bad for a car that's getting on a bit.

I get it serviced every other year.

angelspike · 12/03/2025 19:38

@Beepbeepoutoftheway yes but you were lucky! Many cars wouldn't have and it could have ended up needing a whole new engine
For the sake of paying for an oil and filter change

Beepbeepoutoftheway · 12/03/2025 19:24

angelspike · 12/03/2025 17:55

Oil after 12 years will be absolutely manky though
I don't service mine as often as some but 12 years is asking for issues, it'll be like sludge

Manky enough that it still continued going though.

hookiewookie29 · 12/03/2025 19:00

My vehicle is 34 years old. Passes MOT nine times out of ten- probably because there's not much to go wrong on it as it's so old!

angelspike · 12/03/2025 17:55

Oil after 12 years will be absolutely manky though
I don't service mine as often as some but 12 years is asking for issues, it'll be like sludge

Beepbeepoutoftheway · 12/03/2025 16:13

jasflowers · 12/03/2025 16:01

In 17 years, your car never had an oil and air filter change? or do you mean a garage service?

Even if you did just 5k a year, thats 85000 miles....

Most car oil change intervals on an older car will be yearly/6000 to 10000 miles.

I had it for 12 years and in that time, it never had a service.

jasflowers · 12/03/2025 16:01

Beepbeepoutoftheway · 12/03/2025 15:53

How very presumptuous of you.

I never had my old car serviced and it lived to 17 years old. It sailed through its MOTs too.

And my driving is fine thankyou 🙃

In 17 years, your car never had an oil and air filter change? or do you mean a garage service?

Even if you did just 5k a year, thats 85000 miles....

Most car oil change intervals on an older car will be yearly/6000 to 10000 miles.