Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Or does this sound intentional

215 replies

MaybeBaby1313 · 05/03/2025 16:10

I’ve name changed for this and will try to give as much info as I can to get the best responses.
So apologies for the length

I’ve been with my DH for 7 years, married for 4.
Generally things have been good most of the time.

We don’t have DC, which isn’t relevant to my post but is something that people may ask.

However DH has an intellectual disability and is also neurodiverse, but is exceptionally good at masking so I didn’t realise the full extent of his issues until we lived together.

The biggest issue he has is that when he is upset, usually over something minor, to him it’s huge. He feels his life is over if he has a minor setback and tends to lash out verbally and say the most awful things, I’m told he did this to his parents as a child, and it’s something he’s continued in to adulthood but now I get the brunt of it.

He calms down quickly and is always very sorry for the things he’s said, He has never been physically abusive in any way
he runs away (literally) from any kind of conflict or argument and generally seems to struggle with managing his emotions.

BUT

At times when things between us have been absolutely fine, he would hug me and squeeze a little too tight, not every time, just sometimes.

This would leave my breathing restricted for a few seconds so I’d try to speak or poke him etc to get him to let go.

He would apologise:/ say he didn’t mean to hold me that tight and we’d move on.

But, I started to notice it was happening often, and that it was taking him longer to let go when I tried to alert him to being unable to breathe. I started to feel it may be intentional, although couldn’t figure out the point of it.

I bought it up, made sure not to accuse, just said that he was cutting off my air supply sometimes when he hugged me

And it stopped for a long time.

Lately, he’s taken to coming up and hugging me from behind if I am sat at my desk etc, which seems lovely but he is hugging me by putting his arm around my throat.
And squeezing.

Being mindful of before, I didn’t react. Because if it is deliberate then he must be looking for a reaction.

The first time, he let go, as you would after a hug

The next time, he repositioned himself slightly, and then ‘hugged’ again, tighter

I still didn’t react, so he shifted slightly and did it again.

This has now happened multiple times
So I no longer feel it’s unintentionally just being a little heavy handed with the hug

The last time he did it, although I hadn’t reacted he says ‘sorry, couldn’t you breathe’

So it’s clear to me that he does know what he’s doing and that he’s looking for me to react and tell him I can’t breathe, so when I haven’t done that, he’s doing it harder to get the reaction

Now, I want to be clear that I am strong enough to push him off me, I’ve allowed it to happen so I can try and figure out what he’s trying to achieve but I do not feel in any real danger and would not let him do it to a point where it was dangerous.

But, am I over reacting to a too tight hug, or is he trying to restrict my breathing?

And if he is, why?
He doesn’t lash out physically when he’s upset or angry or at times where it would make sense (although it still wouldn’t be acceptable)

So what is the point in cutting off my air supply for a few seconds in a hug, and then letting go? When life is otherwise good

I just don’t get it, which is why I thought it wasn’t intentional but there’s just no way it can be accidental at this point,

incase it’s relevant, he isn’t controlling in any way, in fact I have the most control in our lives, including with finances.

OP posts:
Theseventhmagpie · 05/03/2025 19:16

Leave. You are in danger.

NebulousDogBollocking · 05/03/2025 19:15

@MaybeBaby1313 are you not reacting so he can't blame you for reacting? You know how they can set you up to react so you'll look like the crazy one? Is that what you're thinking with that? A kind of grey rock thing?

If you didn't know before (I suspect your instincts were telling you or you wouldn't have posted), you'll see from all of our reactions that your situation is way beyond that. Please do whatever you can to get yourself away from him safely as soon as you can Flowers

wizzywig · 05/03/2025 19:12

Could be sensory seeking behaviour. Could be something sinister

EdithStourton · 05/03/2025 19:11

You OP gave me the chills.
I think you should leave. I would not rehanging around to find out how far he would take this behaviour.

IDoWhateverItTakes · 05/03/2025 19:10

He's getting off on hurting you and ramping it up again.

He sounds dangerous to me.

andyouwillknowusbythetrailofdead · 05/03/2025 19:08

It's intentional. He's seeing how far he can push you.

mcmooberry · 05/03/2025 19:07

Yes it sounds intentional and yes it sounds dangerous. Going to add my voice to those advising to leave, it honestly feels like it could escalate. He has masked this dangerous side too, please make plans to separate and soon.

randomrandomium · 05/03/2025 19:06

Please leave

Efrogwraig · 05/03/2025 19:04

Leave. Leave now.

GreyAreas · 05/03/2025 19:03

You say he has never been physically abusive, but he is being physically abusive. Sounds like a dominance move. Abuse moves often are instinctual and not conscious. He may have revenge fantasies because of how strongly he feels his feelings. Would he be able to intellectually understand that it is experienced by you as abusive and that it needs to stop? You've tried not reacting. Now you need to - safely - do something different.

Devonshiregal · 05/03/2025 19:02

Firefly100 · 05/03/2025 17:07

Hi OP, does your husband work? If so what happens at work when
“when he is upset, usually over something minor, to him it’s huge. He feels his life is over if he has a minor setback and tends to lash out verbally and say the most awful things”

How about with his friends?

or does he miraculously manage to hold it in then after all and reserve that behaviour just for you? I agree with previous posters you are under reacting and he sounds dangerous.

This is actually a bit of a difficult comparison as we all have bigger arguments/show our emotions more with our close ones than colleagues.

It would help too if she said what intellectual disability he has and what neurodivergence. They’re not one size fits all.

But yeah the guy is clearly fucked up and probably getting some sexual kick out of this-he probably too scared to ask her if she wants to do the whole strangle thing (or has in the past but she said no) and is just getting his thrills where he can. Im guessing op is thinking well he’s big on the bad mood side so maybe he’s big on the happy mood side and that’s why he’s squeezing too hard.

He’s either Lenny from of mice and men (dangerous but innocent) or he’s a fucked up weirdo (dangerous and intentional). Either way op ends up seriously hurt or dead.

edited to add that the op is really confusing with this post - she sounds genuinely not that worried that this guy is restricting her breathing and very confident about her ability to fight him off (even though she said she had to pinch him because she couldn’t breathe…) so weird. And really, anyone who suspects their husband maybe be secretly evil should leave rather than sticking around to find out - hasn’t anyone watched What Lies Beneath?

Notsuchafattynow · 05/03/2025 18:59

Finmory · 05/03/2025 16:49

Being strangled by a partner makes you 600% more likely to be murdered by that person. This may not be strangulation but the intent to cut off your air is the same.

It's also clear from the fact he was repositioning his hold that he was absolutely trying to stop you from breathing.

I would treat this behaviour extremely seriously, report to the police, and leave the abusive POS.

Exactly.

He's step by step, leading up to it.

It's terrifying. Please leave imeadatly.

LordBummenbachsMagnificentBalls · 05/03/2025 18:57

Op, your partner is intentionally strangling you for your own enjoyment. Their neurodiversity is irrelevant, you are unsafe in this relationship. Please leave as soon as possible

LBFseBrom · 05/03/2025 18:56

This is absolutely terrifying, op. I do not understand why you are with this man.

Please don't stay.

Ellie1015 · 05/03/2025 18:54

If it is intentional it is unsafe. If it is not intentional it is unsafe. So either way it doesnt matter he has to stop.

The fact you are wary of bringing this up suggests you are nervous/controlled by thought of him losing control.

Popfull · 05/03/2025 18:52

Scary to think this goes on behind closed doors

Downright terrifying to think the Op will probably ignore the thread and go on to have children with him

tsmainsqueeze · 05/03/2025 18:52

You must be aware that this bizarre behaviour is extremely dangerous and that you are seriously at risk and that this is not normal ,no way can you overpower a man who is strangling you from behind.
I couldn't possibly contemplate staying with a man who does this, what on earth is going on in his mind when he comes up behind you and does this ? it's absolutely chilling.
You need to get out and i think you should tell the police ,he may choose to do the same to other women too.

valder · 05/03/2025 18:47

Sorry to say it, but it sounds like a game to you. Testing his reaction by your non reaction and so on. This is what you are doing, trying to be the one "in control" because you THINK you can sort him out by ignoring what he is doing and therefore taking the power away from him.

Not happening. As pps have said, he has power and strength, and words and non reaction will lead to your demise or serious injury some day. Don't go there. Stop playing games with your life.

I'd like to shout at you and scream at you that you are playing a very dangerous game of chicken here. But you already deep down know that I'd say.

So take your chances and believe you are overreacting. Or really take control and go somewhere far away from him.

I hope you are not a future statistic.

Ooohee · 05/03/2025 18:44

I hope you’re reading all these replies OP. The consensus is overwhelming. You are not safe with this man.

5128gap · 05/03/2025 18:42

Unless he is disabled, elderly or otherwise frail or you are an athlete, you should absolutely NOT assume you are strong enough to prevent him harming you. An average adult man is almost always capable of overpowering an average woman even where weight and size are similar. Plus, if he is approaching you from behind he has the advantage of positioning, especially if you are seated. You are taking a significant risk in staying with him. It's obviously intentional and he sounds unwell and escalating.

TheBlackSheepbaaaa · 05/03/2025 18:36

Op, I'm not sure why you're playing Russian roulette with your life but that's what you're doing.
You're allowing him to do this so you can figure out what he is trying to achieve? WHY?
He's restricting your breathing and he's doing it on purpose, that's all you need to know. You don't need to analyse why he's doing it, it's enough that he is and he's escalating.
Please find a way to safely leave this marriage, your life is at risk and I don't say that lightly. Please listen to everyone on this thread and get out.

AthWat · 05/03/2025 18:36

Leaving aside the overreacting, the issue is certainly the choking/smothering.

As to why he does this, nobody here is going to know unless they are an expert in the particular condition he has, and as you are not specific, even then they wouldn't be able to help.

What's clear, though, is that it's incredibly unusual and worrying, and you should take no chances, tell him how appalling it is, and seek professional advice. I initially said "if he doesn't stop immediately seek professional advice" but on reflection I think it would be remiss of me to advise you to give him time to stop, as who knows what his reaction to being told might be.

NotMyDayJob · 05/03/2025 18:35

I have no idea how to vote but YABU to put up with this

BlueSkies210 · 05/03/2025 18:34

He’s been verbally and emotionally abusing you for years and now it’s turned physical.

How intellectually disabled is he? Because he knows enough to make it look like an accident and to manipulate you. I wouldn’t have him in my house. It’s premeditated, it’s sinister and he must really hate you.

ginasevern · 05/03/2025 18:29

OP, if you're still reading please leave this man before he kills you. This is intentional and it is control. I felt sick to my stomach reading your post. You are also seriously dillusional if you think you're strong enough to repel him. Even a slightly built man using his full force against a woman will always, always, always win. Don't be so naive and foolish.