Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Or does this sound intentional

215 replies

MaybeBaby1313 · 05/03/2025 16:10

I’ve name changed for this and will try to give as much info as I can to get the best responses.
So apologies for the length

I’ve been with my DH for 7 years, married for 4.
Generally things have been good most of the time.

We don’t have DC, which isn’t relevant to my post but is something that people may ask.

However DH has an intellectual disability and is also neurodiverse, but is exceptionally good at masking so I didn’t realise the full extent of his issues until we lived together.

The biggest issue he has is that when he is upset, usually over something minor, to him it’s huge. He feels his life is over if he has a minor setback and tends to lash out verbally and say the most awful things, I’m told he did this to his parents as a child, and it’s something he’s continued in to adulthood but now I get the brunt of it.

He calms down quickly and is always very sorry for the things he’s said, He has never been physically abusive in any way
he runs away (literally) from any kind of conflict or argument and generally seems to struggle with managing his emotions.

BUT

At times when things between us have been absolutely fine, he would hug me and squeeze a little too tight, not every time, just sometimes.

This would leave my breathing restricted for a few seconds so I’d try to speak or poke him etc to get him to let go.

He would apologise:/ say he didn’t mean to hold me that tight and we’d move on.

But, I started to notice it was happening often, and that it was taking him longer to let go when I tried to alert him to being unable to breathe. I started to feel it may be intentional, although couldn’t figure out the point of it.

I bought it up, made sure not to accuse, just said that he was cutting off my air supply sometimes when he hugged me

And it stopped for a long time.

Lately, he’s taken to coming up and hugging me from behind if I am sat at my desk etc, which seems lovely but he is hugging me by putting his arm around my throat.
And squeezing.

Being mindful of before, I didn’t react. Because if it is deliberate then he must be looking for a reaction.

The first time, he let go, as you would after a hug

The next time, he repositioned himself slightly, and then ‘hugged’ again, tighter

I still didn’t react, so he shifted slightly and did it again.

This has now happened multiple times
So I no longer feel it’s unintentionally just being a little heavy handed with the hug

The last time he did it, although I hadn’t reacted he says ‘sorry, couldn’t you breathe’

So it’s clear to me that he does know what he’s doing and that he’s looking for me to react and tell him I can’t breathe, so when I haven’t done that, he’s doing it harder to get the reaction

Now, I want to be clear that I am strong enough to push him off me, I’ve allowed it to happen so I can try and figure out what he’s trying to achieve but I do not feel in any real danger and would not let him do it to a point where it was dangerous.

But, am I over reacting to a too tight hug, or is he trying to restrict my breathing?

And if he is, why?
He doesn’t lash out physically when he’s upset or angry or at times where it would make sense (although it still wouldn’t be acceptable)

So what is the point in cutting off my air supply for a few seconds in a hug, and then letting go? When life is otherwise good

I just don’t get it, which is why I thought it wasn’t intentional but there’s just no way it can be accidental at this point,

incase it’s relevant, he isn’t controlling in any way, in fact I have the most control in our lives, including with finances.

OP posts:
Horses7 · 05/03/2025 20:19

Yikes 🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩
I’d be running scared especially as this behaviour is escalating - what’s next??

Dweetfidilove · 05/03/2025 20:18

This is beyond terrifying.
I don't know how you sat there testing how far he'd go without responding.
This is thrilling him and he will kill you.
Crikey 😳.

WhatamIreading25 · 05/03/2025 20:16

Changed my name to reply - I am an autism specialist. It doesn’t matter whether this is intentional or sensory seeking or dopamine chasing. It’s dangerous and he could easily kill you, by accident or on purpose. You cannot stay in the same house. Sorry.

JLou08 · 05/03/2025 20:15

If possible I do think you are best discussing this in person with someone who knows you both. It does seem very odd that he would do this if there is no reason to it eg no sign that he is physically aggressive, controlling or wants to hurt you. If he had professionals involved you could speak to them too, they may have an idea on what is driving the behaviour and may be able to assess the risks.

MatriarchCaz · 05/03/2025 20:12

Hollietree · 05/03/2025 20:05

Or maybe some Thai massage might help to relax him?

Breaks away with the lads would also be good for him?

SnippySnappy · 05/03/2025 20:12

Gently - what else does he need to do to you for you to accept he's abusive? Is the near-asphyxiation not enough?

GermanBite · 05/03/2025 20:11

What kind of evidence of intent are you looking for? Being strangled until you pass out? Die?

Wellwellwellys · 05/03/2025 20:11

This is terrifying. I don’t think I could sleep in the same house as him. He wants to, at the very least scare you, at worst hurt you.

I’d be willing to bet he is watching porn that is fetishising this action too. It’s not worth staying to find out if he’ll try again.

PlanningTowns · 05/03/2025 20:09

I’m very much hoping that four hours after posting your long and considered OP that you are safe and well.

this is a man who masked so successfully that you didn’t know the extent of his issues until later - what when you moved in together?

your post is terrifying and you must remember that not all people are nice and people with the issues you describe can be abusers too. The way he is going about it is very much a worry and suggests it is both intentional and considered.

you need to leave, but if you continue to stay then please tell someone in real life so if the inevitable does happen someone knows this background. I’d also suggest you do t underestimate him and more

Hollietree · 05/03/2025 20:05

SerenaSemolena · 05/03/2025 18:16

Does he have any outlet for his energy, op?
Maybe he should join a weekend football team, or something.

Or maybe some Thai massage might help to relax him?

scotstars · 05/03/2025 20:05

OP this is terrifying he is escalating his behaviour I wouldn't be interested in sticking around to find out why. Please get yourself to safety I guarantee when he wants to take this a level further again you won't be able to get free and he could very easily kill you.

supersop60 · 05/03/2025 20:01

Yes, it's intentional.
Get out.
And don't tell him you're going.

Bestfootforward11 · 05/03/2025 20:00

This sounds worrying to me. He is making you physically uncomfortable and you have told him and he seems to be deliberately repeating the actions you told him you didn’t want. The fact you are even thinking about it being deliberate means your instinct is telling you it is. You said he’s not controlling but it sounds to me like he is in some respects. He knows as an adult that he finds managing his emotions difficult for whatever reason but the position seems to be that because he’s been like that since he was young, it’s just the way things are. But that’s not right. He should be taking steps to help him navigate his reactions and not take things out on you. You say he gets disproportionately upset about small things so in a way he is controlling your environment because your experience of a day is significantly dependant on how he has reacted to things and therefore behaved to you. It sounds like he is testing things, how far can he push things. I really do feel quite worried because if he has control of himself why is he doing this and if it’s something he can’t control, that is dangerous full stop. Take care.

BeMellowBrickSquid · 05/03/2025 19:59

SerenaSemolena · 05/03/2025 18:16

Does he have any outlet for his energy, op?
Maybe he should join a weekend football team, or something.

I see you...

Kindyeah · 05/03/2025 19:58

Why on earth are you still with him? Run. Fast.

Bababear987 · 05/03/2025 19:57

Totototo · 05/03/2025 16:22

You sound deranged. He sounds dangerous. Leave. Get therapy.

This!!

Omg OP how can you be playing along with this? He sounds dangerous and is obvs trying to test you. Life is too short for people like this. You will lead a great life without a man that likes to strangle you for kicks

Barney16 · 05/03/2025 19:56

This is very scary. Honestly I would be so frightened I would leave. I couldn't be in the house with him. What could happen when you are asleep?

Mellap · 05/03/2025 19:53

The question isn't why does he do that. The question is why are you accepting this frightening person in your life and how can you find a way to respond appropriately to your situation. Your under-reaction is so so concerning. It really sounds like you need to get to safety as soon as possible. Get away from this dangerous man who is showing you he wants to hurt you. Once you are safe, seek therapy to explore this but first, please, first, get away.

It will be so hard for you to hear this right now as you have come here looking for help rationalising your situation so you can keep it going. But it is irrational. You are not safe. Please wake up and run away before it's too late.

DPotter · 05/03/2025 19:53

Unless he is under 5 ft and you are 6ft 4 with plenty of upper body strength you will not be able to get out of a headlock.

This man is so dangerous and I sincerely hope that after reading 6 of the responses, you have packed a bag and got the hell out of there, and that's why you haven't returned to the thread. If you're reeling from the shock of all the posts - get your handbag and car keys and get the hell out of there now.

7 seconds that's all it would take.
7 seconds

AnxiouslyAwaitingSpring · 05/03/2025 19:52

This is how Gabby Petito was killed 😐

ChocAuVin · 05/03/2025 19:49

My abusive exH once said, calmly, “I want to put my hands around your neck and squeeze until you stop breathing.”

at the time, although it was chilling, I was so gaslit and so many dreadful things were said so often, I didn’t run from the house.

He was dangerous and it was entirely normalised.

In hindsight I want to slap myself and just go. I get the same feeling reading your post. It’s not normal. Leave.

Maurepas · 05/03/2025 19:49

He is crazy.
He is very dangerous.
One day he may/will go to far.
Get Out.

MidnightMusing5 · 05/03/2025 19:48

I was scared for you reading this. 🚩 🏃‍♀️

Pigsears · 05/03/2025 19:47

'he isn't controlling in any way'

I'd say controlling airflow and ability to breathe is a fairly major thing.

JG4 · 05/03/2025 19:44

MaybeBaby1313 · 05/03/2025 16:10

I’ve name changed for this and will try to give as much info as I can to get the best responses.
So apologies for the length

I’ve been with my DH for 7 years, married for 4.
Generally things have been good most of the time.

We don’t have DC, which isn’t relevant to my post but is something that people may ask.

However DH has an intellectual disability and is also neurodiverse, but is exceptionally good at masking so I didn’t realise the full extent of his issues until we lived together.

The biggest issue he has is that when he is upset, usually over something minor, to him it’s huge. He feels his life is over if he has a minor setback and tends to lash out verbally and say the most awful things, I’m told he did this to his parents as a child, and it’s something he’s continued in to adulthood but now I get the brunt of it.

He calms down quickly and is always very sorry for the things he’s said, He has never been physically abusive in any way
he runs away (literally) from any kind of conflict or argument and generally seems to struggle with managing his emotions.

BUT

At times when things between us have been absolutely fine, he would hug me and squeeze a little too tight, not every time, just sometimes.

This would leave my breathing restricted for a few seconds so I’d try to speak or poke him etc to get him to let go.

He would apologise:/ say he didn’t mean to hold me that tight and we’d move on.

But, I started to notice it was happening often, and that it was taking him longer to let go when I tried to alert him to being unable to breathe. I started to feel it may be intentional, although couldn’t figure out the point of it.

I bought it up, made sure not to accuse, just said that he was cutting off my air supply sometimes when he hugged me

And it stopped for a long time.

Lately, he’s taken to coming up and hugging me from behind if I am sat at my desk etc, which seems lovely but he is hugging me by putting his arm around my throat.
And squeezing.

Being mindful of before, I didn’t react. Because if it is deliberate then he must be looking for a reaction.

The first time, he let go, as you would after a hug

The next time, he repositioned himself slightly, and then ‘hugged’ again, tighter

I still didn’t react, so he shifted slightly and did it again.

This has now happened multiple times
So I no longer feel it’s unintentionally just being a little heavy handed with the hug

The last time he did it, although I hadn’t reacted he says ‘sorry, couldn’t you breathe’

So it’s clear to me that he does know what he’s doing and that he’s looking for me to react and tell him I can’t breathe, so when I haven’t done that, he’s doing it harder to get the reaction

Now, I want to be clear that I am strong enough to push him off me, I’ve allowed it to happen so I can try and figure out what he’s trying to achieve but I do not feel in any real danger and would not let him do it to a point where it was dangerous.

But, am I over reacting to a too tight hug, or is he trying to restrict my breathing?

And if he is, why?
He doesn’t lash out physically when he’s upset or angry or at times where it would make sense (although it still wouldn’t be acceptable)

So what is the point in cutting off my air supply for a few seconds in a hug, and then letting go? When life is otherwise good

I just don’t get it, which is why I thought it wasn’t intentional but there’s just no way it can be accidental at this point,

incase it’s relevant, he isn’t controlling in any way, in fact I have the most control in our lives, including with finances.

Op , PLEASE are read what you wrote as if your best friend or your sister had written it . I literally felt a chill whist reading it . His behaviour is far from normal , he is clearly aware of what he is doing and you are in danger .there is absolutely no excuse for someone to cup off your air supply , EVER . Please get out of this situation