Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be angry that the NHS doesn’t take pain seriously?

214 replies

LilyJosephine · 04/03/2025 22:26

AIBU to think that the NHS is regularly dismissive of pain, especially if you are a younger woman? Maybe I’m biased as I’m a regular on the infertility boards (have name changed) where it seems like a lot of women are struggling with a late endometriosis diagnosis (and so now fertility problems) where their pain was dismissed for years.

But now I am in the exact same situation but with my back. After 2 years of extreme pain and having been told by a muscular skeletal specialist (whom you have to be referred to first by your GP as they gatekeep further referral/MRI’s) that there was no way I had spinal stenosis, as I was too young and it’s not genetic 🤷‍♀️ (my parent has it); and that I couldn’t have an MRI as she was sure it was just disc degeneration that everyone gets as they age. She was totally dismissive. Now guess what I’ve just been diagnosed with?

Finally managed to find a sympathetic GP (young male foreign locum if it matters) after multiple visits to others. He was the only one not dismissive of my pain and managed to find a way around to get me an MRI. It’s a good job he did as the spinal stenosis has now progressed to cauda equina and they sent me straight to A and E. The A and E back specialist said “You’ve likely been living with this for years (the spinal stenosis)”. Yeah, you don’t say? 🙄

Two years of struggling to parent my toddler due to the pain (I’m a SMBC) and now I likely face future back operations to avoid paralysis 😢I was planning on having more IVF for a second child and that’s possibly out the window now too. I’m furious.

Thanks if you’ve read all that. AIBU to think the NHS is dismissive of pain? An MRI back then when I needed one would likely have saved NHS costs now as well as my pain - it’s so short sighted!

OP posts:
Msmoonpie · 06/03/2025 19:01

Firefly1987 · 06/03/2025 00:34

Source?

And still no posters have addressed the inability for men to get PSA tests when they ask for it (for a disease that kills in huge numbers) despite claiming men get all their health needs served to them on a silver platter. Whilst women get invited to smear and mammogram tests. The bloody patriarchy eh!

You do know that the PSA test is not very accurate ?

Might be why it’s not often offered.

anon666 · 06/03/2025 18:40

Oh gosh, OP, how unbelievably frustrating thet just be.

Yanbu. I'm not sure it's just the nhs, I think it's healthcare full stop.

Essentially we have a "diagnosis and treatment" service, not a "health" service. I feel that the medical model of healthcare, whilst it has delivered many improvements in clinical outcomes ans life expectancy, has left us with major gaps in compassion and "care".

Doctors are rushed, inundated with guidance, and expected to be everything to everyone. It's just not working for people who have needs other than a straightforward diagnosis and treatment conveyor belt.

I'm not sure whether it's just underresourcing, or attitude, but it's very unfortunate for the poor sod in agony for no obvious reason. I faced two years of aggressive "So what do you want from me?" GPs, when my pain had no easy explanation. I never got any results that explained it, but on my own meticulous research I finally stopped taking statins which helped reduce it to manageable levels.

I'm so sorry that yours turned out to be something like this. And I wish you all the best for the future. 🙏

MMUmum · 06/03/2025 18:35

I tripped and fell recently resulting in a broken wrist and broken nose, I rang my Gp for some decent pain relief and was refused, told to buy over the counter meds, I just wanted to cry 😪 it's just shocking now

Emonade · 06/03/2025 18:23

LilyJosephine · 04/03/2025 22:26

AIBU to think that the NHS is regularly dismissive of pain, especially if you are a younger woman? Maybe I’m biased as I’m a regular on the infertility boards (have name changed) where it seems like a lot of women are struggling with a late endometriosis diagnosis (and so now fertility problems) where their pain was dismissed for years.

But now I am in the exact same situation but with my back. After 2 years of extreme pain and having been told by a muscular skeletal specialist (whom you have to be referred to first by your GP as they gatekeep further referral/MRI’s) that there was no way I had spinal stenosis, as I was too young and it’s not genetic 🤷‍♀️ (my parent has it); and that I couldn’t have an MRI as she was sure it was just disc degeneration that everyone gets as they age. She was totally dismissive. Now guess what I’ve just been diagnosed with?

Finally managed to find a sympathetic GP (young male foreign locum if it matters) after multiple visits to others. He was the only one not dismissive of my pain and managed to find a way around to get me an MRI. It’s a good job he did as the spinal stenosis has now progressed to cauda equina and they sent me straight to A and E. The A and E back specialist said “You’ve likely been living with this for years (the spinal stenosis)”. Yeah, you don’t say? 🙄

Two years of struggling to parent my toddler due to the pain (I’m a SMBC) and now I likely face future back operations to avoid paralysis 😢I was planning on having more IVF for a second child and that’s possibly out the window now too. I’m furious.

Thanks if you’ve read all that. AIBU to think the NHS is dismissive of pain? An MRI back then when I needed one would likely have saved NHS costs now as well as my pain - it’s so short sighted!

Im so sorry you’ve been through this, it is absolutely appalling and they do it’s expect people to live in pain unless they can afford private, especially women it seems.

Panterusblackish · 06/03/2025 08:36

Kingsleadhat · 05/03/2025 00:09

I went to a and e after falling over, told them I'd fainted and that my arm was painful. The doctor I saw queried whether I needed an x-ray saying there's no way that's broken if you were in real pain you'd make more fuss. It turned out I had fractured the humerus in two places and chipped the head of the bone

I've had invisalign braces.

The dentist asked about pain on my first follow up visit. So I told them yes they hurt but its fine.

He and the dental nurse immediately started laughing. She was new and he had told her that every single man that has braces complains bitterly about the pain and every single woman minimises it and i had performed as expected.

Women have for generations had their pain ignored and are expected to cope.

I'm sure there are a million stories of women being told there is nothing wrong with them when in fact they are suffering.

It's the patriarchy at work.

I can only urge those who have been ignored to complain. Even if time has passed since being dismissed.

Iheartmysmart · 06/03/2025 08:01

Blimey, even when we’re discussing women’s health we still have to consider those poor men!

Anyway a comparison from me. My dad went to the GP with slight hand tremors and was immediately referred for further tests. Fortunately it wasn’t Parkinson’s as suspected, just a side effect of one of his COPD medications.

My mum also went to the same GP with hand tremors and shuffling when she was walking. No referral for her, she was definitely suffering with stress. This went on for several years. Her symptoms got much worse but despite repeated visits to the GP she was still refused any further tests. Then she had a bad fall on holiday and had to go to the local A&E for stitches. They were sufficiently concerned to write to her GP. Fortunately on her last visit she saw a locum who was horrified at the state of her and finally made the referral.

Mum does have Parkinson’s and is in a pretty bad way. Had she been offered the same tests as my dad then medication could have been started much sooner and we would have had much more quality time with her.

Even outside of ‘women’s problems’ there is still a huge discrepancy in how men and women are viewed and treated by the NHS.

Whatafustercluck · 06/03/2025 07:41

Yanbu but it's not only young women, it's women in general (see also menopause).

When dsis was 21, she had excruciating pain in the pelvic area. Her (male) GP sent her away telling her it was period pain 🤔 Only when she was doubled over and my dad literally marched into his surgery demanding action did he take it seriously. Turns out she had pelvic inflammatory disease and ended up minus one ovary and with both fallopian tubes too damaged to conceive naturally.

When I was in labour with my first, I was told I wasn't in enough pain to warrant gas and air and was instead told to walk around the hospital until I was really 'ready' for it. After 10 mins of traipsing down stairs and corridors, again bent double, dh demanded that I was given pain relief. When they examined me I was 6cm.

With my second labour, I was told to wait my turn to be 'triaged'. Dh told them after 10 minutes that if I wasn't seen immediately I'd be giving birth in the corridor. 15 mins later, without gas and air, dd was born (indeed I was briefly considered for an emergency c section because she was in distress, wanting to come out!)

And now, at 46, I'm fighting to have my progressive joint stiffness and pain investigated. I've been sent to physio and told it's probably perimenopause and that the physio will 'hopefully' help.

It gives me the rage, more and more. There are countless similar stories.

maddening · 06/03/2025 07:25

Firefly1987 · 06/03/2025 00:34

Source?

And still no posters have addressed the inability for men to get PSA tests when they ask for it (for a disease that kills in huge numbers) despite claiming men get all their health needs served to them on a silver platter. Whilst women get invited to smear and mammogram tests. The bloody patriarchy eh!

https://www.theguardian.com/society/2022/jan/04/women-more-likely-die-operation-male-surgeon-study

I think it is ridiculous to take this as an attack on men - this is comparing outcomes- if there is a space in medicine where men are being failed then I expect no woman would have a problem with them advocating for this. However, the fact that women are failed by the medical industry due to years of sexism is not an attack on men, it is just the truth and there are.known historical causes- eg all practise and study was based on male anatomy. A current example is that the known symptoms of a heart attack are those for men -.women's symptoms are different and largely unknown and they have.worse outcomes here. And women should be able to advocate for this without men taking offence.

My anecdotal note is u am.looking for a diagnosis to a health issue that is.very.under researched - it only impacts women- but 10% of women - the gps have not heard of it, the only treatment is not available in the UK on the nhs, there are no specialists in the UK, getting a diagnosis is v difficult) 5 years trying so far.

https://lordslibrary.parliament.uk/womens-health-outcomes-is-there-a-gender-gap/

https://www.bma.org.uk/news-and-opinion/closing-the-gender-health-gap-the-importance-of-a-women-s-health-strategy

https://www.gov.scot/publications/womens-experiences-discrimination-impact-health/pages/4/

*link removed by MNHQ for privacy concerns.

Women 32% more likely to die after operation by male surgeon, study reveals

Female patients found to have 15% more chance of a bad outcome than if procedure was performed by a woman

https://www.theguardian.com/society/2022/jan/04/women-more-likely-die-operation-male-surgeon-study

Firefly1987 · 06/03/2025 00:34

maddening · 05/03/2025 23:58

Rather than anecdotal cases and emotional guilt tripping, consider facts

Statistically, women undergoing the same surgery as men by male surgeons have worse outcomes and are more likely to die than the male patients.

Source?

And still no posters have addressed the inability for men to get PSA tests when they ask for it (for a disease that kills in huge numbers) despite claiming men get all their health needs served to them on a silver platter. Whilst women get invited to smear and mammogram tests. The bloody patriarchy eh!

Willowkins · 06/03/2025 00:04

Referred for what was thought to be a gynae problem and the doctor was very dismissive of the pain (I was crying) and said there was nothing he could do. It turned out to be a urology problem and suddenly there was plenty of pain relief. You only need to look at the respective waiting rooms to find out why.

maddening · 05/03/2025 23:58

Firefly1987 · 05/03/2025 03:09

No I haven't had any issues with the NHS as a woman, even being diagnosed and treated promptly for an autoimmune disorder. But if you and other posters feel big by shitting on men or making out they have it so easy go for it. My dad never went to A&E with stage 4 cancer pain so I guess he must've been a different sort of male that goes there for "a paper cut".

Edited

Rather than anecdotal cases and emotional guilt tripping, consider facts

Statistically, women undergoing the same surgery as men by male surgeons have worse outcomes and are more likely to die than the male patients.

Spacecowboys · 05/03/2025 18:37

The cauda equina patients I have encountered have been sent to the nearest specialist hospital immediately - via ambulance for emergency surgery. I haven’t heard of partial and wonder if the specialists who reviewed ops images interpreted them differently.
Back pain is such a difficult one. As previously posted, the vast majority of those over the age of 50 have degenerative issues and often, an MRI won’t change management, even for those under 50.

FluffyDashhound · 05/03/2025 18:04

Cauda equine is an emergency and requires surgery to prevent paralysis.

FluffyDashhound · 05/03/2025 18:03

So what's happening with cauda equine have you had emergency surgery. No real treatment for stenosis anyways injections aren't in nice guidelines and they may operate but it only helps leg pain not back pain .

Pasithean · 05/03/2025 17:43

Bed bound following my gp ignoring my consultant and cancelling my painkillers prior to that I was so active, hobbies , animals , swimming .
now my husband late 70’s with a heart problem is my carer.

LilyJosephine · 05/03/2025 17:40

faithspikebuffy · 05/03/2025 17:35

You can have partial I think, mine went from "almost" to "you're going to theatre" very quickly
I never lost bowel or bladder control and was still able to walk

Thanks very much. That’s really useful to know -as generally internet sites seem to make it sound like you must lose all bladder and bowel function and not be able to walk at all for it to be Cauda Equina , but the MRI report seemed quite definite 🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
faithspikebuffy · 05/03/2025 17:35

You can have partial I think, mine went from "almost" to "you're going to theatre" very quickly
I never lost bowel or bladder control and was still able to walk

LilyJosephine · 05/03/2025 16:37

iamnotalemon · 05/03/2025 13:21

@LilyJosephine

Not to scare you but you know that Cauda Equina can cause paralysis and you can lose the use of your bowel and bladder if not treated within a certain time period?

It's not terminal no, but life changing!

Thanks for the info - I googled the same and am really scared. I can only think that if the MRI report is correct, then I must I have partial/gradual caudal equina (if there is such a thing); as while I do have some numbness underneath and in my upper legs, I also still have some sensation too - and can walk, albeit in a lot of pain. They have basically told me while I am “urgent” , they that they have huge numbers of other urgent cases too… basically I’m to rush myself to a and e if the numbness gets significantly worse before they can see me.

I hope you were treated quickly and everything worked out for you - the idea of permanent loss of function is terrifying.

OP posts:
Domino20 · 05/03/2025 15:36

lilythesheep · 05/03/2025 07:12

No it was a man and not in London. So there are 2 doctors going around saying that to patients.

Oh no that's awful. Such a callous thing to say to people. Shockingly unprofessional.

myplace · 05/03/2025 14:53

tiger2691 · 05/03/2025 10:32

Umm, not quite, been living with this since 2012, Cauda Equina, chronic debilitating pain, the stuff below my waist only works when it wants to.

Right, so a ‘broken’ thing that can’t be fixed in your case. But visible and diagnosable, and recognised by medics. I know it’s disabling, I’m sorry.

My point wasn’t that men never have problems. It was that a lot of women suffer a lot of symptoms that aren’t visible or fixable. But still real and needing care-

But dismissed.
No one told me what fibroids do. They just mentioned in passing that I had a big one, after a scan about a coil if I remember correctly.
If I’d known the implications things would have been easier to manage.

iamnotalemon · 05/03/2025 13:21

@LilyJosephine

Not to scare you but you know that Cauda Equina can cause paralysis and you can lose the use of your bowel and bladder if not treated within a certain time period?

It's not terminal no, but life changing!

iamnotalemon · 05/03/2025 13:12

@tiger2691

I'm sorry to hear you have cauda equina. I was diagnosed with that but thankfully treated quickly. Hope you're ok x

faithspikebuffy · 05/03/2025 13:08

JoyousGreyOrca · 05/03/2025 12:24

@Roseshavethorns I have back pain. You can see from how people move if their pain is really bad. And people with really bad pain can not take a dog for a walk. They can not walk that far.
Drs see people in really severe pain. When patients may have zero understanding of how bad pain can get.

Yeah I could walk by dragging one leg behind me, the relief when I lost feeling was insane
I told them to cut my leg off and was going through the best part of a bottle of morphine a day
The consultant said I was grey with pain

HairOfFineStraw · 05/03/2025 12:29

It's everyone these days. My coworker's husband has a kidney stone stuck in his ureter plus a few others and they kept sending him home before it got really bad and they finally opted to blast it which is what they should have done weeks ago.

JoyousGreyOrca · 05/03/2025 12:24

@Roseshavethorns I have back pain. You can see from how people move if their pain is really bad. And people with really bad pain can not take a dog for a walk. They can not walk that far.
Drs see people in really severe pain. When patients may have zero understanding of how bad pain can get.